요한복음 21:1-11의 내러티브 읽기 - 베드로의 인물성격과 역할을 중심으로 -

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article is a critical narrative analysis of John 21:1-11 by focusing on the characterization and role of Peter. The article assumes that John 21 is a natural narrative continuation of the previous chapters (1-20) and it tries to explore a narrative analysis of the fishing expedition and the miraculous catch of 153 fishes. The article is divided into four main scenes (vv. 1-3; vv. 4-6; vv. 7-8; and vv. 9-11) and investigates the critical narrative meaning of the engagement and interaction of main characters, Peter, the beloved disciple, and the risen Jesus. The emphasis is put on the characterization of Peter who engages in four different scenes in John 21:1-11.
Peter lead the other six disciples on a fishing expedition(vv. 2-4), but they did not catch any fish that night. When the risen Jesus commanded them to cast the net on the right side of the boat, they caught a large number of fish. The beloved disciple recognized the miraculous catch of fish as a discerning sign pointing to Jesus on the beach, and delivers the confessional cry (“It is the Lord”) to Peter alone(21:7). Peter quickly wraps himself with his undergarment and jumps into the sea. The characterization of Peter (a bold leap-passion and action) and that of the beloved disciple (a confessional cry-perceptual faith) are not contrasting but cooperative toward the recognition and approach to the risen Jesus. Thus both disciples represent the ideal discipleship in Johannine community.
The article emphasizes the role of Peter as a skillful missionary equipped with great power and care. Peter is the only disciple who obeys Jesus’ command (“bring some of the fish”) and draw the net, full of large fishes, 153, ashore without any damage on the net or losing any of the fishes by demonstrating his powerful missionary skill. The specific number ‘153’ also prophetically anticipates Peter’s missionary capability and accomplishment in a symbolic and historical representation for “catching men.” Peter’s powerful action in 21:11 implies his special role as a responsible leader for the Johannine community to bring people to Christ. For the mission and leadership of the community that exceeds the concerns and interests in John 1-20, the risen Jesus appears again to challenge his disciples (Peter) to draw the people and take care of them for the kingdom of God.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김선정, "한국신약학 50년의 회고와 전망: 요한문헌 연구" 한국신약학회 19 (19): 825-857, 2012

2 김문현, "요한복음의 인물연구 역사와 방법론 고찰" 한국신약학회 15 (15): 769-804, 2008

3 김동수, "요한복음의 베드로와 애제자: 적인가? 동지인가?" 6 : 152-173, 2003

4 서종석, "요한복음서의 베드로와 애제자" 19 : 25-44, 1991

5 김문현, "요한복음 20:1~29의 부활내러티브 읽기 : 애제자를 중심으로" 한국신약학회 16 (16): 1089-1120, 2009

6 김문현, "요한복음 18:1-27에 나타난 ego eimi와 ouk eimi ㅡ 베드로의 인물성격을 중심으로 ㅡ" 한국복음주의신약학회 13 (13): 75-101, 2014

7 김문현, "요한복음 1-20장과 21장의 내러티브 상관관계에 관한 소고" 한국기독교학회 (85) : 65-89, 2013

8 권종선, "신약성서 비평방법의 동향과 전망" 10 (10): 519-553, 2003

9 김문현, "가슴으로 읽는 요한복음" 도서출판 영성네트워크 2005

10 김문현, "가슴으로 읽는 사도행전" 도서출판영성네트워크 381-383, 2008

11 H. M. Crosby, "“Do You Love Me?” Jesus Questions the Church" Orbis 168-, 2000

12 Sandra Schneiders, "Written That You May Believe: Encountering Jesus in the Fourth Gospel" Crossroad Publishing Company 177-, 2003

