학습조직의 촉진요인 및 실천요인 분석 : L 정유 사례를 중심으로

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 최근까지의 학습조직 연구경향들을 종합적이고 체계적으로 제시해 줄 수 있는 학습조직의 통합적 프레임웍을 설정하고, 이에 기초해서 학습조직을 활성화하는 촉진요인과 학습조직의 고유한 활동에 해당되는 실천요인을 분석하여, 그 분석결과에 기초해서 해당조직에 효과적인 학습조직 요인을 제시하고자 하는 목적으로 실시되었다.
이러한 연구목적을 위해서 본 연구에서 논의하고자 하는 연구문제는 다음과 같다.

1. 조직내의 다양한 집단적 특성에 따라서 학습조직 촉진요인과 실천 요인에 차이가 있는가? 있다면 어떤 집단간에 어떤 학습조직 요인 이 차이가 있는가?

1-1. 업무집단에 따라서 학습조직 촉진요인과 실천요인에 차이가 있 는가?
1-2. 재직기간에 따라서 학습조직 촉진요인과 실천요인에 차이가 있 는가?
1-3. 직급에 따라서 학습조직 촉진요인과 실천요인에 차이가 있 는가?

2. 조직의 다양한 집단적 특성을 반영할 경우 이에 해당되는 효과적인 학습조직 촉진요인과 실천요인은 무엇인가?

3. 해당조직이 전체 조직 차원에서 조치를 취해야 할 학습조직 촉진 요인 및 실천요인은 무엇이며, 조치를 취해야 할 우선순위가 높은 것은 무엇인가?

이상의 연구문제를 밝히기 위해서 L 정유에 소속된 130명을 대상으로 설문조사를 실시하였으며, 분석 결과 밝혀진 결론은 다음과 같다.

첫째, 학습조직 추진 시 다음과 같이 조직 내의 다양한 집단적 특성이나 요구를 반영할 필요가 있다:
① 영업 집단의 경우 촉진요인의 상호신뢰, 개방적 의사소통, 끊임없는 도전, 시스템 사고, 실천요인의 지식창출, 팀학습 요인을 활성화시킬 필요성이 크다.
② 현 소속 부서에 재직 기간이 3-6년 된 집단에게는 촉진요인의 위험감수, 부문간 협력, 보상 시스템, 실천요인의 지식활용, 개인학습 요인에 초점을 둔 다양한 활동기회를 제공해 주는 것이 필요하고, 6년 이상된 집단에게는 실천요인의 환경학습 기회를 제공해 주는 것이 필요하다.
③ 직급에 따라서는 차장 이상 집단에게는 보다 적극적으로 실천요인의 지식활용 기회를 제공해 줄 필요가 있다.

둘째, 바람직한 수준과 현재수준과의 격차의 크기에 따르면서 학습조직 요인 영역간 균형을 맞추어서 학습조직 요인을 선정한다면, 촉진요인의 부문간 협력, 보상 시스템, 실천요인의 지식저장, 개인학습에 초점을 두게 될 것이고, 조직의 강점요인을 활용하면서 영역간 균형을 맞춘다면 촉진요인의 끊임없는 도전, 리더십, 실천요인의 지식공유, 팀학습 요인 등에 초점을 두게 될 것이다.

셋째, 본 연구의 적용 대상 기업인 L정유는 2-3년 동안 꾸준하게 학습조직을 추진해 왔지만, 본 연구에서 제시한 촉진요인 및 실천요인 모두가 조직 구성원들이 바라는 수준에는 도달해 있지 못했다. 이는 학습조직 추진은 단기간에 성과를 볼 수 있는 것이 아니라 장기간에 걸쳐서 꾸준하게 추진해야 한다는 것을 시사한다.

넷째, 조직의 시스템 요인은 촉진요인의 권한위임, 부문간 협력, 비전공유, 실천요인의 지식저장, 지식공유, 조직학습, 고객학습, 타사학습 등의 학습요인들과 직ㆍ간접적으로 밀접한 관련을 가질 수 있다.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The purpose of this study was to integrate learning organizational factors,and then to analyze learning organizational facilitation and practice factors, and then to suggest effective learning organizational factors .
Problem statement is as following.

1. Is there difference in the effective learning organizational factors according to the organizational different groups.
2. What is effective learning organizational factors or implemental methods according to the organizational different groups.
3. In the perspectives of entire organization, what are the effective learning organizational factors with higher priority.

For this study L Oil Corporation was chosen, then a survey was conducted to 130 persons. Conclusions in this study are as following.

