The Necessity of Finite Modes in Spinoza

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

It is standard to think that in Spinoza’s system, all things are necessary and in no sense contingent. However, in his classic book, Spinoza’s Metaphysics, published in 1969, Edwin Curley argues based on the proposition 28 of the first part of the Ethics that Spinoza endorses necessitarianism of only a modest kind, according to which when it comes to finite modes, there is a sense in which they are contingent. In this paper, I revisit Curley’s argument. Commentators have responded to Curley’s argument, showing that Spinoza’s remarks on infinite modes entail that finite modes can in no sense be contingent. But this alone falls short of dispelling Curley’s misgivings about the standard interpretation, for it remains unexplained why Curley is wrong in thinking that the proposition 28 supports his moderate necessitarian interpretation. In defense of the standard interpretation, I bolster the usual response to Curley in greater detail than has been done in the literature and explain why, pace Curley, the proposition 28 plays no evidential role in support of Curley’s interpretation.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Lowe, J., "Two Notions of Being : Entity and Essence" 62 : 23-48, 2008

2 Della Rocca, M., "The Power of an Idea: Spinoza’s Critique of Pure Will" 37 : 200-231, 2003

3 Della Rocca, M., "The Parmenidean Ascent" Oxford University Press 2020

4 Martin, C., "The Framework of Essences in Spinoza’s Ethics" 16 (16): 489-509, 2008

5 McDaniel, K., "The Fragmentation of Being" Oxford University Press 2017

6 Morgan, M., "The Essential Spinoza: Ethics and Related Writings" Hackett Publishing Company 2006

7 Garrett, D., "The Cambridge Companion to Spinoza’s Ethics" Cambridge University Press 2009

8 Laerke, M., "The Actual and the Possible" Oxford University Press 2017

9 Hempel, C. G., "Studies in the Logic of Explanation" 15 (15): 135-175, 1945

10 Melamed, Y., "Spinoza’s Metaphysics: Substance and Thought" Oxford University Press 2013

11 Curley, E., "Spinoza’s Metaphysics: An Essay in Interpretation" Harvard University Press 1969

12 Melamed, Y., "Spinoza’s Metaphysics of Substance : The Substance-Mode Relation as a Relation of Inherence and Predication" 78 : 17-82, 2009

13 Schmaltz, T., "Spinoza’s Mediate Infinite Mode" 35 : 199-235, 1997

14 Viljanen, V., "Spinoza’s Geometry of Power" Cambridge University Press 2011

15 Carriero, J., "Spinoza’s Ethics: A Critical Guide" Cambridge University Press 2013

16 Barbone, S., "Spinoza: Metaphysical Themes" Oxford University Press 89-112, 2002

17 Viljanen, V., "Spinoza's Essentialist Model of Causation" 51 : 412-437, 2008

18 Ward, T., "Spinoza on the Essences of Modes" 19 : 19-46, 2011

19 Hübner, K., "Spinoza on Essences, Universals, and Beings of Reason" 97 : 58-88, 2015

20 Zylstra, S., "Spinoza on Action and Immanent Causation" 102 : 29-55, 2020

21 Della Rocca, M., "Spinoza" Routledge 2008

22 Della Rocca, M., "Representation and the Mind-Body Problem in Spinoza" Oxford University Press 1996

23 Pasnau, R., "Primary and Secondary Qualities: The Historical and Ongoing Debate" Oxford University Press 2011

24 Della Rocca, M., "Philosophers’ Imprint 10" 2010

25 Huenemann, C., "Oxford Handbook of Spinoza" Oxford University Press 114-132, 2018

26 Carriero, J., "On the Relationship between Mode and Substance in Spinoza’s Metaphysics" 33 : 245-273, 1995

27 Curley, E., "New Essays on the Rationalists" Oxford University Press 1998

28 Carriero, J., "Mind, Body, and Morality: New Perspectives on Descartes and Spinoza" Routledge 2019

29 Miller, P. Lee, "Introductory Readings in Ancient Greek and Roman Philosophy" Hackett Publishing Company 2015

30 Garrett, D., "Interpreting Spinoza:Critical Essays" Cambridge University Press 2008

31 Wilson, M., "Infinite Understanding, Scientia Intuitiva, and Ethics 1.16" 8 (8): 181-191, 1983

32 Garrett, D., "God and Nature in Spinoza’s Metaphysics" Brill 1991

33 Han, S., "From the Analogy of Being to Modes of Being?" 179 : 3133-3139, 2022

34 Han, S., "Essence and Thisness" 13 : 166-212, 2023

35 Oderberg, D., "Essence and Properties" 75 : 85-111, 2011

36 Fine, K., "Essence and Modality" 8 : 1-16, 1994

37 Koslicki, K., "Contemporary Aristotelian Metaphysics" Cambridge University Press 187-206, 2012

38 Matthews, G., "Aristotle on Existence" 40 : 233-238, 1995

39 Brandom, R., "Adequacy and the Individuation of Ideas in Spinoza’s Ethics" 14 : 147-162, 1976

40 Curley, E., "A Spinoza Reader: the Ethics and Other Works" Princeton University Press 1994