안티고네 신화의 법철학적 이해 = Legal Philosophical Understanding of the Myth of Antigone

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Sophocles’s tragedy Antigone has been one of the most beloved art pieces for a numerous number of philosophers and authors throughout history. In the area of jurisprudence, Antigone used to be understood as a text about the conflict between state law and natural law. However, Antigone contains much more diverse topics for legal philosophy. In this article, Hegel’s idea of ‘law’s dialectical self-development’, Derrida’s thought of ‘the deconstruction of law and its relationship to justice’, and Badiou’s suggestion of ‘law as nonlaw and nonlaw as law’ are discussed in relation to Antigone, and the question of law’s irrational source, which is raised by British legal theorists Douzinas and Warrington, is addressed. Furthermore, this article accepts and critically reinterprets those ideas to suggest ‘individual unconscious’ and the ‘Amor Fati(the love of fate)’ as the source of the force of nonlaw. Additionally, Greek mythology is invited to the arena of legal philosophy. Focus has been especially put on the power of Greek mythology to unfamiliarize current law and morality, and its function as a medium for the communication between the conscious and the unconscious. What we can learn from Hegel's theory of tragedy with regards to contemporary jurisprudence is also discussed in relation to the crime of hubris, which is one of the essential topics of Greek mythology.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 R. Posner, Law, Harvard University Press 124-, 2009

2 G.W.F. Hegel, "헤겔미학 II. 동양예술, 서양예술의 대립과 예술의 종말" 나남신서 249-, 1996

3 Mark W. Roche(번역: 심철민), "헤겔 비극론의 위대성과 한계" 한국헤겔학회 (19) : 19-68, 2006

4 최봉철, "해체적 정의와 법적 판단" 11 : 312-, 1995

5 원준호, "포스트구조주의의 헤겔 정치철학 비판에 대한 반(反)비판－ 헤겔에서의 가족과 국가의 가부장성에 대한 데리다의 비판을 중심으로 －" 한국헤겔학회 (16) : 113-138, 2004

6 임철규, "죽음의 미학-안티고네의 죽음" 2 (2): 97-, 1978

7 G.W.F. Hegel, "정신현상학 2" 한길사 46-, 2005

8 안재오, "인륜성의 비극 ―예나 시절 헤겔의 자연법 논문에 나타난 고대 그리스 비극 개념 연구" (10) : 143-, 2001

9 장영란, "우리 신화학은 어디에 서 있는가?" 2 (2): 92-, 2002

10 T. Eagleton, "우리 시대의 비극론" 경성대학교출판부 263-264, 2006

11 오정진, "영화와 법의 만남" 법학연구소 48 (48): 93-112, 2007

12 J. Butler, "안티고네의 주장" 동문선 98-, 2005

13 박동준, "안티고네(Antigone)의 문학적 신화 창조와 변천" 18 : 198-, 2000

14 최혜영, "안티고네 담론 소포클레스 및 세네카, 장 아누이, 브레히트를 중심으로 본 소재의 변용" 한국서양고전학회 27 (27): 151-186, 2006

15 이상돈, "법정신분석학입문" 법문사 2010

16 이상돈, "법이론" 세창출판사 135-, 2005

17 J. Derrida, "법의 힘" 문학과지성사 58-, 2005

18 이소영, "법문학비평과 소수자의 내러티브 ―박민규, 윤성희, 김애란의 단편소설에 대한 법문학비평―" 한국법철학회 14 (14): 205-232, 2011

19 이소영, "법문학" 新英社 104-106, 2005

20 이상돈, "문헌연구 포스트모더니즘과 법" 세창출판사 179-190, 2006

21 장영란, "그리스 신화" 살림 320-, 2005

22 임철규, "그리스 비극" 한길사 282-, 2007

23 이윤기, "그리스 로마 신화 제2권" 웅진지식하우스 131-132, 2010

24 Sophokles, "“안티고네,” 오이디푸스왕·안티고네" 문예출판사 407-, 2011

25 S. Freud, "“두려운 낯설음,” 예술, 문학, 정신분석" 열린책들 405-411, 2007

26 F. Nietzsche, "“나는 왜 이렇게 영리한지,” 이 사람을 보라" 책세상 373-374, 2005

27 C. Castoriadis, "World in Fragments: Writings on Politics, Society, Psychoanalysis, and the Imagination" Stanford University Press 93-, 1997

28 A. Badiou, "Theory of The Subject" continuum 309-, 2009

29 M. Howenstein, "The Tragedy of Law and the Law of Tragedy in Sophocles’ Antigone" 493 : 493-, 2000

30 J. Lacan, "The Ethics of Psychoanalysis" Norton 279-, 1992

31 G. Steiner, Antigones, "The Antigone Myth in Western Literature, Art and Thought" Oxford 1986

32 D. Manderson, "Requiem: Green Death-Aesthetic Interpretations and Influences in the Death Penalty, In Songs without music" University of California Press 95-, 2000

33 E. Gemmette, "Law and Literature: Joining the Class Action" 665 : 686-, 1995

34 W. Conklin, "Hegel, the Author and Authority in Sophocles’ Antigone, In Law in Greek Political Thought" Rowman & Littlefield 139-140, 1997

35 B. Bosteels, "Force of Nonlaw: Alain Badiou’s Theory of Justice" 1907-, 2008

36 R. Sterne, "Endorsing Ethical Natural Law: A Reply to David A. Reidy’s “Antigone, Hegel & The Law" 263 : 263-, 1995

37 C. Douzinas, "Antigone’s law: A genealogy of jurisprudence, In Politics, Postmodernity and Critical Legal Studies" Routeledge 189-, 1994

38 D. Reidy, "Antigone, Hegel & The Law: An Essay" 239 : 239-, 1995