Effect of Metal Chloride Solutions on Coloration and Biaxial Flexural Strength of Yttria-Stabilized Zirconia

오계정,Kwangmin Lee,이도재,Hyun-Pil Lim,Kwi-Dug Yun,Jae-Sam Ban,Kyung-Ku Lee,존피셔,박상원 대한금속·재료학회 2012 METALS AND MATERIALS International Vol.18 No.5

The effect of three kinds of transition metal dopants on the color and biaxial flexural strength of zirconia ceramics for dental applications was evaluated. Presintered zirconia discs were colored through immersion in aqueous chromium, molybdenum and vanadium chloride solutions and then sintered at 1450 °C. The color of the doped specimens was measured using a digital spectrophotometer. For biaxial flexural strength measurements, specimens infiltrated with 0.3 wt% of each aqueous chloride solution were used. Uncolored discs were used as a control. Zirconia specimens infiltrated with chromium, molybdenum and vanadium chloride solutions were dark brown, light yellow and dark yellow, respectively. CIE L*,a*, and b* values of all the chromium-doped specimens and the specimens infiltrated with 0.1 wt% molybdenum chloride solution were in the range of values for natural teeth. The biaxial flexural strengths of the three kinds of metal chloride groups were similar to the uncolored group. These results suggest that chromium and molybdenum dopants can be used as colorants to fabricate tooth colored zirconia ceramic restorations.

크롬염화물 첨가에 따른 지르코니아 색상 및 물리적 성질 변화에 관한 연구

오계정,서윤정,윤귀덕,임현필,박상원,이경구,임태관,이도재,Oh, Gye-Jeong,Seo, Yoon-Jeong,Yun, Kwi-Dug,Lim, Hyun-Pil,Park, Sang-Won,Lee, Kyung-Ku,Lim, Tae-Kwan,Lee, Doh-Jae 대한치과보철학회 2011 대한치과보철학회지 Vol.49 No.2

