It is necessary that bullying needs to be dealt with significantly since it is a serious social problem and influences students who experience it continuously in the long term. Though there have been various efforts by the government organizations and...
It is necessary that bullying needs to be dealt with significantly since it is a serious social problem and influences students who experience it continuously in the long term. Though there have been various efforts by the government organizations and studies on it, they have not solved this problem yet. The reason is that the prior studies only emphasized the characteristics of individuals divided into bullies and victims, had a shallow understanding of a variety of characteristics and lacked the consideration of environmental conditions.
Accordingly, this study aimed to enhance understanding of a variety of characteristics of the variables through relational self and by placing more emphasis on bystanders’ reaction towards bullying than on bullies and victims. In addition, it looked into the class environments in order to reflect the group dynamics, and rather than analyzing the characteristics of the group to which students belonged and the characteristics of individuals at the same level, it used all the characteristic variables as units of analysis through multilevel analysis. Since multilevel analysis has the advantage of reflecting the hierarchical nature of multilevel data, both the student characteristic variables and the class characteristic variables can be used as the units of analysis, which is why this study is differentiated from the prior studies. In practice, students form a hierarchical structure in class, so analysis of this with the existing statistical methods for single-layered structures such as regression analysis may cause errors.
Thus, this study assumed that the student characteristic variables (perceived support from relation, agency, over-dependency to relation, empathy-care, instrumental reaction, avoidance of relation, consciousness of others) and the class characteristic variables corresponding to the class environment (peer support, teacher support, peer tolerance of class bullying, teacher tolerance of class bullying, class rules, class cohesiveness) would influence bystanders’ reaction towards bullying (assisting behavior, bystanding behavior, defending behavior) differently, which is because this study judged that bystanders’ reaction towards bullying could not only depend on the aspect of personal relations but also be influenced by the surrounding environment. Relational self was expected to influence the surrounding people’s different reactions in the event of bullying since it acts as a mechanism to motivate individuals and make them choose or control their consistent reactions. In addition, it was considered that the class environment needed to be examined together in that it was a developmental context that had an important impact on the formation of students’ thoughts, attitudes, beliefs and behaviors. The class environment is in itself an influential protective or risk factor for bullying, but it was also expected to function as a moderator variable that suppressed or strengthened the relative influence of the student characteristic variables.
For this, the questionnaires were distributed to a total of 1,170 students in the first to third grades in 58 classes of six middle schools in Seoul and Chungnam, and the data from 978 out of them were used for the final data analysis. Descriptive statistics analysis and correlation analysis were performed using the SPSS 22.0 program, and two-level multilevel analysis was performed using HLM 6.08 program in order to figure out the influences of the student characteristic variables that corresponded to relational self (perceived support from relation, agency, over-dependency to relation, empathy-care, instrumental reaction, avoidance of relation, consciousness of others) and the class characteristic variables (peer support, teacher support, peer tolerance of class bullying, teacher tolerance of class bullying, class rules, class cohesiveness) on influence bystanders’ reaction towards bullying (assisting behavior, bystanding behavior, defending behavior). Besides, it examined whether the class characteristic variables would have a moderating effect when the student characteristic variables influenced bystanders’ reaction towards bullying.
The main results of this study are summarized as follows. First, the explanatory power of the student characteristic variables with regard to assisting behavior in bullying was 13.81%. Among them, over-dependency to relation and instrumental reaction had a significantly positive influence on it while perceived support from relation and empathy-care had a significantly negative influence on it. The explanatory power of the class characteristic variables with regard to assisting behavior in bullying was 63.64%. Among them, teacher support and teacher tolerance of class bullying had a significantly negative effect on it. In particular, assisting behavior in bullying showed an interactive effect. Teacher support in class and teacher tolerance of class bullying were found to significantly adjust the relation between individual instrumental reaction and assisting behavior in bullying. To put it more concretely, the relation between instrumental reaction and assisting behavior in bullying was found to be positive, and it was more influential in the class with low teacher support and teacher tolerance of class bullying.
Second, the explanatory power of the student characteristic variables with regard to bystanding behavior in bullying was 20.24%. Among them, empathy-care had a significantly negative influence on it while instrumental reaction and consciousness of others had a significantly positive influence on it. The explanatory power of the class characteristic variables with regard to bystanding behavior in bullying was 35.71%. Among them, teacher support had a significantly negative influence on it while peer tolerance of class bullying had a significantly positive influence on it.
Third, the explanatory power of the student characteristic variables with regard to defending behavior in bullying was 15.26%. Among them, over-dependency to relation and empathy-care had a significantly positive influence on it while instrumental reaction and consciousness of others had a significantly negative influence on it. With regard to defending behavior in bullying, however, there was no difference between classes after the influence of the student characteristic variables was corrected, so the influence of the class characteristic variables was not identified. This result may be attributed to the fact that defending behavior in bullying is more influenced by individual characteristics than by class characteristics in that it is an attempt to break the imbalance in power, unlike assisting behavior in bullying or bystanding behavior in bullying.
The results of this study above provide its significance as follow. First, it verified both the student characteristic variables and the class characteristic variables that influenced bystanders’ reaction towards bullying by using multilevel model. Second, it identified the importance of relational self that had been overlooked in the studies on bullying. Third, it found that the problem of bullying among adolescents was influenced by not only the individual characteristics of students but also the class environment. Hopefully, practical and advanced studies to come up with comprehensive solutions to bullying based on this study will continue to be published.