메이저 석유회사에 의한 선박검사의 실태분석과 개선방안의 제시

채종주,정연철 한국항해항만학회 2009 한국항해항만학회지 Vol.33 No.8

The Major inspection is a ship inspection which is executed voluntarily for tankers by Major oil companies(hereinafter it is called "Major"). To take the Major's cargo tanker should pass Major inspection. Thus, even though Major inspection is executed voluntarily, it is more important one than any other inspection for ship's crews and owner because it is closely related to the business profit of shipping company. In this study, authors suggested the improving measures after checking the problems concerned with Major inspection through status analysis. For the status analysis, authors carried out a questionary survey and interview with the interested parties, such as tanker crews, persons in charge of shipping company and inspectors, as well as studied the related literature and statistics data. Major Inspection은 Major Oil Companies(이하 Major라 함)에 의해 탱커를 대상으로 시행되는 자발적인 선박검사이다. Major의 화물을 운송하기 위해서 탱커는 Major Inspection에 합격해야만 한다. 따라서 Major Inspection이 자발적인 검사라고는 하지만 선사의 영업이익과 밀접한 관련이 있기 때문에 선주 및 탱커 승무원들에게는 어느 검사보다 중요한 검사이다. 본 연구에서 저자들은 실태분석을 통해 Major Inspection과 관련된 문제점을 파악하고 그에 따른 개선방안을 제시하였다. 실태분석을 위해 관련문헌과 통계자료를 조사할 뿐만 아니라 이익당사자, 예를 들면, 탱커 승무원, 선박회사 담당자, 검사관 등을 대상으로 설문조사 및 인터뷰를 실시하였다.

DP 선박 위치손실사고의 인적오류에 관한 연구

채종주,Chae, Chong-Ju 해양환경안전학회 2015 海洋環境安全學會誌 Vol.21 No.5

본 연구에서는 10년간(2001 2010) IMCA에 보고된 DP 선박 LOP(Loss of Position)사고 612건에서 인적오류에 의한 사고 103건을 확인하여 이를 HFACS로 분류하였다. 그리고 이를 베이지안 네트워크에 적용하여 인적오류의 조건부 확률을 확인해 보았다. 그 결과 103건의 인적오류관련 사고는 모두 불안전한 행동에 의해서 발생하였고 이들 중 기술 기반 오류가 70건(68.00 %)으로 가장 큰 인적오류 비율을 차지하였다. 기술 기반 오류 중에서는 부주의한 DP 선박 운용 60건(58.3%), 절차 미 준수 8건(7.8%)이었고, 의사결정 오류에 의한 잘못된 조종이 21건(20.8%)을 차지하였다. 이러한 HFACS 분류의 베이지안 네트워크 적용을 통해서는 불안전한 감독(68%)이 불안전한 행동의 가장 큰 잠재적 요인으로 작용하고 있다는 것을 확인 할 수 있었다. 결론적으로 HFACS와 연계한 베이지안 네트워크는 인적오류를 분석하는 데 유용한 도구임을 확인 할 수 있었고, 분석 결과를 바탕으로 DP 선박안전 운용을 위한 정책, 내부 관계, 훈련등과 같은 인적오류를 경감 및 제거하기 위한 권고 9가지를 제안하였다. This study reviewed 612 DP LOP(Loss of Position) incident reports which submitted to IMCA from 2001~2010 and identified 103 human error caused incidents and classified it through HFACS. And, this study analysis of conditional probability of human error on DP LOP incidents through application of bayesian network. As a result, all 103 human error related DP LOP incidents were caused by unsafe acts, and among unsafe acts 70 incidents(68.0 %) were related to skill based error which are the largest proportion of human error causes. Among skill based error, 60(58.3%) incidents were involved inadvertent use of controls and 8(7.8%) incidents were involved omitted step in procedure. Also, 21(20.8%) incidents were involved improper maneuver because of decision error. Also this study identified that unsafe supervision(68%) is effected as the largest latent causes of unsafe acts through application to bayesian network. As a results, it is identified that combined analysis of HFACS and bayesian network are useful tool for human error analysis. Based on these results, this study suggest 9 recommendations such as polices, interpersonal interaction, training etc. to prevent and mitigate human errors during DP operations.

