논문 : 지속가능한 도시를 위한 그린 다자인 계획요인 중요도 분석

이진성 ( Jun Sung Lee ),김현숙 ( Hyun Suk Kim ),이진성 ( Jun Sung Lee ) 디자인융복합학회 2013 디자인융복합연구 Vol.12 No.5

본 연구는 그린 디자인이 지속가능한 도시를 구현하기 위해 반드시 필요한 도시의 디자인 개념이라는 전제하에 도시의 구성요소 분류(도시컨텐츠, 도시기반시설, 도시공간, 도시자연문화)의 세부 부분별로 그린디자인에 어느 부분이 더욱 중요한지를 찾아보는 연구이다. 그린디자인을 사업의 실시에 있어서도 더욱 주요한 부분을 우선적으로 고려하여 진행하는 것이 제정의 배분에 있어서도 효율적이기 때문이다.연구의 진행은 그린디자인이 적용되기 위한 도시구성요소들을 도출하기 위해 선행연구를 살펴보고 지표의 종합과정과 FGI, 지표의 적합성 검증을 거쳤으며, 도출된 도시구성요소의 지표의 중요도를 도출하기위해 도시디자인관련 전문가 집단에게 AHP설문을 실시하였다. AHP분석결과 도시기반시설부분이 가장 우선적으로 그린디자인을 적용해야할 부문으로 도출되었으며, 도시컨텐츠, 도시자연문화, 도시공간 순으로 도출되었다. 각 세부항목을 살펴보면 도시컨텐츠 부분은 교육(0.0729), 캠페인(0.0702), 프로그램(0.0621), 제도(0.0648)로 도출되었으며, 도시기반시설 부분은 공간시설(0.0868), 교통시설(0.0961), 공공문화체육시설(0.0682), 환경기초시설(0.0589) 순으로 도출되었으며, 도시공간 부분은 상업공간(0.0532), 업무공간(0.0494), 주거공간(0.0456), 생태공간(0.0418)의 순으로 도출되었다. 마지막으로 도시자연문화부분에서는 자연환경(0.0667), 역사(0.0598), 사회문화(0.0529)의 순으로 도출된 것을 볼 수 있었다. In this study, we purpose a test a hypothesis that a Green Design is essentially need to design Sustainable City. And it evaluate which part of the green design are more important thought classifying the structural elements of the city (city contents, city facilities, city space, natural culture in city) in detail. We purpose a test a hypothesis that a Green Design is essentially need to design Sustainable City. And it evaluate which part of the green design are more important thought classifying the structural elements of the city (city contents, city facilities, city space, natural culture in city) in detail. Because it is more efficient to distribute financial resources considering the more important parts while the green city design is on the progress. The research proceeded looking over the literature reviews and deduced city structural factors delivering green design. After then it examined synthetic course of index and FGI, appropriateness of index and it surveyed using AHP from professionals related with the city design for eliciting the importance about the index of city structural elements. According to the result of AHP, the city facility is the most essential to apply green design and the others are city condense, natural facility in city, city space in order. Looking at the each one in detail, there are education (0.0729), campaign (0.0702), program (0.0621), system (0.0648) in city content. Part. Also there were space facilities (0.0868), transport (0.0961), public culture and activity institutions (0.0682) and environmental facilities (0.0589) in city facility part. It deduced commercial space (0.0532), business space (0.0494), residential area (0.0456), and ecological space (0.0418) in city space part. Finally environment (0.0667), history (0.0598), and social and culture (0.0529) were presented in the city natural and culture part.