13 Johannes Beutler, S. J., "Word, Theology, and Community in John" Chalice Press 26-27, 2002

14 D. H. Gee, "Why did Peter Spring into the Sea? [John 21:7]" 40 : 481-489, 1989

15 Gail R. O'Day, "The Word Disclosed: Preaching the Gospel of John" Chalice Press 101-, 2002

16 M. Nun, "The Sea of Galilee and its Fishermen in the New Testament" Kibbutz Ein Gev 1989

17 A. H. Maynard, "The Role of Peter in the Fourth Gospel" 30 : 531-548, 1984

18 B. Milne, "The Message of John" InterVarsity 310-, 1993

19 F. F. Bruce, "The Gospel of John: Introduction, Exposition and Notes" Pickering and Inglis 399-, 1993

20 C. S. Keener, "The Gospel of John: A Commentary, vol. 2" Hendrickson 1229-, 2003

21 R. Bultmann, "The Gospel of John: A Commentary" Basil Blackwell 1971

22 Francis J. Moloney, "The Gospel of John (Sacra Pagina)" The Liturgical Press 1998

23 B. Lindars, "The Gospel of John" Eerdmans 627-, 1972

24 J. H. Bernard, "The Gospel According to St. John, vol. 2 (ICC)" T&T Clark 696-, 1928

25 C. K. Barrett, "The Gospel According to St. John" SPCK 1978

26 H. N. Ridderbos, "The Gospel According to John: A Theological Commentary" Eerdmans 600-, 1997

27 R. E. Brown, "The Gospel According to John, vol. 2" Doubleday 1970

28 D. A. Carson, "The Gospel According to John" Eerdmans 1991

29 Thomas L. Brodie, "The Gospel According to John" Oxford University Press 1993

30 A. Guilding, "The Fourth Gospel and Jewish Worship: A Study of St. John's Gospel to the Ancient Jewish Lectionary System" Claredon 226-, 1960

31 H. E. Edwards, "The Disciple Who Wrote These Things: A New Inquiry into the Origins and Historical Value of the Gospel according to St. John" J. Clarke 180-, 1953

32 Craig Koester, "Symbolism in the Fourth Gospel: Meaning, Mystery, Community" Fortress Press 1995

33 Bradford B. Blaine Jr., "Peter in the Gospel of John: The Making of an Authentic Disciple" SBL 2007

34 James L. Resseguie, "Narrative Criticism of the New Testament: An Introduction" Baker Academic 2005

35 B. Witherington, "John's Wisdom: A Commentary on the Fourth Gospel" Westminster John Knox 355-, 1995

36 Haenchen, "John 2: A Commentary on the Gospel of John Chapters 1-6" Fortress 223-, 1984

37 Gerald L. Borchert, "John 12-21" Broadman & Holman Publishers 2002

38 J. R. Michaels, "John (New International Bible Commentary on the New Testament)" Paternoster 351-, 1991

39 G. M. Burge, "John (NIV Application Commentary)" Zondervan 2006

40 R. Kysar, "John (ACNT)" Augsburg 313-314, 1986

41 Mark W. G. Stibbe, "John" Sheffield Academic Press 1993

42 George R. Beasley-Murray, "John" Word 399-, 1978

43 R. M. Chennattu, "Johannine Discipleship as a Covenant Relationship" Hendrickson 2006

44 B. Bauckham, "Jesus in Johannine Tradition" Westminster John Knox 111-, 2001

45 "Jerome's Commentary on Ezekiel in Migne, PL, 25.474c"

46 M. D. Hooker, "Endings: Invitations to Discipleship" Hendrickson 2003

47 S. Van Tilborg, "Das Johannes-Evangelium: Ein Kommentar für die Praxis" Verlag Katholisches Bibelwerk 310-, 2005

48 Wes Howard-Brook, "Becoming Children of God; John Gospel and Radical Discipleship" Orbis Books 2001

49 "Augustine's Comments on John in section 122.8 in Migne, PL, 35.1963-64"

50 R. Alan Culpepper, "Anatomy of the Fourth Gospel: A Study in Literary Design" Fortress 1983

51 J. N. Sanders, "A Commentary on the Gospel According to St. John (HNTC)" Harpers & Brothes 447-448, 1957