베토벤 피아노 소나타에 나타나는 코다(coda) 처리 기법 = A Study of Beethoven’s Handlings of the Coda as Seen in His Piano Sonatas

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Although music scholars have researched a musical form, particularly sonata form for over 200 years, they tended to downplay structural roles of the final formal unit, “coda.” A close inspection of the music dictionaries reflects such a tendency that roles of the coda in the sonata form have been devaluated in comparison to the proceeding sections. However, recent studies from a Schenkerian perspective reveal that the 18th-century standpoint of the coda, in which one understands it simply as a rhetorical appendix to the proceeding main body, experiences a modification and supplementation.
The goal of this article is to study Beethoven’s unique ways of handlings the coda by examining sonata-form movements from his piano sonatas. For this task, I have reviewed concepts of the coda by Heinrich Schenker, Robert Hopkins, John Rink, etc. and then taken Joseph Kerman’s monumental study as a point of departure for the stylistic analysis of Beethoven’s piano works. I distinguished distinctive functions of the coda in first movements of Op. 2/3, Op. 53, and, Op. 81a, and third movement of Op. 31/2, by espousing critically Kerman’s opinions on distinctive roles of the coda. The analytic result proves that codas of each work carry quite different functions: in Op. 2/3, Beethoven put structural significance into the coda by interpolating it between divided codettas; in Op. 53, the coda serves as strategic place that dissolves accumulative large-scale dissonance; and Op. 81a, and Op. 31/2 take the coda as a peroration containing diverse motivic reworking processes.

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Although music scholars have researched a musical form, particularly sonata form for over 200 years, they tended to downplay structural roles of the final formal unit, “coda.” A close inspection of the music dictionaries reflects such a tendency that roles of the coda in the sonata form have been devaluated in comparison to the proceeding sections. However, recent studies from a Schenkerian perspective reveal that the 18th-century standpoint of the coda, in which one understands it simply as a rhetorical appendix to the proceeding main body, experiences a modification and supplementation.
The goal of this article is to study Beethoven’s unique ways of handlings the coda by examining sonata-form movements from his piano sonatas. For this task, I have reviewed concepts of the coda by Heinrich Schenker, Robert Hopkins, John Rink, etc. and then taken Joseph Kerman’s monumental study as a point of departure for the stylistic analysis of Beethoven’s piano works. I distinguished distinctive functions of the coda in first movements of Op. 2/3, Op. 53, and, Op. 81a, and third movement of Op. 31/2, by espousing critically Kerman’s opinions on distinctive roles of the coda. The analytic result proves that codas of each work carry quite different functions: in Op. 2/3, Beethoven put structural significance into the coda by interpolating it between divided codettas; in Op. 53, the coda serves as strategic place that dissolves accumulative large-scale dissonance; and Op. 81a, and Op. 31/2 take the coda as a peroration containing diverse motivic reworking processes.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 송무경, "조성음악의 분석이론. 음악이론과 분석" 심설당 55-92, 2005

2 송무경, "음악분석의 즐거움과 효용 : 베토벤 피아노 소나타 op31/2 <폭풍> 1악장에 대한 두 가지 이야기 분석" 한국서양음악학회 8 (8): 9-36, 2005

3 이희승, "국어대사전" 민중서림 1994

4 Hopkins, Robert, "When a Coda is More Than a Coda: Reflections on Beethoven. In Explorations in Music, the Arts, and Ideas: Essays in Honor of Leonard B. Meyer" Pendragon 393-410, 1988

5 Spitzer, Michael, "The Significance of Recapitulation in the ‘Waldstein Sonata" 5 : 103-117, 1996

6 Song, Moo Kyoung, "The Evolution of Sonata-Form Design in Ludwig van Beethoven’s Early Piano Sonatas, WoO 47 to Opus 22" The University of Texas at Austin 2002

7 Caplin, William, "The Classical Cadence: Conceptions and Misconceptions" 57 (57): 51-117, 2004

8 Rink, John, "Structural Momentum’ and Closure in Chopin's Nocturne Op. 9, No. 2. In Schenker Studies" Cambridge University Press 1999

9 Rosen, Charles, "Sonata Forms. 다양한 소나타 형식" 수문당 1995

10 Webster, James, "Sonata Form. In The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians" Grove’s Dictionaries Inc. 687-698, 2001

11 Plantinga, Leon, "Romantic Music: A History of Musical Style in Nineteenth-Century Europe" W. W. Norton & Company Inc. 1984

12 Schenker, Heinrich, "Organic Structure in Sonata Form. In Readings in Schenker Analysis and Other Approaches" Yale 38-53, 1977

13 Kerman, Joseph, "Notes on Beethoven’s Codas, in Beethoven Studies" Cambridge University Press 141-159, 1982

14 Dahlhaus, Carl, "Nineteenth-Century Music" University of California Press 1989

15 Cavett-Dunsby, Esther, "Mozart's Codas" 7 (7): 31-51, 1988

16 Ratner, Leonard, "Key Definition-A Structural Issue in Beethoven’s Music" 23 (23): 472-483, 1970

17 LaRue, Jan, "Guidelines for Style Analysis" Harmonie Park Press 1992

18 Schenker, Heinrich, "Free Composition" Longman 1979

19 Green, Douglass, "Form in Tonal Music. 조성음악의 형식" 수문당 1998

20 Janet Schmalfeldt, "Form as the Process of Becoming: The Beethoven-Hegelian Tradition and the ‘Tempest’ Sonata" 4 : 37-71, 1995

21 Chodkowski, Andrzej, "Die Koda in der Sonatenform Beethovens. Bericht uber den Internationalen Beethoven-Kongress" 1973

22 Smyth, David, "Codas in Classical Form: Aspects of Large-Scale Rhythm and Pattern Completion" University of Texas at Austin 1985

23 Randel, Don, "Coda. In The New Harvard Dictionary of Music" 178-, 1986

24 Bullivant, Roger, "Coda. In The New Grove Dictionary of Music and Musicians" Grove’s Dictionaries Inc. 82-, 2001

25 Rosen, Charles, "Classical Style: Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven" Norton 1997

26 Caplin, William, "Classical Form: A Theory of Formal Functions for the Instrumental Music of Haydn, Mozart, and Beethoven" Oxford University Press 1998

27 Kinderman, William, "Beethoven" University of California Press 1995

28 Kamien, Roger, "Aspects of the Recapitulation in Beethoven Piano Sonatas" 4 : 195-235, 1976

29 Dahlhaus, Carl, "Approach to His Music" Clarendon Press, Oxford University Press 1991

30 Tovey, Donald F, "A Companion to Beethoven’s Pianoforte Sonatas: Bar-by-Bar Analysis" Associated Board of the Royal Schools of Music 1931