The purpose of this study was to investigate how the essential behavioral characteristics and the attention mechanism differed among the attention-deficit/hyperactivity (ADHD) subtypes. Children (aged 7-12) diagnosed as ADHD at a local hospital were i...
The purpose of this study was to investigate how the essential behavioral characteristics and the attention mechanism differed among the attention-deficit/hyperactivity (ADHD) subtypes. Children (aged 7-12) diagnosed as ADHD at a local hospital were initially recruited, whose parents or teachers were asked to rate them using the DSM-IV criteria for ADHD and using the Sluggish Cognitive Tempo (SCT). Forty-one children who met the criteria for ADHD-Inattention type (ADHD/I), and 44 who met the criteria for ADHD-Combined type were eventually selected to participate in this study. Forty-four children from a local elementary school who did not meet any of the criteria for ADHD were also included in this study as the control group.
This study is composed of three parts. In Study 1, to test the differences in the essential characteristics and the attention problem between the two ADHD subtypes, the groups were compared on the ADHD score and on the SCT score. Exploratory factor analysis revealed two factors. Factor 1 included all DSM-IV hyperactivity items and impulsivity items, Factor 2 included SCT items. The most interesting result in Study I was that DSM-IV attention items were divided into sustained attention and hypoactive attention. Sustained attention referred to the four inattention items from DSM-IV that correlated with the hyperactivity factor, and hypoactive attention referred to the five inattention items that correlated with the SCT factor.
ADHD/I group exhibited significantly more SCT symptoms than the ADHD/C group and the control group, but ADHD/I group and ADHD/C group were not significantly different on the hypoactive attention score. ADHD/C group exhibited significantly higher hyperactivity/impulsivity score and sustained attention score than did ADHD/I group and the control group. Such results suggest that ADHD/C is characterized by hyperactivity/impulsivity and sustained attention deficit, whereas the behaviors of the ADHD/I are characterized by SCT consisting of behaviors such as drowsiness, hypoactivity, and psychomotor retardation.
Study 2 explored the attention mechanism in the ADHD subtypes. The attentional mechanism in ADHD/C and ADHD/I was examined using the covert orienting of visuospatial attention task and the executive inhibition task. In the executive inhibition task, the Korean letters 'ㄱ' and 'ㄴ' were presented randomly on a computer and the participants were instructed to respond as quickly as possible by pressing a button each time they saw the letter ‘ㄱ’. In covert orienting task, participants were instructed to keep their eyes fixed on the central cross and to press a response button as quickly as possible whenever they detected a target. The cues were either valid (i.e., correctly indicating target location) or invalid (i.e., indicating contralateral to target location).
Compared to ADHD/C group, the ADHD/I group showed a more severe deficit in the movement as well as a higher disengagement in covert visuospatial attention. However, the ADHD/C group showed an executive inhibitory deficit. Such results indicate that these two ADHD subtypes have two distinct attentional mechanisms.
In Study 3, the covariance structural modeling was utilized to investigate the relationship between the essential features and the attention mechanism of the ADHD subtypes. The proposed prediction model showed that executive inhibition is linked to hyperactivity/impulsivity behavior, sustained attention, and hypoactive attention, while disengagement and movement of attention is linked to SCT, hypoactive attention, and sustained attention.
The results found in the three studies suggest that SCT may well be the most sensitive symptom for differentiating the attention problem of the ADHD/C and ADHD/I. In addition, SCT is linked to the underlying deficit in the engagement and the movement of attention. The ADHD/C showed inhibition problems that were not present in ADHD/I, whereas the ADHD/I showed problems in the engagement and the movement of attention that were not present in ADHD/C. In conclusion, it is suggested that ADHD/C and ADHD/I can be distinguished from each other by their essential characteristics and underlying attention mechanisms.