都市計劃思潮에 입각한 녹색도시의 認識基盤에 관한 연구

전영길(Jeon Yeong-Gil),이성익(Lee Seong-Yik) 한국지적정보학회 2010 한국지적정보학회지 Vol.12 No.2

본 연구는 현재 우리정부가 미래의 도시모델로 제안하는 ‘녹색도시’개념에 대한 인식을 바르게 하고자 하는 시도이다. 이를 위한 첫 단계로, 우리는 먼저 현재의 녹색도시 개념의 인식요소들이 도시 계획의 역사속에서 어떠한 ‘사조(思潮)’를 반영하고 있는지 대조해 보아야 한다. 그러한 현재의 녹색 도시의 개념 또한 새로운 도시계획사조의 하나로 인식되어야 하기 때문이다. 다음단계로, 본 연구는 현 정부에 의해 녹색시범도시로 유일하게 지정된 강릉시의 실제 녹색도시모델의 인식요소들을 탐색 하도록 하는 사례연구를 시도하였다. 1) 분석결과, 도시계획사조와의 관계에서는, 녹색도시 개념은 종래까지의 도시계획사조 중 이상주의(공상주의), 바로크시대의 도시양식, 전원도시모델, 또는 시카고의 백색도시계획안 등과 밀접히 관련된다. 2) 현재의 사례를 볼 때, 녹색도시 구상은 도시계획사조로 볼 때 (이른바) ‘이상(공상)주의적 전원 도시 계획안’에 유사하다고 할 수 있다. 3) 비판적인 시각에서 본 다면, ⅰ) 현재 정부의 녹색도시 구상은, 현재의 토지이용계획에 대한 기본적 고려없이, 첨단과학기술에만 의존한 “저탄소, 기후변화” 대응 등만을 강조한다. ⅱ) 또한 도시전체지역 중 녹색지대가 이미 형성된 농촌의 작은 지역에 녹색(시범)도시를 하나 더 덧붙여 만든다는 발상에서, 도심을 비롯한 시가지 전체를 녹색화하려는 근원적인 발상의 전환이 시급히 필요하다. This study is to recognize accurately the 'Green City' concept that our government porpose the feture city model. At the first stage, we should compare the recognitive components of Green City concept with those of several trends in urban planning history, for such a new concept should be regarded as 'a new trend' in urban planning history. Secondly, this study intended to scrutinize the recognitve components of 'real Green City model' in Gangneung City, as a case study, which appointed as a (pilot) Green City uniguely. As a result of analysis; 1) Green City concept is deeply related with those trends of Ideolgical planning, Baroque style, Garden City model and the 'White City plan' of Chicago. 2) The present 'Green City (pilot) plan (in Gengneung)', as a urban planning trend, may be recogonized as, so called, ' Ideological (new)Garden City plan'. 3) As a critics on this Green City (pilot) plan', ⅰ) We can easily find the problems that this governmental plan over-emphasize only on the 'low-carbon, climate change' or other technological basis, without understanding or regarding on the foundamental Land Use planning. ⅱ) Also, such a Green City concept, which located on the small suburban rural area, should be urgently changed into another concept that covers all over the city area including CBD.

통일의 녹색비전과 남북의 생태도시협력

박영균 ( Park Young-kyun ) 한국철학사상연구회 2017 시대와 철학 Vol.28 No.1

이 글은 통일의 녹색비전이라는 관점 속에서 남북 간의 생태도시협력을 다루고 있다. 도시는 근대 산업화와 더불어 농촌을 억압하고 지배했다. 게다가 오늘날 자본의 지구화는 도시화를 통해서 가속화되고 있다. 따라서 근대 산업화가 낳은 폐해와 자본의 지구화가 낳은 위험들을 극복하기 위해서는 도시 그 자체를 바꾸어야 한다. 오늘날 `어바니즘`이 주목을 받는 것은 이 때문이다. 게다가 오늘날 국민국가는 더 이상 과거와 같은 중앙통제력을 가지고 있지 못하며 지방자치단체 및 시민들과의 거버넌스에 의해 통치되고 있다. 따라서 이 글은 그린 어바니즘에 기초한 생태도시 형성 전략이 필요한 이유를 제시한 이후, 남/북에 있는 도시들 간의 녹색협력을 주장하고 있다. 하지만 이와 같은 남북 도시들 간의 녹색협력은 각 도시가 가진 고유성 및 내재적 잠재력에 근거해야 한다. 따라서 이 글은 둘째로, 남북의 도시화 및 남북의 도시들이 가지고 있는 특징들을 비교하면서 남북의 생태도시협력에서 북쪽 도시들이 가지고 있는 장점들이 무엇인지를 제시하고 있다. 셋째로, 이 글은 생태도시로 알려진 세계적인 도시들이 가지고 있는 특징들에 대한 논의를 기반으로 하여 생태도시 형성의 전략적 방향을 3가지로 정리해서 제시하고 있다. 이어 이 글은 남북 간의 도시들에 의한 녹색협력의 방안들 및 생태도시 형성 전략이 가지고 있는 역사적 의미를 제시하고 있다. This paper deals with the cooperation of eco-city between North and South within the perspective of green vision of unification. The city suppressed and dominated rural areas with modern industrialization. Moreover, today, the globalization of capital is accelerating through urbanization. Therefore, in order to overcome the dangers of modern industrialization and the globalization of capital, it is necessary to change the city itself. This is why today `urbanism` gets attention. In addition, today, the nation-state does not have the same central control as in the past and is governed by governance with local governments and citizens. Therefore, this paper suggests the necessity of eco-city formation strategy based on green urbanism, and then insists on the green cooperation between cities in North/South Korea. However, the green cooperation between cities in North/South should be based on the inherent and potential of each city. Therefore, secondly, this paper compares features of urbanization and cities of North/South and deals with the advantages of the northern cities in the cooperation of eco-city between North and South. Third, this paper presents four strategic directions for eco-city formation based on the discussion of features of global cities known as eco-cities. Next, this paper presents the historical meanings of the eco-city formation strategy and the plans of the green cooperation between cities in North/South.