1. It is needed to consider different group characters as following.

① Marketing group needed facilitation factors such as mutual trust, open communication, continuous challenges, systems thinking, and practicing factors such as knowledge creating, team learning.
② The group of 3-6 years tenure needed facilitation factors such asrisk taking, corporation between divisions, compensation system, reward system, and practicing factors such as knowledge utilization, individual learning. 6 years over group needed practicing factor, environmental learning.
③ According to position level, middle manager, chjang, needed the opportunity to utilize their knowledge.

2. If we choose learning organizational factors according to the gap between desirable level and current level, and according to balance among factor areas, we will focus to facilitation factors such as corporation between divisions, reward system, and practicing factors such as knowledge storing, individual learning.

3. Even though LOil Corporation has made an effort to become a learning organization for 2-3 years, both facilitation factors and practicing factors did not reach to the level organizational members want. This imply that learning organization can not be built within 2-3 years but require long term years.

4. Organizational system factors can be connected to the facilitation factors such as empowerment, corporation between divisions, shared vision, and to practicing factors such as knowledge storing, organizalional learning, learning from customers, learning from other companies.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 서론 1
• 1. 연구의 필요성 1
• 2. 연구 문제 4
• 3. 용어의 정의 5
• 4. 연구의 제한점 6
• Ⅱ. 이론적 배경 7
• 1. 학습조직 개념에 대한 논의 7
• 1) 실천요인을 강조한 정의 8
• 2) 실천요인을 1차로, 촉진요인을 2차로 강조한 정의 10
• 3) 촉진요인을 1차로, 실천요인을 2차로 강조한 정의 10
• 4) 결과요인을 1차로, 실천요인을 2차로 강조한 정의 12
• 5) 본 연구의 학습조직 정의 13
• 2. 선행 연구 분석 14
• 1) 학습 프로세스에 근거한 연구 14
• 2) 학습조직 촉진요인에 근거한 연구 18
• 3) 조직의 위계적 학습유형에 근거한 연구 23
• Ⅲ. 학습조직의 통합적 프레임웍 26
• 1. 학습조직 촉진요인 27
• 1) 행동특성 요인 27
• 2) 시스템 요인 35
• 2. 학습조직 실천요인 39
• 1) 학습 프로세스 요인 39
• 2) 학습유형 요인 44
• Ⅳ. 연구방법 54
• 1. 연구대상 54
• 2. 진단도구 54
• 1) 진단도구 제작과정 54
• 2) 진단도구 신뢰도 55
• 3) 진단도구의 측정준거 및 척도 57
• 3. 자료처리 및 통계분석 방법 57
• Ⅴ. 결과분석 59
• 1. 업무분야에 따른 집단간 학습조직 요인의 차이 59
• 1) 업무분야에 따른 집단간 학습조직 촉진요인의 차이 59
• 2) 업무분야에 따른 집단간 학습조직 실천요인의 차이 65
• 2. 재직기간에 따른 집단간 학습조직 요인의 차이 70
• 1) 재직기간에 따른 집단간 학습조직 촉진요인의 차이 70
• 2) 재직기간에 따른 집단간 학습조직 실천요인의 차이 75
• 3. 직급에 따른 집단간 학습조직 요인의 차이 80
• 1) 직급에 따른 집단간 학습조직 촉진요인의 차이 80
• 2) 직급에 따른 집단간 학습조직 실천요인의 차이 84
• 4. 전체 집단의 학습조직 요인의 바람직한 수준과 현재수준간의 격차의 차이 89
• 1) 전체 집단의 격차에서 학습조직 촉진요인의 차이 89
• 2) 전체 집단의 격차에서 학습조직 실천요인의 차이 91
• Ⅴ. 논의 및 결론 93
• 1. 요약 93
• 2. 논의 95
• 1) 학습조직 추진 방법의 획일성 대 다양성에 대한 논의 95
• 2) 학습조직 요인의 보편성 대 조직의 특수성에 대한 논의 97
• 3) 시스템 요인이 학습조직 요인에 미치는 영향에 대한 논의 98
• 4) 학습조직 요인 선정시의 집중 대 균형에 대한 논의 100
• 3. 결론 및 제언 103

참고문헌 (Reference)

