서비스 회복공정성과 만족의 관계에서 조절변수의 효과 = Effects of moderator variables in the relationship between service recovery justice and satisfaction

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study examined the effects of three dimensions of recovery justice. Namely procedural justice, interactional justice and distributive justice, which customers perceive after experiencing failure in the course of the service recovery process offered by the firm after service failure, on satisfaction. Effects of distributive justice on satisfaction were examined as well as the relationship between commitment and relationship quality, which is comprised of satisfaction and trust. In addition, the effects of relationship quality factors, comprised of satisfaction, trust and commitment on behavior intention variables, such as positive word-of-mouth intention and repurchase intention, were examined. In particular, the focal point of this study was to verify the moderation role played by the controllability and stability of service failure attribution factors in the course of service failure, and customization, relationship intimacy, past relationship experience, relational exchanges and the severity of the service failure of relationship marketing factors, in the relationship between recovery justice and satisfaction as perceived by the customer.
For a more realistic approach, empirical research was conducted on consumers who patronize department stores in Seoul, Daegu and the Kyungbuk region and who responded to have experienced service failures. 275 samples were used for this analysis. Collected samples were tested by factor analysis and Cronbach's Alpha coefficients and were found to be satisfactory in terms of validity and reliability. Futhermore, fitness of the measurement model was tested by using confirmatory factor analysis and fitness of the model for hypothesis testing were shown to be adequate on various goodness of fit indices(GFI, AGFI, RMR, CFI, RMSEA).
The results of the empirical research can be summarized as follows :
First, it was found that procedural justice, interactional justice, and distributive justice of three dimensions of recovery justice, which customers perceived in the course of recovery process after a service failure, had significant effects on customer satisfaction. Distributive justice had the greatest effect followed by interactional justice and procedural justice. Second, customer satisfaction had a significant effect on trust and commitment which showed customer satisfaction had an important role in trust and commitment. Third, relationship quality factors, which are satisfaction, trust and commitment, had significant effect on positive word-of-mouth intention and repurchase intention. Trust and commitment had a greater effect on the positive word-of-mouth intention. Fourth, controllability, which is a service failure attribution factor, had a moderation role in the relationship between procedural and distributive justice and satisfaction, but not on interactional justice. Stability only had a moderation role in the relationship between distributive justice and satisfaction. Of the relationship marketing factors, customization had a moderation role in the relationship between interactional justice and satisfaction, and intimacy had a moderation effect on the relationship between procedural justice and interactional justice. Finally, severity was found to have a moderation role in the relationship between procedural and distributive justice and satisfaction.
Based on the empirical analysis, some managerial implications can be proposed for formulating effective marketing strategies.
First, rather than emphasizing simply one dimension of justice, firms should utilize all three dimensions of justice in order to achieve more effective results. Second, if service failure occurs, recovery strategy programs such as aggressive compensation and problem solving should be sought rather than the strategy of simply satisfying the customer. Third, firms need a strategic approach. Through effective recovery strategy, firms could improve customer satisfaction and focus on generating revenue, and through trust building and commitment, firms can convey a positive image to potential customers so as to achieve higher performance. If service failures do occur, firms need to segment the problems according to the varying degree of customers' perception of the problems and execute customized and differentiated recovery strategies accordingly so as to obtain effective results. Finally, firms need to develop and implement relationship marketing programs so that they can carry out not only short-term transactions, but also long-term transactions with the customer.
Despite these implications, this study has several limitations. The first limitation concerns the measurement method. The survey method used in this study chose to measure actual customers' experiences, but such methodology can be exposed to customers' memory effects. Second is the limitation in generalization. Thus, it would be more effective if reactions to service failure were measured on various industries and examined varying reactions between the industries in the future. Third, this study only presents results of cross-sectional study of variables. It would be more beneficial if longitudinal study is conducted in the future study. Fourth, when testing the moderation effect, it was difficult to clearly comprehend the characteristics of groups. Thus, the future survey should be designed so that respond traits of respondents can be accurately differentiated.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• 목차
• Ⅰ. 서론 = 1
• 1. 문제제기 및 연구목적 = 1
• 2. 연구방법 및 구성 = 6
• Ⅱ. 회복공정성, 관계품질, 조절변수 및 행동의도에 관한 이론적 고찰 = 8
• 1. 서비스 회복공정성 = 8
• 1) 서비스 회복의 정의 및 구성 = 8
• 2) 서비스 회복의 필요성 = 11
• 3) 서비스 회복전략 = 13
• 4) 서비스 회복공정성 이론과 유형 = 15
• 2. 관계품질 = 20
• 1) 만족 = 21
• 2) 신뢰 = 23
• 3) 몰입 = 25
• 3. 조절변수로서 서비스 실패의 귀인요인, 관계마케팅요인 및 실패의 심각성 = 27
• 1) 서비스 실패의 귀인요인 = 28
• 2) 관계마케팅요인 = 32
• 3) 서비스 실패의 심각성 = 38
• 4. 행동의도 = 39
• 1) 긍정적 구전의도 = 40
• 2) 재구매의도 = 41
• 5. 회복공정성, 관계품질, 행동의도 및 조절변수간의 관계에 관한 연구 = 42
• 1) 회복공정성과 만족의 관계 = 42
• 2) 만족과 신뢰 및 몰입의 관계 = 45
• 3) 관계품질(만족, 신뢰, 몰입)과 행동의도의 관계 = 47
• 4) 서비스 실패 귀인요인의 조절효과 = 49
• 5) 관계마케팅요인의 조절효과 = 52
• 6) 서비스 실패 심각성의 조절효과 = 56
• Ⅲ. 실증연구의 설계 = 58
• 1. 연구모형의 설정 = 58
• 2. 연구가설의 설정 = 59
• 3. 변수의 정의 및 측정방법 = 68
• 4. 조사방법 = 76
• 1) 예비조사 및 본 조사 = 76
• 2) 표본설계 및 자료수집 = 77
• 3) 설문지 구성 = 77
• 4) 자료 분석 방법 = 79
• Ⅳ. 실증분석 = 80
• 1. 표본의 특성 = 80
• 2. 측정항목의 타당성 및 신뢰성 검증 = 81
• 3. 연구가설의 검증 = 92
• 4. 분석의 결과 및 해석 = 103
• Ⅴ. 결론 = 112
• 1. 연구의 요약 및 시사점 = 112
• 2. 한계점 및 미래 연구 방향 = 116
• 참고문헌 = 119
• Abstract = 129
• 설문지 = 132

