Comparing Minimum Wage Setting Mechanisms in Japan and Korea: Searching for the Sources of Difference

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The paper examines developments on minimum wage setting mechanisms (MWSM) in Japan and Korea in recent years, focusing on institutions, processes and outcomes of MWSM. Such attributes of the institution are examined as the basic minimum wage setting structures, the constitutions and deliberation procedures of the consultative bodies, and the factors considered in deciding annual minimum wage deliberation.
Some similarities are found. Both countries heavily rely on tripartite committees at the national level. Besides, both governments try to influence minimum wage setting procedures by indicating higher minimum wage is desirable. Contrarily, some differences are discovered. One difference is shown in the process of MWSM: it is much tougher in Korea than Japan.
Another difference is observed in the outcome of MWSM: the minimum wages have increased much faster and higher in Korea than in Japan. From a system perspective, the differences may be related to what factors minimum wage setting organizations consider. While income distribution is one of the important factors to be considered in Korea, it is not the case in Japan. It seems that the Korean MWSM is assigned a wider role to reduce income gap among workers, while the Japanese counterpart is allowed to focus more on specifically low wage group of workers.
The authors remind people of policy circles of the importance of wider perspective in examining performance of minimum wage policy. A minimum wage policy may produce expected results under certain circumstances and may not under other conditions. In order to reach a conclusion, one needs to consider wide range of related policies besides economic/social factors.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이정민, "최저임금이 고용에 미치는 영향" 한국노동경제학회 39 (39): 1-34, 2016

2 김대일, "최저임금의 저임금 근로자의 신규 채용 억제효과" 한국노동경제학회 35 (35): 29-50, 2012

3 Abe Yukiko, "The Wage Disparity Between Regular Workers and Part-Time Workers and the Role of Regional Minimum Wage 1990 - 2001" 568 : 77-92, 2007

4 Tamai, Kingo, "The Minimum Wage System and Its Contemporary Issues from the Viewpoint of Social Policy: Focusing on the Case of Osaka" 254 : 35-43, 2016

5 Kawaguchi, D., "The Impact of Minimum Wage on Female Employment in Japan" 25 (25): 107-118, 2007

6 Hong Min-Gi, "The Effect of Minimum Wage Increase on Employment in 2018" 43-56, 2018

7 Neumark, David, "Revisiting the Minimum Wage-Employment Debate: Throwing Out the Baby with the Bathwater?" 67 : 608-648, 2014

8 Newmark, David, "Minimum Wages, Labor Market Institutions, and Youth Employment: A Cross-National Analysis" 57 (57): 223-248, 2004

9 Addison, John T., "Minimum Wages, Labor Market Institutions, and Female Employment: A Cross-Country Analysis" 65 (65): 779-809, 2012

10 Ogasawara, Koichi, "Minimum Wage and Public Assistance: From the Viewpoint of Normative Request under the Article, Vol. 9, No. 3 of Minimum Wage Act" 738 : 2-20, 2018

11 Iwata, Masami, "Minimum Wage System and Public Assistance System: Consistency of Work-Based Remuneration and Public Assistance Policy" 2 (2): 5-12, 2010

12 Ohtake, Fumio, "Minimum Wage Reform: How to Change the Way of Working in Japan" Nihon-Hyoron-Sya 2013

13 Jung, Jin-Ho, "Measures to Improve the Minimum Wage System" Korea Labor Institute 2003

14 Kanki, Chikako, "Legal Regulation of Minimum Wage and Public Assistance: Comparative Legal study between Japan, the UK, and France" Shinzan-Sya 2011

15 Commons, John R., "Legal Foundations of Capitalism" Macmillan 1924

16 Kaufman, Bruce E., "Institutional Economics and the Minimum Wage: Broadening the Theoretical and Policy Debate" 63 (63): 427-453, 2010

17 Tamada, Keiko, "How is the Minimum Wage Determined?" 593 : 16-28, 2009

18 International Labour Office, "Global Wage Report 2008/09: Minimum Wages and Collective Bargaining. Towards Policy Coherence" ILO 2008

19 Kim, Yoo-Sun, "Effect of Minimum Wage on Employment" KLSI 1-13, 2018

20 Leonard, "Does the UK Minimum Wage Reduce Employment? A Meta-Regression Analysis" 52 (52): 499-520, 2014

21 Allegretto, S., "Do Minimum Wage Really Reduce Teen Employment? Accounting for Heterogeneity and Selectivity in State Panel Data" 50 (50): 205-240, 2011

22 Tachibanaki, Toshiaki, "A Study on Poverty in Japan" University of Tokyo Press 2006

23 Japan Institute for Labour Policy and Training, "(JILPT Document Series, No. 177) Conditions of Wages after the Minimum Wage Law Amendment in 2007"