1. 한경영, 이장우, 김영사, , 1997

2. Powershift, Tofflir, , 1990

3. Brain Power, Stewart, , 1991

4. Learning Curve, Eisman, , 1995

5. Managing chaos, Stacey, Managing Chaos, , 1992

6. 한국보고서, 매일경제신문사, , 1988

7. Needs Assessment, Rossett, , 1991

8. Systems Thinking, Senge, , 1996

9. Unfolding Meaning, Bohm, , 1985

10. Industrial dynamics, Forrester, Jay Wright, M.I.T. Press, , 1961

11. Nummi vs. Uddevalla, Berggren, , 1993

12. The Tacit dimension, Polanyi, Michael, Doubleday, , 1966

13. Intellectual Capital, Stewart, Intellectual Capital, , 1997

14. Skilled Incompetence, Argyris, , 1986

15. The Learning company, Boydell, Pedler, , 1992

16. The general managers, Kotter, John P., Free Press, The General Managers, , 1982

17. Experiential learning, Kolb, Experiential Learning, , 1984

18. Liberation Management, Peters, , 1992

19. The achieving society, McClell, D.C, , 1961

20. Battle of the Buzzards, Benson, , 1997

21. Changing Organizations, Bennis, W., Bennis, , 1966

22. Concurrent Engineering, 사이또우 미로루, , 1995

23. Entrepreneurship: Text, Ronstadt, , 1984

24. Self Directed Learning, Treffinger, , 1982

25. The myopia of learning, March, Levinthal, , 1993

26. TransformationalChange, Limerick, Cunnington, Passifield, , 1995

27. Choices for the manager, Stewart, Rosemary, Prentice-Hall, , 1982

28. Communities of practice, Wenger, , 1998

29. Contrasts in Management, Stewart.R, , 1976

30. Science of the Artifical, Simon, , 1969

31. Time-and-Motion regained, Adler, , 1993

32. We are What We can Learn, Flower, , 1996

33. Decision Making at the Top, Donaldson, Lorsch, , 1983

34. New patterns of management, Likert, Rensis, McGraw-Hill, New Patterns of Management, , 1961

35. Charting the Corporate Mind, Hampden-Turner, , 1990

36. Decisions and organizations, March, James G, Basil Blackwell, , 1987

37. Hardwiring the Organization, Redding, , 1997

38. Management and World's Work, Drucker, , 1988

39. Unlearning the Organization, Slocum, McGill, , 1993

40. Why a Learning Organization?, Karash, , 1996

41. Institutionalizing Innovation, Jelinek, , 1979

42. Re- educating the corporation, Tobin, , 1993

43. The Nature of Managerial Work, Minzberg, The Nature of Managerial Work, , 1973

44. Acquisition of Cognitive Skill, Anderson, , 1982

45. Field theory in social science, Lewin, Field Theory in Social Science, , 1970

46. Leadership and the new science, Wheatley,M.J, , 1999

47. Leading Learning Organizations, Senge, , 1999

48. The Architecture of Simplicity, Miller, , 1993

49. The knowledge-creating company, Nonaka, Ikujiro^, Oxford University Press, The Knowledge Creating Company, , 1995

50. Theory of Cognitive Dissonance, Festinger, , 1957

51. A behavioral theory of the firm, Cyert, Richard Michael, Prentice-Hall, , 1963

52. Action Science and Intervention, Argyris, , 1982

53. Building Knowledge Organization, Darling, , 1996

54. Building Learning Organizations, Senge, , 1992

55. How Microsoft Competes"Research, Cusumano, Selby, "How Microsoft Competes""Research", , 1996

56. Organizational Crises andChange, Beak.J, Fink, Taddeo .K, , 1971

57. The Collaboration Skills Manual, Joiner, , 1985

58. The Global LearningOrganization, Reynolds, Marquardt M, , 1994

59. IT and The Learning Organization, King, , 1996

60. In Search of Management: Culture, Watson, , 1994

61. The Wisdom of Strategic Learning, Cunningham, , 1994

62. The new society of organizations, Drucker, The New Society of Organizations, , 1992

63. A Becoming a LearningOrganization, Wierdsma, Swieringa, , 1992