The STCW Manila amendments and its challenges to the Far East

채종주 한국항해항만학회 2014 한국항해항만학회지 Vol.38 No.3

The comprehensive review of the STCW 1978, as amended in 1995 and associated Code was carried out from 2006 to 2010. These amendments will have a certain degree of impact on Maritime Education and Training(MET) institutes in terms of education and training of seafarer worldwide. Particularly, the Far East region countries are effected more than other regions since they covered about 30% of officers and 37% ratings in the world. In view of these facts this dissertation conceived to analyze the problems in the Far East main seafarer supply countries faced the implementation of “STCW Manila Amendments” To analyze these problems, this dissertation carried out questionnaire research to 7 targeted main MET of major Far East seafarer supply countries. After research this dissertation suggests the possible solutions such as, Joint On-Board Training Center; Joint Asia Maritime E-learning Systems; methods to reducing work-load, ship inspection burden and determine mandatory minimum safety manning standards in a safe way; technical cooperation fund to installation of training equipment; and clarify vague terminology of STCW Manila Amendments, to solve problems identified through the questionnaires.

DP 선박의 안전한 운영을 위한 위치참조시스템에 대한 FSA의 적용

채종주,정연철 한국항해항만학회 2017 한국항해항만학회 학술대회논문집 Vol.2017 No.춘계

IMO 회원국감사제도의 시행과 대한민국의 대응 방안에 대한 고찰

채종주 해양환경안전학회 2018 해양환경안전학회지 Vol.24 No.6

IMO는 해사안전 및 환경보호와 관련된 IMO 국제협약의 효과적인 적용을 위해 자발적 회원국감사 제도를 개발하여 ’06년부터 ’15년까지 시행해 왔다. 이를 통해 IMO 회원국 감사제도의 목적 및 절차 등을 시범적으로 적용하였고 개선점을 식별하여 2016년 1월 1일부터 강제적 회원국 감사제도(IMSAS)를 시행하게 되었다. IMSAS는 IMO 협약을 비준한 IMO 회원국 중에 기국, 연안국 및 항만국으로서 주어진 책임을 적절히 수행하고 있는지 확인하여 식별된 사항의 개선을 통해 IMO 국제협약의 효과적인 적용을 위해 시행되었다. 본 연구 에서는 2020년 예정된 대한민국의 IMSAS 감사에 대비하기 위해서 IMO 문서를 참조하여 IMSAS의 내용 및 절차에 대해서 확인하였다. 더불어 과거 대한민국의 VIMSAS 수검 결과, 타국의 VIMSAS 수검 시 주요한 지적 사항 및 2018년 IMO III 5차 회의에 제출된 첫 IMSAS 수검 통합 결과 보고서에 대한 분석을 바탕으로 대한민국의 원활한 IMSAS 수검을 위해 해양수산부훈령의 최신화, IMO 협약에 의해 요구되는 정보 보고사항의 모니터링을 위한 시스템 개발, 전문가 지정, 관련 법령의 영문화, IMSAS 감사관 양성 및 IMSAS 수검 대응 조직구성을 제안하였다. IMO developed VIMSAS for effective application of IMO instruments related to maritime safety and environmental protection and was implemented from 2006 to 2016. Based on this, the purpose and procedures of VIMSAS applied to IMO member states by trial, and IMSAS was enforced from January 1st 2016. IMSAS was implemented to ensure that IMO Member States, such as flag states, coastal states and port states that ratified the IMO Convention, are properly performing their given responsibilities and to ensure the effective implementation of the IMO instruments through the improvement of identified non-conformities. In this study, the auditing contents and procedures were verified based on IMO documents in order to prepare for the IMSAS audit of Republic of Korea scheduled for 2020. For this purpose, this study proposed an update of a directory, development of monitoring system for information reporting required by IMO instruments, designation of relevant experts, preparation of an English version of related national laws, training of IMSAS auditors and establishment of an IMSAS audit response team for audit of IMSAS in 2020 by referring to the results of the VIMSAS for Republic of Korea, major findings of the VIMSAS of other IMO member states, and Consolidated Audit Summary Report (CASR), which was submitted at the 5th IMO III sub-committee.

