지적재조사 사업 조정금 제도 개선 방안에 관한 연구-이천시 이의신청 사례분석을 중심으로- = A Study on Improvement Measures for the Adjustment Fee Calculation System in the Cadastral Resurvey Project -A Focus on Appeal Cases in Icheon City-

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study is to present improvement measures for the compensation assessment system and practices by analyzing the current status and case studies of objections related to compensation assessments in cadastral resurvey projects. Cadastral resurvey projects are conducted to align the cadastral records with the actual conditions of the land, thereby resolving disputes in areas with cadastral discrepancies. Although there is a system to adjust compensation based on land area changes, these projects are often delayed due to objections raised by landowners and other interested parties.
The study analyzed essential data, including parcels with area increases or decreases, to grasp the characteristics of cadastral resurvey zones and predict the direction of future projects. The objections that caused the most significant delays were categorized into boundary adjustments, area changes, and compensation assessments, with the majority relating to compensation. Compensation assessments are conducted based on area changes per parcel, responding to objections, administrative appeals, and subsequent litigation as necessary.
This study proposes measures to reduce disputes and objections regarding compensation assessments. Before conducting cadastral survey measurements, community briefings should be held to address boundary settings and compensation evaluations, allowing landowners to express opinions and thus minimize conflicts. Regulations should be established to allow preliminary compensation assessments at the pre-boundary confirmation stage, and legal provisions should specify the methods and content of objections more clearly. Furthermore, to address delays caused by personnel changes among officials handling cadastral resurvey operations and to promptly resolve resident complaints, standards and manuals for the compensation assessment process are essential. Detailed guidelines or manuals should be developed to ensure reliability, objectivity, and fairness in compensation assessments.
Through a detailed analysis of objections in cadastral resurvey projects, this study proposes new legal provisions, transparency in the selection of evaluation agencies, a formal procedure for reviewing landowners' opinions, and improvements in compensation evaluations conducted prior to final boundary determination.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 국토교통부, "지적재조사질의회신집"

2 유선종 ; 노민지 ; 도주은, "지적재조사의 합리적 조정금 산정기준의 필요성에 관한 연구" 45 (45): 27-44, 2015

3 유선종, "지적재조사의 조정금 산정에 관한 연구" 22 (22): 173-195, 2012

4 이경훈 ; 정종철, "지적재조사와 감정평가의 효과적 적용 방안" 16 (16): 80-88, 2013

5 강연희, "지적재조사에 있어서 조정금에 관한 연구" 경상국립대학교 2016

6 서용수, "지적재조사 조정금 징수방법 개선 연구" 26 (26): 1-14, 2024

7 박문재 ; 김재명 ; 최윤수 ; 안종욱, "지적재조사 조정금 제도 개선 방안에 관한 연구" 22 (22): 48-61, 2020

8 이홍규, "지적재조사 조정금 산정시 감정평가기준 개선에 관한 연구" 21 (21): 3-31, 2022

9 국토교통부, "지적재조사 업무사례집"

10 국회입법조사처, "지적재조사 사업의 현황과개선 과제" 2015

11 김홍열, "지적재조사 사업의 사업기간 단축에 관한 연구" 전주대학교 2020

12 김준현 ; 신현선, "지적재조사 사업의 경계 설정방법에 관한 연구" 35 (35): 81-91, 2019

13 김종수, "지적재조사 사업 조정금 제도의 쟁점과개선방안" 13 (13): 71-86, 2014

14 최재헌, "지적재조사 사업 조정금 산정제도 개선요인 중요도에 관한 연구" 목원대학교 2023

15 최재헌 ; 이재우, "지적재조사 사업 조정금 산정제도 개선방안 중요도 분석" 21 (21): 33-57, 2022

16 정우형, "지적재조사 사업 조정금 산정 단계의사례연구" 31 (31): 75-86, 2015

17 국토교통부, "지적재조사 사업 제3차 기본계획" 2021

18 국토교통부, "지적재조사 기본계획 수정계획(2021~2030)" 2021

19 "온라인행정심판"

20 한국감정평가사협회, "법원감정평가실무" 2017

21 "바른땅"

22 "국가법령정보센터"

23 유미영 ; 최윤수 ; 최한영 ; 박문재, "경계 설정에 따른 지적재조사의 조정금 개선방안 연구" 50 (50): 117-132, 2020