64. Benchmarking Knowledge Management, R.J.Hiebeler, , 1996

65. Cognitive Conceptions of Learning, Shuell, , 1986

66. Doublelooplearninginorganizations, Argyris, , 1977

67. Learning organizations come alive, Gephart, , 1996

68. Managing Learning in Organization, Casey, , 1993

69. The organizational learning cycle, Dixon, , 1995

70. Thecorecompetenceofthecorporation, Rychen, Salganik, , 2003

71. Culture and OrganizationalLearning, Cook, , 1993

72. How Organizations Lean and Unlearn, Hedberg.I.B, , 1982

73. Overcoming Organizational Defenses, Argyris, , 1990

74. Reflective Inquiry: AMethod for OL, Robinson, Keating, Clemson, , 1998

75. The Human Side of Strategic Change, Sharpe.M.E, , 1996

76. Managing in the Age of Discontinuity, Burdett, , 1995

77. Using Reflecting to LeverageLearning, Hall, Daudelin, , 1997

78. The Emergence of Learning Communities, Ryan, , 1994

79. How to Make Reengineering Really Work?, Hall, Rowenthal, Wade, , 1993

80. The Spirit of the LearningOrganization, Mullen, Kim.D.H, , 1994

81. To avoid Organizational Crises,Unlearn, Starbuck, Nystrom.P, "To avoid Organizational Crises, , 1984

82. Leaders: The Strategies of takingCharge, Bennis, Nanus, , 1985

83. Managing Organizational Learning Cycles, Kim, , 1994

84. Research that Reinvents the Corporation, Brown, , 1991

85. The Economic Institutions of Capitalism, Williamson, Oliver E, , 1985

86. Transforming the Practice of Management, Senge, , 1993

87. Why Change Programs Don't ProduceChange, Beer, B.Spector, R.Eisenhardt, , 1990

88. New paradigmsforlearning in theworkplace, Marsick, , 1987

89. Strategy, change, and defensive routines, Argyris, Chris, Pitman, "Strategy, , 1985

90. Learning to Unlearn for a Flexible Future, Overell, , 1996

91. The Wizard's Curtain : A Replyfrom Oregon, Rhodes, Sandow, , 1996

92. A New Paradigm for DevelopingOrganizations, Stroh, Kiefer, , 1984

93. Diversification strategy and profitability, Rumelt, , 1982

94. Finding and Keeping CorporateEntrepreneurs, Kierrulff, , 1979

95. Lecture at the University of Massachusetts, Peters, , 1994

96. Needs assessment : concept and application, Kaufman, Roger A, Educational Technology Publications, Needs Assessment: Conceptand Application, , 1979

97. Action Learning: New Techniques forManagers, Revans, , 1980

98. Cultural Constraints in Management Theories, Hofstede, , 1993

99. Learning from Experience : Toward Conscious, Torbert, , 1972

100. A Survey of Organizational Learning Practice, Denton, , 1996

101. A Typology of Organizational LearningSystems, Shrivastava, , 1983

102. Harnessing the Power of Intellectual Capital, Bassi, , 1997

103. Additional Aspects of Entrepreneurial History, Martin, , 1982

104. Knowledge for Action: Changing the Status Quo, Argyris, , 1993

105. Motorola U: When Training Becomes anEducation, Wiggenhorn, , 1990

106. The Social Psychology of Organizing.(2nd ed.), Weick, The Social Psychology of Organizing(2nd ed.), , 1979

107. Toward a theory oforganizational socialization, Van Maanen, Schein, , 1979

108. 지식경제시대의 인적자원개발전략, 조우현, , 1997

109. Can Organizations Have "A Learning Disability ?, Day, "Can Organizations Have ""A Learning Disability ?", , 1994

110. Designed for Learning; A Tale oftwo Auto Plants, Adler, Cole, , 1993

111. Hypermedia for CorporateKnowledge Dissemination, Gershman, Gottsman, , 1993

112. Quality, productivity, and competitive position, Deming, W. Edwards, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Center for Advanced Engineering Study, "Quality, , 1982