Dynamic Positioning 원리 및 Position Reference System

채종주 한국항해항만학회 2012 한국항해항만학회 학술대회논문집 Vol.2012 No.공동학술

Dynamic Positioning 선박들의 사고사례 분석

채종주,정연철,Chong-Ju Chae,Yun-Chul Jung 한국항해항만학회 2015 한국항해항만학회지 Vol.39 No.3

Dynamic Positioning System(DPS)은 동력, DP control 장치, DP 컴퓨터, 위치참조시스템(PRS), 센서, thruster 시스템 및 DP 운용 자(DPO) 7가지로 구성되어 있다. DP 선박은 이들 구성요소들에 문제가 발생하면 그 기능을 상실할 수 있는데 이러한 DP 선박의 위치손실사 고(Loss of Position, LOP)는 선주가 자발적으로 매년 IMCA에 보고하고 있다. 본 연구에서는 2001∼2010년까지 10년 동안 IMCA 보고된 DP 선박 관련사고 612건에 대한 분석을 바탕으로 DPS의 7가지 구성요소와 관련된 사고 원인을 파악하고 이들 중 높은 비율을 차지하는 요인의 정성적, 정량적 분석을 통한 DP 선박의 안전운항 방안을 모색하고자 한다. 10년 평균 가장 높은 비율을 차지한 DPS 사고원인 요소는 PRS였 다. 이를 전문가들의 브레인스토밍을 통해 작성된 flowchart를 바탕으로 베이지안 네트워크 분석을 시행한 결과 PRS 각 요소별 조건부 확률 을 확인할 수 있었다. DP 선박의 drive off를 발생시키는데 주요한 영향을 미치는 것은 DGPS, microwave radar 및 HPR 이었고 DGPS에 주 요한 영향을 미치는 에러 요인은 signal blocked, electric components failure, relative mode error 및 signal weak or fail이라는 것도 확인할 수 있었다. The Dynamic Positioning System consists of 7 elements which are namely Power system, Human machine interface, DP Computer, Position Reference System(PRS), Sensors, Thruster system and DP Operator. Incidents like loss of position(LOP) on DP vessel usually occur due to errors in these 7 elements. The purpose of this study is to find out safety operation method of DP vessel through qualitative and quantitative analyze of DP LOP incidents which are submitted to IMCA every year. The 612 DP LOP incidents submitted from 2001 to 2010 were analyzed to find out the main cause of the incidents and its rate among other causes. Consequently, the highest rate of incidents involving DP elements are PRS errors. DP computer, Power system, Human error and thruster system came next. The PRS has been analyzed and a flowchart was drawn through expert brainstorming. Also, the conditional probability has been analyzed through Bayesian Networks based on this flowchart. Consequentially, the main causes of drive off incidents were DGPS, microwave radar and HPR. Also, this study identified the main causes of DGPS errors through Bayesian Networks. These causes are signal blocked, electric components failure, relative mode error, signal weak or fail.

A Study on FSA Application for Human Errors of Dynamic Positioning Vessels Incidents

채종주 한국항해항만학회 2017 한국항해항만학회지 Vol.41 No.5

Formal Safety Assessment (FSA) has been mostly implemented on the hardware aspects of vessels. Although there are guidelines regarding human error FSAs, there have not been many assessments in such areas. To this end, this study seeks to use precedent studies for the safe operation of DP vessels, conducting an FSA regarding human error of DP LOP (Loss of Position) incidents. For this, the study referred to precedent studies for the frequency of DP LOP incidents caused by human errors, adding the severity of LOP incidents, and then applying them to the Bayesian network. As a result, the study was able to confirm that among DP LOP incidents caused by human errors, the drive-off from skill-based errors was 74.3% and the drive-off from unsafe supervision was 50.5%. Based on such results, RCOs (Risk Control Options) were devised through a brainstorming session with experts coming up with proposals including providing mandatory DPO training, installing DP simulator on the vessels, drawing up measures to understanding the procedures for safe operation of DP vessels. Moreover, it was found that mandatory DPO training is reasonable in terms of cost benefits and that while installing a DP simulator is not suitable in terms of cost benefits, it can significantly reduce risks when operating DP vessels..

