도시계획의 변경으로 인한 개발이익 환수 — 용도지역 상향을 중심으로 — = Return of development gains due to changes in urban planning — Focusing on up-zoning —

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The country needs to flexibly adjust land use through changes in urban planning according to social development and industrial changes. When building permits are newly granted or building permit requirements are eased due to changes in urban planning, the objective use value of the land increases. It has become a subject of social debate whether it is reasonable for the development gains generated by this to belong only to the landowner. As a result, the contents of the subject, method, standard the return of development gains were determined through legislative policy. Korea has various development gains return systems under the public law. They are public contribution, development levy, and reconstruction levy. Each system is operated individually, so there is a certain limit to the systematic return of development gains resulting from urban planning changes. In particular, in view of the gradual increase in demand for up-zoning, it is urgent to reorganize the system to properly return the development gains resulting from urban planning change.
Under the current public law, the development gains return system recognizes a mutually complementary relationship in each phase and is similar in nature, so it is necessary to unify the conceptual system of development gains and link and reorganize each system. The return of development gains due to urban planning changes is determined at the urban planning change phase in the case of public contribution and at the project completion phase in the case of development levy. In addition, the nature of development levy and reconstruction levy can be seen to be similar, considering that the development gains to be returned are derived from development of land, that is, the change in urban planning. If so, the concept of development gains under the Development Gains Return Act is defined as the increase in land use value that belongs to the landowner or implementer of development project due to a change in urban planning or implementation of the development project for the target land. This is a reasonable adjustment of the conceptual elements of development gains. Based on this conceptual system, the concept of development gains returned as public contribution and reconstruction levy can also be determined and operated in an integrated manner. This will help to increase the effectiveness of the development gains return system by establishing a simple, consistent and dense return network. Landowners can also get opportunities for various development projects that can be more easily accepted by society through the return of development gains.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 성낙인, "헌법학, 제21판" 법문사 2021

2 홍정선, "행정법원론(하), 제29판" 박영사 2021

3 박균성, "행정법론(하), 제21판" 박영사 2023

4 김동희, "행정법Ⅱ, 제25판" 박영사 2019

5 김종보, "토지형질변경허가의 법적 성질" 한국행정판례연구회 11 : 383-422, 2006

6 이선영, "토지재산권의 가치보장과 개발이익 환수의 한계 -개발부담금제도를 중심으로-" 한국토지법학회 26 (26): 189-224, 2010

7 정희남, "토지에 대한 개발이익환수제도의 개편방안" 국토연구원 2003

8 이정전, "토지문제에 대한 4가지 패러다임" (43) : 2005

9 이우진, "토지공개념과 개발이익환수제" 동북아법연구소 12 (12): 285-318, 2018

10 허영, "토지거래허가제의 헌법상 문제점" 1989

11 허지인 ; 김종보, "지구단위계획과 공공기여의 산정" 행정법이론실무학회 (67) : 137-162, 2022

12 길준규, "재건축 개발이익환수제도의 법적 문제" 한국비교공법학회 7 (7): 47-76, 2006

13 성소미, "재건축 개발이익환수에 관한 법적 쟁점" 한국토지공법학회 31 : 1-28, 2006

14 김웅, "재건축 개발이익 환수제도의 헌법적 의의와 그 한계" 고려대학교 2021

15 김나래, "부동산 개발이익 환수에 관한 법적 고찰" 한국부동산법학회 25 (25): 49-72, 2021

16 정해영, "법치행정의 원리와 공공기여금" 법학연구소 10 (10): 198-220, 2017

17 김종보, "도시계획의 핵심기능과 지적제도의 충돌 ― 건축단위와 건축허용성을 중심으로 ―" 행정법이론실무학회 16 : 55-81, 2006

18 김종보, "도시계획변경거부의 처분성" 행정법이론실무학회 11 : 243-272, 2004

19 송시강, "공법상 부담금에 관한 연구 ― 재원조달책임에 있어서 평등원칙 ―" 행정법이론실무학회 (57) : 93-139, 2019

20 이형찬, "계획이익 조정체계 정비에 관한 연구" 국토연구원 2016

21 김종보, "건축허용성의 부여와 반영" 법학연구소 53 (53): 145-173, 2012

22 김종보, "건설법의 이해, 제7판" 북포레 2023

23 유해웅, "개발이익환수제도의 발전적 전개를 위한 고찰" 9 : 2000

24 이춘원, "개발이익환수에 관한 검토" 한국부동산법학회 21 (21): 129-159, 2017

25 김종보, "개발사업에서 국공유지의 법적 지위" 행정법이론실무학회 (57) : 1-24, 2019

26 허지인, "개발사업법상 공공시설에 관한 공법적 연구" 서울대학교 2020

27 김남욱, "개발부담금제도에 관한 고찰" 10 : 2000

28 차진아, "개발부담금의 법적 성격에 관한 헌법재판소 판례의 분석과 평가" 비교법학연구소 59 : 155-206, 2020

29 신정규, "개발부담금의 법적 성격과 우선징수권에 관한 고찰 - 헌법재판소 2016. 6. 30. 2013헌바191, 2014헌바473 (병합) -" 한국토지공법학회 76 : 131-156, 2016

30 최진수, "개발부담금의 법적 성격과 그 합헌성 심사기준에 관한 고찰" 한국공법학회 49 (49): 535-560, 2020

31 Department of Communities and Local Government, "Section 106 Afffordable Housing Requirement Review and Appeal" 2013

32 Michael Purdue, "A Practical Approach to Planning Law 14th Edition" Oxford University Press 2019