113. The Building Blocks of theLearning Organization, O'Brien, Bennett, , 1994

114. The different drum : community-making and peace, Peck, M. Scott, Simon and Schuster, , 1998

115. 조직학습, 학습조직, 그리고 학습인, 박광량, "조직학습, , 1996

116. The Challenge of Sustaining CompetitiveAdvantage, Slater, , 1996

117. The Role of Good Conversation in Business Ethics, Bird, , 1990

118. The Transfer of Management Innovations fromJapan, Lillrank, , 1995

119. Building a Health and SafetyLearning Organization, Lawrence R, , 1996

120. Complex Organizations: A Critical Essay (3rd ed.), Perrow, , 1986

121. Cooperation and competition : theory and research, Johnson, David W, Interaction Book Company, , 1989

122. How do You Know if Your Organization isLearning ?, Senge, , 1994

123. Rethinking Assumptions Behind CorporateGovernance, Blair, , 1995

124. The Chief Learning Officer: New Title for NewTimes, Willets, , 1995

125. 21세기 열린교육의 비전과 교육 정보화, 허운나, , 1997

126. A Dyamic Theory of Organizational KnowledgeCreation, Nonaka, , 1994

127. Lessons Learned on the Knowledge Highways andByways, Ward, , 1996

128. Saving an Organizationfrom a Stagnating Environment, Starbuck, Hedberg, , 1997

129. The Changing Practices ofOrganizational Development, Black.D.H, Synan.C.D, , 1996

130. How Institutions Learn: A Socio-CognitivePerspective, Stein, , 1997

131. Predictors of Entrepreneurship in a SimulatedEconomy, Kourilsky, , 1980

132. Research and the Practice of Management: A FrenchView, Berry, , 1995

133. Situated Learning: "Legitmate PeripheralParticipation, Wenger, Lave, "Situated Learning: ""Legitmate PeripheralParticipation", , 1990

134. The Leader's New Work: Building LearningOrganizations, Senge, , 1990

135. The Link between Individual and OrganizationalLarning, Kim, , 1993

136. The network nation : human communication via computer, Hiltz, Starr Roxanne, Addison-Wesley Pub. Co., , 1978

137. A Systems Approach toCompetency-Based Learning Systems, erson, Davidson, , 1996

138. Joint Ventures: Theoretical and Empirical Perspectives, Kogut, Joint ventures: Theoretical and empirical perspectives, , 1988

139. Managing Strategic Change : The Role ofSymbolic Action, Johnson, , 1990

140. Notes on Continuous Learning, Culture andOrganizations, Mingie, "Notes on Continuous Learning, , 1996

141. Paths of Managerial Learning in the East GermanContext, Geppert, , 1996

142. Resolving the Leadership Paradox: The Doctor'sDialogue, Maccoby, , 1996

143. Shared Learning : "A Proven Participative ChangeDesign, Lyons, "Shared Learning : ""A Proven Participative ChangeDesign", , 1996

144. Team Memory : Information Management forBusiness Teams, Morrison, , 1993

145. Change:Principles of Problem Formulation and Resolution, Watzlawick, Weakland, Fisch, , 1974

146. Exploration and Exploitation in Organizational Learning, March, , 1991

147. Information Characteristics as Constraints toInnovation, Landry, , 1992

148. Interpersonal Competence and OrganizationalEffectivenss, Argyris, , 1962

149. Locus of control: current trends in theory and research, Lefcourt, , 1976

150. Situated learning : legitimate peripheral participation, Lave, Jean, Cambridge University Press, Situated Learning: LegitimatePeripheral Participation, , 1991

151. Personal and organizational change through group methods, Bennis, Schein, , 1965

152. Conceptual Options in the Study ofOrganizational Learning, Weick, , 1992

153. Dynamic Manufacturing: Creating the learning organization, Clark K.B, Wheelwright, Heyes, , 1988

154. Intrapreneurs; Fostering Innovation Inside theCorporation, Atkinson, , 1986

155. Sources,Procedures and Microeconomic Effects ofInnovation, Dosi, "Sources, , 1988

156. Toward a model of organizations as interpretation systems, Weick, Toward a Model of Organizationsas Interpretation Systems, , 1984

157. Gaining Competitive Advantage through Knowledge Management, Brookes, , 1996

158. Lessons from Microsoft: A model for Strategyand Leadership, Laverty, , 1996

159. New Directions for Organizational Learning inEastern Europe, Czegledy, , 1996

160. The Turning Point : Science, Society, and the risingculture, Capra, "The Turning Point : Science, , 1982

161. In Search ofExcellence: Lessons fromAmerica'sBest-runCompanies, Waterman, In Search of Excellence :Lessons from America's Best-run Companies, , 1982

162. Managing with A Power : Politics and Influence inOrganizations, Pfeffer, , 1992

163. Assessing Needs forSchool, District Allocation of Federal Funds, Lane, Hall, "Assessing Needs forSchool, , 1983

164. Metanoic Organizations:Experiments in Organizational Innovation, Senge, Kiefer, , 1986

165. Reasoning, learning, and action : individual and organizational, Argyris, Chris, Jossey-Bass, "Reasoning, , 1982

166. High-impact Learning: Building and Diffusing Learning Capability, Ulrich, D., , 1993

167. Ideas on " Learning Organizations": The "What""Why", "How", "Who, Willard, "Ideas on "" Learning Organizations"": The ""What""""Why"", , 1994

