미국의 티켓재판매시장 규제입법에 관한 연구

한세론,최유 한국법제연구원 2019 법제연구 Vol.- No.56

In these days There are many complain about ticket scalping. They argue that most fans who want to see their favorite show, concert, and sporting events are frustrated because they couldn’t buy ticket at the moments of the ticket’s released. Then fans are forced to rely on the secondary ticket market and purchase the ticket at the price above the face value. This is largely result from the use of “ticket purchase program” which allows the ticket scalper to bypass an internet ticket site’s security measures. But Current law, ticket scalping is not regulated. Ticket scalping is nothing new in U.S. From 1900’s, ticket scalping problem emerged and got serious. In reaction to this negative connotation, State legislative have been passing anti-scalping law. These laws vary from state to state. While Some state prohibit ticket scalping, Other state permit the practice but regulate it. For example, under New York law, ticket resale is not illegal but regulated it through any forms including licence and taxation. Furthermore it is unlawful, similar to BOTS Act, to use ticket purchasing software to buy the ticket. For anti-scalping law, the U.S. Supreme Court’s ruling is changed over time. Early courts view such statutes as violations of liverty interests and property rights. Accordingly Anti-scalping law is unconstitutional and struck down. But since Nebbia decision and Gold decision, it is acknowledged that the statute restricting the ticket resale is exercise of state police power for public interest. Based on these development of the ticket scalping and current law restricting ticket resale in U.S. I intend to draw implications for the proper and effective measures of the regulation of ticket resale transactions. 최근 온라인에서의 암표를 규제하여야 한다는 목소리가 높다. 온라인 시장이 성장하며대부분의 티켓 거래가 온라인에서 이루어지고 있는데, 티켓이 발매되자마자 티켓구매프로그램을 이용한 티켓을 대량으로 선점하는 행위가 빈번하게 나타나고 있는 것이다. 결과적으로 소비자들은 티켓구매에 어려움을 겪으며, 2차 시장에서 티켓을 구매할 수 밖에 없게 된다. 그러나 이 때 티켓의 가격이 천정부지로 높아지며 암표상들이 부당한 이익을 얻고 있어 심각한 사회문제로 대두되고 있다. 그러나 우리나라에서 온라인 암표를 규제하는 법률은 없으며, 사실상 법의 사각지대에 놓여 적절한 관리ᐧ감독이 이루어지고 있지 않다. 그러나 액면가 이상으로 티켓을 재판매하는 문제는 우리나라에만 국한된 문제가 아니며, 오늘날 새롭게 등장한 문제도 아니다. 미국에서의 암표규제를 위한 논의는 1900년대부터이루어져왔다. 또한 미국의 경우 암표규제는 주별로 다양하게 이루어지고 있다. 일부 주는티켓 재판매 자체를 금지하기도 하며, 일부 주는 일정 요건 하에 티켓 재판매를 허용한다. 대표적으로 뉴욕주에서는 티켓산업을 규제산업으로 접근하여 관리ᐧ감독하고자 한다. 티켓재판매를 규제하는 주법에 대하여 초기 미국 법원의 태도는 자유권적 이익과 재산권을 바탕으로 하여 주가 규제하는 것이 위헌적이라는 입장에서 공공이 이익을 위하여 규제할 수 있는입장으로 변화하였다. 현재 미국에서는 연방법 차원에서 온라인티켓판매법(Better Online Ticket Sales Act of 2016)을 제정하여 티켓자동구매프로그램의 사용을 금지하고 있으며, 주법 차원에서는 각 주별로 티켓 재판매에 관한 법률을 제정하여 규제강도를 달리하여 규제하고 있다. 따라서 본 연구를 통하여 암표규제에 있어 오랜 역사를 갖는 미국에서의 티켓 재판매에대한 논의의 발전을 살펴보고, 현재 미국에서의 티켓 재판매 규제의 내용을 살펴봄으로써이를 통해 우리나라의 티켓 재판매 규제의 적절하고 실효성 있는 입법방안에 시사점을 도출하고자 한다.

