한일폐기물법제에 있어서의 원인자부담원칙 = The Polluter Pays Principle (Verursacherprinzip) in Korean-Japanese Waste Management Law

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Environmental Burden means ``activities which is possible to cause trouble in environmental protection``, that leads to the issue of ``who get charged and why they do``. When it comes to the responsibility of environment, the point is the concept of ``polluter(verursacher)``. There exists ``The Polluter Pays Principle`` or ``Verursacherprinzip`` accepted internationally as an explanation on ``who get charged and why they do``. This dissertation is aimed to examine the disposal responsibility of who are polluters(verursacher) and why they get charged` in Korean and Japanese waste management law in the perspective of ``The Polluter Pays Principle(or Verursacherprinzip)`` based on the consideration of illegally disposed waste, and contemplate what is a design for more effective and fairer institution. The way of thinking such as Polluter Pays Principle or Verursacherprinzip, which means that people who pollute environment have to pay the cost for protecting it, matches the idea of justice and fairness in general. According to Polluter Pays Principle in the waste management laws of both countries, the case of ``polluters unknown`` or ``they having no capability`` brings about some situations : landlord(the third party) responsible or government or municipalities (supervisor/final subject in disposal charge) responsible, which blocks effective operation of institution Therefore, in order to realize the minimization on environmental burden effectively without limiting Polluter Pays Principle or Verursacherprinzip, three should be required in the disposal responsibility on waste: paying attention to the producer placed in the very first stage in product distribution; figuring out the life-cycle of the product; utilizing various institutions such as Producer Pays Principle expanding some responsibility to producer.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김명길, "환경법" 삼영사 2004

2 정훈, "폐기물처리에 관한 법적 고찰-한국의 폐기물법과 독일의 순환관리 및 폐기물법을 중심으로" 전남대학교 2001

3 방극채, "폐기물의 처리책임에 관한 비교법적 연구" 전남대학교 2008

4 박균성, "폐기물관리의 기본원칙과 처리책임에 관한 연구" 경희대학교 법학연구소 33 (33): 1998

5 조홍식, "토양환경침해에 관한 법적 책임" 20 : 1998

6 문미희, "토양환경보전법의 문제점과 개선법안－ 토양환경침해에 관한 법적 책임을 중심으로" 경희대학교 2002

7 곽윤직, "채권각론" 박영사 1995

8 大塚直, "産業廃棄物の事業者責任に関する法的問題" (1120) : 1997

9 北村喜宣, "環境負荷と責任, In 行政法の争点〔第3版〕" 有斐閣 2004

10 環境経済, "環境経済·政策学の基礎知識" 有斐閣 2006

11 大塚直, "環境法における費用負担論·責任論" 法学教室 269号 (269) : 2003

12 阿部泰隆, "環境法〔第3版補訂版〕" 有斐閣 2006

13 大塚直, "環境法〔第3版〕" 有斐閣 2010

14 山村恒年, "検証しながら学ぶ環境法入門－その可能性と課題〔全訂3版〕" 昭和堂 2006

15 熊本一規, "日本の循環型社会づくりはどこが間違っているのか" 合同出版 2009

16 조홍식, "廢棄物管理法上 事業場廢棄物 排出事業者의 法的 責任" 법학연구소 45 (45): 97-155, 2004

17 廃棄物処理法編集委員会, "廃棄物処理法の解説(平成21年版)"

18 阿部泰隆, "廃棄物処理法の改正と残された法的課題(四)" 自治研究 69巻 10号 69 (69): 1993

19 桑原勇進, "廃掃法改正の評価と今後の課題" (1256) : 2003

20 高木光, "先端科学技術と人権―日独共同研究シンポジウムー in 先端科学技術と人権―日独共同研究シンポジウムー" 信山社 2005

21 弘文館法研究会, "2007年環境関係法規Ⅲ－廃棄物篇" 弘文館 2007