This study will go through the procedure of criminal investigation of the Korean police which probably has the biggest odds to infringe on human rights among many of police actions to perform its duty: protection of people's life and property, prevent...
This study will go through the procedure of criminal investigation of the Korean police which probably has the biggest odds to infringe on human rights among many of police actions to perform its duty: protection of people's life and property, prevention and investigation of crimes, collection of criminal information, maintenance of traffic, and sustenance of country's well-being and order. For this, we will see the factors of hindering protection of human rights with actual cases, and based on these findings, analyze the cause of failure at the structural level, and this is the very goal of this study to provide solutions for these problems to attain people's trust on police investigation.
Suggested problems of criminal investigation of the police in this study are as follows:
First, protection of human rights in a secret investigation deals with problems like: not enough rule of law before the official launch of a criminal investigation, legal disposition during a secret investigation and its own system to regulate itself, and denial of the generally permitted ways to protect defendant's rights under little influence of the law of criminal procedure.
Second, protection of victims deals with problems like: little consideration for victims even with those efforts of the police to change its focus away from the old day's adherence to performance records, 2nd impact on victims in the course of an actual investigation, lack of professionals to care for victimized women, too short period for victims of sexual offence to overcome psychological wound and prepare for a case, lack of information on criminal procedure for victims, and appliance of a mutual agreement to the criminal system.
Third, protection of a witness who has the most important role in finding out the truth but no obligation deals with procurement of his or her cooperation to secure testimony.
Fourth, malpractice of the press to assume guilt on the defendant in its reports deals with the problem of lack of a concrete and fair standard in its selection of possible reports and inexperienced public relations of the police.
Fifth, possible problems of police detention argues legal basis for a thorough physical examination of the detainee and its selection as well as the very existence and poor condition of this house for detention, its management by the investigation department, and setup of a substitute cell.
To solve above-mentioned problems, this study suggests as follows:
First, concerning the subject of a secret investigation, it is advisable to legalize its process as part of the criminal procedure in a broader sense or status of the subject as same as that of a defendant in the context of a pro-active interpretation of the Supreme Court's decision.
Second, we should protect victim's rights with sincere care to prevent another victimization from investigation, build a network to support and help victims with civil sectors, abolish absurd time limit to raise a suit, provide various information regarding criminal procedure for victims, introduce the system of assigning a counsel to a victim and encouraging a mutual agreement to avoid a criminal suit, strengthen publicity about police efforts to protect victims, and enlarge scope of application for re-evaluation of a case.
Third, we need to further protect a witness' identity and security by introducing various means like a home-visit.
Fourth, to prevent any infringement of human rights by the press, we need to make a delicate balance between people's right to know and human rights of the report's subject by a concrete standard while the police makes its public relations more professional.
Fifth, to further protect detainees, police should make clear the criteria for a thorough physical examination, change the management to the office of inspection or police administration bureau, keep up the drive to move out a substitute cell and make National Human Rights Commission of Korea responsible for inspecting police detention instead of prosecutors, improve general condition of the detention house, and make more professional detention guards.
National Police of South Korea has strived to amend parts of the criminal law regulating working relations between the police and prosecutors for last tens of years, and in the due course, endured many hardships endowed by the prosecutors. We need to see this struggle's core not as some power game between two agencies but as Korean police's sincere effort to attain people's trust on its criminal investigation, and for this, what people really want to see is realization of protection of human rights in any criminal investigation by the police. It is now an obligation for Korean police to protect human rights, not a choice any more.