시스템 다이내믹스를 이용한 농업용수 재이용시스템 경제성 분석 = Economic Analysis of Wastewater Reuse Systems for Agricultural Irrigation using a System Dynamics Approach

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Many studies have reported additional treatment is needed to use wastewater for agricultural purpose. Economic considerations should be taken into account to establish infrastructure for agricultural reuse because of a large amount of water use in irrigation and relatively low water quality requirement. The objective of this study was to conduct economic analysis of wastewater reclamation and reuse systems for agriculture. A system dynamics approach considering complexity and dynamics in the wastewater reuse systems was used for the economic analysis, which are related with social, environmental, and economic problems. Sensitivity and benefit cost analysis for wastewater reuse systems was conducted through the established economic assessment model. The result of sensitivity analysis showed that water resources development and installation cost were the most sensitive for total benefits and costs, respectively. The scenario-based test of the organized economic assessment model shows marginal cost ranges and enables decision-makers to decide reasonable cost for the wastewater reuse systems for agriculture.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 최종수, "하수처리시설 건설 및 유지관리비용 산출방안" 대한환경공학회 25 (25): 5-37, 2003

2 정한석, "하수처리수의 농업용수 재이용에 따른 논벼 수확량 모의" 한국농공학회 53 (53): 67-74, 2011

3 정석환, "시스템다이내믹스 방법론을 이용한 정책파급효과분석 : 성매매특별법을 중심으로" 한국행정학회 39 (39): 219-236, 2005

4 이중훈, "비선호시설 입지갈등에 대한 인과지도 작성과 정책 대안" 한국시스템다이내믹스학회 8 (8): 151-171, 2007

5 여규동, "대체비용법을 이용한 하천 수질개선편익 산정" 한국수자원학회 42 (42): 343-353, 2009

6 김길호, "경제성분석에 의한 소수력 개발의 최적규모 결정 방안" 한국수자원학회 40 (40): 995-1005, 2007

7 김상단, "개념적인 토양수분 모의모형을 이용한 미래 극한 가뭄사상의 시공간적 해석" 한국방재학회 11 (11): 349-356, 2011

8 Haruvy N., "Wastewater reuse—regional and economic considerations" 23 : 57-66, 1998

9 Chu, J. Y., "Wastewater reuse potential analysis : implications for China's water resources management" 38 : 2746-2756, 2004

10 Eberlein, R., "Vensim User's Guide (version 5)" Ventana Systems 2007

11 Shin, D. I., "Value Proposition Modelling and Analysis for Business Models of Product-Service Systems Using System Dynamics" Seoul National University 2011

12 Jimenez, B., "Treatment technology and standards for agricultural wastewater reuse: a case study in Mexico" 54 (54): S22-S33, 2005

13 Cirelli G. L., "Treated municipal wastewater reuse in vegetable production" 104 : 163-170, 2012

14 Meadows, D. H., "The unavoidable a priori. In Elements of the System Dynamics Method" The MIT Press 23-57, 1980

15 Weick, K. E., "The social psychology of organzing" Addison-Wesley Publishing Company 1979

16 Minsitry of Environment(ME), "The analysis results of management condition of public wastewater treatment plants in 2011(in Korean)"

17 Richmond, B., "Systems thinking : critical thinking skills for the 1990s and beyond" 9 (9): 113-133, 1993

18 Kim, D. H., "Systems Thinking: Thinking Through Systems" Sunhaksa 2004

19 Barlas Y., "System dynamics: systemic feedback modeling for policy analysis. In Knowledge for Sustainable Development—An Insight into the Encyclopedia of Life Support Systems" UNESCO Publishing 1131-1175, 1175

20 Ryu J. H., "System dynamics to sustainable water resources management in the eastern snake plain aquifer under water supply uncertainty" 48 (48): 1-17, 2012

21 Kim, D. H., "System Dynamics" Daeyoung Moonhwasa 1999

22 Im, S. J., "Surveying Water Supply from Irrigation Reservoirs in the Han River Basin" 42 (42): 37-44, 2000

23 Korea Development Institute(KDI), "Study on the revision for general guide to perform preliminary feasibility test(in Korean)"

