치과주조용 비귀금속 합금의 금속 용출 수준 = Concentration of elemental ions released from non-precious dental casting alloys

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Purpose: This study was to assess the extents of the release of metals from the non-precious alloys used for dental casting by measuring the differences in the extents of the release of metals by types of alloys, pH level and elapsed time. Methods: Uniform-sized specimens(10 each) were prepared according to the Medical Device Standard of the Korea Food and Drug Administration(2010) and International Standard Organization(ISO22674, 2006), using four types of alloys(one type of Ni-Cr and one type of Co-Cr used for fixed prosthesis, and one type of Ni-Cr and one type of Co-Cr used for removable prosthesis). A total of 12 metal-release tests were performed at one-day, three-day, and two-week intervals, for up to 20 weeks. The metal ions were quantified using an Inductively Coupled Plasma-Atomic Emission Spectrometer. Results: The results showed that the extent of corrosion was higher in the ascending order of Jdium-$100^{(R)}$, Bellabond-$Plus^{(R)}$, Starloy-$C^{(R)}$, and Biosil-$F^{(R)}$. The lower the pH and the longer the elapsed time were, the greater the increase in metal corrosion. At pH 2.4, the release of Ni from Jdium-$100^{(R)}$, a Ni-Cr alloy, was up to 15 times greater than the release of Co from the Co-Cr alloy from two weeks over time, indicating that the Ni-Cr alloy is more susceptible to corrosion than the Co-Cr alloy. Conclusion: It is recommended that Co-Cr alloy, which is highly resistant to corrosion, be used for making dental prosthesis with a non-precious alloy for dental casting, and that non-precious alloy prosthesis be designed in such a way as to minimize the area of its oral exposure. For patients with non-precious alloy prostheses, a test of the presence or absence of periodontal tissue inflammation or allergic reaction around the prosthesis should be performed via regular examination, and education on the good management of the prosthesis is needed.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 National Institute Of Dental Research, "Workshop : biocompatibility of metals in dentistry" 109 (109): 469-471, 1984

2 International Standards Organization, "Water for analytical laboratory use - Specification and test methods. ISO 3696" 1987

3 Napangkangas R, "Twenty-year follwup of metal-ceramic single crown : a retrospective study" 21 (21): 307-311, 2008

4 Wataha JC, "The release of elements of dental casting alloys into cellculture medium" 70 (70): 1014-1018, 1991

5 Evans EJ, "The in vitro toxicity of cobalt-chrome-molybdenum alloy and its constituent metals" 7 (7): 25-29, 1986

6 Franz G, "The frequency of allergy against dental materials" 1981

7 Stipetic J, "The Release of Nickel Ions from Three Different Dental Casting Alloys" 36 (36): 389-395, 2002

8 Rincic N, "The Release of Ions from the Base Co-Cr-Mo Casting Alloy in vitro into the Phosphate Buffer at pH 6.0" 37 (37): 13-16, 2003

9 McGlynn W, "The Importance of Food pH in Commercial Canning Operations"

10 Trombelli L, "Systemic contact dermatitis from an orthodontic appliance" 27 (27): 259-, 1992

11 Kerosuo H, "Systemic contact dermatitis caused by nickel in a stainless steel orthodontic appliance" 36 (36): 112-113, 1997

12 Veien NK, "Stomatitis or systemically induced contact dermatitis from metal wire in orthodontic materials" 30 (30): 210-213, 1994

13 Lygre GB, "Reporting on adverse reactions to dental materials-.intraoral observations at a clinical follow-up" 31 (31): 200-206, 2003

14 Wataha JC, "Release of elements from dental casting alloys into cell-culture medium over 10 months" 14 (14): 158-163, 1998

15 Wataha JC, "Precision of and new methods for testing in vitro alloy cytotoxicity" 8 (8): 65-70, 1992

16 Temesvari E, "Nickel sensitivity from dental prosthesis" 18 (18): 50-51, 1988

17 Gjerdet NR, "Nickel and iron in saliva of patients with fixed orthodontic appliances" 49 (49): 73-78, 1991

18 Schmalz G, "Metal content of biopsies from the neighborhood of casting alloys" 78 : 236-, 1999

19 "Medical Devices Standards and Specifications. Some revised Notice(No.2010-36)"

20 Geis-Gerstorfer J, "Ion release from Ni-Cr-Mo and Co-Cr-Mo casting alloys" 4 (4): 152-158, 1991

21 Faccioni F, "In vivo study on metal release from fixed orthodontic appliances and DNA damage in oral mucosal cells" 124 (124): 687-694, 2003

22 Elshahawy WM, "In vitro cytotoxicity evaluation of elemental ions released from different prosthodontic materials" 25 (25): 1551-1555, 2009

23 Reuling N, "Histomorphometrical studies on the histocompatibility of dental alloys" 46 (46): 215-219, 1991

24 Jiang J, "GFAAS Determination of Ni in Artificial Saliva Eroded from Ni-Cr Alloy Dental Crown" 45 (45): 112-113, 2009

25 Hamano H, "Fundamental studies on biological effects of dental metals-nikel dissolution, toxicity and distribution in cultured cells" 59 (59): 456-478, 1992

26 Jacobsen N, "Epithelial-like cells in culture derived from human gingiva : response to nickel" 85 (85): 567-574, 1977

27 Elshahawy WM, "Elemental ion release from four different fixed prosthodontic materials" 25 (25): 976-981, 2009

28 Wataha JC, "Effect of pH on element release from dental casting alloys" 80 (80): 691-698, 1998

29 International Standards Organization, "Dentistry - Metallic materials for fixed and removable restorations and appliances. ISO 22674"

30 Richter G, "Dentalwerkstoffe-Problemsubstanzen in der allergologischen Diagnostik? Teil Ⅱ : Patchtestdiagnostik und Relevanzbewertung bei ausgewahlten Dentalwerkstoffgruppen" 47 (47): 844-849, 1996

31 International Standards Organization, "Dental metallic materials-corrosion test methods, was applied to provide test methods. ISO 10271"

32 Craig RG, "Dental materials, properties and manipulation" The C. V. Mosby Company 1983

33 Craig RG, "Cytotoxicity of experimental casting alloys evaluated by cell culture tests" 69 (69): 1539-1542, 1990

34 Choi YJ, "Cytotoxicity of dental cast base metal alloys on human oral keratinocytes" 37 (37): 717-728, 1999

35 Khamis E, "Corrosion evaluation of recasting non-precious dental cast alloys" 45 (45): 209-217, 1995

36 Bumgardner JD, "Corrosion and cell culture evaluation of nickel-chromium dental casting alloys" 5 (5): 203-213, 1994

37 Bumgardner JD, "Cellular Response to Metallic Ions Released from Nickel-Chromium Dental Alloys" 74 (74): 1521-1527, 1995

38 Morris HF, "Casting alloys : the materials and the clinical effect" 6 (6): 28-31, 1992

39 Limberger F, "Biological examination of cobalt and nickel-based alloys in comparison of implantalt and nicin aniltl expandments" 42 (42): 1635-1647, 1991

40 International Standards Organization, "Biological evaluation of medical devices - Part 5: Tests for In Vitro Cytotoxicity. ISO 10993-5"

41 Moneret-Vautrin DA, "Allergy to nickel in dental alloys" 36 (36): 311-312, 2004

42 Wataha JC, "Ag, Cu, Hg and Ni ions alter the metabolism of human monocytes during extended low-dose exposures" 29 (29): 133-139, 2002

43 Taggart WH, "A new and accurate method of making gold inlays" 49 : 1117-, 1907