항공운송서류의 전자화

최준선 法務部 商事法務課 2009 선진상사법률연구 Vol.- No.45

2008년에 입법 예고된 상법 제6편(항공운송편) 제정안에는 전자항공권과 전자항공화물운송장에 대한 규정을 두었다. 이로써 해상법에 이은 항공운송법 분야에서도 운송서류의 전자화가 이루어질 전망이다. 본고에서는 전자여객항공권(electronic ticket, e-ticket)과 전자항공화물운송장(electronic airway bill)의 사용가능성 및 법률문제에 관하여 논의하였다. 특히 항공운송과 관련하여 적용될 법률로서 전자거래기본법의 내용을 살펴보았다. 전자여객항공권의 활용가능성과 활용 추이를 살펴보았으며, 전자항공권을 이용한 여객운송 계약의 계약체결과정을 설명하였다. 전자계약의 성질로서 이것이 대화자 간의 거래인지 격지자 간의 거래인지 다툼이 있어 왔는데, 필자로서는 격지자 간의 거래임을 전자거래 기본법의 규정을 원용하여 밝혀내었다. 전자계약체결의 시점은 격지자 간의 계약의 체결 시점인 승낙의 통지를 발송한 때 성립함을 민법 제531조를 원용하여 설명하였고, 전자계약의 체결장소는 계약이 성립할 시점에 전자문서가 소재하는 곳임을 주장하였다. 항공운송계약의 성립시점과 장소에 관하여도 이와 유사한 원칙을 적용하여 해석하였다. 과거 70여 년 간 문제되었던 운송증권의 교부와 책임제한에 관한 고지문제의 연혁을 살펴보고, 몬트리올협약에 의거하여, 오늘 날에는 큰 의미가 없다는 것도 살펴보았다. 전자항공화물운송장의 허용에서는 전자항공화물운송장의 사용의 근거법률을 고찰하였고, 이어 전자항공화물운송장의 등록문제를 논의하였으며, 국제재판관할, 국내재판관할 등을 고찰하고, 장차 100% 전자항공증서가 이용된다고 보고, 이 분야에 대한 확고한 이론적 실무적 준비가 반드시 필요함을 지적하였다. The Korean Commercial Code is going to introduce electronic ticket and electronic airway bill. An electronic ticket or e-ticket is used to represent the purchase of a seat on a passenger airline, usually through a internet website. The electronic ticket has many merits against traditional paper ticket. It is safer than paper ticket because an e-ticket cannot be forgotten, misplaced or stolen. The cost of issuing an electronic ticket amounts only to 1 USD saving at least 9 USD per ticket. The electronic ticket will soon substitute 100 % of the traditional paper tickets. This article discusses the legal problems arising out of issuing and using an electronic tickets and an electronic airway bill, including the process of issuing an electronic tickets, the time and place of formation of electronic contracts. In the traditional notion of contract formation, the general rule is that formation of contract requires an offer and acceptance to be communicated between the parties. As a result, a contract is formed when acceptance is communicated to the offeror in face-to-face negotiation. However, the electronic contract is deemed to be a contract concluded over the distances. Early case law has created the "mailbox rule" for ordinary mail, wherein acceptance is deemed to be communicated to the offeror when it enters the postal system. Likewise, the electronic contract is formed when a notice of acceptance is communicated to the offeror. It is true in the issuing of the electronic ticket, because it is also a distance contract. Further, this article discusses the jurisdiction issue under the Montreal Convention of 1999 and other legal issues on the using electronic airway bill.