연구 목적: 본 연구의 목적은 색소체인 크롬염화물을 지르코니아에 첨가함으로써 지르코니아의 색상 및 물리적 성질, 그리고 미세구조가 어떻게 변화하는지 알아보고자 한다. 연구 재료 및 방법: 크롬염화물의 함량이 지르코니아 분말에 각각 0.06, 0.12, 0.25 wt%가 되도록 측량하고 알코올에 녹여 액상상태의 크롬염화물을 준비하였다. 지르코니아 분말과 각각의 액상상태의 크롬염화물을 혼합하고 혼합된 분말을 이용하여 디스크형태의 지르코니아 시편을 제작하였다. 제작된 시편은 $1450^{\circ}C$에서 완전소결 후 색상 및 물리적 성질, 그리고 미세구조를 관찰하였다. 색상은 분광측색장치를 이용하여 국제조명위원회 (CIE) ISO 기준인 D65 광원, SCE 방식으로 측정하여 $L^*$, $C^*$, $a^*$, $b^*$ 값으로 분석하였다. 밀도는 아르키메데스 법으로 측정하였고, 주사전자현미경과 X선 회절 분석기를 이용하여 시편의 미세구조 및 결정상을 관찰하였다. 파괴인성은 압흔 형성법(Vickers indentation법)을 이용하여 시편에 압흔 형성 후, 광학현미경으로 압흔의 크기를 측정하고 이를 이용하여 파괴인성을 구하였다. 결과는 일원배치분산분석 (one-way ANOVA)으로 통계처리 하였고, Tukey test로 사후 검정하였다. 결과: 1. 크롬염화물을 첨가하여 지르코니아의 색상을 조절할 수 있음을 확인하였으며, 크롬염화물 첨가 함량이 증가함에 따라 지르코니아 색상은 백색계통의 갈색에서 짙은 색의 갈색으로 변하였다. 2. 크롬염화물의 첨가는 시편의 밀도를 점점 감소시켰으며, 크롬염화물이 첨가되지 않은 시편과 비교 시, 크롬염화물의 첨가량이 증가할수록 통계학적으로 유의한 차이를 보였다 (P<.05). 3. 크롬염화물이 첨가된 시편은 첨가되지 않는 시편에 비해 결정립 크기가 증가하였다. 4. X-선 회절 분석결과, 크롬염화물의 첨가 여부와 첨가 함량에 상관없이 지르코니아 결정상의 차이점은 관찰되지 않았다. 5. 지르코니아에 크롬염화물을 첨가 시 크롬염화물의 첨가 함량에 따라 파괴인성값은 감소하였고, 특히 0.25 wt%의 크롬염화물을 첨가 시 가장 낮은 파괴인성 값을 보였다 (P<.05). 결론: 이상의 결과로 크롬염화물을 액체상태로 첨가하여 지르코니아의 색상을 조절할 수 있음을 확인하였으며, 제작한 유색 지르코니아의 색상은 자연치아 색상과 다소 차이가 있지만, 본 소재는 임상에서 사용되는 완전도재관 코어 (Core) 재료로써 사용할 수 있을 것으로 생각한다. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to examine the effects of chromium chloride addition on coloration, mechanical property and microstructure of 3Y-TZP. Materials and methods: Chromium chloride was weighed as 0.06, 0.12, and 0.25 wt% and each measured amount was dissolved in alcohol. $ZrO_2$ powder was mixed with each of the individual slurry to prepare chromium doped zirconia specimen. The color, physical properties and microstructure were observed after the zirconia specimen were sintered at $1450^{\circ}C$. In order to evaluate the color, spectrophotometer was used to analyze the value of $L^*$, $C^*$, $a^*$ and $b^*$, after placing the specimen on a white plate, and measured according to the International Commission on Illumination (CIE) standard, Illuminant D65 and SCE system. The density was measured in the Archimedes method, while microstructures were evaluated by using the scanning electron microscopy (SEM) and XRD. Fracture toughness was calculated Vickers indentation method and indentation size was measured by using the optical microscope. The data were analyzed with 1-way ANOVA test (${\alpha}$ = 0.05). The Tukey multiple comparison test was used for post hocanalysis. Results: 1. Chromium chloride rendered zirconia a brownish color. While chromium chloride content was increased, the color of zirconia was changed from brownish to brownish-red. 2. Chromium chloride content was increased; density of the specimen was decreased. 3. More chromium chloride in the ratio showed increase size of grains. 4. But the addition of chromium chloride did not affect the crystal phase of zirconia, and all specimens showed tetragonal phase. 5. The chromium chloride in zirconia did not showed statistically significant difference in fracture toughness, but addition of 0.25 wt% showed a statistically significant difference (P<.05). Conclusion: Based on the above results, this study suggests that chromium chlorides can make colored zirconia while adding in a liquid form. The new colored zirconia showed a slight difference in color to that of the natural tooth, nevertheless this material can be used as an all ceramic core material.

수종의 색소체용액으로 제작된 유색 지르코니아의 색조비교

오계정,정종현 대한치과기공학회 2014 대한치과기공학회지 Vol.36 No.4

Purpose: The aim of this study was to evaluate the effect of colored zirconia with different coloring liquids. Methods: Total 30 specimens were prepared. Specimens were classified into 6 groups: IPS e.max Ceram(P), Uncolored zirconia(C), VITA In-Ceram 2000 YZ LL1(L), Zirkonzahn coloring liquid(Z), Wieland coloring liquid(W), and Kuwotech coloring liquid(K). Four different types of zirconia coloring liquid, VITA In-Ceram 2000 YZ LL1(VITA Zahnfabrik, Germany), Zirkonzahn coloring liquid(Zirkonzahn, Italy), Wieland coloring liquid(Wieland, Germany), Kuwotech coloring liquid(Kuwotech, Korea) were used to fabricate colored zirconia by using infiltrating method and then completely sintered. The color of the all specimens was measured using the spectrophotometer(CM-2600d, Konica Minolta, Japan) and expressed in terms of the 3-coordinated values (CIE L*a*b*). Color differences were calculated using the equation ΔE*= [(ΔL*)2+(Δa*)2+(Δb*)2]1/2. Results: L*a*b* values of the colored zirconia were affected by the coloring liquids. The uncolored zirconia(C) group showed the highest L* value and zirkonzahn coloring liquid(Z) group showed the lowest L* value. Zirkonzahn coloring liquid(Z) showed the highest a* value and VITA In-Ceram 2000 YZ LL1(L) group showed the highest b* value. Generally, the color difference(ΔE*) in all groups showed higher than 3.7 except between IPS e.max Ceram(P) and wieland coloring liquid(W) group. Conclusion: Within the limitations of this study, various coloring liquids influenced the L*, a*, and b* values of colored zirconia. IPS e.max Ceram(P) and wieland coloring liquid(W) group did not show clinically perceiving color difference.