참고문헌 (Reference)

1. Theory and Research, E.Berscheid, G.W.Walster, Walster, , 1978

2. Spontaneous Causal Search, Weiner, , 1985

3. Rediscovering Satisfaction, Mick, Fournier, , 1999

4. LISREL 구조방정식모델, 배병렬, LISREL 구조방정식모델, , 2006

5. Why Satisfied Customers Defect, Jones,T.O., Why Satisfied Customers Defect, , 1995

6. New Directions in Equity Research, Walster.G.W, , 1976

7. An Applied Service Marketing Theory, Gronroos, An Applied Service Marketing Theory, , 1982

8. Psychometric Theory, Second Edition, Nunnally, "Psychometric Theory, , 1978

9. The four faces of mass customization, Gilmore, Pine, , 1997

10. Managing Word-Of-Mouth Communications, Haywood, , 1989

11. Buyer-Seller Relationships: Similarity, Smith, , 1998

12. My Employees Are My Service Guarantees, Firnstahl, My Employees are My Service Guarantees, , 1989

13. A TypologyofRetailFailuresandRecoveries, Kelly, M.A.Davis, , 1993

14. Breaking the Cycleof Failure in Service, Schlesinger, , 1991

15. Service breakdown: The road to recovery, Bell, Zemke, , 1987

16. The structure of commitment in exchange, Mentzer, J. T, Achrol,R.S., Gundlach, G. T., , 1995

17. Consumer Awareness and Complaining Behaviour, Agbonifoh, , 1986

18. 소비자행동 : 마케팅 전략적 접근, 이학식, 法文社, 소비자 행동--마케팅전략적 접근, , 2000

19. How industrial sales people gaincustomer trust, Swan, Silva, , 1985

20. The Behavioral Consequences of Service Quality, Parasuraman, Berry, Zeithmal, , 1996

21. Personality Variables and Cigarette Brand Choice, Fry, , 1971

22. Antecedents to Satisfaction with Service Recovery, T.W.Adreassen, Antecedents to Satisfaction with Service Recovery, , 2000

23. Identification and Analysis of Moderator Variables, Subhash Sharma, , 1981

24. FactorsAffectingTrustin MarketResearch Relationships, Moorman, , 1993

25. From Disgust to Delight: Do Customers Hold a Grudge?, Andreassen, , 2001

26. The commitment-trusttheory of relationship marketing, Morgan,R.M, Hunt,S.D, The Commitment-Trust Theory of Relationship Marketing, , 1994

27. Word of Mouth: Indirect Effects of Marketing Efforts, Bayus, , 1985

28. Developing a Comprehensive Picture of Service Failure, Colgate M, , 2001

29. The Effect of Supplier Fairness on Vulnerable Reseller, Lisa K.Scheer, Jan-Benedict E.M.Steenkamp, Kumar, , 1995

30. Tracking Service Failure and Employee Recovery Effects, S.W.Kelley, H.M.Rotalsky, Hoffman, , 1995

31. Multivariate Data Analysis with Readings, Fourth Edition, Hair Jr, Anderson, Grablowsky, Joseph F, "Multivariate Data Analysis with Readings, , 1995

