도로부지의 보상평가규정에 대한 비판적 고찰 = A Critical Study of the Compensation Valuation Rules of the Road Bed

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Due to the nature of public goods the roads have the difficulty of getting marketability . For the road doesn`t have profitable market performances, it is difficult to appraise the road by applying the three methods in theory and practice. So, in the case of the private road, the conventional evaluation of road was based on the theory that the value of the road was transferred to the adjacent land. However, it is difficult to apply the ``hwache`` (transfer of the value) theory in theory and practice. Therefore it was primarily used to justify the logic of the low valuation of the road. The low valuation of the private land is based on the market value which reflects the constraints caused by the regal regulations and the real situation. Nevertheless, the hwache theory still makes confusion in the road compensation because it becomes the logical base of the low valuation of the private road. To resolve this confusion, we should start from clarifying the theoretical basis of the evaluation of the road. The value of the land consists of the sum of the present value of the income during the holding period and the present value of the market value at the time of disposal. Reflecting the uniqueness of the road, it should be evaluated on the basis of this theoretical fundamental. In fact, the legal or real status of the road is very various. Therefore, compensating the road according to the three legal status is not appropriate. This problem caused controversy and litigation. Through the emprical, quantitative studies of various roads we can appraise the road more appropriately and the compensation value of the road can reflect the realities and possibilities of the road values.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이선영, "신토지수용과 보상법론" 리북스 2005

2 조주현, "부동산학원론" 건국대학교 출판부 2006

3 안정근, "부동산평가이론" 법문사 1998

4 이선영, "부동산감정평가 및 가격공시법론" 리북스 2010

5 김준호, "민법강의" 법문사 2005

6 한국감정원 감정평가연수원 연구개발부, "도로의 감정평가" 한국감정원 1992

7 임호정, "도로에 의한 사권제한과 권리구제" 한국감정평가협회 14 (14): 2004

8 이현준, "도로에 따른 보상금액 결정의 문제점과 개선방향 연구" 한국지적학회 28 (28): 1-14, 2012

9 임호정, "도로부지의 보상평가방법에 관한 연구" 한국감정평가협회 13 (13): 2003

10 임호정, "도로부지의 보상평가방법" 한국감정평가협회 12 (12): 2002

11 김민정, "도로부지의 보상기준에 관한 연구" 건국대학교 부동산대학원 2003

12 박근호, "도로부지 보상기준의 개선방안에 관한 연구" 영남대학교 행정대학원 2012

13 이홍규, "감정평가실무강의" 리북스 2008

14 류지태, "감정평가 및 보상법규" 회경사 2006