보험범죄 억제를 위한 형사정책적 연구 = A Criminal Justice Policy Study to Restrain Insurance Frauds

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

As an insurance industry is rapidly growing into a developed country's level due to an advancement of industry in Korea, the insurance crime continues to increase. Accordingly, there are the studies relating to the insurance prime in progress, but most of studies relating to the crime type and problems are focused on an exposure for preventing the insurance company's business deterioration yet. There is no satisfactory study conducted for the purpose of reducing the crime effectively by preventing the insurance crime in advance through strengthening the government aspect's institutional arrangement.
Currently, Korea has the world's seventh insurance scale. We need to review the progressive plan of the insurance-advanced country through legislating the strong form's new regulation as the special law.
The purpose of this study is to analyze what factors out of necessary factors for reduction of insurance crime are more important and should be first taken. A questionnaire survey was conducted for the insurance company's special investigators and the insurance crime-exclusive policemen in order to search the priority of factors required for the reduction of insurance crimes and the insurance crime reduction measures through Analytic Hierarchy Process that can measure a quantitative or tangible criteria as ratio scale in such an empirical analysis.
To achieve the above purpose, the alternative and criteria suitable for the study were established and the questionnaires were analyzed by using the AHP structure and the Excel 2007 program to evaluate the relative importance of each evaluation factor with the scale with 1~9 and inverse number.
Considering the police and insurance company's AHP analysis results on the measures for reduction of insurance crime, it can be concluded that the legal and institutional arrangements such as the insurance crime reduction-related special law, information offering • sharing-relevant law, and an enactment of insurance fraud are the most important measures to reduce the insurance crime.
Also, if the institutional arrangements such as the enactment of Special Criminal Act are completed to reduce the insurance crime, the crime will be easily prevented through arousing people's attention on the insurance crime, and the insurance crimes will be eradicated by actual and constant investigation. In addition, through preventing the leakage of insurance money, multiple good policy-holders will be protected and the healthy insurance industry will be promoted.
In conclusion, this study is intended to suggest the legislation of special law for prevention of insurance crime as the policy alternative among legal-institutional arrangements by using the mutual comparison method through Analytic Hierarchy Process that presents the policy alternative to reduce the insurance crime, not the insurance criminal exposure-focused study.

목차 (Table of Contents)

• Ⅰ. 서론
• Ⅱ. 이론적 논의
• Ⅲ. 보험범죄 현황 및 분석
• Ⅳ. 연구설계·분석
• Ⅴ. 결론

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 윤일현, "현대생활과 보험" 형설출판사 2006

2 안경옥, "한국의 보험범죄의 실태 및 대책" 한국형사정책연구원 14 (14): 2-104, 2003

3 최인섭, "한국의 금융범죄 실태와 사회적 대응 방안" 2002

4 금융감독원, "정례프리핑 자료"

5 황만성, "우리나라의 보험사기 방지 선진화 방향 연구" 한국형사정책연구원 2006

6 최기원, "상법학신론(하)" 박영사 2003

7 김헌수, "비통계적 링크분석을 활용한보험사기의 효과적 적발방법 연구" 보험연구원 14 (14): 107-146, 2003

8 김천경, "부동산 권원분석․보험론" 박문각 1993

9 진태국, "보험사기의 현황 및 정책 방향" 한국리스키관리학회 2009

10 최병규, "보험사기의 문제점과 쟁점분석" 한국상사판례학회 19 (19): 145-178, 2006

11 유주선, "보험사기의 문제점과 예방에 관한 고찰" 한국경영법률학회 18 (18): 269-291, 2008

12 신정훈, "보험사기에 대한 현행 대처방안의 문제점과 개선방안" 한국공안행정학회 (24) : 115-150, 2006

13 박세민, "보험사기에 대한 현행 대응방안 분석과 그 개선책에 대한 연구" 한국법학원 (111) : 140-177, 2009

14 양채열, "보험사기범죄에 대한 분석 : 고의 교통사고 유도 - 합의금 요구 사건을 중심으로" 한국재무관리학회 23 (23): 227-242, 2006

15 금융감독원 보험개발원, "보험사기관리 Best Practic & Template보고서" 2001

16 금융감독원, "보험사기 조사제도 및 조사사례"

17 김광용, "보험사기 조기적발을 위한 전문가 시스템의 개발: 퍼지이론과 AHP을 중심으로" 18 (18): 1997

18 안철경, "보험사기 적발 및 방지방안" 보험개발원 1999

19 박일용, "보험사기 성향 및 규모추정" 보험개발원 1999

20 안공혁, "보험범죄조사" 대한손해보험협회 2005

21 이병희, "보험범죄의 형사판례분석" 한국형사정책연구원 2002

22 이재복, "보험범죄의 방지를 위한 법률적 대처방안 : 생명보험계약을 중심으로" 2001

23 조해균, "보험범죄의 발생원인과 그 대처방안에 관한 연구" 보험학회 35-, 1990

24 이병희, "보험범죄에 관한 연구 : 생명보험범죄를 중심으로" 淸州大學校 大學院 1999

25 탁희성, "보험범죄에 관한 연구" 한국형사정책연구원 2000

26 장인권, "보험범죄에 관한 실증적 연구" 경상대학교 대학원 2010

27 김창섭, "보험범죄 실태와 대책" 손해보험 391-, 2001

28 이홍무, "보험과 범죄 , 月足一淸, 生命保險犯罪:事例解明防止對策" 東 洋經濟新報社 1997

29 김헌수, "보험가입자의 연성 보험사기 행위에 대한 실험 분석적 검토" 보험연구원 16 (16): 77-118, 2005

30 법무부, "법과생활" 2006

31 김용준, "범죄학" 교학사 2005

32 이상현, "범죄심리학(개정9판)" 박영사 2002

33 조해균, "도덕적 위험관리" 보험연수원 1999

34 오세경, "대법전" 법전출판사 2009

35 안철경, "국내외 보험사기관리 실태 분석 선진사례 및 설문분석을 중심으로" 보험개발원 2002

36 Kieholz, Walter, "Strategic Issues in Insurance : Essays in Honour of Orio Giarini" Blackwell Publisher 2001

37 Cummins, David J, "Moral Hazard in Insurance. 1996. Claiming: Evidence from Automobile Insurance" 12 : 1996

38 Saaty, Thomas. L, "Models, Methods, Concepts & Applications of the Analytic Hierarchy Process" Kluwer Academic Publishers 2000

39 Conning & Co, "Insurance Fraud : The Quiet Catastrophe" Conning Insurance Research & Publications 1996

40 Insurance Research Council, "Fraud and Buildup in Auto Injury Claims"

41 Carroll, Eero, "Emergence and Structuring of Social Insurance Institution: Comparative Studies on Social Policy and Unemployment Insurance" 1999

42 Saaty, Thomas. L, "Decision Making for Leaders" RWs Publication 1995

43 Doerpinhaus, Helen I, "An Analysis of Complaint Data in the Automobile Insurance Industry" 58 : 120-127, 1991

44 보험개발원, "2007년 보험통계연감"