168. Skill-Based PayCase Number 3: Honeywell Ammuniton Assembly Plant, Ledford, Tyler, Dixey, , 1990

169. TowardsaStrategicTheory oftheFirm,CompetitiveStrategicManagement, Rumelt, "Towards a Strategic Theory of the Firm, , 1984

170. Manufacturing Innovation: Lessons from theJapanese Auto Industrry, Cusumano, , 1988

171. Disciplines of Organizational Learning:Contributions and Critiques, Easterby-Smith, , 1997

172. Dynamic Core Competencethrough Meta-Learning and Strategic Context, Lei, Bettis, , 1996

173. The Furure of Capitalism: How Today's EconomicForces Shape Tomorrow, Thurow, , 1996

174. Towards Middle-Up-Down Management:Accelerating Information Creation, Nonaka, , 1988

175. Developing Effective Managers: A NewApproach to Management Education, Revans, , 1971

176. New Language for New Leverage: theTerminology of Knowledge Management, Murray, , 1998

177. Develping an OrganizationCapable of Implementing Strategy and Learning, Beer, , 1996

178. Everyday Understanding inScience and Daily Life In Every Understanding, Gergen, Semin.G.R, , 1990

179. Microworlds andSemiworlds: Practice Fields for the Learning Organization, Fulmer, Stump, Keys, , 1996

180. The fifth discipline : the art and practice of the learning organization, Senge, Peter M, Currency/Doubleday, The Fifth Discipline : The Art and Practice ofthe Learning Organization, , 1994

181. How can Organizations Learn Faster: TheProblem of Entering the Green Room, Schein, , 1992

182. Redrawing the Portrait of a LearningOrganization: Inside Knight-Rider, Inc, Wishart, D.Robey, "Redrawing the Portrait of a Learning Organization : Inside Knight-Rider, , 1996

183. The Change Masters : Innovation andProductivity in the American Corporation, Kanter.R.M, , 1983

184. Building Organizations that Learn : The MITCenter for Organizational Learning, Fulmer, , 1995

185. Understanding and Creating Whole OrganizationalChange Through Learning Theory, Hendry, , 1996

186. A Preliminary Typology of Organizational Learning :Synthesizing the Literature, Miller, , 1996

187. Exploring OrganizationalLearning: Some Obsernations on Resistance and Leadership, Foppen, Ayas, Maljers, , 1996

188. Implications for Learning :Human Resource Management in East-West Joint Ventures, Cyr, Schneider, , 1996

189. 학습조직과 정보기술 : 디시전컨퍼런싱을 위한 이용한 팀학습, 전기정, 이진하, , 1996

190. Strategic Alliance, Organizational Learning andCompetitive Advantage: The HRM Agenda, Puck, "Strategic Alliance, , 1998

191. Impressions about the Learning Organization:Looking to see What is behind the Curtain, Jacobs, , 1995

192. Sculpting the learning organization : lessons in the art and science of systemic change, Watkins, Karen E., Jossey-Bass, Sculpting the LearningOrganization: Lessons in the Art and Science of SystemicChange, , 1993

193. Competition for Competence and Inter-parterLearning within International Strategic Alliances, Hamel, , 1991

194. Moving from Needs Assesssment toImplementation : Strategies for Planning and Staff Development, Fessler, , 1980

195. Global Corporate Competition : "Who's Winning,Who's Losing and the R&D Factor as One Reason Why, Franko, "Global Corporate Competition : ""Who's Winning, , 1989

196. The Information SourceSelection Decision: The Role of Entreprenieurial PersonalityCharacteristics, Welsch, Young.E.C, , 1983

197. Interorganizational Collaboration and the Locus of Innocation: Networks of Leraning in Biotechnology, Powell, Smith-Doerr, Koput, , 1996

198. Three Faces of Eden: The Persistence ofCompeting Theories and Multiple Diagnosis in OrganizationalIntervention Research, Edmondson, , 1996

199. Human Resurce Management and the Politics ofKnowledge: Linking the Essentional Knowledge Base of theOrganization to Strategic Decision Making, Ryan, , 1995

200. Factors Contributions to the Emergence of anIntraprenurial Event, and Exploratory Study of OrganizationalLearning in Ecological Configurations, Susan, "Factors Contributions to the Emergence of anIntraprenurial Event, , 1989

201. Do Normsof Decision-making Styles, Organizational Design andRearnagement Affect Performance of Japanese Firms? AnExploratory Study of Medium and Large Firm, Wehrung, Vertinsky, Shibata, "Do Normsof Decision-making Styles, , 1991