납형의 크기와 형태가 티타늄의 주조성에 미치는 영향

서윤정,오계정,이효일,신유진,김홍주,박상원,Seo, Yoon-Jeong,Oh, Gye-Jeong,Lee, Hyo-Il,Shin, Yoo-Jin,Kim, Hong-Joo,Park, Sang-Won 대한치과보철학회 2013 대한치과보철학회지 Vol.51 No.4

연구 목적: 본 연구는 납형의 크기 및 형태 변화가 티타늄의 주조성에 어떠한 영향을 미치는지 확인하고자 하였다. 연구 재료 및 방법: 납형의 크기에 따라 Small Pattern군과 Large Pattern군으로 나누었고, 각각 Flat, Semicircular, Horse-shoe 및 V-shape형으로 납형의 형태에 따라 4개의 하위군으로 나누어 총 8개의 군으로 분류하였다. 모든 납형의 주입선은 Runner-bar형으로 하였다. 티타늄 주조 전용 매몰재인 실리카계 매몰재(Rematitan Plus$^{(R)}$, Dentarum, Germany)를 이용하여 매몰하였고, 아크용융 방식의 원심 주조기(Ti Cast Super R$^{(R)}$, Selec, Japan)를 사용하여 주조하였다. 주조성 평가는 완전한 형태로 주조 된 격자의 개수를 척도로 재현 정도를 확인하였다. 통계처리는 SPSS ver. 19.0 for WIN (SPSS. Inc. Chicago, IL, USA)를 사용하였다. 납형의 크기 및 형태에 따른 티타늄의 주조성을 이원변량 분산분석(Two-way ANOVA)을 이용하여 분석하였다. 결과:납형의 평균 재현율은 Small Pattern군은 95.14%, Large Pattern군은 94.30%로 Small Pattern군의 주조성이 유의하게 높았다(P<.05). 납형의 형태 변화에 따른 주조성은 Small Pattern군에서 Semicircular군 133.20개(96.52%), Horse-shoe군 132.40개(95.94%), Flat군 132.00개(95.65%), V-shape군 127.60개(92.46%) 순으로 감소하였다. Large Pattern군은 Flat군 198.60개(95.94%), V-shape군 197.80개(95.56%), Semicircular군 196.40개(94.88%), Horse-shoe군 188.00개(90.82%)순으로 감소하였다. Small Pattern군과 Large Pattern군 모두에서 납형의 형태변화에 따른 주조성은 유의할 만한 차이를 보이지 않았다(P>.05). 결론:주조체의 크기가 작을수록 주조성이 높아짐을 알 수 있었고 형태에 따른 주조성에서는 큰 영향을 받지 않는 것을 알 수 있었다. Purpose: The purpose of this study was to investigate the effect of geometrically different wax pattern shapes and sizes on the castability of Grade2 Cp-Ti (commercially pure titanium). Materials and methods: Total of 40 mesh wax pattern ($61mm{\times}24mm$, 207 grids), ($61mm{\times}17mm$, 138 grids) was cast in this experiment. Depending on the geometrical shape of the wax pattern, 8 groups was organized; Flat, Semicircular, Horse-shoe and V-shape, each consisting 5 samples. Runner-bar sprue was used in all patterns. The number of completely cast grid in wax pattern served as a measure for the castability of comercially pure titanium. Results: The mean value of square count in each group was as followed; 133.20 squares in group SS (96.52%), 132.40 squares in group SH (95.94%), 132.00 squares in group SF (95.65%), 127.60 squares in SV (91.43%), 198.60 squares in group LF (95.94%), 197.80 squares in group LV (95.56%), 196.40 squares in group LS (94.88%), and 188.00 squares in group LH (90.82%). Conclusion: Within the limitations of this study the results indicate that there were no sttistically significant difference in castability of titanium regarding wax pattern shape (P>.05). However, Small size wax patterns were showing the noticeable castability more than Large size pattern.

