Meta-analysis of the Correlation between Sport Achievement Goal Orientation and Sport Confidence in Korea

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Objectives The purpose of this study was to meta-analyze the correlation between sport achievement goal orientation and sport-confidence in Korea.
Met hods Academic databases (DBpia, KCI, NAL, RISS) were used to search for literature for the metaanalysis.
Based on the selection criteria, 22 journal articles and 12 dissertations were selected. The R program was used to calculate publication bias and effect sizes.
Results The correlation coefficients of sport achievement goal orientation and sport-confidence variables showed no publication bias, and the meta-analysis was analyzed with a random effects model due to high heterogeneity. The meta-analysis of the correlations between task-orientation achievement goals and sportconfidence variables showed large effect sizes, and among ego-orientation achievement goals and sportconfidence variables, proving skills showed a large effect size. A meta-analysis of the correlation between ego-orientation achievement goals and physical/mental preparation, coach leadership, and social support found moderate effect sizes.
Conclusions Task-orientation achievement goals was more strongly associated with sport-confidence than ego-orientation achievement goals. However, setting goals that take into account both task-orientation and ego-orientation achievement goals may be more effective in improving sport-confidence.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Kim WB, "Verification on the Validity of Sources of Sport-Confidence Questionnaire" 10 (10): 107-122, 1999

2 Mills BD, "Trait sport confidence, goal orientation and competitive experience of female collegiate volleyball players" 82 (82): 1085-1086, 1996

3 Mussweiler T, "Theories in Social Psychology" 119-139, 2011

4 Brawley LR, "The nature of group goals in sport teams : A phenomenological analysis" 6 (6): 323-333, 1992

5 Halsey LG, "The fickle P value generates irreproducible results" 12 (12): 179-185, 2015

6 Heper E, "The examine goal orientation and sports self confidence level of soccer players" 159 : 197-200, 2014

7 Nicholls JG, "The competitive ethos and democratic education" Harvard University Press 1989

8 김윤태 ; 홍승후, "The Relationships Among Achievement Goal Orientation, Competitive State Anxiety, Self-efficacy and Performance Outcome in the Golfers" 22 : 379-390, 2004

9 한태준, "The Relationship among Amateur Wrestlers’Achievement Goal Orientation, Self-management and Sport Self-confidence" 19 (19): 35-52, 2008

10 김백수 ; 김용국, "The Relationship Between Teenager Athletes`s Perceptional Sport Confidence and Inner Motivation" 35 : 587-596, 2009

11 김학권 ; 윤상영, "The Moderating Effects of Self-Management in the Relationship between Badminton Participants’ Achievement Goal Orientation and their Sport Confidence" 90 : 267-277, 2022

12 고화섭 ; 전병관, "The Effects of College athlete’Self-management to Sport Confidence and Perceived Performance" 23 (23): 547-561, 2014

13 정은화 ; 조영갑, "The Effects of Badminton Players’Achievement Goal Orientation on Sports Confidence" 17 (17): 755-767, 2019

14 김용규 ; 김덕진 ; 조성현, "The Effect of Squash player’s Achievement Goal Orientation and Competitive Anxiety on Performance Self-Confidence" 7 (7): 291-300, 2005

15 조민선 ; 박채희 ; 이용국 ; 정현택, "The Effect of Achievement Goals and Sport confidence of Athletes on Leadership Style of Judo Coach’s" 11 (11): 55-68, 2016

16 Elliot AJ, "Test anxiety and the hierarchical model of approach and avoidance achievement motivation" 76 (76): 628-644, 1999

17 Duda JL, "Task and ego orientation and intrinsic motivation in sport" 26 (26): 40-63, 1995

18 Cohen J, "Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences" Routledge 2013

19 Vealey RS, "Sources of sport-confidence : Conceptualization and instrument development" 20 (20): 54-80, 1998

20 Hollenbeck GP, "Self-confidence and leader performance" 33 (33): 254-269, 2004

21 Schmitt NW, "Research methods in human resources management" South-Western Pub 1991

22 Duda JL, "Psychometric characteristics of the TEOSQ" University Houston 1990

23 Dweck CS, "Motivational processes affecting learning" 41 (41): 1040-1048, 1986

24 Hall HK, "Motivational antecedents of precompetitive anxiety in youth sport" 11 (11): 24-42, 1997

25 Duda J, "Motivation in sport and exercise" Hum Kinet 57-91, 1992

26 Duda JL, "Motivation in sport and exercise" Human Kinetics Books 57-91, 1995

27 Jackson GB, "Methods for integrative reviews" 50 (50): 438-460, 1980

28 한기훈 ; 김영욱, "Meta-analysis of the Relationship between Athletes’ Achievement Goal Orientation and Self-management" 73 : 331-340, 2018

29 Oh SS, "Meta-analysis : theory and practice" Konkuk University Press 2002

30 Egger M, "Meta-analysis : principles and procedures" 315 (315): 1533-1537, 1997

31 Hwang SD, "Meta analysis" Hakjisa 2014

32 Smith D, "It’s all in the mind : PETTLEP-based imagery and sports performance" 19 (19): 80-92, 2007

33 Borenstein M, "Introduction to meta-analysis" John Wiley & Sons 2021

34 Park MW, "Influence of Taekwondo instructor’s style of leadership upon the players’ achievement goal orientation and self-actualization" Dong-A University 2007

35 Duda JL, "Handbook of research on sport psychology" MacMillan 421-436, 1993

36 Weinberg RS, "Foundations of sport and exercise psychology" Hum Kinet 2023

37 Cohn PJ, "Effects of a cognitive-behavioral intervention on the preshot routine and performance in golf" 4 (4): 33-47, 1990

38 Choi HJ, "Effects of Achievement Goal Orientation on Internal Motivation and Sport Self-Confidence of University Taekwondo Athletes" Pukyong National University 2017

39 Duda JL, "Dimensions of achievement motivation in schoolwork and sport" 84 (84): 290-299, 1992

40 Vealey RS, "Conceptualization of sport-confidence and competitive orientation : Preliminary investigation and instrument development" 8 (8): 221-246, 1986

41 Higgins JPT, "Cochrane handbook for systematic reviews of interventions version 6.4"

42 Elliot AJ, "Approach and avoidance achievement goals and intrinsic motivation : A mediational analysis" 70 (70): 461-475, 1996

43 Whitehead J, "Advances in sport and exercise psychology measurement" Fitness Information Technology 21-48, 1998

44 Robert GC, "Advances in motivation in sport and exercise" Human Kinetics 1-50, 2001

45 Nicholls JG, "Achievement motivation : Conceptions of ability, subjective experience, task choice, and performance" 91 (91): 328-346, 1984

46 Ames C, "Achievement attributions and self-instructions under competitive and individualistic goal structures" 76 (76): 478-487, 1984