24 Jang, T. I., "Safe application of reclaimed water" 8 : 227-233, 2010

25 Pereira, B. F. F., "Reclaimed wastewater : Effects on citrus nutrition" 98 : 1828-1833, 2011

26 Vasiloglou V., "New tool for wastewater treatment units location" 248 : 1039-1048, 2009

27 Ford, A., "Modeling the Environment" Island Press 2009

28 Petterson, S. R., "Microbial risks from wastewater irrigation of salad crops : a screening-level risk assessment" 72 : 667-672, 2001

29 Ministry of Land, Trnasport and Maritime Affairs(MLTM), "Long-Term Plans for Water Resources(in Korean)"

30 Forrester, J. W., "Industrial Dynamics" The MIT Press 1961

31 Blumenthal, U. J., "Guidelines for wastewater reuse in agriculture and aquaculture: recommended revisions based on new research evidence" WELL Resource Centre 2000

32 World Health Organization(WHO), "Guidelines for the safe use of wastewaters, excreta and greywater" World Health Organization 2006

33 Mara, D, "Guidelines for the Safe Use of Wastewater and Excreta in Agriculture and Aquaculture" World Health Organization 1989

34 Forslund, A., "Faecal contamination and hygiene aspect associated with the use of treated wastewater and canal water for irrigation of potatoes" 98 : 440-450, 2010

35 Asano, T., "Evaluation of the California wastewater reclamation criteria using enteric virus monitoring data" 26 (26): 1513-1524, 1992

36 Hoffman, E. O., "Evaluation of Uncertainties in Environmental Radiological Assessment Models, In Radiological Assessments: a Textbook on Environmental Dose Assessment" Nuclear Regulatory Commission 11-55, 1983

37 Cho, E. H., "Estimating Benefit of Water Quality Improvement by Raising Dam Project with Replacement Cost Method" Inha University 2012

38 Jang T. I., "Environmental effects of reclaimed wastewater irrigation on paddy fields" Seoul National University 2009

39 Stevens, D. P., "Effects of long-term irrigation with reclaimed water on soils of the northern Adelaide plains, SA" 41 : 933-948, 2003

40 Ayres, R. M., "Contamination of lettuces with nematode eggs by spray irrigation with treated and untreated wastewater" 26 (26): 1615-1623, 1992

41 Hall, R. I., "Causal policy maps of managers : Formal methods for elicitation and analyis" 10 (10): 337-360, 1994

42 Kang M. S., "Assessment of reclaimed wastewater irrigation impacts on water quality, soil, and rice cultivation in paddy fields" 42 : 439-445, 2007

43 Jang T. I., "Assessing nutrient losses of reclaimed wastewater irrigation in paddy fields for sustainable agriculture" 104 : 235-243, 2012

44 Kim, H. D., "Application of wastewater reuse system for agriculture: status and prospects" 42 (42): 36-43, 2009

45 Park, S. W., "Application of wastewater reuse system for agriculture" Seoul National University 2007

46 Park, S. W., "Application of integrated technologies for wastewater reclamation and reuse system for agriculture" Seoul National University 2011

47 Jung, Y. H., "Application and Verification of System Dynamics Model for Media Diversity in an Era of Multimedia and Multichannel" Seoul National University 2012

48 Yang H., "Analysis of wastewater reuse potential in Beijing" 212 : 238-250, 2007

49 Khan S., "Analysing complex behavior of hydrological systems through a system dynamics approach" 24 (24): 1363-1372, 2009

50 Haruvy, N., "Agricultural reuse of wastewater: nation-wide cost-benefit analysis" 66 : 113-119, 1997

51 Korean Statistical Information Service (KOSIS), "Agricultural census data"

52 Liberti, L., "Advanced Treatment for Municipal Wastewater Reuse in Agriculture. Ⅲ-Ozone Disinfection" 22 (22): 151-166, 2000

53 Qi, J., "A systems dynamics approach to competitive strategy in mobile telecommunication industry" 26 (26): 155-168, 2009

54 Stave, K. A., "A system dynamics model to facilitate public understanding of water management options in Las Vegas, Nevada" 67 : 303-313, 2003

55 Vlachos, D., "A system dynamics model for dynamic capacity planning of remanufacturing in closed-loop supply chains" 34 : 367-394, 2007

56 Nasiri F., "A system dynamics approach for urban water reuse planning: a case study from the great lakes region"

57 Peasey A. U., "A review of policy and standards for wastewater reuse in agriculture: a Latin American perspective. Task No: 68 Part II" WELL study 2000

58 Hong, W. S., "A Study on the Sensitivity Analysis for WASP4 Model" Seoul National University 1993