The current study investigated how cooperation or competition in a mixed-motive setting affects subsequent self-regulatory performance based on the self-regulation strength model. In experiment 1, the hypothesis proposing that choice against cultural ...
The current study investigated how cooperation or competition in a mixed-motive setting affects subsequent self-regulatory performance based on the self-regulation strength model. In experiment 1, the hypothesis proposing that choice against cultural norm in a social dilemma setting (a 2-person prisoner's dilemma game) produces ego-depletion is tested. Half of the participants consistently made the competitive choice against cooperative or non-cooperative opponent and the other half consistently made the cooperative choice against cooperative or non-cooperative opponent. According to Hostede(1980), countries in North-Eastern Asia, including Korea, are classified as having a collectivistic culture. Thus, it was hypothesized that in Korean culture, regardless of opponent's choice, the cooperation requires less regulatory effort. On the contrary, the competition against a cooperative opponent requires more regulatory resource than the cooperation with a non-cooperative opponent (reciprocal strategy). Results found that participants who made the choice of competition against a cooperative opponent showed significantly poorer performance on a subsequent self-control task (handgrip) and reported higher levels of guilt-related emotions than did those who made the choice of competition against a non-cooperative opponent. Inconsistent to the expectations, however, participants who made the choice of cooperation with a noncooperative opponent also tended to perform poorer on the self-control task than did those who made the choice of cooperation with a cooperative opponent. This result implies that it needs to be specified the role of anger in the self-regulatory performance.
Experiment2 was conducted to examine the effect of group task situation as a devise of dissolving guilt on subsequent self-regulatory task. In experiment 2, it was hypothesized that choices in a mixed motive setting(a ultimatum game) could affect the level of regulatory performance peending on tyee of subsequent task setting(group task situation vs. individual task situation). In addition, participants were each divided into two groups('cooperato g' or 'competito g') according to their score of sed motvmouto tientation. Results showed that cooperato g in both choice conditions reported that theyd intumed smmol amhat of psychological resource s were re is no significant difference between the conditions. Rewever, cooperato g in the competition condition showed better performance on the group task than on the individual task. This result was interpreted to indicate that cooperato g exerted t was interpreteowed b on group taskg in order to dissolve the guilt-related emotion or e of sychological discomed b elicited by e of reviosok situation vs. indg in ultimatum game. In formance on the operato in the cooperation condition showed poor performance on the group task than on the individual task, which suggests that cooperato g in the cooperation condition who performed the group task atteitted to restore es rty bted ducing their effort to a level that equaled their reward, which was motivated by distributive injustice in the previous competitive choices in ultimatum game.
On the other hand, it was reported that the competitors consumed more psychological resource in the cooperation condition than the competition condition, and consistent to this result, competitors in the former condition showed poor performance regardless of the task type. However in the latter, although they had enough regulatory resources, competitors showed poorer performance in the group task condition than in the individual task condition. This result was interpreted as a free-riding tendency which is evoked in group settings where competitors perceived that their opponents are fitted well with their motivational orientations in the previous mixed-motive interaction experience. Implications of these findings and suggestions for future studies are discussed.