색소체용액 침투가 지르코니아 및 전장용 세라믹의 전단결합강도에 미치는 영향

정종현,오계정 대한치과기공학회 2016 대한치과기공학회지 Vol.38 No.4

Purpose:This study was to evaluate the effect of coloring liquids on the shear bond strength between zirconia and veneering ceramic. Methods: Zirconia(15 mm in diameter, 2.5 mm in thickness; n=40) used in the experiment were divided into 5 groups depending on the coloring liquid. Each specimen were polished using a polishing machine(LaboPol-2,Struers, UK). A cylinder of veneering porcelain(6 mm in diameter, 3 mm in thickness) was fabricated and fired on zirconia surfaces. The shear bond strength was measured using a universal testing machine(Model 4302, Instron,USA). All data were analyzed statistically using a one-way ANOVA and Tukey s multiple comparisons test. After the shear bond test, fracture surfaces were examined by SEM. Results: Colored zirconia showed a higher shear bonding strength than that of uncolored zirconia except for colored zirconia immersed in Zirkonzahn coloring liquid. In particular, colored zirconia immersed in Kuwotech coloring liquid showed the highest shear bond strength. After the shear bond test, mixed failure patterns were mainly observed in the failure between zirconia and veneering ceramic. Conclusion: Coloring liquid enhanced the shear bond strength zirconia and veneering ceramic than uncolored zirconia.

벼 재배 시 녹비작물 헤어리베치의 부분경운 파종 효과

전원태,성기영,오계정,조현숙,정광호,오인석,박성태,김충국,강위금 한국작물학회 2010 한국작물학회 학술발표대회 논문집 Vol.2010 No.04

녹비작물 재배는 작부체계상 토양의 건전성(soil quality) 향상과 농업생태계의 지속성(substantiality) 유지에 중요한 역할을 한다. 본시험의 목적은 답리작에서 녹비작물 헤어리베치 (Vicia Villosa R.)의 재배 및 벼 이용 시 안전성을 증진하기 위하여 수행하였다. 시험은 2006/2007년부터 2008/2009년까지 3개년간 포장에서 수행 하였다. 시험포장은 경기도 수원시 소재 국립식량과학원 벼 시험포장인 신흥통(식양질)에서 수행하였다. 헤어 리베치는 중국에서 수입한 H-1을 10월 상순경에 벼 부분경운파종기를 이용하여 파종하였다. 벼 품종은 중생 종인 풍미벼(‘07, ’08)와 조생종인 운광벼(‘09)로 25~30일묘를 6월 상순에 기계이앙하였다. 시험 기간 3년 모두 부분경운파종 시 헤어리베치의 biomass 및 질소 생산성은 벼 입모중파종과 유의적인 차이는 없었고 벼 수량도 차이가 없었다. 또한 2008/2009년에는 부분경운 파종 시 파종량 9 kg/10a와 6 kg/10a도 헤어리베치 biomass와 쌀수량이 유의적 차이가 없었다. 따라서 답리작에서 부분경운파종법을 이용하면 녹비작물 헤어리 베치의 재배 및 벼 이용의 안전성 뿐만아니라 녹비작물의 종자대 절약도 가능할 것으로 판단되었다.

한국 유치악 성인의 상악 중절치 위치 및 견치간 거리에 관한 연구

양동헌,이지윤,반재삼,오계정,박상원,Yang, Dong-Hun,Lee, Jee-Yun,Ban, Jae-Sam,Oh, Gye-Jeong,Park, Sang-Won 대한치과보철학회 2013 대한치과보철학회지 Vol.51 No.3

