송덕수 교수의 “명의신탁된 부동산을 명의수탁자가 처분한 경우의 법률관계: 명의신탁 유형에 관한 논의를 포함하여”에 관한 평석 = Critical Analysis of Professor Tuck Soo Song’s Article “Rechtsverhältnisse bei Verfügung des Grundbuchtreuhänders über das Treuhandgut: einschliesslich des Eingehens auf die Formen der Grundbuchtreuhandschaft”

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This paper aims at understanding Professor Tuck Soo Song’s academic performance, scholarly attitude and academic legacy left to academically younger generations by analyzing his article, “legal relations in the case of a nominal trustee disposing of trusted real estate: including studying various types of nominal trusts”, published by Ewha Law Journal vol 19 no. 1, in September 2014 so as to contribute to his retirement ceremonial publication of Ewha Law Journal. This paper shows how his world view or value permeates his article analyzed here, as it is more common in legal research works than any other social science, because legal research tends to be influenced by researchers’ world view or value view. This paper confirms that the analyzed article is an evidence that he has sought to interpret various provisions and legal tools in Korean civil code in accordance to whole codification system of the civil code as well as to their literal meaning. This paper evaluates as well that he sought to interpret nominal trusts of realties according to the law of expression of intention and its interpretation before the legislation of Act on the Registration of Real Estate under Actual Titleholder’s Name, whereas, since the mentions legislation, he has sought to interpret the Act faithfully to the literal meaning of the legal provisions. This paper makes much of it that his interpretation method and scholarly attitude importantly contribute to the consolidation of civil law lawyers’ theories. But this paper makes a point that, whereas he is of the generation who were academically trained and brought up during 1970s, new generations, who have faced radically changed points of social value view and complicated and complex conflicts of interest prevailing in the society since trend of globalization starting from 1995, need to reflect more serious whether his academic approach and interpretation method can apply to current society. From this perspective, this paper analyzed some cases which were dealt with in Professor Song’s article in depth.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 제철웅, "사학의 자율성과 공공성의 조화를 위한 모색 : 여당의 사학관련법 개정안을 중심으로" 법과사회이론학회 (27) : 445-475, 2004

2 최경수, "부동산실명제와 앞으로의 정책과제" 국토연구원 (162) : 1995

3 권오창, "부동산실명제시행에 따른 부동산 시장의 전망" 국토연구원 (166) : 1995

4 조창현, "부동산실명제 실시현황과 추진방향" 국토연구원 (179) : 1996

5 양창수, "부동산실명법의 사법적 규정에 의한 명의신탁의 규율-소위 계약명의신탁을 중심으로" 박영사 5 : 1999

6 재정경제원, "부동산실명법 해설" 1995

7 박동진, "부동산실명법 제4조에 의한 부동산 명의신탁의 효력" 한국법학원 32 (32): 1999

8 곽윤직, "민법주해 5" 박영사 2009

9 곽윤직, "민법주해 2" 박영사 1995

10 제철웅, "미국의 특별수요신탁에 관한 일고찰" 법학연구소 32 (32): 153-175, 2016

11 송덕수, "명의신탁된 부동산을 명의수탁자가 처분한 경우의 법률관계- 명의신탁의 유형에 관한 논의를 포함하여 -" 법학연구소 19 (19): 1-49, 2014

12 이동진, "매도인 악의의 계약명의신탁과 명의수탁자의 부동산 처분에 대한 책임- 대법원 2013.9.12. 선고 2010다95185 판결 -" 한국재산법학회 34 (34): 279-304, 2018

13 제철웅, "등기청구권과 침해부당이득: 새로운 법리의 형성과정에 관한 고찰" 한국민사법학회 93 : 281-323, 2020

14 제철웅, "담보법" 율곡출판사 2017

15 GRAHAM MOFFAT, "TRUSTS LAW 5" Cambridge Express 2009

16 Larenz, "Methodenlehre der Rechtswissenschaft" Springer 1995

17 Larenz, "Lehrbuch des Schuldrechts, Bd. II HalbBd 2" C.H. Beck 1994

18 CHARLES GLENN, "FINDING THE RIGHT BALANCE" Lemma BV 2002

19 Volker Emmerich, "Das Recht der Leistungsstörungen" C.H. Beck 1997

20 Honsell, "Basler Kommentar zum Schweizerischen Privatrecht: Zivilgesetzbuch II" Helbing & Lichtenhahn 2003

21 송오식, "3자간 등기명의신탁과 불법원인급여 해당 여부- 대법원 전원합의체 2015다13850사건과 관련하여-" 한국재산법학회 36 (36): 55-83, 2019