입장권 등의 재판매에 관한 비교법적 검토

송재우(Sohng, Chai Woo) 부산대학교 법학연구소 2018 법학연구 Vol.59 No.4

문화의 고급화, 대중화 추세와 함께 공연을 즐기려는 수요는 공급에 비하여 늘어나고 있는 추세이다. 이와 같은 추세와 함께 종래 소수의 암표상에 의하여 이루어지던 입장권의 재판매행위는 온라인 거래 기술의 발전과 더불어 종전과 비교할 수 없을 정도로 확대되었다. 그런데, 이러한 입장권 2차 판매시장의 확대는 입장권이 최초의 입장권판매가격에 비하여 수배, 수십 배되는 가격으로 팔리게 되는 결과를 가져왔다. 이러한 입장권 가격의 앙등은 공연을 보려는 일반소비자들에게 부당한 부담을 가하는 한편, 공연주최자가 취할 수 있었던 정당한 이익을 입장권의 재판매업자가 취득하게 되는 결과를 가져왔다. 이러한 폐해를 방지하기 위하여 입장권의 재판매를 규제하고자 하는 입법 요구가 있었다. 본고에서는 비교법적으로 캐나다 법령을 검토하였는바, 캐나다의 온타리오주는 최근 입장권 재판매를 규제하는 법을 시행하였고, 캐나다의 다른 주 역시 유사한 입법에 착수하였다. 이러한 규제는 크게 입장권판매업자의 영업규제, 자동구매프로그램을 이용한 입장권의 매점 방지 및 입장권의 재판매가격의 규제로 구분된다. 특히 입장권재판매가격의 규제는 재판매가격을 최초 입장권 가격 및 기타 관련 비용의 50% 이상의 웃돈을 얹어 파는 것을 금지하고 그 비용의 구체적인 명세를 밝혀 구매자의 합리적인 판단을 가능하도록 하고 있다. 한국의 경우 입장권의 재판매는 지금까지 논의가 된 바는 별로 없었으나 최근 입장권의 재판매 및 높게 형성되는 가격에 대한 구매자의 불만이 더욱 늘어나고 있다. 따라서 한국의 입장권판매시장에서도 입장권 시장의 규모와 가격책정의 구조를 고려한 적절한 규제가 이루어져야 할 것이다. In these days, there are so many performances and events from ballet, opera, musical, film to sports game, and there are just as many fans who would be eager to purchase tickets regardless of the price. Furthermore, the ticket resale market has expanded enormously due to the development of technologies for online transactions, in contrast to before when ticket resale was done by the fewer scalpers in person near the theatre. This expansion of secondary ticket market caused the secondary ticket price to be sold at a much higher price than that by the primary ticker seller. It is argued that as a byproduct of this, consumers who intend to participate in the event must suffer from the unfair financial burden, and the event organizer must be deprived of the profit which might be earned by him/herself. To correct for this unfairness, the government of Ontario, Canada has brought the new “Ticket Sales Act” this year, 2018, and other provinces are now considering the following legislation of similar regulations. The major regulations under the Act are (i) restriction of secondary ticket sales business, (ii) restriction of using the ‘bot’ in purchasing the tickets from the primary seller and (iii) cap on the ticket resale price. Under the Act, the premium for ticket resale shall be limited to within 50% of the face value of the ticket. In Korea, there is no explicit regulations regarding ticket resales as listed above, except for the sanction against the scalping of the tickets in the offline market. However, the so-overpriced ticket resale price has been found in various secondary ticket markets. In this regard, the legal analysis, whether to regulate ticket resales or not, including the cap on ticket resale price, should be discussed upon the consideration of the secondary ticket market and the pricing mechanism in Korea.

분할투표의 유형 및 동기: 20대 총선 분석

류재성(Jaesung Ryu) 한국정당학회 2020 한국정당학회보 Vol.19 No.1

본 연구는 20대 총선에서의 분할투표를 분석했다. 본 연구는 기존 연구에서 밝혀졌던 분할 투표자의 사회인구학적 특성을 확인했다. 20대 총선에서 분할투표자는 서울, 경기·인천, 대구·경북 거주, 젊은 층, 고학력, 진보성향을 지닌, 더불어민주당, 국민의당, 정의당 등의 야당 지지자 및 무당층 유권자로, 2016년 당시 박근혜 대통령에 대해 부정적으로 평가하고 5년 후 한국경제 상황을 비관적으로 전망하는 응답자가 분할투표할 가능성이 크게 나타났다. 본 연구는 ‘어떻게 분할투표했는가’라는 연구 질문을 제기하고, 분할투표자의 ‘정파적’ 동기와 더불어 분할투표 대상 정당 선택에 있어 ‘이념적’ 동기가 작동한다고 주장한다. 즉 정당지지자의 경우 본인의 정치이념과 최단 거리에 있는 정당으로 비례 이탈 정당을 선택하며, 정당의 이념 방향을 고려하여 지역구 후보 이탈 정당을 선택한다고 주장한다. 기존 연구에서는 거대정당 지지자의 비례 정당투표 이탈투표자를 연합보장 전략적 분할투표로, 소수정당 지지자의 지역구 후보투표 이탈자를 사표방지 전략적 분할투표로 분류했지만, 이들의 이탈 정당 선택 동기에 대해서는 분석하지 않았다. 본 연구는 이들의 분할투표 대상 정당 선택이 이념 거리를 기준으로 이루어진다고 밝혔다. 즉 거대정당 지지자의 연합보장 전략적 분할투표 대상은 자신과 최단 이념 거리 정당이며, 소수정당 지지자의 사표방지 전략적 분할투표 대상 역시 자신과 이념 성향이 유사한 정당임을 밝혔다. 추가로 정의당 지지자의 경우 많은 지역구에서 후보자가 없어 지역구 후보투표에서 지지 정당을 이탈하는 강제적 분할투표가 이루어졌음을 밝혔다. This study analyzed split-ticket voters in the 20th National Assembly Election in Korea. I confirm the findings of previous studies, which found out sociodemographic characteristics of split-ticket voters. That is, split-ticket voters are likely to be relatively younger adults, more educated, liberal-leaning, and outparty identifiers who in large part do not support president Park and negatively predict the economic situation after 5 years. This study specifically asks the question of ‘how did split-ticket voters chose a political party when they split their tickets.’ I argue that ideological motivation as well as partisan motivation plays a critical role in this decision making. Party identifiers choose the ticket-splitting party which is evaluated in the shortest ideological distance from his/her ideological self-positioning. Previous studies categorized split-ticket voters into the party-coalition-making motivated strategic split-ticket voters by major party identifiers, the free-fromticket-waste motivated strategic split-ticket voters by minor party identifiers, and the balancing motivated split-ticket voters by major party identifiers. But these studies did not focus on which party they choose for this strategic splitticket and why. This study finds out that major party identifiers as well as minor party identifiers choose a specific party for split-ticket, motivated by ideological distance between party’s ideological position and his/her self-identified ideological position. In addition, many of Jung-Eu Party identifiers are ‘enforced’ to split their tickets because they do not have Jung-Eu Party candidate in their districts.