사고분석을 통한 선장 비상대응 역량강화 연구

채종주,박용선,조소현,강석용,이호,김홍범 해양환경안전학회 2019 海洋環境安全學會誌 Vol.25 No.4

Maritime accidents are always accompanied by human/property damages. If management level ship's officers properly respond to emergency situation in a correct manner based on knowledge required by international conventions, when maritime accidents occur, it will be possible to minimize such human/property damages. To improve the ability to deal with maritime accidents, this study analyze maritime accident cases to identify which competencies ships' officers' were lacking, compared the emergency response competencies required by international conventions, analyzed various emergency management manuals of shipping companies and carried out questionnaire surveys to suggest improvements of emergency response capability for ship's master. Through the analysis of maritime accidents, it was identified that management level ship's officers lacked competencies regarding damage stability and intact stability, and that the training for emergency response required by international conventions had been insufficiently carried out. In addition, even though emergency management manuals of ships were generally adequate, it has been identified that there were limitations in terms of practical use of emergency response manual. Therefore, based on the questionnaire, this study proposed the expansion of emergency response training required by international conventions based on use of simulators, and the development of guidelines or manuals for effective and efficient response in emergency situations. 해양사고는 항상 인적/물적 피해를 동반한다. 이러한 해양사고가 발생하였을 때 선박의 관리급 해기사가 정확한 지식을 바탕으로 비상 상황에 적절히 대응 한다면 이러한 인적/물적 피해는 최소화 할 수 있을 것이다. 본 연구에서는 해양사고 사례분석을 바탕으로 해양사고 발생 시 부족했던 해기능력 식별, 국제협약에서 요구하는 비상대응 능력을 비교, 선사가 보유하고 있는 다양한 비상대응 매뉴얼 분석 및 설문을 통해 해기사의 비상대응능력 향상을 위한 개선 사항을 제안하였다. 주요 해양사고사례를 통해서 많은 관리급 항해사가 손상복원력, 비손상복원력에 대한 지식의 부재를 식별하였고, 국제협약에서 요구하는 비상대응 해기능력의 경우 일부 축소해서 제공되고 있다는 것을 확인할 수 있었다. 더불어 선사의 비상대응 매뉴얼은 대체로 잘 갖추어져 있으나 실제 비상시 활용 측면에서는 한계가 있다는 것을 식별하였다. 이러한 분석을 바탕으로 선원 및 선사 관계자를 대상으로 설문을 시행하여 국제협약에서 요구하는 비상대응 해기교육의 확대, 시뮬레이터를 활용한 비상상황에 대한 간접경험 기회제공 확대 및 비상 시 효과적이고 효율적인 대응을 위한 지침 또는 매뉴얼의 개발 등을 제안하였다.

A Study on FSA Application to PRS for Safe Operation of Dynamic Positioning Vessel

채종주,정연철 한국항해항만학회 2017 한국항해항만학회지 Vol.41 No.5

The Formal Safety Assessment (FSA) is a structured and systematic methodology developed by the IMO, aimed at assessing the risk of vessels and recommending the method to control intolerable risks, thereby enhancing maritime safety, including protection of life, health, the marine environment and property, by using risk analysis and cost-benefit assessment. While the FSA has mostly been applied to merchant vessels, it has rarely been applied to a DP vessel, which is one of the special purpose vessels in the offshore industry. Furthermore, most of the FSA has been conducted so far by using the Fault Tree Analysis tool, even though there are many other risk analysis tools. This study carried out the FSA for safe operation of DP vessels by using the Bayesian network, under which conditional probability was examined. This study determined the frequency and severity of DP LOP incidents reported to the IMCA from 2001 to 2010, and obtained the Risk Index by applying the Bayesian network. Then, the Risk Control Options (RCOs) were identified through an expert brainstorming and DP vessel simulations. This study recommends duplication of PRS, regardless of the DP class and PRS type and DP system specific training. Finally, this study verified that the Bayesian network and DP simulator can also serve as an effective tool for FSA implementation.