The research purpose of this study is to examine levels of human rights awareness among police officers. Human rights awareness of police officers is considered important, but there is a lack of evaluative studies on this subject matter. Since police ...
The research purpose of this study is to examine levels of human rights awareness among police officers. Human rights awareness of police officers is considered important, but there is a lack of evaluative studies on this subject matter. Since police officers directly deal with people who are vulnerable to human rights violations, the importance of their human rights awareness cannot be disputed. Thus this study intends to empirically analyze human rights awareness of police officers and seek ways to enhance human rights awareness and supportive attitudes for human rights among police officers.
The dependent variables of this study are human rights awareness of police officers, and a subset of variables. “Human rights sensitivity” and “human rights perception”, were operationalized for measuring these variables. Demographic characteristics such as gender, age, educational attainment, rank, duration of service and department, and sensitivity to human rights training were used as independent variables. Sample of this study were 300 police officers working in Seoul.
Summary of results are as follows.
First, the level of human rights sensitivity of the sampled police officers was relatively high(mean of 3.53). Human rights sensitivity was especially high in regards to arresting a suspect solely based on a witness testimony without solid evidence. Analysis of perception differences based on characteristics of the sampled police officers, there were group differences based on rank and sensitivity to human rights training. In other words, policemen were relatively higher in human rights sensitivity compared to other ranks and also those, who felt more positive towards human rights training, had higher human rights sensitivity compared to others.
Secondly, human rights perception of the sampled police officers had a mean of 3.63. They were especially supportive of protecting human rights of socially disadvantaged people. Analysis of differences in human rights perception based on characteristics of sampled police officers showed human rights level of police officers with the rank of policeman and the rank of lieutenant or above were higher than others. Also, those who felt positive towards human rights training had higher human rights perception compared to other others.
Based on the above results, the following implications can be made.
First, human rights training should be more effectively conducted. The results of this study showed many variables did not have significant effect on the dependent variable, while sensitivity to human rights training was significantly related to most dependent variables. In other words, those who felt more positive towards human rights training had higher perceptions of human rights than the others. Therefore all police departments should conduct systematic and effective human rights training on police officers.
Second, there is a need to establish a clear standardized definition of “rights”. While it is important to instill human rights awareness for suspects, victims, and socially disadvantaged through human rights training. it is also important to provide a solution for the fundamental dilemma of weighing between the rights of the suspect and the victim that police officers working in the field have to face. For example, guidelines for publicizing identity of violent offenders change from time to time, and different NGOs strongly protest for publicizing or not publicizing the identity. Therefore, there should be efforts on part of the police to become more fair and balanced over human rights matters through clearly specified standards of human rights in practice.
Lastly, there should be efforts to foster a humanitarian society of mutual respect. Protection of human rights should also concern the human rights of police officers. In reality, the police officers are requested to assume the role of “protectors of human rights” as they have to also protect the rights of suspects. If society does not consider the human rights of police officers, that would be equivalent to requiring police officers to unilaterally sacrifice themselves in the effort to protect human rights.
There are some limitations to this study. As previously stated, lack of previous research acted as a limitation throughout the research process, and the survey used in this study has many limitations to fully grasp the level of human rights awareness among police officers. The sampled 300 police officers also cannot be generalized to reliably represent all police officers. Despite these limitations however, this study is meaningful in that it attempted to empirically analyze the level of human rights awareness of police officers. Hopefully this study will contribute to further understanding of the human rights awareness of police officers, and the human rights situation of the police field.