Green Energy Contents Research of Sun, Wind, Bio, Water

Lee, Jae Ik(이재익) 한국전시산업융합연구원 2018 한국과학예술융합학회 Vol.32 No.-

In Korea, active development policies and the need for investment by government is increasing and it is responding to global external factors such as enactment of the convention on climate change and the continued high oil prices. In particular, as the supply of local governments and private enterprises to major green energy such as solar power, wind power, bio, and hydroelectric power has expanded, various support and upbringing strategies such as energy zero science museum research linked with tourism industry have been also suggested. This study will upgrade the cities of each local government to a clean smart city image in response to this trend and to study green energy content development plan of solar, wind, bio, water linked with and to activate tourism industry. The contents and method of the study are as follows: First, we examine the current status and research trends of green energy at home and abroad. Second, we study the characteristics of green energy content and image attributes for clean smart city. Third, we will integrate the results of research on the current status and research trends, policies, and detailed projects of domestic and foreign countries, and the results of research on solar energy, wind, bio, water green energy contents. As a result, policy development plans and guidelines for green energy contents research that can contribute to the formation of advanced clean smart city image, energy balance development linked with tourism industry by each local government, green energy contents utilization plan for energy zero science museum. The results of this study are as follows: First, as a result of studying overseas situation and research trends, The following countries lead in distribution and investment in the following fields: China in water energy, solar energy power generation, wind energy, solar heating; UK in land wind energy; the U.S in bio energy such as bio diesel and bio ethanol; Germany in wind energy; Indonesia in geothermal power generation. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a clear policy intention and a practical policy to cope with the policy changes of countries in the world due to the expansion of the green energy market and the spread of the electricity tariff system. Second, as a result of examining the domestic situation and research trends, the government`s active support for clean green energy and the interest of private civilian and public should be further expanded. In particular, policy support, investment and growth strategies for various local governments such as energy zero science museum research connected with tourism industry per local government and green energy contents research for a smart city of sun, wind, bio, and water should be further expanded Third, as a result of examining the current status and cases of green energy contents in the world, Spain, Denmark, Germany, USA, UAE, etc. are integrating solar energy, wind energy, bio energy and water energy, even presenting it as tourism resources. In Korea, efforts are underway to plan the construction of smart cities by local governments in conjunction with energy zero science museums research and to make it as tourism resources. However, there is a great deal of conflict in the national consensus and the government and politicians need to present the solution for this. Fourth, it is absolutely necessary to develop and agree on a policy roadmap for the sequential distribution and replacement on clean green energy sources and be wary of unconditional rejection of high-efficiency energy sources such as nuclear power rising out of concerns for the distribution, investment, and support of clean green energy. Fifth, just as solar energy, wind energy, bio energy, and water energy need to maximize the advantages and disadvantages and symbolic values of each clean energy source, the balanced energy development considering regional characteristics of Korea should be closely co

