헌법재판소법 제39조에 대한 헌법소원 심판청구의 청구기간의 기산점 = The time Limit for filing constitutional complaint against Article 39 of the Constitutional Court Act: When does it begin?

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Whenever a complainant repeatedly files the same constitutional complaint against the Article 39 of the Constitutional Court Act, the Constitutional Court newly counts the time limit for filing constitutional complaint from the date of the latest complaint. Thus, Constitutional Court would dismiss constitutional complaint for which the filing time limit may have lapse, if the filing time limit were determined on the basis of the previous constitutional complaint. This attitude of the Constitutional Court goes against its established judicial precedent about the time limit for filing constitutional complaint against statute which says that if a reason arises under the law and thus the filing period begins, then even if another reason thereafter newly arises under the law, a new filing period cannot be seen as continuing. Such an attitude also goes against the purpose of establishing a filing period provision for constitutional complaint, as complainants can repeatedly dispute Article 39 of the Act without being bound by the filing time limit. Thus, the Constitutional Court should determine the beginning date of filing period on the basis of the initial constitutional complaint against Article 39 of the Act, and should decide to dismiss the later constitutional complaint for which the filing period have elapse.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 정종섭, "헌법소원심판청구에 있어서의 청구기간에 관한 연구" 헌법재판소 4 : 149-203, 1993

2 허영, "헌법소송법론(제7판)" 박영사 2012

3 정종섭, "헌법소송법(제6판)" 박영사 2010

4 김현철, "판례 헌법소송법" 전남대학교 출판부 2011

5 정구환, "불기소처분 헌법소원에서의 보충성원칙 및 청구기간(2)" (553) : 5-38, 2002

6 정구환, "불기소처분 헌법소원에서의 보충성원칙 및 청구기간(1)" (552) : 5-47, 2002

7 정종섭, "법령에 대한 헌법소원절차에 있어 청구기간의 적용여부 - 헌재 1992. 6. 26. 91헌마25결정" 국제헌법학회한국학회 1 : 344-362, 1994

8 박종보, "법령에 대한 헌법소원의 청구기간 재론" 대한변호사협회 (237) : 23-38, 1996

9 오훤, "법령에 대한 헌법소원심판의 청구기간에 관한 연구 : 헌법재판소 결정례를 중심으로" 연세대학교 대학원 2011

10 朴鍾普, "법령에 대한 헌법소원 : 그 대상과 요건을 중심으로" 서울大學校 大學院 1994