Since the 1970s, Korean society has achieved rapid economic growth and qualitative advance in various areas of the society. Entering the 2000s, however, the society has been going through rapid changes and long?]lasting economic recession. Particula...
Since the 1970s, Korean society has achieved rapid economic growth and qualitative advance in various areas of the society. Entering the 2000s, however, the society has been going through rapid changes and long?]lasting economic recession. Particularly due to the global financial crisis in the 2008, young people have difficulty in finding jobs and middle and old?]aged people are faced with threats to their career life or business. With such an increase in uncertainty and anxiety, since the foreign currency crisis, some immoral enterprisers and a small number of sellers who preoccupied the market have utilized various frauds in sales. They suggested multi?]level selling as an alternative with the groundless talk that they can make money easily. This made the public attached to illegal multi?]level selling and, consequently, lost their normal career life or their pride in their job. Furthermore, some of them suffered the breakup of traditional human relations with friends and neighbors. Even there are many people who experienced not only the loss of properties but also bad credit or personal bankruptcy. As a consequence, multi?]level sellers?f sales increased rapidly within a short period, and the expectation that an ordinary people can make a big fortune overnight produced a large number of illegal multi?]level sellers in Korea. Furthermore, because of tight regulations on multi?]level selling, various forms of illegal multi?]level selling are emerging. Thus, in order to solve the problem of illegal multi?]level selling, it is necessary to examine factors related to damage from illegal multi?]level selling from macroscopic and microscopic viewpoints. Then, we may be able to prevent such damage, to make countermeasures, and to contribute to uprooting illegal multi?]level selling. However, most of previous studies gave superficial explanations and suggested improvised measures without thorough deliberation on the origin of the program. Recognizing the problem, this study was conducted with objectives as follows. First, it reviewed several types of illegal multi?]level selling, surveyed damage from illegal multi?]level selling through a questionnaire survey, and analyzed relations among variables contributing to the damage.
Second, this study divided factors related to damage from illegal multi level selling into macroscopic factors such as situational factor and anomie, and microscopic factors such as discriminative contact, social relation (social control), rational choice, and personal characteristic, and analyzed how they influence damage from the crimes. In addition, the subjects of this study included multi?]level selling companies that were being operated as door?]to door retailers using the loopholes in the Act on Door?]to?]Door Sales, etc. (hereinafter ?eAct on Door?]to?]Door Sales?f), unregistered companies that were doing business without registration as a multi?]level seller, and those officially registered as a multi?]level seller but being operated illegally. In addition, the participants in the survey were limited to the victims of multi?]level selling, in particular, those who had experience in monetary, mental and relational damage by illegal multi?]level sellers. In analysis, we analyzed difference in and relations among the factors according to the type of damage, assuming that there are macroscopic and microscopic factors related to damage from illegal multi?]level selling. That is, we examined macroscopic factors such as situational factor and anomie, and microscopic factors such as discriminative contact, social relation, rational choice, and personal characteristics. In case of the macroscopic damage factors, in situational factor, the results were generally significant and were different according to damage from illegal multi?]level selling. In case of microscopic damage factors, discriminative contact showed a significant difference from each type of damage from illegal multi?]level selling. Social relation showed a significant difference in attachment, involvement and belief in case of monetary damage, and in attachment, involvement and participation in case of mental damage. In addition, relational damage did not show any significant difference from social relation. Furthermore, rational choice and the type of damage from illegal multi?]level selling showed a significant difference in all of the rationality of damage and profit and legal punishment. In personal characteristic, on the other hand, speculative spirit and addiction showed a significant difference in each illegal multi?]level selling. Therefore, in order to reduce damage from illegal multi?]level selling, we suggest policies as follows.
First, there should be an institution that provides practical supports for recovery from mental and financial damage from illegal multi?]level selling. It may provide a professional mental counselor for the treatment of mental damage, and support systematic legal tasks for recovery from financial losses.
Second, the number of multi?]level sellers registered as door?]to?]door retailers has been decreasing since 2002, but the number of door?]to?]door retailer is steadily increasing. This means that illegal multi?]level sellers have merely switched their business area, escaping from the tightened regulation by the Act on Door?]to?]Door Sales and the obligation to register. Thus, the distinction between door?]to?]door retailing and multi?]level selling should be abolished.
Third, the government should build an accurate database on multi?]level selling and door to door retailing, and provide practical information to sellers who want to join. In addition, because abnormal ways of business may produce a large number of victims, education should be executed regularly for those who want to join as a multi?]level seller and regulation should be applied continuously to the violations of the law.
Fourth, counseling and therapy centers should be operated for those working in the field of illegal multi?]level selling, which is highly addictive like drug or gambling, and psychotherapy programs should be developed so that they can return to normal social life.
Fifth, in order to secure an effective means of regulating illegal multi?]level selling companies, it is necessary to improve the criteria for calculating fines for illegal acts under the Act on Door?]to?]Door Sales.