Green Energy Contents Research of Sun, Wind, Bio, Water

이재익 한국전시산업융합연구원 2018 한국과학예술융합학회 Vol.32 No.-

In Korea, active development policies and the need for investment by government is increasing and it is responding to global external factors such as enactment of the convention on climate change and the continued high oil prices. In particular, as the supply of local governments and private enterprises to major green energy such as solar power, wind power, bio, and hydroelectric power has expanded, various support and upbringing strategies such as energy zero science museum research linked with tourism industry have been also suggested. This study will upgrade the cities of each local government to a clean smart city image in response to this trend and to study green energy content development plan of solar, wind, bio, water linked with and to activate tourism industry. The contents and method of the study are as follows: First, we examine the current status and research trends of green energy at home and abroad. Second, we study the characteristics of green energy content and image attributes for clean smart city. Third, we will integrate the results of research on the current status and research trends, policies, and detailed projects of domestic and foreign countries, and the results of research on solar energy, wind, bio, water green energy contents. As a result, policy development plans and guidelines for green energy contents research that can contribute to the formation of advanced clean smart city image, energy balance development linked with tourism industry by each local government, green energy contents utilization plan for energy zero science museum. The results of this study are as follows: First, as a result of studying overseas situation and research trends, The following countries lead in distribution and investment in the following fields: China in water energy, solar energy power generation, wind energy, solar heating; UK in land wind energy; the U.S in bio energy such as bio diesel and bio ethanol; Germany in wind energy; Indonesia in geothermal power generation. Therefore, it is necessary to develop a clear policy intention and a practical policy to cope with the policy changes of countries in the world due to the expansion of the green energy market and the spread of the electricity tariff system. Second, as a result of examining the domestic situation and research trends, the government's active support for clean green energy and the interest of private civilian and public should be further expanded. In particular, policy support, investment and growth strategies for various local governments such as energy zero science museum research connected with tourism industry per local government and green energy contents research for a smart city of sun, wind, bio, and water should be further expanded Third, as a result of examining the current status and cases of green energy contents in the world, Spain, Denmark, Germany, USA, UAE, etc. are integrating solar energy, wind energy, bio energy and water energy, even presenting it as tourism resources. In Korea, efforts are underway to plan the construction of smart cities by local governments in conjunction with energy zero science museums research and to make it as tourism resources. However, there is a great deal of conflict in the national consensus and the government and politicians need to present the solution for this. Fourth, it is absolutely necessary to develop and - 220 - agree on a policy roadmap for the sequential distribution and replacement on clean green energy sources and be wary of unconditional rejection of high-efficiency energy sources such as nuclear power rising out of concerns for the distribution, investment, and support of clean green energy. Fifth, just as solar energy, wind energy, bio energy, and water energy need to maximize the advantages and disadvantages and symbolic values of each clean energy source, the balanced energy development considering regional characteristics of Korea should be closely connected to the speciali...

A Study on Strategies of Smart Green City - The Priority Analysis and Application of Planning Technique-

이서정,오덕성 한국생태환경건축학회 2015 한국생태환경건축학회 논문집 Vol.15 No.2

Purpose: The goal of this research is to identify the planning techniques of Smart Green City with Ubiquitous method and carbon-neutral city planning techniques and to induce the main planning techniques through the analysis of relative importance and practical adaptation. Method: First of all, eighteen planning techniques were derived and categorized into three organization systems and six sectors through literature review and FGI analysis considering the applicability of Ubiquitous service for carbon-neutral city planning techniques. Secondly, based on expert surveys and AHP analysis, the importance of Smart Green City planning techniques was evaluated. Thirdly, using case study, six cases related to Smart Green City were analyzed for the current status of application of planning techniques. Lastly, considering the importance of planning techniques and practical aspects, the characteristics of Smart Green City and its implication were estimated. Result: Energy, Resource and Waste and Transportation sector were identified as important sectors for Smart Green City. In addition, ‘Construction of Smart Grid’, ‘System for Utilization of New & Renewable Energy’, ‘Smart Resource Circulation Management System’, ‘Establishment of Public Transportation Information System basis’, ‘Construction of Pedestrian / Bicycle oriented Road Environment’ are essential planning techniques to create Smart Green City.

