한국어 수용성 판단의 실험방법론 비교 연구 = A Comparative Study of Acceptability Judgment Collection Methods in Korean

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The main purpose of this study is to investigate the differences among three experimental methods that have been widely used in the areas of experimental syntax and psycholinguistics. Specifically, this study examined the differences among Likert Scale (LS), Magnitude Estimation (ME), and Thermometer Task (TT) that were applied to analyze the multiple accusative construction in Korean. In this study, a total of 104 participants were randomly assigned to the three experimental conditions and the data was analyzed with several statistical methods. The findings of this study showed that there were significant differences statistically among the three experimental methods. These results have implications for the experimental syntax.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 홍재성, "현대 한국어 동사구문의 연구" 탑 출판사 1987

2 김영희, "한국어통사론의 모색" 탑 출판사 1988

3 유형선, "한국어의 목적어" 도서출판 월인 299-331, 2001

4 임홍빈, "한국어의 주제와 통사 분석" 서울대학교 출판부 2007

5 조용준, "한국어 실험통사론의 모색: 대격중출구문에 대한 수용성 판단을 중심으로" 건국대학교 2015

6 연재훈, "한국어 구문 유형론" 태학사 2011

7 성광수, "타동성 목적어와 중목적어: 목적어 중출에 대한 재검" 안암어문학회 22 (22): 115-127, 1981

8 양정석, "이중주어문”과 “이중목적어문”에 대하여" 연세대학교 국어국문학과 20 : 255-318, 1987

9 신현숙, "목적격 표지 {-를}의 의미연구" 7 : 119-139, 1982

10 이선희, "국어의 조사와 의미역 – 조사 {-를}과 논항 실현을 중심으로-" 한국문화사 2004

11 우형식, "국어 타동구문 연구" 박이정 1996

12 孫仁鎬, "국어 조사 ‘을/를’의 연구" 啓明大學校 大學院 1994

13 성기철, "격조사 ‘-를’의 의미" 국제한국어교육학회 5 : 31-50, 1994

14 Gibson, E., "Weak Quantitative Standards in Linguistics Research" 14 : 233-234, 2010

15 Featherston, S., "Was ist Linguistische Evidenz?" Shaker Verlag 2008

16 Gibson, E., "Using Mechanical Turk to Obtain and Analyze English Acceptability Judgments" 5 : 509-524, 2011

17 Bader, M., "Toward A Model of Grammaticality Judgments" 46 : 273-330, 2010

18 Sim, C. -Y., "To Make a Case for All: Syntactic Structure, Semantic Interpretation and Case Morphology" University of Delaware. 2005

19 Gibson, E., "The Need for Quantitative Methods in Syntax and Semantics Research" 28 : 88-124, 2013

20 Sprouse, J., "The Empirical Status of Data in Syntax : A Reply to Gibson and Fedorenko" 28 (28): 222-228, 2013

21 Sprouse, J., "The Cambridge Handbook of Biolinguistics" Cambridge University Press 2012

22 Shibatani, M., "Syntax and Semantics (vol. 5)" Academic Press 1976

23 Chomsky, N., "Syntactic Structures" The Hague 1957

24 Ferreira, F., "Psycholinguistics, Formal Grammars, and Cognitive Science" 22 : 365-380, 2005

25 Sprouse, J., "Power in Acceptability Judgment Experiments and the Reliability of Data in Syntax" University of California, Irvine 2011

26 박병수, "On the double object constructions in Korean" 6 (6): 91-113, 1981

27 Stevens, S. S., "On the Psychophysical Law" 64 : 153-181, 1957

28 Weskott, T., "On the Informativity of Different Measures of Linguistic Acceptability" 87 : 249-273, 2011

29 류병래, "Multiple Case Marking Constructions in Korean Revisited" 한국언어정보학회 17 (17): 1-27, 2013

30 Bard, E. G., "Magnitude Estimation of Linguistic Acceptability" 72 : 32-68, 1996

31 Bloomfield, L., "Language" Holt, Rinehart and Winston 1933

32 Phillips, C., "Japanese/Korean Linguistics 17" CSLI Publications 2009

33 Gordon, P., "Intuitive Knowledge of Linguistic Coreference" 62 : 325-370, 1997

34 Wasow, T., "Intuitions in Linguistic Argumentation" 115 : 1481-1496, 2005

35 Greenbaum, S., "Informant Elicitation of Data on Syntactic Variation" 31 : 201-212, 1973

36 Hill, A. A., "Grammaticality" 17 : 1-10, 1961

37 Keller, F., "Gradience in Grammar: Experimental and Computational Aspects of Degrees of Grammaticality" University of Edinburgh. 2000

38 Cowart, W., "Experimental Syntax: Applying Objective Methods to Sentence Judgments" Sage Publications, Inc 1997

39 Grewendorf, G., "Empirical Evidence and Theoretical Reasoning in Generative Grammar. Theoretical" 33 : 369-381, 2007

40 Langendoen, D. T., "Dative Questions : A Study of the Relation of Acceptability to Grammaticality of an English Sentence Type" 451-478, 1973

41 Featherston, S., "Data in Generative Grammar : the Stick and the Carrot" 33 : 269-318, 2007

42 Fanselow, G., "Carrots - Perfect as Vegetables, But Please Not as a Main Dish" 33 : 353-367, 2007

43 Sprouse, J., "Assessing the Reliability of Journal Data in Syntax: Linguistic Inquiry 2001–2010" University of California, Irvine 2010

44 Clifton, C., Jr., "Amnestying Superiority Violations: Processing Multiple Questions" 27 : 51-68, 2006

45 Sprouse, J., "A Test of the Cognitive Assumptions of Magnitude Estimation : Commutativity Does Not Hold for Acceptability Judgments" 87 : 274-288, 2011

46 Sprouse, J., "A Program for Experimental Syntax" University of Maryland 2007

47 Sprouse, J., "A Comparison of Informal and Formal Acceptability Judgments Using a Random Sample from Linguistic Inquiry 2001-2010" 134 : 219-248, 2013