연구 목적: 이 연구는 정상배열을 가지고 있는 한국 유치악 성인에서 얼굴형과 성별에 따라 절치유두를 기준으로 한 상악전치의 위치와 견치폭경 계측치를 제시한다. 연구 대상 및 방법: 전남대학교 치의학 전문대학원에 다니는 학생 중 crowding 및 spacing이 없으며, Angles Class I의 정상 교합관계를 가지고 있는 42명을 대상으로 조사하였다. 선정된 학생들의 두부 측면 방사선 사진을 찍고, posterior facial height (PFH)과 anterior facial height (AFH)을 측정하여 PFH / AFH%를 구하여 cephalic type을 나누었다. 그 후 42명의 상악 모형을 준비하여 버니어캘리퍼스로 상악 중절치 절단연에서 절치 유두 중앙까지의 수평거리(A)와 상악 견치간 거리(B)를 계측, 평균값을 구하였으며, SPSS version 15를 사용하여 통계분석 및 유의성을 검토하였다. 결과: Dolichocephalic type을지닌10명에서A의 평균값은 $8.43{\pm}0.61$, B의 평균값은 $36.73{\pm}2.17$으로 나타났다. Mesocephalic type과 brachycephalic type의경우각각A의평균값은 $8.51{\pm}1.27$, $8.76{\pm}1.03$, B의 평균값은 $35.91{\pm}1.86$, $37.34 {\pm}2.23$로 나타났다. 성별에 따른 계측 결과 남성에서A의 평균값은 $8.86{\pm}1.04$, B의 평균값은 $37.60{\pm}0.24$으로 나타났으며, 여성에서A의 평균값은 $8.41{\pm}0.93$, B의 평균값은 $36.18{\pm}2.01$로 나타났다. A값의 경우 남성이 여성보다 큰 값을 보였으나 그 차이는 통계적으로 유의하지 않았다(P>.05). B값의 경우 남성이 여성보다 큰 값을 보였으며, 통계적으로 유의성을 나타내었다 (P<.05). 결론:한국에서 정상 치열 및 교합을 가진 평균 연령 30세, 42명의 학생을 대상으로 조사하였을 때, 절치유두에서 상악 중절치 절단연까지의 수평 거리는 cephalic type이나 성별에 따른 차이가 없었고, 견치 교두정간 거리는 cephalic type에 따른 차이가 없었지만, 성별에 따라 유의한 차이를 보였으며 남성이 여성보다 큰 값을 나타냈다. Purpose: The aim of this study was to propose the position of maxillary anterior teeth and intercanine width measurements based on the incisive papilla in accordance with the cephalic type and gender of dentate Korean adult with normal teeth alignment. Materials and methods: 42 students with Class I normal occlusion, without crowding or spacing, were selected from the Chonnam National University School of Dentistry. The lateral skull radiographs of the subjects were taken and were classified as different cephalic types, based on their PFH / AFH ratios. 42 casts of their maxilla were prepared and both the distance between the upper central incisors and the middle of the incisor papilla was measured with a vernier caliper (A) and the distance between the maxillary canine cusp tips (B) were measured. Statistical analysis was performed using SPSS version 15 and their significance was investigated. Results: For dolichocephalic group, the mean values for A and B were 8.43 (SD: 0.61) and 36.73 (SD: 2.17), respectively. The mean value for A was 8.51 (SD: 1.27) for the mesocephalic group and 8.76 (SD 1.03) for the brachycephalic group. The mean value for B was 35.91 (SD: 1.86) for the mesocephalic group and 37.34 (SD: 2.23) for the brachycephalic group. For the male group, the mean A value was 8.86 (SD: 1.04) and the mean B value was 37.60 (SD: 0.24). For the female group, the mean A value was 8.41 (SD: 0.93) and the mean B value was 36.18 (SD: 2.01). The difference between male and female group in A values were not statistically significant (P>.05). The B values of the male subjects were greater than those of the female subjects and was statistically significant (P<.05). Conclusion: 42 students with normal dentition and occlusion in korea, the distance from the incisive papilla and the incisal edge of maxillary central incisors had no difference in cephalic type or gender. However, the distance between the cusp tip of both canines had significant difference in gender where the male showed higher values than the female, while having no difference in cephalic types.

Evaluation of marginal fit of 2 CAD-CAM anatomic contour zirconia crown systems and lithium disilicate glass-ceramic crown

지민경,박지희,박상원,윤귀덕,오계정,임현필 대한치과보철학회 2015 The Journal of Advanced Prosthodontics Vol.7 No.4

PURPOSE. This study was to evaluate the marginal fit of two CAD-CAM anatomic contour zirconia crown systems compared to lithium disilicate glass-ceramic crowns. MATERIALS AND METHODS. Shoulder and deep chamfer margin were formed on each acrylic resin tooth model of a maxillary first premolar. Two CAD-CAM systems (Prettau®Zirconia and ZENOSTAR®ZR translucent) and lithium disilicate glass ceramic (IPS e.max®press) crowns were made (n=16). Each crown was bonded to stone dies with resin cement (Rely X Unicem). Marginal gap and absolute marginal discrepancy of crowns were measured using a light microscope equipped with a digital camera (Leica DFC295) magnified by a factor of 100. Two-way analysis of variance (ANOVA) and posthoc Tukey’'s HSD test were conducted to analyze the significance of crown marginal fit regarding the finish line configuration and the fabrication system. RESULTS. The mean marginal gap of lithium disilicate glass ceramic crowns (IPS e.max®press) was significantly lower than that of the CAD-CAM anatomic contour zirconia crown system (Prettau®Zirconia) (P<.05). Both fabrication systems and finish line configurations significantly influenced the absolute marginal discrepancy (P<.05). CONCLUSION. The lithium disilicate glass ceramic crown (IPS e.max®press) had significantly smaller marginal gap than the CAD-CAM anatomic contour zirconia crown system (Prettau®Zirconia). In terms of absolute marginal discrepancy, the CAD-CAM anatomic contour zirconia crown system (ZENOSTAR®ZR translucent) had under-extended margin, whereas the CAD-CAM anatomic contour zirconia crown system (Prettau®Zirconia) and lithium disilicate glass ceramic crowns (IPS e.max®press) had overextended margins.

