작전운용성능 수정 원인 분석과 진화적 획득 평가항목지표 개발 연구 = Analysis of the Cause of Required Operational Capability(ROC) Correction and A Study on the Development of Evaluation Item Index for an Evolutionary Acquisition

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Weapon systems' required operational capability (ROC) is an important factor that determines the success of a new weapon system for performance and acquisition. Excessive ROC can delay a project or cause failure, while if it is too low, it can lead to technology obsolescence. Therefore, in order to successfully acquire new weapon systems, a single or evolutionary acquisition strategy must be determined based on the ROC. The purpose of this study was to analyze the causes of ROC correction by identifying 160 cases in the last 10 years (2011-2020). Then, 'evaluation item index' to apply to the evolutionary acquisition/ROC of a new weapon system project was developed, and the weight (importance) and priorities were determined through an analytic hierarchical process (AHP). The main correction causes were classified using 6 categories, and the most frequent one was the difficulty of predicting the technology level (41%). There are 8 evaluation item indexes based on the correction causes, such as "technical readiness level (0.428)" and "military force delivery time (0.128)," which have high weights. The "evolutionary acquisition/ROC evaluation item index" presented in this paper is expected to help with rational and scientific decision-making during the review process to apply evolutionary acquisition strategies and contribute to successful weapons-system acquisition projects.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 천종웅 ; 정석재, "무기체계 진화적 작전운용성능(ROC) 적용 가능성 판단을 위한 평가지표 연구" 화랑대연구소 75 (75): 143-172, 2019

2 엄동환, "무기체계 작전운용성능 설정 및 시험평가방법 개선에 대한 연구" 한국시스템엔지니어링학회 15 (15): 9-16, 2019

3 HUFFPOST, "They say they are training together with equipment that can't even identify friends and family"

4 John C. Mankins, "Technology Readiness Levels, White paper" 1995

5 Park, G. H., "Problems and Countermeasures of 'GOP Scientific Guard System Project' which failed for 7years" The 21st Century Korea Research Institute for Military Affairs 50-57, 2012

6 News2day, "North Korea’s Small Unmanned Aerial Vehicle Threat, Claims “Need to Reinforce Capacity from a Systematic Perspective”" News today corporation

7 Kwon, O. J., "Multi-criteria Decision Making Methodology Theory and Application" Bookshill 610-, 2018

8 MunHwa Newspaper, "Enemy Missile Evasion ‘Acceleration Performance’ K-2 ‘9 Sec’ vs Germany Tank ‘6Sec’"

9 Editorial Department, "Defense and Technology" Korea Defense Industry Association 14-15, 2014

10 Military Force Policy Division, "Defense Forces Development Task Official Order" Korean Law Information Center Publishers 9-10, 2022

11 Ministry of National Defense, Republic of Korea, "Defense Budget"