32. 여행업체의 여행 서비스 회복에 관한 연구, 김판영, , 2003

33. Attributions and outcomes of the service recovery process, Kelly, Swanson, , 2001

34. Service Recovery: A Framework and Empirical Investigation, Miller, C.W.Craighead, K.R.Karwan, , 2000

35. Anexaminationofthenatureoftrustin buyerseller relationships, P.M.Doney, An Examination of the Nature of Trust in Buyer-Seller Relationships, , 1997

36. Customer Loyalty: Toward an Integrated Conceptual Framework, Dick,A.S., Customer Loyalty: Toward an Integrated Conceptual Framework, , 1994

37. Negative Word-of-Mouth by DissatisfiedConsumers:A PilotStudy, Richins, Negative Word-Of-Mouth by Dissatisfied Consumers: A Pilot Study, , 1983

38. Post Purchase Consumer Processes and theComplaining Consumer, M.C.Gilly, B.D.Gelb, , 1982

39. Service Failure and Recovery: Impact, Attributes and Process, Johnston, "Service Failure and Recovery: Impact, , 1995

40. Relationship Marketing Can Mitigate ProductandServiceFailures, Priluck, Relationship Marketing can Mitigate Product and Service Failures, , 2003

41. An Investigation into the Determinants of Consumer Satisfactions, Churchill Jr, C.Surprenant, , 1982

42. Consumer Reactions to Product failure : AnAttributional Approach, V.S.Folkes, Consumer Reactions to Product Failure: An Attributional Approach, , 1984

43. 호텔 서비스 실패에 대한 회복 공정성과 그 효과, 유은나, 세종대학교 대학원, 호텔서비스 실패에 대한 회복 공정성과 그 효과, , 2002

44. 소매업태별 관계마케팅 요인과 성과에 관한 연구, 이준호, , 2001

45. A national customer satisfaction barometer:The Swedish experience., Fornell,C., A National Customer Satisfaction Barometer: The Swedish Experience, , 1992

46. Customer-Firm Relationship, Involvement, and Customer Satisfaction, Goodman, P.R.Snyder, "Customer-Firm Relationship, , 1995

47. Using Neural NetworkAnalysis to Evaluate Buyer-seller Relationship, Bejou, Palmer, Wray, , 1994

48. 불평에 대한 기업반응과 불평처리 후 소비자 반응, 류갑경, , 2001

49. Customer Switching Behavior in ServiceIndustry:An Exploratory Study, Keaveney, Customer Switching Behavior in Service Industry: An Exploratory Study, , 1995

50. Determinants of continuity in conventional industrial channel dyads, Anerson, Determinants of Continuity in Conventional Industrial Channel Dyads, , 1989

51. Fair Service,” in Advances in Service Marketing and Management, 5, B.Schneider, Clemmer, "Fair Service, , 1996

52. Linking ServiceQuality,CustomerSatisfaction and BehavioralIntention, Wooside, Robert T.D, Lisa L.F, "Linking Service Quality, , 1989

53. Selected Determinants of Consumer Satisfaction and Complaint Report, Bearden W.O, Teel J.E, , 1983

54. The antecedents and consequences of customer satisfaction for firms, Sullivan, M.W., Anderson, E, W., The Antecedents and Consequences of Customer Satisfaction for Firms, , 1993

55. An EmpiricalExamination oftheModeratorsofthe Service Recovery Paradox, Magnini, An Empirical Examination of the Moderators of the Service Recovery Paradox, , 2004

56. The Role of Employee Effort in Satisfaction with Service Transactions, Mohr, Bitner, , 1995

57. Perceived justice needs and recovery evaluation : Acontingency approach, Kelley, Holfman, Perceived Justice Needs and Recovery Evaluation: A Contingency Approach, , 2010

58. The SOCO scale: A measurement of the customer orientation of salespeople, Weitz, Saxe, , 1982

59. Customer Voluntary Performance,” Customer as Partner in Service Delivery, Bettencourt, , 1997

60. Consumer Decision Making Following A Failed Service Encounter: A Pilot Study, Tax, rashekaran, , 1992

61. A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents andConsequences of Satisfaction Decision, Olver, A Cognitive Model of the Antecedents and Consequences of Satisfaction Decision, , 1980

62. Customer Equity Considerations in ServiceRecovery: A Cross-industry Perspective, Ruyter, Customer Equity Considerations in Service Recovery: A Cross-industry Perspective, , 2000

63. Interpersonal Aspects of Procedural Justice: A new Perspectives on Pay Fairness, Greenberg J, McCart C.L, , 1990

64. 관계형성 유지에 대한 신뢰와 만족의 매개역할에 관한 연구, 양희진, 이수형, 이재록, 한국마케팅관리학회, "마케팅 관리연구, , 2001

65. Service Characteristics, Consumer Research and Classification of Retail Services, J.G.Guiltinan, W.H.Jones, Davis, "Service Characteristics, , 1978