A Study on Implementation and Design of Scheme to Securely Circulate Digital Contents

김용,김은정 한국정보관리학회 2009 정보관리학회지 Vol.26 No.2

With explosive growth in the area of the Internet and IT services, various types of digital contents are generated and circulated, for instance, as converted into digital-typed, secure electronic records or reports, which have high commercial value, e-tickets and so on. However, because those digital contents have commercial value, high-level security should be required for delivery between a consumer and a provider with non face-to-face method in online environment. As a digital contents, an e-ticket is a sort of electronic certificate to assure ticket-holder’s proprietary rights of a real ticket. This paper focuses on e-ticket as a typical digital contents which has real commercial value. For secure delivery and use of digital contents in on/off environment, this paper proposes that 1) how to generate e-tickets in a remote e-ticket server, 2) how to authenticate a user and a smart card holding e-tickets for delivery in online environment, 3) how to save an e-ticket transferred through network into a smart card, 4) how to issue and authenticate e-tickets in offline, and 5) how to collect and discard outdated or used e-tickets.

SNS특성이 공연예술소비자의 티켓구매의도에 미치는 영향 - 기술수용모델을 중심으로

정상현,이화형 한국문화경제학회 2023 문화경제연구 Vol.26 No.2

이 연구는 공연예술소비자의 SNS특성이 공연예술소비자의 티켓구매의도에 미치는영향 관계를 규명하여 공연예술 마케팅의 기초자료를 제시하는 데 연구의 목적이 있다. 연구 대상자는 SNS를 통해 공연예술 티켓을 구매한 경험이 있는 공연예술소비자로 선정하였고, 온라인 설문 플랫폼 Google docs를 이용하여 261부의 자료를 수집하였다. 실증 분석은 모두 유의수준 α=.05 에서 검증하였으며, 통계 처리는 SPSS 28.0 및 AMOS 28.0 프로그램을 사용하여 분석하였다. 실증 분석을 통해 도출한 결과는 다음과 같다. 첫째, SNS특성 중 상호작용성, 유희성, 관계성은 지각된 유용성에 정(+) 의 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났으며, 실재감은 지각된 유용성에 영향을 미치지 않는것으로 나타났다. 둘째, SNS특성 중 상호작용성, 유희성은 지각된 용이성에 정(+)의영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났으나, 관계성, 실재감은 지각된 용이성에 영향을 미치지않는 것으로 나타났다. 셋째, 공연예술소비자의 지각된 용이성은 지각된 유용성에 정(+)의 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다. 넷째, 공연예술소비자의 지각된 유용성은 티켓구매의도에 정(+)의 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다. 다섯째, 공연예술소비자의 지각된용이성은 티켓구매의도에 정(+)의 영향을 미치는 것으로 나타났다. 따라서, SNS특성의하위요인인 상호작용성, 유희성, 관계성을 강조하는 SNS를 기획·제작하여 공연예술소비자의 지각된 유용성과 지각된 용이성을 높임으로써 티켓구매의도에 긍정적인 영향을미치도록 해야 할 것이다. This study proposes a research model that investigates that influential relationship of the major variables set when searching for performing arts, including the characteristics of SNS, perceived usefulness, perceived ease of use, and ticket purchase intention. The subjects were performing arts consumers with experiences of purchasing a performing arts ticket via SNS. A total of 261 questionnaires were collected with the online survey platform Google Docs. The empirical analysis results were tested at the significance level of α=.05, and statistical treatments were analyzed with the SPSS 28.0 and AMOS 28.0 programs. The empirical analysis results led to the following findings: First, the study empirically analyzed the impact of SNS characteristics on searching for performance arts included interaction, playfulness, relationship, and reality on perceived usefulness, and found that interaction, playfulness, and relationship had significant positive (+) effects on perceived usefulness, and reality did not have any effect on it. Second, the study also empirically analyzed the effects of SNS characteristics on searching performing arts including interaction, playfulness, relationship, and reality on perceived ease of use, and found that interaction and playfulness had positive (+) effects on it with relationship and reality having no effects on it. Third, the study empirically analyzed the effects of perceived ease of use on perceived usefulness in performing arts consumers and found that the former had positive (+) effects on the latter. Fourth, the study empirically analyzed the effects of perceived