타부와 의례 = `이항대립적 사고체계`의 구성과 해체, 그리고 정치적 재구성

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Claude Levi-Strauss argued that human cognition, which is based on logical thought, is independent of social context. From this, he proposed that the taboo is a comprehensive and coherent classificatory system enabling individuals to classify the world in a rational fashion. In this judgment, he explained that the taboo is a nominal difference which has a logical validity. Its acceptance amounts to validate the differential attribute between the forbidden and the permitted, in epistemology between one cognizable and another cognizable, and to renounce their mixture. When we abide by the nominal rule, its effectiveness will be maintained. The rule dishonored will be naturally related to the loss or weakening of meaning, even if a punishment is imposed.
But, in our perspective, the taboo is the epistemological difference involved in the dynamic activity of thought based on the opposition between the sacred and the impure; in other words, between the non-cognizable and the cognizable, which should be defined only in terms of one another. Here, in dignity and power and as a source of inspiration and identity, the sacred is superior to the impure. It is therefore directly related to the discriminative judgment.
In this condition, it is necessary to understand that violation the taboo is usually not considered to be a loss or weakening of its significance, because an intentional defiance, what we said as a ritual violation, is inherent in the system itself of taboo. The efficiency of taboo is fundamentally based on the existence of the inevitable violation. Actually, if the entire member does not attend in the ritual, the ritual violation will reproduce a discriminative structure between the attendants and the non-attendants.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김기현, "현대 인식론" 민음사 2003

2 Vries, Josef de, "인식의 근본 문제(1980)" 가톨릭출판사 2007

3 Rovighi, V. Sofia, "인식론의 역사" 가톨릭대학교출판부 2004

4 Eliade, Mircea, "성과 속(1957)" 한길사 1998

5 김성례, "무교 신화와 의례의 신성성과 연행성" 10 : 1997

6 강진옥, "‘신성과의 소통방식’을 통해 본 무속의례와 신화의 공간성 연구" 비교민속학회 39 (39): 387-438, 2009

7 Coppet, Daniel de, "tabou, In Encyclopaedia Universalis" CORPUS 2002

8 Lévi-Strauss,Claude, "Totémisme aujourd'hui" PUF 1962

9 Freud, Sigmund, "Totem et Tabou(1913), trad. fr. par Serge Jankélévitch" Petite Bibliothèque Payot 1965

10 Turner, Victor, "The Ritual Process: Structure and Anti-Structure" Aldine de Gruyter 1969

11 Bonte, Pierre, "Tabou, In Dictionnaire de l’ethnologie et de l’anthropologie" Paris: PUF 1991

12 Steiner, Franz, "Taboo" Routledge 1956

13 Bastide, Roger, "Sociologie et Psychanalyse" PUF 1950

14 Kilani, Mondher, "Sacré, In Le Dictionnaire des Sciences humaines" PUF 2006

15 Douglas, Mary, "Purity and danger: an analysis of concepts of pollution and taboo" Routledge & Kegan Paul 1966

16 Cuisenier, Jean, "Penser le rituel" PUF 2006

17 Caillois, Roger, "L’homme et le sacré" Gallimard 1939

18 Dubuisson, Daniel, "L’Occident et la religion : mythes, science et idéologie" Éditions Complexe 1998

19 Cazeneuve,Jean, "Les rites et la condition humaine" PUF 1958

20 Durkheim, Émile, "Les formes élémentaires de la vie religieuse : le système totémique en Australie(1912)" PUF 1960

21 Ries, Julien, "Les chemins du sacré dans l’histoire" Aubier 1985

22 Lévi-Strauss, Claude, "Les Structures élémentaires de la parenté(1949)" Mouton & Co 1967

23 Masson, Michel, "Le sacré en Chine" BREPOLS 2008

24 Jankélévitch, Vladimir, "Le pur et l’impur, In Philosophie morale(1960)" Flammarion 1998

25 Parrinder,Geoffrey, "Le Sexe dans les religions du monde" Le Centurion 1980

26 Frazer, James Georges, "Le Rameau d’Or (The Golden Bough), t. I : Le Roi magicien dans la société primitive" Robert Laffont 1981

27 Maranda, P, "Le Crâne et l’Utérus : Deux Théorèmes Nord-Malaitains, In Échanges et Communications, Hommages offerts à Claude Lévi-Strauss pour son 60e anniversaire" Mouton 1970

28 Lévi-Strauss,Claude, "La pensée sauvage" Plon 1962

29 Lombard, Jacques, "La peine et la répression, In Histoire des Mœurs II" Gallimard 1991

30 Calame-Griaule, Geneviève, "La parole et le discours, In Histoire des Mœurs II" Gallimard 1991

31 Rabant, Claude, "Interdit, In Encyclopaedia Universalis" CORPUS 2002

32 André, Jacques, "Incestes" PUF 2001

33 Laplanche, Jean, "Inceste, In Vocabulaire de la Psychanalyse" PUF 1998

34 Durkheim,Émile, "De la définition des phénomènes religieux L’Année sociologique, 1897-1898" PUF 1969

35 Durkheim,Émile, "Cours sur les origines de la vie religieuse, L’Année sociologique, 1897-1898" PUF 1969