시스템 다이내믹스를 이용한 킬체인 체계 전투기 할당 문제에 관한 연구

정병기 ( Jung Byungki ) 한국시스템다이내믹스학회 2017 한국시스템다이내믹스 연구 Vol.18 No.3

This paper analyzes an effects of the initial allocation ratio of attack aircraft for the performance of Kill Chain systems (KC) which are built to deal with the threat of North Korea’s nuclear and ballistic missiles. The Lanchester’s combat models which are commonly used in war games are used to establish engagement between aircraft and air defense systems (AD), and aircraft and transporter-erector-launcher (TEL), i.e. KC attack. The system dynamics are used to determine dynamic decision making of aircraft allocation between AD and KC attack. To maximize the performance of KC, it is essential to allocate minimum but sufficient amount of AD attack aircraft to ensure the survivability of aircraft, and the rest of all are allocated to KC attack. If the number of total aircraft are increased, the optimal allocation ratio of KC attack aircraft will be increased either. This paper applies relatively simple combat situation, so it is needed to consider more realistic battle environment and decision making process of aircraft allocation for the future study.

TFDEA를 이용한 무인항공기 기술예측에 관한 연구

정병기(Byungki Jung),김현철(H. C. Kim),이춘주(Choonjoo Lee) 한국기술혁신학회 2016 기술혁신학회지 Vol.19 No.4

무인항공기는 현대 전장 환경에서 감시정찰을 위한 필수요소이며, 전장의 복잡성과 불확실성이 증가함에 따라 그 중요성은 더욱 커지고 있다. 본 연구에서는 1982년부터 2014년까지 개발된 96대의 군용무인항공기를 대상으로 비모수적이며 비통계적 기술예측 방법인 TFDEA를 이용한 기술예측을 실시하였다. 2001년에 최초로 소개된 이후 Inman 외(2006) 등은 TFDEA가 SOA 분석에서 회귀분석과 같은 전통적인 계량방법론보다 예측력이 우수함을 실증하였다. 본 연구에서는 무인항공기에 대한 기술예측결과 연간 평균기술변화율이 4.06%로 향상되었으며, 개발된 대부분의 무인항공기는 첨단기술 프론티어(SOA) 보다 낮은 수준이었다. 이는 무인항공기를 개발하는 대부분의 국가가 기술적으로 중진국이고, 기술적 선진국인 북미와 유럽의 국가들이 세계 무인항공기 시장의 60% 이상을 장악하고 있다는 것에 기인한다고 볼 수 있다. 본 연구는 TFDEA의 적용분야를 미래체계로서 관심의 대상인 무인화 기술개발 분야로 확대하여 기술혁신의 특성을 분석함으로써 미래 무인항공기의 개발과 기술발전에 관한 기술예측의 기법으로서 적용가능성을 확인하였다. 특히 군의 작전요구성능과 연구개발관리에 필요한 정량적 지표를 설정하는데 활용할 수 있을 것으로 평가된다. Unmanned Aerial Vehicles (UAVs) are essential systems for Intelligence, Surveillance, and Reconnaissance (ISR) operations in current battlespace. And its importance will be getting extended because of complexity and uncertainty of battlespace. In this study, we forecast the advancement of 96 UAVs during the period of 32 years from 1982 to 2014 using TFDEA. TFDEA is a quantitative technology forecasting method which is characterized as non-parametric and non-statistical mathematical programming. Inman et al. (2006) showed that TFDEA is more accurate in forecasting compared with classical econometrics (e.g. regression). This study got 4.06% point of annual technological rate of change (RoC) for UAVs by applying TFDEA. And most UAVs in the period are inefficient according to the global SOA frontiers. That is because the countries which develop UAVs are in the middle class of technological level, so more than 60% of world UAVs markets are shared by North America and Europe which are advanced countries in terms of technological maturity level. This study could give some insights for UAVs development and its advancement. And also can be used for evaluating the adequacy of Required Operational Capability (ROC) of suggested future systems and managing the progress of Research and Development (R&D).

합동성을 고려한 한국형 항공모함의 임무 수행능력 분석

정병기(Byungki Jung),김기태(Kitae Kim),박성제(Sungje Park) 한국해군과학기술학회 2022 Journal of the KNST Vol.5 No.2

ROK Navy is securing a Korean-type aircraft carrier, and quantitative analysis using scientific·systematic methods is required to form a consensus based on clear recognition. In this study, the mission performance (diversity) of Korean-type aircraft carrier considering jointness was quantitatively analyzed using Forced Decision Matrix Method. The Korean-type aircraft carrier(CVX) equipped with stealth fighters(F-35B) had the best mission performance at 0.250. It was 1.05 - 2.50 times better than other assets such as aegis destroyer (DDG), 3,000-ton class submarine(KSS-III), stealth fighter(F-35A), ballistic missile(Hyeonmu-4). In addition, the mission performance of CVX and DDG was highly calculated, It was confirmed that the characteristics of naval power were sufficiently expressed.