usefulness on the ticket purchase intention of performing arts consumers and found that it had positive (+) effects on their ticket purchase intention. Finally, the study empirically analyzed the effects of perceived ease of use on the ticket purchase intention of performing arts consumers and found that it had positive (+) effects on their ticket purchase intention. Based on these findings, the study had the following discussions: First, one of the subfactors of SNS characteristics to search performing arts is interaction, which turned out to have the biggest effects on perceived usefulness. This raises a need to actively review performing arts marketing and emphasize interaction, which allows performing arts consumers to share and communicate various content among themselves via SNS to obtain performance information. Second, another subfactors of SNS characteristics to search performing arts is playfulness, which turned out to have the greatest influences on perceived ease of use. This raises a need to plan and develop performing arts promotions and content tjat gives performing arts consumers the feeling of fun, interest, and pleasure by using SNS in order to increase their perceived ease of use. Third, perceived ease of use had positive effects on perceived usefulness in performing arts consumers. It is thus necessary to do research on promotion and marketing strategies recognizable at a glance so that performing arts consumers can obtain information about performing arts and overcome their difficulties with SNS to increase their perceived usefulness. Fourth, perceived usefulness turned out to have positive impacts on the ticket purchase intention of performing arts consumers. These findings suggest that the field of performing arts should be active in developing marketing strategies to plan diverse events and promotions that provide performance information via SNS to consumers so that performing arts consumers will purchase more tickets. Finally, it was demonstrated that perceived ease of use had effects on the ticket purchase intention of performing arts consumers. It is thus needed to analyze the age groups of consumers and implement promotions targeting specific age groups to increase the ticket purchase of performing arts consumers. In short, this study promotes the understanding of performing arts consumers' behavior...

Secure Electronic Ticketing System based on Consortium Blockchain

( Xuelian Li ),( Jie Niu ),( Juntao Gao ),( Yue Han ) 한국인터넷정보학회 2019 KSII Transactions on Internet and Information Syst Vol.13 No.10

In electronic ticketing system, the malicious behavior of scalpers damages the customer’s interest and disturbs the normal order of market. In order to solve the problem of scalpers, we took two steps. Firstly, we established the electronic ticketing system based on the consortium blockchain (CB-ETS). By establishing CB-ETS, we can make the ticketing market develop better in a controlled environment and be managed by the members in the consortium blockchain. Secondly, we put forward a kind of taxation mechanism for suppressing scalpers based on CB-ETS. Together with the regulatory mechanism, our scheme can effectively reduce the scalpers’ profits and further inhibit scalpers. Through the above two steps, the scheme can effectively resist the malicious behavior of scalpers. Among them, in the process of transferring tickets, we optimized the transfer mechanism to achieve a win-win situation. Finally, we analyzed the security and efficiency of our scheme. Our scheme realizes the anonymity through the mixed currency protocol based on ring signature and guarantees the unforgeability of tickets by multi-signature in the process of modifying the invalidity of tickets. It also could resist to Dos attacks and Double-Spending attacks. The efficiency analysis shows that our scheme is significantly superior to relevant works.

