South Korea introduced The 112 report system in 1957 in order to provide police services quickly and accurately to the people who need help . The 112 report system had begun to be organized systematically in 1980s, had became an important momentum to ...
South Korea introduced The 112 report system in 1957 in order to provide police services quickly and accurately to the people who need help . The 112 report system had begun to be organized systematically in 1980s, had became an important momentum to maximize the efficiency of utilization of police human resources and equipments, minimize the first response time. Also 112 was a significant step to improve the poor number of Call for service to police because of the lack of Communication facilities and PR.
However, the number of reported 112 increases approximately three times in 10 years from 1999 to 2009. While the local police human resources had increased only 10 percent. Because of these, Dispatch was delayed when reports were concentrated, Police was criticized that the ability to respond had been rather weakened.
Police established "The Plan of test-operating of the 112 corresponding system improvement" in 2007, then operated the plan nationwide for two years from 2008 to 2009 on the four local agencies (Incheon, Daejeon, Chungbuk, Gyeongnam). And all police stations across the country have implemented this system from 1 January 2010. The new 112 system order the dispatch by code 1-3 depending on the urgency of the case, importance, and the need, which put focus on the urgent matters, and also don't provide the police service on the case irrelevant to police work or if there is no need for on-site field dispatch. This police response system to minimize waste of the police and police resources in order to promote the efficient operation have already been conducted in foreign countries as the "Differential Police Response".
This study tries to access the performance of the "Differential Police Response" and find the systematic and efficient operation method of 112 report-response system. Also, this study proposes a variety of performance measurement for the continuous development of the 112 system.
First of all, this study designs an indicator to evaluate the effectiveness of "Differential Police Response". Based on some related previous studies, evaluation indicators of police activity are categorized in two sides, on aspects of public interest and police activity. On aspects of public interest, security promotion and people's satisfaction in the region are selected as indicators. On aspects of police activity, the cost-effectiveness and work-effectiveness of the police resources are selected as indicators.
The evaluation results are as follows.
First, crime reports which is one of the Indicator of security promotion in the region increase even after the enforcement of "Differential Police Response". Average on-site arrival time difference is delayed further. However, over time, Difference of the average on-site arrival time between general dispatch and urgent dispatch accords with the purpose of the code-response in "Differential Police Response".
Meanwhile, the increasement of the on-site-handling ratio among the 3 type crime handling ratio shows that new 112 system can promote the substantial security of the region through 'selection and concentration'.
In conclusion, this study can not find the evidence that Differential Police Response increases effectiveness in security promotion. However, we should take look at the promotion of the regional security from the long-term perspective, then we can look forward to the increasement of the effectiveness if continuous and efficient methods in the use of police resources are prepared.
Second, the citizen's satisfaction of 112 report system increases compared to the previous. But, It is difficult to conclude that Differential Police Response had contributed to improve citizen's satisfaction, because speed, kindness and integrated satisfaction in Metropolitan area had decreased relatively compared to the rest of the country. This result is estimated to be affected by environmental factors associated with the character of the region. For example, that is the number of 112-report, traffic congestion, the frequency of contact with residents. Specific reasons for the correlation and causal relationships will require further analysis.
Third, about the cost effectiveness of police resources, police dispatch by 112 report had decreased 12.5 to 13% since the implementation of the Differential Police Response. These results support that the Differential Police Response has increased the cost effectiveness at the police organizational level.
However, It is difficult to feel the saving of police resources at the level of personal.
Fourth, about the awareness evaluation of the effectiveness, Dispatch center workers and local police officers recognized as negative after the implementation. However, comparison between groups in mean, people who are trained, have promotional experiences, have experience requesting cooperation to related authorities and living in Metropolitan City like Seoul etc. recognized as positive and statistically significant compared with a group of opposition.
This study discusses the requirement for the development of Differential Police Response. First, at the organizational level, a concrete strategy is required to turn reduced manpower, time and money into problem-oriented police activities and crime prevention activities. Second, plans to promote the morale is required for turning police officer's recognition a negative into a positive. Third, plans to improve citizen satisfaction measures taking into account regional characteristics are required in relation to the relative reduction of metropolitan citizen's satisfaction.
Based on the discussion of evaluation results, the proposed improvement measures for increasing the effectiveness of Differential Police Response are as follows.
First, In order to enhance the 'Rapid Crime Response crime', Rapid Patrol Car Dispatch System expand to motorcycle by GPS mount. Also, this study propose Crime Prevention CCTV system utilization, a system for locating mobile phones, and the code classification standards through 'standardized questionnaire'
Second, this study propose substantial strategies to increase efficiency of police resources operation ; Evaluation criteria focusing on crime prevention and problem-oriented police activities, Expansion of non-emergency civil complaint phone reception, Educational programs and training opportunities supply.
Third, improving police service strategies can be accessed in two ways citizen satisfaction and police morale. For improving police morale, rational allowance system like 'additional allowance for dispatch' and recruitment of local police personnel, improving relationships and partnerships with agencies are required.
And, To improve public satisfaction, informing the police response process and result using text messages, assessment system by relator are proposed in this study.
Through this study, Differential Police Response is expected to improve cost-effectiveness of police resources and police services, and ultimately, contribute to the promotion of regional security.
In addition, performance indicators for the systematic, objective analysis of differential police response can also be applied to various activities of the police as well as 112 report-response. However, a variety of items must be collected and analyzed additionally for measure the performance of Differential Police Response. In future, about 112 report-response system connecting police with citizen, academics and citizens' interest and follow-up studies about will be needed.