무기체계 단위비용을 고려한 K2 체계의 효과분석 방법 연구

정병기,Jung, Byungki 한국시뮬레이션학회 2017 한국시뮬레이션학회 논문지 Vol.26 No.2

본 연구는 무기체계의 단위비용을 고려한 K2(KC와 KAMD) 체계의 효과분석을 수행하였다. 단일 KC와 다중(고층 및 저층) KAMD를 가정하고, 각 체계에 임의의 무기체계를 설정하여 각각의 조합에 따라 총 12개의 시나리오를 작성하였다. 효과도는 전체 탄도미사일 위협 수량 대비 감소된 탄도미사일 위협의 비율로 정의하였으며, 비용은 발사된 무장의 수량과 단위비용으로 계산하였다. K2 체계의 효과도와 총비용은 몬테카를로 시뮬레이션을 1,000번 반복하여 추정하였다. 각각의 시나리오를 대안으로 하여 비용대 효과분석을 실시하였고, 효과고정법을 사용하여 최적 대안을 선정하였다. 연구 결과 KC 능력이 K2 체계의 방어 효과와 총비용을 결정하는 가장 중요한 요소였으며, 적정 수준의 저층방어체계를 갖춰야 요구되는 방어 효과를 달성할 수 있음을 확인하였다. 향후 연구에서 실질적인 무기체계 제원과 수명주기비용을 고려한 비용대 효과분석이 이루진다면 더욱 현실적인 분석이 가능할 것이다. This paper analyses the effectiveness of Kill Chain (KC) and Korea Air and Missile Defense (KAMD), also known as the K2 systems, using monte carlo simulation. It is assumed that the K2 systems are consisted with unitary KC and multi-layered (upper-tier and lower-tier) KAMD. And each system has two or three arbitrary weapon systems and its combination makes 12 scenarios. Measures of effectiveness (MOE) of the K2 systems were defined as ratio of eliminated ballistic missiles from total threats. And total cost was calculated by number of weapon launched and its unit cost. MOE and total cost of the K2 systems were estimated using monte carlo simulation with a thousand iteration for each scenario. Cost-effectiveness analysis was performed and the best candidate was selected using fixed effectiveness approach. As a result, the performances of KC are prime factor that affects both effectiveness and total cost of the K2 systems. It is also, acquired proper level of lower-tier KAMD to achieve desired defense effectiveness. For future work, it needs to be performed cost-effectiveness analysis based on practical specification and life cycle cost of weapon systems.

국가 역량을 고려한 효율성 기반 한국형 항공모함 규모 최적화 연구

정병기,김기태,박성제,Jung, Byungki,Kim, Kitae,Park, Sungje 한국산업경영시스템학회 2022 한국산업경영시스템학회지 Vol.45 No.3

ROK Navy intends to secure the Korean-type aircraft carrier in order to effectively prepare for various future security threats. In general, the Korean national competency is considered to be at the level of having an aircraft carrier, but it is unclear what scale aircraft carrier would be appropriate. In this study, the efficiency was evaluated through the relative comparison between national competency(national power, economic power) and the scale of aircraft carriers, and the optimal scale of the Korean-type aircraft carrier that could be acquired was presented. A DEA(Data Envelopment Analysis) model was applied to aircraft carriers(19 aircraft carriers in 11 countries) currently in operation and scheduled to be possessed in the world. As input variables, CINC(Composite Index of National Capability) and GDP(Gross Domestic Product), which are the most widely used as indicators of national and economic power, and as output variables, the full-load displacement, length, and width of aircraft carriers were selected. ARIMA(short-term within 5 years) and simple regression(long-term over 5 years) were used to estimate the future national competency of each country at the time of aircraft carriers acquisition. The relative efficiency score of the Korean-type aircraft carrier currently being evaluated is 1.062, and it was evaluated as small-scale aircraft carrier compared to the national competency. Based on Korean national competency, the optimal scale of the Korean-type aircraft carrier calculated by aggregating benchmark groups, is 58,308.1 tons of full-load displacement, 279.4m in length, and 68.3m in width.