협동연구성과 결정요인에 관한 연구: 우수연구센터의 연구자원과 연구성과를 중심으로 = Do Sectors Make Difference in the Performance of Collaborative Research: A Review of the First Round Evaluation of the Centers of Excellence of Korea

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This studty aims at seeing whether resource publicness would make a difference in research performance at the Centers of Excellence. The data was obtained from the 1st round comprehensive evaluation report of the Centers of Excellece program, in which basic and performance statistics is presented for 27 individual centers. Our analysis reveals that the publicness perspective, measured by researchers` sectoral affiliations and funding sources, has a partial power of explanation, thereby implicating a some degree of explanatory power of research fields. With certain data caveats, this study shows some interesting findings: Government fund has placed considerable pressures toward the production of academic papers on both types of centers, i.e., SRCs and ERCs, and functioned as a seed money for the generation of industrial results. Non-governmental fund, including funds form businesses, was positively related to the generation of industrial results in an inconsistent way, but with obviously positive effects for ERCs. The involvement of government laboratories was effective neither for academic performance nor for industrial performance. Increasing number of researchers and their assistants, particularly ones from universities, was rather negatively related to the generation of SCI papers. Implications are discussed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 한국과학재단, "협동연구의 유형별 쟁점과 정책대응방안"

2 "한국과학재단"

3 최영훈, "학？연 연구개발협동의 저해요인- KIST-고려대 협동연구를 중심으로 -" 한국정책학회 11 (11): 303-332, 2002

4 김미나, "지방정부 주도적 연구개발지원사업의 구조와 성과:Y 지방의 지역협력연구센터(RRC) 사례를 중심으로" 한국행정연구소 44 (44): 305-327, 2006

5 최영훈, "일본의 정산연구의 결정요인과 효과성" 7 (7): 339-363, 1998

6 최영훈, "이공계대학 연구비관리체제의 주요 쟁점 및 개선방안" 한국정책분석평가학회 2005

7 한국과학재단, "우수연구센터 최종보고서"

8 홍형득, "산학협력 활성화를 위한 산학연계전략수립에 관한 연구: 국립 산업대학의 역할모형을 중심으로" 한국행정학회 2002

9 변창률, "산학협력 연구성과의 영향요인 분석: 대학의 연구기능을 중심으로" 성균관대학교 2004

10 이장재, "대학부설연구조직의 특성과 육성방안" 한국정책학회 271-291, 1998

11 최영훈, "과학기술정책 관리의 변화와 대응: 지역협력센터 사업을 중심으로" 10 (10): 155-176, 2001

12 최영훈, "과학기술계 정부출연연구기관 성과제고 방안" 한국산업기술연구회 2007

13 Katz, J. S, "What is Research Collaboration?" 26 : 1-18, 1997

14 Geisler, E, "University-Industry Relations" Kluwer Academic Publishers 1989

15 Etzkowitz, H, "Universities and the Global Knowledge Economy" Continuum 1997

16 Von Hippel, E, "The Sources of Innovation" Oxford University Press 1988

17 Cozzens, Susan E, "The Research Systems in Transition" Kluwer Academic Publishers 1990

18 Caloghiroua, Y, "The Performance of Research Partnerships" 24 : 85-99, 2003

19 Gibbons, M, "The New Production of Knowledge" SAGE Publications 1994

20 Bozeman, B, "The NSF Engineering Research Centers and the University Industry Research Revolution: A Brief History Featuring an Interview with Erich Bloch" 29 (29): 365-375, 2004

21 Kostoff, N, "The Handbook of Research Impact Assessment" Office of Naval Research 1996

22 Audretsch, D. B, "The Economics of Science and Technology" 27 (27): 155-203, 2002

23 Dodgson, M, "Technological Collaboration in Industry" Routledge 1993

24 Choi, Y, "Success Factors for Transferring Technology to SMEs" 25 (25): 237-246, 2000

25 Corley, E, "Scientists’ Participation in University Research Centers: What are the Gender Differences?" 30 (30): 371-381, 2005

26 황석원, "SCI와 연구개발 성과 평가" 과학기술정책연구원 2006

27 Beaver, D. D, "Reflections on scientific collaboration (and its study): past, present, and future" 52 (52): 365-377, 2001

28 Crow, M, "R&D laboratory classification and public policy: the effects of environmental context on laboratory behavior" 16 (16): 1987

29 Van Wart, "Public Sector Values and Productivity" Marcel Dekker 2004

30 Choi, Y, "Partnering Government Laboratories with Industry" Syracuse University 1996

31 López-Martínez, R, "Motivations and obstacles to university industry cooperation (UIC)" 24 (24): 17-31, 1994

32 GAO, "Measuring Performance: Strengths and Limitations of Research Indicators" Report to Congressional Requesters 1997

33 Crow, M, "Limited by Design: R&D Laboratories in the U.S. National Innovation System" Columbia University Press 1998

34 Gray, D. O, "Industry-University Research Centers" 26 (26): 247-254, 2001

35 Rees, J, "Industry Knowledge Sources and the Role of Universities" 11 (11): 6-25, 1992

36 OECD, "Frascati Manual" OECD 2002

37 Austin, A. E, "Faculty Collaboration" The George Washington University 1991

38 Shenhav, Y. A, "External Effects on Research Endeavors" 42 (42): 403-421, 1989

39 Weingart, P, "Bibliometric Indicators for Assessing Strengths and Weaknesses of West German Science" North-Holland 1988

40 Hall, B, "Barriers Inhibiting Industry from Partnering with Universities" 26 (26): 87-98, 2001

41 Bozeman, B, "All Organizations Are Public.San" Jossey-Bass Publishers 1987

42 Mansfield, E, "Academic research underlying industrial innovations" 77 (77): 55-65, 1995

43 Mansfield, E, "Academic research and industrial innovations" 20 (20): 1-12, 1991