타이타늄 표면 코팅이 도재 결합에 미치는 영향

김연미,김현승,이광민,이도재,오계정,임현필,서윤정,박상원,Kim, Yeon-Mi,Kim, Hyun-Seung,Lee, Kwang-Min,Lee, Doh-Jae,Oh, Gye-Jeong,Lim, Hyun-Pil,Seo, Yoon-Jung,Park, Sang-Won 대한치과보철학회 2007 대한치과보철학회지 Vol.45 No.5

Statement of problem: The adhesion between titanium and ceramic is less optimal than conventional metal-ceramic bonding, due to reaction layer form on cast titanium surface during porcelain firing. Purpose: This study characterized the effect of titanium-ceramic adhesion after gold and TiN coating on cast and wrought titanium substrates. Material and method: Six groups of ASTM grade II commercially pure titanium and cast titanium specimens$(13mm{\times}13mm{\times}1mm)$ were prepared(n=8). The conventional Au-Pd-In alloy served as the control. All specimens were sandblasted with $110{\mu}m\;Al_2O_3$ particles and ultrasonically cleaned for 5min in deionized water and dried in air before porcelain firing. An ultra-low-fusing dental porcelain (Vita Titankeramik) was fused on titanium surfaces. Porcelain was debonded by a biaxial flexure test at a cross head speed of 0.25mm/min. The excellent titanium-ceramic adherence was exhibited by the presence of a dentin porcelain layer on the specimen surface after the biaxial flexure test. Area fraction of adherent porcelain (AFAP) was determined by SEM/EDS. Numerical results were statistically analyzed by one-way ANOVA and Student-Newman-Keuls test at ${\alpha}=0.05$. Results: The AFAP value of cast titanium was greatest in the group 2 with TiN coating, followed by group 1 with Au coating and the group 3 with $Al_2O_3$ sandblasting. Significant statistical difference was found between the group 1, 2 and the group 3 (p<.05). The AFAP value of wrought titanium was greatest in the group 5 with TiN coating, followed by the group 4 with Au coating and the group 6 with $Al_2O_3$ sandblasting. Conclusion: No significant difference was observed among the three groups (p>.05). The AFAP values of the cast titanium and the wrought titanium were similar. However the group treated with $Al_2O_3$ sandblasting showed significantly lower value (p<.05).

녹비작물 헤어리베치(Vicia villosa)의 재배방법에 따른 녹비생산성 및 토양물리성 변화

전원태,성기영,김민태,이종기,오계정,오영미,구자환,오인석 한국작물학회 2008 한국작물학회 학술발표대회 논문집 Vol.2008 No.10

녹비작물은 농업생산의 건전성과 지속성 유지를 위하여 작부체계내의 재배기술이 중요하다. 특히 두과 녹비작물인 헤어리베치는 공중질소를 고정할 뿐만 아니라 생초 생산력과 질소함량이 높아서 생물비료로써는 높은 효과를 가지고 있다. 본시험은 이러한 효과를 가진 헤어리베치의 답리작에서 안전성을 구명하고자 파종방법별 녹비생산력 및 토양 이화학성의 변화를 구명하고 수행하였다. 시험장소는 경기도 수원시 서둔동 국립식량과학원 벼 시험포장에서 벼 수확 후 답리작으로 시험을 수행하였다. 시험토양은 신흥통으로 식양질이었고, 헤어리베치는 중국에서 도입한 H-1을 파종하였다. 파종방법은 벼 입모중 파종과 벼수확 후 부분경운파종 및 세조파를 하였다. 입모중파종과 부분경운파종이 세조파에 비하여 녹비 생산성이 우수하였고 토양물리성도 개선되는 경향이었다.