중국 복지체제의 성격 = A Critical Review on the Characteristics of Chinese Welfare Regime

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The Chinese welfare regime is unique because a socialist state leaded social security reforms to settle the socialist market economy. Therefore, several attempts for explaining it were tried. Those are the east asian welfare model, the corporatist regime of social welfare, the authoritarian state centered model and the neoliberal model.
However, these models have critical defects. The east asian welfare model can`t explain the historical, qualitative and substantial differences between China, the western welfare states and the east asian capitalist states. The corporatist regime model can`t be accepted because the power of state overwhelms enterprises and workers. The authoritarian state-centered model can`t explain fundamental differences of state legitimacy and societal system between China and other two countries, Korea and Japan. The neoliberal model is just a narrow approach to explain the Chinese pension reform.
It means that the existing models can`t explain the Chinese welfare regime well. The reason is uniqueness of China. In other words, China has its own unique experiences which are different from the western welfare states and the east asian capitalist states, and therefore it can`t be categorized in one model with these countries. Those are the transition from collective welfare to state welfare, the dual welfare structure, the hukou system and weakness of NGOs. These special situations make China has to go its own way, `the Chinese way.`

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이중희, "중국의 사회보장제도의 도입과 추진" 아태지역연구센터 28 (28): 15-42, 2004

2 리우밍푸, "중국의 사회보장제도" 12 (12): 2007

3 오정수, "중국의 사회보장" 집문당 2006

4 최금해, "중국의 사회보장" 나눔의집 2008

5 백승욱, "중국의 노동자와 노동정책: ‘단위 체제’의 해체" 문학과지성사 2001

6 원석조, "중국의 ‘조화사회론’과 사회보장 개혁" 한국사회복지정책학회 36 (36): 419-445, 2009

7 장야리, "중국에서의 사회경제적 격차문제와 사회보장제도" 7 : 2006

8 최진백, "중국 사회보장제도의 발전과 그 성격" 11 (11): 2006

9 김태곤, "중국 사회보장 연구:중국 사회보장제도 개혁을 위한 원칙 모색" 147-172, 2004

10 백승욱, "중국 단위 복지체제의 해체 : 사회보험제도 개혁을 중심으로" 21 (21): 1997

11 박병현, "동아시아 사회복지연구" 공동체 2007

12 김병철, "도시와 농촌으로 이원화된 중국의 공공부조-최저생활보장제도를 중심으로-" 한국사회복지정책학회 35 (35): 61-86, 2008

13 신현방, "개혁정책 이후 중국사회보장제도의 변화" 6-, 2005

14 김병철, "개혁개방 전후의 중국사회보험제도의 변화" 15 (15): 68-75, 2010

15 郑秉文, "试论东亚地区福利国家的“国家主义中心”特征" 2002

16 王元月, "社会保障" 企业管理出版社 2004

17 中国統计局, "中国統计年鉴" 2009

18 宋曉俉, "中国社会保障制度改革" 淸华大学出版社 2002

19 王梦奎, "中国社会保障体制改革" 中国发展出版社 2001

20 Gabriel, S. J., "What Do You Mean China is Socialist? Satya Gabriel’s Online Papers: China Essay Series 21"

21 White, G., "Welfare Orientalism and the Research for an East Asian Welfare Model. in: The East Asian Welfare Model" Routledge 1998

22 Chen, A., "Urbanization and Social Welfare in China" Ashgate 2004

23 Liu, Y., "Urban Pauperization under China’s Social Exclusion: A Case Study of Nanjing" 30 (30): 2008

24 Ka, L., "Transformation of the Chinese Social Security System: Collective Welfare vs. State Welfare"

25 Wilensky, H. L., "The Welfare State and Equality：Structural and Ideological Roots of Public Expenditure" Univ. of California Press 1975

26 Sicular, T., "The Urban-Rural Income Gap and Inequality in China" 53 (53): 2007

27 Xing, L., "The Transformation of Ideology from Mao to Deng: Impact on China’s Social Welfare Outcome" 8 (8): 1999

28 Esping-Andersen, G., "The Three Worlds of Welfare Capitalism" Polity Press 1990

29 Lei, J. Z., "The Thirty Years of the Social Work Programme of Yanjing University. Status-Quo, Challenge and Prospect: Collected works of the seminar of the Asian-Pacific region social work education" Beijing Univ. Press 1991

30 Aspalter, C., "The State of Social Welfare in Asia" Casa Verde 2008

31 Li, M., "The Rural-Urban Divide in Chinese Social Security: Political and Institutional Explanations" 6 (6): 2005

32 Sheldon, M., "The Reform of Social Welfare in China" 25 (25): 1997

33 Baldwin, P., "The Politics of Social Solidarity：Class Base of the European Welfare State 1875-1975" Cambridge Univ. Press 1990

34 Linda, W., "The Market in Chinese Social Policy" Palgrave 2001

35 Lu, Y., "The Limitations of NGOss: A Preliminary Study of Non-Governmental Social Welfare Organizations in China" 2000

36 Goodman, R., "The East Asian Welfare State: Peripatic Learning, Adaptive Change and Nation Building. in: Welfare State in Transition: National Adaptations in Grobal Economics" Sage 1996

37 Goodman, R., "The East Asian Welfare Model" Routledge 1998

38 Xin, C., "The Development of Social Security Net System in China. in: Emerging Urban Poverty in East Asia" East Asian Development Network Regional Research Project 2004

39 Slivinski, S., "The Corporate Welfare State" 592 : 2007

40 Dixon, J., "The Chinese Welfare System, 1949-1979" Praeger 1981

41 Li, L. C., "The Chinese State in Transition: Processes and Contests in Local China" Routledge 2008

42 Wang, S. B., "The Age of Social Policy and Government Capacity-Building in Social Policy" 4 : 2004

43 Mishra, M., "Society and Social Policy: Theories and Practice of Welfare" Macmillan 1981

44 Xiong, Y. G., "Social Welfare Policy and Social Work Practice in China: Past, present and future" Korea Association of Social Workers 2005

