The appraisal of Buddhist craft works falls broadly into style-based appraisal and technique-based appraisal.
First, style-based appraisal can be further addressed in the aspect of form, material quality, color sense and rusty condition. Appraisal ...
The appraisal of Buddhist craft works falls broadly into style-based appraisal and technique-based appraisal.
First, style-based appraisal can be further addressed in the aspect of form, material quality, color sense and rusty condition. Appraisal by form refers to a work to well characterize Buddhist craft works, focusing upon several points. It seeks to analyze Buddhist craftworks many of which originate from traditionally inherited forms rather than designed for any intended purpose or functionality in usage. In some cases, they have unnatural forms designed not for simple purposes, but were originally designed to meet people's needs in their daily life like today. In advanced regard of historical characteristics and culture, it is important to identify which purposes or usages each Buddhist craftwork has in certain age. And it is required to carefully note that any artifact without certain usage is very likely a fake, although it is necessary to examine if a craftwork has its form complying with its purposes.
Next, appraisal of Buddhist crafrworks can be based on material quality and color sense. In case of metallic craftworks, there may be differences in color sense depending on their material quality, so it is required to correctly analyze material quality among others, and it is also necessary to employ a scientific analysis system like non-destructive analyzer, if necessary, to characterize chemical compositions of artifact. For instance, the appraisal of golden craft works requires clearly identifying if they are made of pure gold or are plated with gold, and the appraisal of gold-plated craftworks requires characterizing traditional golden amalgam plating depending on differences in their color sense. Damaged sections of Buddhist craft works should be more accurately analyzed in the appraisal, and bronze craftworks may reveal differences in color sense depending on alloy content applied at original molding process. And the color sense of silver craftworks sometimes tum from original white color to black staining over time, causing difficulties in correctly identifying it they were originally made of silver. In addition, brassware produced in the era of Joseon dynasty may appear crude, but it requires careful consideration of differences in the content of tartar. Overall, it is recommended to appropriately employ data obtained from conservation science or composition analysis, and make a good use of instruments like magnifier with high magnification.
Rusty condition is considered a crucial criterion for appraisal of traditional metallic craftworks. Bronze rust formed over hundreds of years is balanced and also has a wide variety of color senses ranging from deep green to emerald, and artificially rust-coated metallic craftworks have relatively even rusty surface, but there is almost no case of uniform rust formed on the surface of metallic craftworks. Monotonous blue rust is considered artificial, and serious chemical smells from rust leave a large room of questions, so it is important to have a smell of rust formed on metallic craftworks. Non-rotted inscriptive writings on the rotted surface of metallic craftworks are a good evidence of in-scriptive writings which were carved extra later or have been forged recently.
Secondly, technique-based appraisal of Buddhist craftworks can fall broadly again into inscriptive analysis, patterns, decoration and preparation technique. Inscription requires careful observations, since it adds extra values to Buddhist craftworks, and traditional artifacts containing inscriptive writings are usually high priced in market, so that there are many cases of fake inscription modeled after original artifacts.