韓美 FTA의 間接收用과 韓國 損失補償 法理의 比較 硏究 = Indirect Expropriation in the Korea-U.S. FTA and the Korean Compensation Requirement under the Constitution

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper explores how the indirect expropriation provision in the Korea-U.S. FTA will affect the Korean legal system on the similar principle. To do this, it examines the development and the meaning of indirect expropriation in international law and regulatory taking in the U.S.; and compares with the Korean legal principle under the Constitution. As a result, it has found that the Korean courts have already recognized the similar concept to regulatory taking or indirect expropriation, although they do not admit the term of regulatory taking or indirect expropriation. However, it is likely that the Korea-U.S. FTA will further the change of the Korean legal principle on the compensation requirement under the Constitution toward more reasonable structure.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 "헌법재판소 1999.10.26. 97헌바26 (장기미집행도시계획시설에 대한 보상을 위한 입법개선 촉구)"

2 "헌법재판소 1999. 4. 29. 94헌바37 외 66건(병합) (택지소유상한에관한법률 제2조 제1호 나목 등 위헌소원)"

3 "헌법재판소 1998.12.24. 89헌마214. 90헌바16. 97헌바78병합 (도시계획법 제21조에 대한 위헌소원)"

4 정하중, "헌법상의 재산권보장체계에 있어서의 경계이론과 분리이론" 5 : 2003

5 김관호, "한미 FTA와 간접수용: 국내 재산권 보호 제도에의 시사점" 한국규제학회 16 (16): 37-66, 2007

6 김배원, "한국헌법상 토지재산권의 보장과 제한: 헌법재판소 판례를 중심으로" (20) : 2005

7 고헌환, "토지재산권의 사회적 구속성과 한계에 관한 법리" 24 : 2006

8 김지엽, "토지이용규제에 대한 한국과 미국의 비교 연구- 헌법의 재산권 보장 관점을 중심으로-" 대한국토ㆍ도시계획학회 42 (42): 7-28, 2007

9 박철곤, "토지소유권 제한의 한계에 관한 사법적 연구" 전주대 2003

10 김문현, "재산권의 사회구속성과 공용수용의 체계에 대한 검토- 소위 '분리이론'의 한국헌법상 수용에 대한 평가를 중심으로" 한국공법학회 32 (32): 1-18, 2004

11 한수웅, "재산권의 내용을 새로이 형성하는 법규정의 헌법적 문제" 32 (32): 1999

12 유인출, "도시계획제한에 따른 사유재산권의 침해와 권리구제에 관한 연구:개발제한구역을 중심으로" 한남대 2003

13 "대법원 1990.5.8. 선고 89부2 결정; 1992.11.24. 선고 92부14 판결"

14 김종보, "계획제한과 손실보상논의의 재검토" 부동산 법학 1999

15 김민호, "간접수용 법리의 합헌성 연구" 한국법학원 (96) : 88-102, 2007

16 Christie, George C., "What Constitutes a Taking of Property Under International Law" 38 : 1982

17 Aldrich, George H., "What Constitutes a Compensable Taking of Property?: The Decisions of the Iran-United States Tribunal" 88 : 1994

18 "Ukr., Inc. v. Ukr., ICSID (W. Bank) ARB/00/9 (2003) (Award)"

19 Mouri, Allahyar, "The International Law of Expropriation as Reflected in the Work of the Iran-U.S. Claims" 70 : 1994

20 Allahyar, Mouri, "The International Law of Expropriation as Reflected in the Work of the Iran-U.S. Claims" 70 : 1994

21 Been, Vicki, "The Global Fifth Amendment NAFTA’s Investment Protections And The Misguided Quest For An International Regulatory Takings Doctrine" 78 : 2003

22 Yoo, John C., "The Constitutionality of Congressional Executive Agreements" 99 : 2001

23 "Tecnicas Medioambientales Tecmed S.A. v. Mexico, ICSID Case No. ARB(AF)/00/2, 43 I.L.M. 133"

24 "Tahoe-Sierra Preservation Council, Inc. v. Tahoe Regional Planning Agency, 535 U.S. 302"

25 Pope, "Statement of Defense" NAFTA Ch 155-156, 1999

26 "S.D. Myers, Inc. v. Government of Canada"

27 Mandelker, Daniel R., "Planning and Control of Land Development: Cases and Materials" Lexis 2001

28 "Pennsylvania Coal Co. v. Mahon, 260 U.S. 393"

29 "Penn Central Transportation Co. v. New York City, 438 U.S. 104"

30 "Nollan v. California Coastal Community, 483 U.S. 825"

31 Parisi, Michael G., "Moving toward Transparency? An Examination of Regulatory Takings in International Law" 10 : 2005

32 "Missouri v. Holland, 252 U.S. 416"

33 "Methanex Corp. v. United States, 44 I.L.M. 1345 (NAFTA Ch.11 Arb. Trib. 2005)"

34 "Metalclad Corp. v. United Mexican States, Award P 103 (ICSID (Additional Facility) Case No. ARB(AF)/97/1, Aug. 30, 2000), 16 ICSID Rev. - Foreign Inv. L.J. 168"

35 "MTD Equity Sdn. Bhd. V. Chile, ICSID Case No. ARB/01/7"

36 "Lucas v. South Carolina Coastal Commission 505 U.S. 1003"

37 "Loretto v. Teleprompter Manhattan,. 458 U.S. 419"

38 "Lingle V. Chevron U.S.A. Inc., 544 U.S. 528"

39 Stanley, Jon A., "Keeping Big Brother Out of Our Backyard: Regulatory Takings as Defined in International Law and Compared to American Fifth Amendment Jurisprudence" 15 : 2001

40 "Kaiser Aetna v. United Stastes, 444 U.S. 164, 176"

41 Wagner, Martin. J., "International Investment, Expropriation and Environmental Protection" 29 : 1999

42 Edsall, Rachel D., "Indirect Expropriation Under NAFTA and DR-CAFTA: Potential Inconsistencies in the Treatment of State Public Welfare Regulations" 86 : 2006

43 "Hodel v. Irving, 481 U.S. 704"

44 Nolon, John R., "Historical Overview of the American Land Use System: A Diagnostic Approach to Evaluating Governmental Land Use Control" 2007

45 "Hadacheck v. Sebastian, 239 U.S. 394"

46 Bradley, Curtis A., "Foreign Relations Law: Cases and Materials" Aspen 2006

47 "Feldman v. Mexico, Award, (NAFTA Trib. 2002)"

48 "Dolan v. City of Tigard, 512 U.S. 374"

49 Weston, Burns H., "Constructive Takings Under International Law: A Modest Foray into the Problem of Creeping Expropriation" 16 : 1976

50 "Connolly v. Pension Ben. Guar. Corp., 475 U.S. 211"

51 Muse-Fisher, Michael, "CAFTA-DR and the Iterative Process of Bilateral Investment Treaty Making: Towards a United States Takings Framework for Analyzing International Expropriation Claims" 19 : 2007

52 "Banco Nacional de Cuba v. Sabbatino, 307 F.2d 845"

53 "Armstrong v. United States, 364 U.S. 40"

54 Sampliner, Gary, "Arbitration of Expropriation Cases Under U.S. Investment Treaties: A Threat to Democracy or the Dog that Didn't Bite" 18 : 2003

55 "Andrus v. Allard, 444 U.S. 51"

56 "Agins v. City of Tiburton, 447 U.S. 255"