세계화시대의 도시범죄관련 미국 도시설계와 질서유지정책 = Crime-related U.S. Urban Design and Order Maintenance Policy in the Era of Globalization: Policy Implications for the Future Urban Design Practices

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Recent development in information technology did not reduce the necessity of centrality but significantly increased the flexibility of production resources such as capital in the era of globalization. This phenomenon then leads to competition between local to international geographical regions to secure financial resources, making cities and regions vulnerable to the needs and interests of globalized industry. Under such circumstances, crime-related U.S. urban design and order maintenance policy are blamed to be a tool for urban spatial segregation. This paper therefore argues that current crime-related urban design practices or 'crime prevention through environmental design(CPTED)' should be revised and that the change may be facilitated by first shifting its major goal from crime prevention to fear-of-crime reduction in ways that can enhance the quality of urban life. This more comprehensive approach will ensure increased participation of local urban residents and will help come up with context-based, more successful outcomes. This paper, however, calls for follow-up empirical studies revisiting current major design principles of CPTED in association with fear-of-crime reduction and the quality of urban life.

국문 초록 (Abstract)

본 연구는 경제적 세계화가 미국 내 도시범죄관련 도시설계와 질서유지정책(the order maintenance policy)에 미친 부정적인 영향을 살펴보았다. 정보관련 기술의 발전을 수반한 경제적 세계화는 도심의 중요성을 강조하였고, 극도로 유동화된 자본과 기업체를 유치하기 위한 지역 및 도시 간의 경쟁체제를 조성하였다. 이러한 상황 속에서 미국의 도시설계와 지방정부의 질서유지정책은 세계화된 자본의 구미에 맞는 새로운 개념의 준사유화된 공공공간을 창출, 범죄문제의 근원적 해결책이 되기보단 도시구성계층 간의 공간적 격리수단으로 사용되었다.
미국에서 야기된 이와 같은 부정적 영향을 거울삼아, 향후 도시설계적 접근방식은 범죄예방보단 ‘범죄관련 우려’ 경감을 주요 목표로 설정해야 하며, 도시민의 ‘삶의 질’ 제고에 초점을 맞춘 지역개선프로그램의 일부로서 전환되어야 함을 제시하는 바다. 이와 같은 방향 전환은 지역 구성원의 적극적 참여를 유도, 지역실정에 적합한 대응방안을 수립하는 데 많은 도움이 될 것으로 기대된다. 마지막으로, 본 연구는 미국 사례를 중심으로 선언적 제시를 하는 데 그치고 있다. 따라서 기존 CPTED의 주요 원칙을 ‘삶의 질’ 제고 측면에서 재조명 하는 국내 현장중심의 실증적 연구가 뒤따라야 할 것이다.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김길섭, "안전한 도시를 위한 CPTED적용 방안에 관한 연구" 한세대학교 경찰법무대학원 2008

2 김유리, "담장허물기사업이 거주민의 안전의식에 미치는 영향:서울시 단독주택지 사례를 중심으로" 연세대학교 2008

3 강석진, "공동주택단지 외부공간을 중심으로 한 안전한 생활환경 조성방안에 관한 연구" 대한건축학회 21 (21): 19-28, 2005

4 김태경, "공간특성에 따른 지역별 주거만족도 결정요인 분석" 국토연구원 53 : 131-146, 2007

5 경찰청, "각 연도 경찰백서"

6 Loukaitou-Sideris,A., "Urban Design Downtown:Poetics and Politics of Form" Univ.of California Press 1998

7 Murray,C, "The physical environmentand. in.Crime." Institute for Comtemporary Studies 1994

8 Hall,P, "The World Cities." Weidenfeld and Nicolson 1966

9 Short,J, "The Urban Order" Blackwell Publishers Ltd 1996

10 Gottdiner,M., "The Theming of America: Dreams, Visions and Commercial Spaces. in Splintering Urbanism: Networked Infrastructures, Technological Mobilities and the Urban Condition." Routledge 2001