66. 외식업체의 서비스 회복시스템을 통한 관계마케팅 전략수립, 신서영, , 2001

67. The one to one future: Building relationships one customer at a time, Garden City, Peppers, M.Rogers, "The one to one future: Building relationships one customer at a time, , 1993

68. A Field Study of Causal Inference and Consumer Reaction: The View from the Airport, S.Koletsky, J.L.Graham, Folkes, , 1987

69. 항공사 서비스 회복을 통한 고객관계유지 및 성과에 관한연구, 김은주, 계명대학교 대학원, 항공사 서비스 회복을 통한 고객관계유지 및 성과에 관한 연구, , 2002

70. SERVQUAL: A Multiple Item Scale for Measuring Consumer Perception of Service Quality, Parasuraman, V.Zeithaml, L.L.Berry, , 1988

71. The different roles of satisfaction ,trust ,and commitmentin customer relationships., Johnson, M.S., Garbarino, E.,, "The Different Roles of Satisfaction, , 1999

72. 서비스회복이 고객만족과 행동의도에 미치는 영향에 관한 연구, 정현영, 청주대학교, 청주대학교 박사학위논문, , 2000

73. A Dynamic ProcessModel of Service Quality : From Expectations to Behavioral Intentions, R.Staelin, Zeithaml A., A Dynamic Process Model of Service Quality: From Expectations to Behavioral Intentions, , 1993

74. A model of customersatisfaction with service encounters involving failure and recovery, Smith, J.Wagner, , 1999

75. Equity and Disconfirmation Perceptions as Influences on Merchant and Product Satisfaction, Richard L.Oliver, Equity and Disconfirmation Perceptions as Influences on Merchant and Product Satisfaction, , 1989

76. Evaluating Service Encounters: The Effect of Physical Surroundings and Employee Responses, Bitner, , 1990

77. Customer benefits and company consequences of customer-salesperson relationships in retailing, Beatty, Reynolds, , 1999

78. 실패된 서비스와 회복 만족간의 관계연구: 지각된 공정성을 중 심으로, 이수원, 이용기, , 1999

79. Psychological Models of the Justice Motive: Antecedents of Distributive and Procedural Justice, Weun, Psychological Models of the Justice Motive: Antecedents of Distributive and Procedural Justice, , 1997

80. Empowerment, Attribution and Apologizing as Dimensions of Service Recovery: An Experimental Study, Boshoff, "Empowerment, , 1998

81. Consumer perceptions ofInterpersonal Equity and Satisfaction in Transaction: A FieldSurveyApproach, John E.S, Richard, Consumer Perceptions of Interpersonal Equity and Satisfaction in Transaction: A Field Survey Approach, , 1989

82. Consumer Responses To Service Failures: Influence of Procedural And Interactional Fairness Perception, Ross, Goodwin, Consumer Responses to Service Failures: Influence of Procedural and Interactional Fairness Perception, , 1992

83. When Consumers Complain:A Path Analysis of the Key Antecedents of Consumer ComplaintResponse Estimates, Wikes, Singh, , 1996

84. Preliminary Evidence on the Composition of Relational Exchange and Its Outcomes: The Distributor Perspective, P.M.Simpson, Siguaw, T.L.Baker, , 2003

85. The Impact of Customer Participation and Service Expectation on Locus Attributions following Service Failure, Yen, K.P.Gwinner, W.Su, , 2004

86. 전자자료교환시스템 도입에 따른 경영통제시스템의 변화 : 기업성과에 대한 영향, 최종민 ( Jong Min Choe ), 한국산업경영학회, , 2006

87. A Longitudinal Assessment of Customer Satisfaction/Dissatisfaction: The Dynamic Aspect of the Cognitive Process, D.Mazursky, LaBarera, , 1983

88. Influence on Exchange Processes : Buyer's Preconceptions of a Seller's Trustworthiness and Bargaining Toughness, Shurr, J.L.Ozanne, , 1985

89. 대학교육서비스에 대한 공정성 인식이 관계품질과 고객의 자발적 행위에 미치는 영향, 윤만희, 한국경영학회, "경영학연구, , 2003

90. A Dynamic Model of Duration of the Customer Relationship with a Continuous Service Provider: A Role of Satisfaction, Bolton, , 1998

91. 레스토랑의 서비스 품질이 고객유지와 구전에 미치는 영향: 관계적 요인의 매개적 효과를 중심으로, 한상린, , 2004

92. The Recover Paradox: A Conceptual Model and Empirical Investigation of Customer Satisfaction and Service Quality Attitudes after Service Failures and Recovery, McCollough, , 1995