45 White, G., "Social Security Reforms in China: Toward an East Asian Model?. in: The East Asian Welfare Model" Routledge 1998

46 Leung, J., "Social Security Reforms in China: Issues and Prospects" 12 : 2003

47 Williamson, J. B., "Social Security Reform: Does Partial Privatization Make Sense" 19 : 2005

48 Titmuss, R. M., "Social Policy: An Introduction" Allen & Unwin 1974

49 Chen, S., "Social Policy of the Economic State and Community Care in China Culture" Ashgate 1996

50 Chen, J., "Social Insurance Provision in Urban China: Variations according to Region and Workplace Ownership" 2009

51 Esping-Andersen, G., "Social Foundations of Post-Industrial Economics" Oxford Univ. Press 1999

52 Gao, Q., "Social Benefits and Income Inequality in Post-Socialist China and Vietnam" National Univ. of Singapore 2009

53 Eastman, R., "Rural and Urban Income Inequality and Poverty: Does Convergence between Sectors Offset Divergence within Them?. in: Inequality, Growth and Poverty in an Era of Liberalization and Globalization" Oxford Univ. Press 2004

54 Lu, M., "Reforming the Welfare System in the People’s Republic of China" 25 : 2008

55 Dickson, B., "Red Capitalists in China: The Party, Private Entrepreneurs, and Prospects for Political Change" Cambridge Univ. Press 2004

56 Zhu, Y., "Recent Developments in China’s Social Security Reforms" 55 (55): 2002

57 Feldstein, M., "Realizing the Potential of China’s Social Security Pension System" 24 : 2006

58 Cook, L. J., "Postcommunist Welfare State: Reform Politics in Russia and Eastern Europe" Cornell Univ. Press 2007

59 Wilensky, H., "Political Legitimacy and Consensus：Missing Variables in the Assessment of Social Policy. in: Evaluating the Welfare State：Social and Political Perspectives" Academic Press 1983

60 Wang, F., "Organizing through Division and Exclusion: China’s Hukou System" Stanford Univ. Press 2005

61 Su, T., "On Shequ Study. in: The Theory and Practice of Shequ Construction" 2001

62 Chan, R., "Notion of the Welfare State in China Revisited" 40 (40): 1997

63 Jones, C., "New Perspectives on the Welfare State in Europe" Routledge 1993

64 Flora, P., "Modernization, Democratization, and the Development of Welfare States in Western Europe. in: The Development of Welfare State in Europe and America" Transaction Books 1981

65 Godement, F., "Models and Policies for Asian Social Policies. A Report of UN Public Administration Network" UNPAN 2000

66 Wong, L., "Marginalization and Social Welfare in China" Routledge 1998

67 Lue, P. J., "Making a Liberal Labor Market: The Political Economy of the Chinese State-Owned Enterprises Welfare Reform. A Paper to be presented at International Sociological Association Research Committee on Poverty" Social Welfare and Social Policy 2007

68 Chan, K. W., "Is China Abolishing the Hukou System?" 195 : 2008

69 Wilensky, H., "Industrial Society and Social Welfare" Free Press 1965

70 Wong, B., "Historical Lessons about Contemporary Social Welfare: Chinese Puzzles and Global Challenges" The Univ. of Manchester, Brooks Word Poverty Institute 2008

71 Midgley, J., "Growth, Redistribution and Welfare: Toward Social Investment" 1999

72 Hussain, A., "Exploring China" Institute for Philanthropy 2009

73 Zheng, B., "Corporatism: Rebuilding the Framework of China’s Welfare Regime" 4 : 2002

74 Aspalter, C., "Conservative Welfare State Systems in East Asia" Praeger 2001

75 Wilensky, H., "Comparative Social Policy：Theories, Methods, Findings" Institute of International Studies. Univ. of California 1985

76 Lee, M., "Chinese Occupational Welfare in Market Transition" St. Martin 2000

77 Ministry of Human Resources and Social Security, People’s Republic of China, "Chinese Government’s Experience and Practices in Extending Social Insurance Coverage. Good Practices in Social Security" ISSA 2009

78 Zhu, H., "China’s Social Security System" Foreign Language Press 1996

79 Guan, X., "China’s Social Policy: Reform and Development in the Context of Marketization and Globalization" 34 (34): 2000

80 Li, J., "China’s New Social Security System in the Making: Problems and Prospects" 31 : 2008

81 Luo, G., "China’s Family Support System: Challenges and Solutions under the Circumstances of Rural-Urban Female Labour Migration" UNRISD 2005

82 Tang, K., "China: Developmentalism and Social Security" 10 : 2001

83 Tang, K. L., "China: Developmentalism and Social Security" 10 (10): 2001

84 Dixon, J., "China. in: Social Welfare in Socialist Countries" Routledge 1992

85 Slee, C., "China Today: Socialist or Capitalist?" 2009

86 Xijin, J., "China Civil Society Report: An Overview of Social Work with the Disabled in China" 2008

87 Breslin, S., "Capitalism with Chinese Characteristics: the Public, the Private and the International" 2004

88 Gu, E. X., "Beyond the Property Rights Approach: Welfare Policy and the Reform of State-Owned Enterprises in China" 32 : 2001

89 Guo, X., "Asset-Based Policy in Rural China: An innovation in the retirement social insurance programme" 1 (1): 2008

90 Bao, W., "Agencies Study Future of Charity, Social welfare system"

91 Doyal, L., "A Theory of Human Needs" Guilford Press 1991