11 Angel,S, "The Other Side of Defensible Space" ASIS International 63-66, 1991

12 Goss,J, "The Magic of the Mall:an Analysis of Form,Function,and Meaning in Comtemporary Retail Environment" Association of American Geographers. 83 : 18-47, 1933

13 Jacobs,J, "The Life and Death of Great American Cities." Random House 1961

14 Castells,M, "The Information City:Information Technology,Economic Restructuring and the Urban-Regional Process" Blackwell Publishers Inc 1989

15 Sassen,S, "The Global City,New York,London,Tokyo." Princeton University Press 1991

16 Bram J., "The Evolution of Commuting patterns in the New York City metro area" Federal Reserve Bank of New York 11 (11): 1-7, 2005

17 Castells,M, "The Castells Reader on Cities and Social Theory." Blackwell Publishers Inc 2002

18 Massey,D, "The Age of Extreme:Concentrated Affluence and Poverty in the Twenty-first Century" Project MUSE. 33 : 395-412, 1996

19 Harvey,D, "Spaces of Hope." Univ.of California Press 2000

20 Harvey,D, "Spaces of Capital:Towards a Critical Geography." :Routledge 2001

21 Clarke,R.V, "Situational crime prevention. inBuilding a Safer Society:Strategic Approaches to Crime Prevention.Crime and Justice vol.19." 91-150, 1995

22 Matthews,R, "Replacing ‘Broken Windows’:crime,incivilities and urban change.in Issues in Realist Criminology." Sage 1992

23 Harcourt,B, "Policing Disorder:Can We Reduce Serious Crime by Punishing Petty Offenses" 27 (27): 16-22, 2002

24 Taylor,R.B., "Physical Environment and Crime"

25 Greenberg,S., "Neighborhood Design and Crime" 50 : 48-61, 1984

26 Crilley,D, "Megastructures and Urban Change:Aesthetics,Ideology,and Design.in The Restless Urban Landscape" Prentice Hall. 127-164, 1993

27 Weiss,R, "Introduction to Criminal Justice and Globalization at the New Millennium" Social Justice 27 (27): 1-17, 2000

28 Wood,E, "Housing Design,a Social Theory." Citizen's Housing and Planning Counsel of New York 1961

29 Lewis,D., "Fear of Crime:Incivility and the Production of a Social Problem" Praeger 1986

30 Maxfield,M, "Explaining fear of crime:evidence from the 1984 British Crime Survey" Home Office Research Paper 43-, 1987

31 Kelling,G.L., "Do Police Matter? an Analysis of the Impact of New York City's Police Reforms" New York:Manhattan Institute 22 : 2001

32 Angel,S, "Discouraging Crime Through City Planning" University of California Press 1968

33 Hough,J.M, "Designing Out Crime." HMSO 1980

34 Newman,O, "Defensible Space:People and Design in the Violent City." McMillan 1972

35 Logan,J, "Cycles and Trends in the Globalization of Real Estate.in ,P.The Restless Urban Landscape." Prentice Hall 1993

36 Jeffery,C.R, "Crominology:An Interdisciplinary Approach." :Prentice-Hall 1990

37 Zimring,F.E., "Crime is Not the Problem:Lethal Violence in America." Oxford Univ.Press 1997

38 Jeffery,C.R, "Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design.2nd" Sage 1977

39 Jeffery,C.R, "Crime Prevention Through Environmental Design." Sage 1971

40 Mitchell,W, "City of Bits:Space,Place,and the Infobahn." The MIT Press 1995

41 Wilson,J.Q., "Broken Window:the Police and Neighborhood Safety" Atlantic Media Company. 269 (269): 29-39, 1982

42 Fishman,R, "Bourgeois Utopia:The Rise and Fall of Suburbia." Basic Books 1987

43 Whiteson,L, "Bold New Look,Same Old Hope:New Pershing Square Declares Confidence,but Can Design Change L.A.'s Social Habits?"

44 Hope,T., "Area Crime and Incivility:a Profile from the British Crime Survey. in Communities and Crime Reduction." HMSO 1988

45 Gootman,E, "A Police Department's Growing Allure:Crime Fighters from Around World Visit for Tips" 24 : 2000