지방자치단체의 저탄소 녹색도시 정책방향 설정에 관한 연구 - 화성시 사례를 중심으로 -

이재준,이원호,김도영 국토지리학회 2011 국토지리학회지 Vol.45 No.2

This study first identifies more than 100 low-carbon green city projects through case studies and literature review so that it can set up the low-carbon green city policy orientation at the local level and apply it to the context of Hwaseong-si, Gyeonggi-do. The study then identifies 15 projects which consist of 5 green structure projects including low-carbon green village construction, 5 green transportation projects including daily bike path and 5 green life projects including eco-friendly local food through the intensive interview of the experts and academic professionals. The 15 projects are suggested with the key concepts, core contents and project locations applicable to the city of Hwaseong, which also reflects the consideration of local situations and the result of local expert interviews. This study has a limitation because it focuses on presenting the policy orientation for low-carbon green city of Hwaseong rather than formulating the concrete project plan for the policy implementation. However, it is of some significance in that this study provides timely policy orientations for realizing the low-carbon green city of Hwaseong in the future. 본 논문은 지방자치단체에서 저탄소 녹색도시 정책방향을 도출하고 이를 경기도 화성시에 적용하기 위한 정책방향 설정을 목적으로 국내외 정책 및 기존문헌 분석을 통해 100여개 저탄소 녹색도시 사업을 추출하였다. 이 후 전문가 인터뷰 등을 통해 저탄소 녹색마을 조성 등 5개의 녹색기반사업, 생활형 자전거 도로 등 5개의 녹색교통사업, 친환경 로컬푸드 등 5개의 녹색생활사업 등 3대 부문, 15개 정책을 도출하였다. 도출된 15개의 저탄소 녹색도시사업은 화성시 여건 및 지역전문가 인터뷰를 반영하여 화성시에 적용가능한 사업개념, 주요내용, 주요위치 등의 정책방향과 적용도면으로 제안하였다. 이러한 분석결과는 화성시의 저탄소 녹색도시 실현을 위한 정책방향을 제시하는데 초점이 맞추어져 있어 실제 정책추진을 위한 사업계획으로서 한계가 있으나, 향후 화성시의 저탄소 녹색도시 추진을 위한 방향을 제시했다는데 그 의미가 있다.

녹색성장을 위한 부동산법제의 과제

강현호(Kang, Hyunho) 한국부동산법학회 2009 不動産法學 Vol.16 No.-

토지를 포함한 부동산법제에 있어서 지금까지의 화두는 ‘지속가능한 발전(sustainable development)’이었다. 그런데 이제는 ‘녹색성장’이라는 단어가 국민 생활의 전 영역에 뿌리를 내리고 있다. 그러나 녹색성장의 실체에 대해서 법학 내지 사법부에서는 보다 냉철한 관점을 견지할 필요가 있다. ‘녹색성장’안에는 엄청난 공권력(öffentliche Gewalt)이 스며들어 있다. 법적인 통제가 없는 경우에는 국민의 기본권에 대한 중대한 침해도 ‘녹색성장’을 위한다는 명목으로 가볍게 덮어버릴 수도 있다. ‘녹색성장’이라는 미명으로 개인의 재산권에 대해서 과도한 침해를 할 수도 있고, 기존의 발전된 법치주의의 통제를 벗어나고자 시도할 수도 있다. 또한 새로운 것처럼 등장하는 ‘녹색성장’이라는 공권력의 실체를 정확하게 파악하여 공권력 행사에 대한 법적 관점 즉 사법적 통제의 관점을 잃어버리면 ‘녹색성장’을 먹고 자라는 ‘녹색독재자’들이 우리 사회를 지배할 수도 있다. 부동산법제는 충돌하는 이해관계를 적정하게 조절하는 기능을 수행하므로, 부동산법제를 논하기 위해서는 무엇보다도 먼저 특정정책과 관련이 있는 다양한 고려요소들에 대한 탐구가 선행되어야 한다. 그런데 “녹색성장을 위한 부동산법제의 과제”에서는 이러한 부동산법제가 추구하는 방향이 바로 녹색성장에 있다는 의미인데, 그러므로 핵심적인 내용이 되어야 할 것은 바로 녹색성장의 의미 내지 내용이다. 녹색성장의 의미에 있어서는 성장에 녹색옷을 입힌 것에 다름이 아니다는 견해도 있고, 녹색성장이 마치 현존하는 모든 문제의 해결사가 되는 듯한 견해도 있다. 그런데 정작 ‘녹색성장’의 의미에 대해서도 모든 문제이해하기가 쉽지 아니하다. 특히 기존의 ‘지속가능한 개발’ 내지‘환경친화적 개발’색성장이개념과 어떻게 구별할 것인가도 문제이다. 아무튼 녹색성장이라는 행정목표와 행정활동에 대해서도 매크로적인 시각에서 보아 법치주의, 형량주의 그리고 절차적 적정성 등과 같은 법리를 여하히 관통시킬 것인가가 과제이다. 또한 마이크로적인 시각으로서 행정조직적인 측면에서의 기구의 통일성의 문제, 토지이용계획제도의 정비, 적절한 지원행정, 그리고 현실적인 보상문제를 여하히 해결할 것인가가 주요한 과제들이다. Green Growth is a mode for our country. After the announcement of President Lee Myungbak became the word ‘green’ more popular among the people in the country. From the viewpoint of the real estate law system, there are various missions for green growth. At the first time we need the clearance of the various definitions about green growth, because the countermeasure depends on the contents of green growth. There are many organizations, which define the meaning of green growth. According to those definitions we can find the key words like environment, preservation, green technology, job opportunities, competitiveness in the world. For the pursuit of green growth there are various activities of administrative branches. It is thought to build ecological city, compact city, green way, green high way, green road and also to establish zones for green city. From the point of administrative law we can divide the approach in two ways, the first from macro dimention and the second from micro dimention. First of all the spirit of rule of law must reign over green growth. The main content of rule of law is that the agency has to administer governmental actions according to the law and the law only can provide the agency with the power to intervene the rights of the people. Because of the character of the activities of administrative branches in the area of green growth it is not easy to adapt the rule of law in green growth. The agencies create many concrete guidelines for the matter, but there are few methods to control them. There are also problems of the value conflictions in the process of green growth. Green growth has various values in itself like environmental preservation, peace, happiness on one hand, growth, job, competitiveness on the other hand. These values have their own directions, therefore it is very difficult to adjust them, even to control the activities. In details there are also many works to organize green growth in the administrative branches, to create proper land use planning system, to support the activities rationally and to compensate the sacrifice of the people. For green growth there are many works, which are helpful and effective. We have confidence to reach the goal of green growth, if we go on steadily.

