'Electronic monitoring system', the issue case of this thesis, is applied to highly-dangerous crimes, such as sexual violence, abduction of the minor, and murder. Given the characteristics of the crimes, their impacts as social problems are so big tha...
'Electronic monitoring system', the issue case of this thesis, is applied to highly-dangerous crimes, such as sexual violence, abduction of the minor, and murder. Given the characteristics of the crimes, their impacts as social problems are so big that they tend to become social issues as they occur. Since the social consensus of requesting the prevention of recidivism of the highly-dangerous crimes and the security of social safety net was formed, the issue 'electronic monitoring system' has rapidly developed into a public agenda, and then the government's agenda with the support of public opinion and policy innovators, and thus relevant policies have very quickly been established. As such, the policies have been institutionalized without enough consideration of the future cost and side-effects in their establishment step. As a result, in the policy execution step, the criticism that it has low cost-effectiveness has arisen, and the argument of abolishing the project has been emerged. The ‘electronic monitoring system' faced the risk of declination. Generally, as an issue gets weakened and thus a relevant policy comes to an end, the government's policy support is terminated. However, despite the criticism of the cost and side-effects of the 'electronic monitoring system', the project's application scope continues to be expand, and its relevant policies are developed through change and supplementation. Such the government's policy direction lead into a lot of disputes, and consequently the somewhat unpopular issue of the electronic monitoring system has get reignited.
In the background, the purpose of this study is to analyze the features of the social attention cycle of the 'electronic monitoring system' and the effect of the cycle on relevant policies, and find out why the government does not terminate the project which comes to lose the public's attention, but maintain and expand it. To achieve the purpose, this thesis applied Downs' Issue Attention Cycle Model, which has been studied previously in various areas because the project related policies have drawn a lot of public attention from its pre-introduction time to 2013, and analyzed the project's issue attention cycle. In addition, this thesis analyzed the number of news articles and columns, opinion poll results, and voting results in the national assembly records, and the national assembly records to find out the effect of the issue attention cycle on relevant policies. Aside from that, despite the negative public opinions of the electronic monitoring system, it examined why the government continues to change and supplement relevant policies to expand the project's application scope. Since the public has the criticism that the electronic monitoring system results in high cost and side effects (low efficiency), this researcher measured the invested cost and its effect to analyze the project's economic validity, and thereby examined the validity of the high-cost and low-efficiency problem of the project.
Downs' model was applied to analyze the issue attention cycle of the 'electronic monitoring system' was analyzed. As a result, compared to Downs' model, the issue attention cycle of the project didn't go into a decline phase after the step of the public's perception of high-cost and side-effects, but entered into an issue-reignition phase which means that the 'electronic monitoring system approaching a decline phase is not terminated, but its policies are expanded through change and supplementation.
To analyze such a policy change, this researcher analyzed cost-effectiveness. According to the analysis, the electronic monitoring system positively influenced a drop in a second conviction rate overall. Second conviction rates were compared before and after the performance of the project. A second conviction rate after the project remarkably dropped more than that before the project. Also, it was analyzed that the number of recidivists fell more annually thanks to the project. According to the analysis on the cost spent in supervising one person wearing an electronic tagging, the cost spent every person wearing it gradually fell. It meant that since the initial investment in facilities was too large, the project's economic feasibility in its beginning was very low, and that since the expansion of the project's application scope in terms of crime types, more offenders have worn the bracelet, and consequently the influence of the initial facility investment has become smaller. Therefore, it is predicted that with the lapse of time, the economy of scales will get better, and it is judged that the economic validity of the project will be secured. As such, it was analyzed that unlike the public's perception that the project highly costs and is low efficient, the electronic monitoring system brought about its performance effect, reduced the number of expected recidivists, and produced the economy of scales. It is estimated that now that the economy of scales gets larger as the project's application scope is more expanded, the government continues to expand the application scope despite of the public's perception of high cost and side effects. It may be presumed that the policy change is attributable to constant occurrence of sexual violence cases drawing social attention, and a relevant organization's resistance against policy termination. However, given that it has only been six years since the performance of the electronic tagging, and thus it is still in its initial step, it is too much to see that the government's tendency of maintaining and expanding relevant policies is due to the resistance against policy termination.
By applying Downs' Issue Attention Cycle Model to the overall policies of the 'electronic monitoring system'' from its introduction to the present time, this thesis revealed that the project has an issue reignition phase, a unique issue attention cycle different from the Down's issue attention cycle. Also, it found the reasons why the project approaching a recline phase of issue is not terminated, but its relevant policies are maintained and expanded through an issue reignition phase; and proved the project's economic validity through cost-effectiveness analysis. This study is judged to be valuable academically and practically in the point that it induced the change of the public's perception that the project highly costs and is low efficient
In the future, it will be necessary to compare the electronic monitoring system with other systems whose purpose is similar to the project's and thereby analyze the validity of the project more deeply and thoroughly.