Investigating the Determinants of Major IT Incident Tickets: A Case Study of an IT Service Provider Firm for Logistics and Distribution Industry

Mohamad Izham Che Ros,Wee-Yeap Lau 한국유통과학회 2016 유통과학연구 Vol.14 No.12

Purpose - This study investigates the determinants that affect the number of IT Incident tickets of an IT Service Provider (“ITSP”) to logistics industry in order to improve its management process by reducing the incident tickets. Research design, data, and Methodology - This study uses weekly data of IT incident tickets from September 2012 to June 2015. Correlation and regression analyses are conducted. Six identified determinants i.e., IT Change, User Errors, Shipment Volume, Network, Hardware and Software Issues are used as the explanatory variables. Results - Our findings show as following. First, our analysis indicates that IT Change is not a significant determinant as opposed to what commonly believed by many as the most important factor. Second, Software issue is the highest contributor to the Major IT incident tickets, followed by User Error, Network and Hardware issues. Third, it seems there is lead-lag relationship between IT Change and Major IT Incidents tickets as indicated by earlier studies. Fourth, the relationship between IT Change and Major IT tickets is also affected by shipment volume. Conclusions - As policy recommendation, all identified determinants should be treated according to priority. In addition, improving the way IT Changes are implemented will definitely reduce the IT incident tickets.

Research on Characteristics of Platforms for Purchasing Airline Tickets: Focusing on Air Ticket Distribution in Korea

Seonhee KO(Seonhee KO) 한국유통과학회 2023 유통과학연구 Vol.21 No.2

Purpose: This study intended to examine the effects of the characteristics of platforms for purchasing airline tickets on perceived ease of use, usefulness, and e-loyalty, applying the technology acceptance model. Research design, data and methodology: A research model was established based on previous studies, and data were collected from consumers with experience in the airline ticket purchasing platform. 175 valid samples were used and analyzed using SEM. Results: Characteristics of the ticket purchase platform were classified into sub-factors of accessibility, functionality and information reliability through theoretical consideration. The established hypotheses for the research were partially accepted. Conclusions: First, functionality and information reliability were found to have significant positive effects on perceived ease of use, while accessibility did not have such effect. Second, accessibility did not affect the perceived usefulness, and both functionality and information reliability had a significant positive effect on perceived usefulness. Third, it was found that the perceived ease of use had a positive effect on perceived usefulness. Finally, it was found that perceived ease of use did not affect e-loyalty of the ticket purchasing platform, only perceived usefulness affected e-loyalty. This study had important academic and practical implications in the context of air ticket distribution.

The New Mixed Electoral System in Korea

Wang Sik Kim(김왕식) 한국정치학회 2005 한국정치학회보 Vol.39 No.4

이 논문은 설문자료를 분석하여 한국에 새로이 도입된 혼합선거제도의 효과를 살펴본 것이다. 이 제도 도입의 가장 큰 특징으로 나타나는 분할투표율은 20.8%로 그리 높지 않았다. 분할투표에 가장 큰 영향을 미친 요인은 성별, 연령, 이념성향 그리고 정당선호도였다. 유권자들의 분할투표는 전반적으로 보아 전략적 투표행위라고 말할 수 있으나 그 전략적 고려는 그리 크지 않았다. 혼합선거제도의 도입은 정당체제에 영향을 미쳤다. 민주노동당은 이 제도의 혜택을 가장 많이 받았으며, 정당비례대표선거에서 자당을 지지하는 분할투표를 많이 얻어 제 3당이 될 수 있었다. 1인 2표제를 근간으로 하는 혼합선거제도의 도입이 정당득표율과 의석점유율간의 비비례성을 교정하는 효과는 극히 적었으며, 투표율에 영향을 미치거나 지역주의적 투표성향을 약화시키지도 않았다. Analyzing survey data, this paper examined the effect of the newly introduced electoral system in Korea. The rate of ticket splitting was not significantly high, recording only 20.8%. Sex, age, ideological stance, and party preferences were important factors that contributed to ticket splitting. The ticket-split voting behavior of the Korean voters in the 17th National Assembly election could be seen as being strategic, but strategic calculations of the voters were not so strong. Introduction of new electoral system affected party arrangement. The Democratic Labor Party was benefitted most and able to become the third largest party with the help of the great number of split-ticket voting in a proportional representative election supporting the party. The effect of the introduction of the “one man two votes” electoral system to resolve disproportionality was minimal. The introduction of the “one man two votes” electoral system neither affected the voting turnout systematically nor mitigated the traditional regionally based voting behavior of the Korean voters.