저탄소 녹색도시를 위한 태양에너지 이용 선진사례 조사

김지수(Kim Ji-Su),이응직(Lee Eung-Jik),이충식(Lee Chung-Sik) 한국태양에너지학회 2009 한국태양에너지학회 학술대회논문집 Vol.- No.-

We are in search for many method at 21th century thinking about the environment internationally. One is among them low carbon green city. Consequently this dissertation put a system solar energy key point of low carbon green city and purpose of low carbon green city Besides system and technique about the solar energy best practices try to do the investigation analysis. It's important of low carbon green city's environmental friendly system such as solar heat system, solar power generation, ecological greening, All these systems are connected each other and organize low carbon green city. A solar energy system uses pure energy of the situation directly most among the environmental friendly system. Energy saving and environment-friendly city in the world must do not a choice. However, recognition conversion and infrastructure of the Korea still has not come true. But South Korea and the international best practices is not the same system. But plan to solar city, the concept of green city in Cheongju, Deagu local government. And many meetings are in progress.

개발제한구역 내 도시의 지속가능한 개발을 위한 연구

정재용(Chung, Jae-Yong),오민준(Oh, Min-Jun) 한국산학기술학회 2011 한국산학기술학회논문지 Vol.12 No.12

본 연구는 지속가능한 개발을 위한 컴팩트시티형 도시개발의 기본전략과 계획요소를 도출하여 개발제한구역 내 도시들의 개발사업들을 분석하고자 하였다. 분석을 통해 얻은 결과는 다음과 같다. 첫째, 20세기 후반부터 선진국 들은 컴팩트시티를 지속가능한 도시개발의 기준으로 삼고, 세부적인 도시개발계획을 추진하였다. 둘째, 이와 같은 지 속가능한 컴팩트시티형 도시개발은 지속가능한 개발과 컴팩트시티 이론을 바탕으로 하며, 이 개발계획을 도시공간, 도시환경, 도시커뮤니티, 도시관리로 구분하여 계획요소를 도출하였다. 이를 바탕으로 개발제한구역 내 적용가능한 요 소를 산정하고 컴팩트시티와의 관련 유형으로 분류하였다. 셋째, 과천, 의왕, 하남의 개발제한구역 내 다수의 개발계 획들을 지속가능한 컴팩트시티형 도시개발과 비교해본 결과 유사점과 한계를 볼 수 있다. 이에 본 연구에서 분석한 바를 고려하여, 앞으로 개발제한구역 내 도시개발사업에 있어서 지속가능한 컴팩트시티형 도시개발의 정책적인 반영 이 필요하다. This study suggests Compact City type urban development strategies and planning elements with the purpose of sustainable development. The suggestions are based on analysis of the development projects promoted in the cities within Green-Belt. Following are the findings of this study: First, in the late 20th century, Compact-City has been suggested as standard of sustainable urban development in the developed countries, and this promoted urban development plans were presented in detail. Second, The development plans are suggested plan elements by urban environment, space, community, and management. It was classified as an applicable element in Green belt and Compact City type. Finally, after comparing several city development projects (Gwacheon, Uiwang, Hanam), differences and Limitations between the Compact-City type urban development. Considering analysis of this study, urban development projects in Green Belt should be prepared to sustainable Compact city type urban development.