개방형 혁신에 의한 R&D 연구의 효율성 평가 분석 : 과학기술적 성과 관점에서 AHP-DEA방법론 적용 = Open Innovation R&D Efficiency Evaluation by Integrated AHP‐DEA

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The current environment of technological and competitive changes influences not only the business R&D environment but also government driven national R&D strategies. Open innovation has now become an important paradigm that is replacing the outdated paradigm of closed innovation. Many companies and nations have been increasing R&D investment because R&D has been considered a driving force for national and corporate competitive advantage. The purpose of this paper is to evaluate and compare the performance of R&D focused on open innovation according to scientific and technological outputs which is based on paper publications, patents and etc. Comparisons should not be only based on the quantity but also on the quality of the output. This paper shows that it is possible to develop DEA models that utilize the Analytical Hierarchical Process in order to transform the qualitative index into a quantitative index. Hence, the relative efficiency for R&D organizations is obtained based on both quantity and quality outputs and subsequently provides comprehensive and realistic methods for decision makers to identify levels of project efficiency.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 윤진효, "특허기반 개방형 혁신 분석 모델 개발 및 적용 연구" 한국기술혁신학회 13 (13): 99-123, 2010

2 박성민, "복합성과평가지수를 활용한 정부지원 R&D 과제의 성과평가에 관한 연구*: 응용기술개발지원 융자사업을 중심으로" 대한경영학회 25 (25): 1259-1281, 2012

3 박석종, "과학기술적 성과 관점에서 정부 R&D사업 효율성 분석에 관한 연구" 한국기술혁신학회 14 (14): 205-222, 2011

4 Meng, W., "Two-level DEA approaches in research evaluation" 36 : 950-957, 2008

5 Berchicci, L., "Towards an open R&D system : Internal R&D investment, external knowledge acquisition and innovative performance" 42 : 117-127, 2012

6 Lee, J.J., "The Role of Government and The Strategy of Post Catch-up Science and Technology" 223-239, 2010

7 손소영, "Structural equation model for the evaluation of national funding on R&D project of SMEs in consideration with MBNQA criteria" 30 : 10-20, 2007

8 Choi, T.G., "Strategic Design of the Government R&D Management System based on the Analysis of Relationship between R&D Program Types and their Outputs" Konkuk University

9 Banker, R.D., "Some models for estimating technical and scale inefficiencies in data envelopment analysis" 30 : 1078-1092, 1984

10 Wang, E.C., "Relative efficiency of R&D activities : A cross-country study accounting for environmental factors in the DEA approach" 36 : 260-273, 2007

11 박성민, "R&D 프로젝트의 성과평가를 위한 DEA효율성지수와 정규화지표의 합치도 분석" 대한경영학회 24 (24): 1999-2014, 2011

12 박성민, "R&D 프로젝트 효율성 상관분석 및 사업포지셔닝 조사를 위한 2단계 DEA/AR-I 성과평가모형" 대한경영학회 23 (23): 3285-3303, 2010

13 Chesbrough, H.W., "Open Innovation : the new imperative for creating and profiting from technology" Harvard Business school press 2006

14 Management Manual of R&D Performance in Ministry of Education, Science and Technology, "Ministry of Education" Science and Technology, National Research Foundation of Korea 50-51, 2009

15 Charnes, A., "Measuring the efficiency of decision making units" 3 : 429-444, 1978

16 Hsu, P.M., "Measuring realtive efficiency of government-sponsored R&D projects : A three- stage approach" 32 : 178-186, 2009

17 Kim, M.S., "Internet shopping mall evaluation by AHP/DEA" Korea University 2001

18 Ho, W., "Integrated analytic hierarchy process and its applications-A literature review" 186 : 211-228, 2008

19 Lee, K.W., "Implication and Analysis of Application system and management of Pubic R&D Performance" 2 : 3-7, 2012

20 Saaty, T.L., "How to Make a Decision : The Analytic Hierarchy Process" 48 : 9-26, 1990

21 Jyoti, Banwet D.K., "Evaluating performance of national R&D organizations using integrated DEA-AHP technique" 57 : 370-386, 2008

22 Cho, Y.G., "Development of an evaluation model in public R&D programmes-conceptual approach" korean Operations Research and Management Science Society 1045-1051, 2005

23 Bae, J.T., "Development of a performance index in private company R&D activity" 12 : 45-69, 1998

24 이덕주, "DEA/AHP 모형을 이용한 R&D 프로젝트 선정모형 및 Web 기반 R&D 프로젝트 선정시스템 개발" 대한산업공학회 32 (32): 18-28, 2006

25 Liu, J.S., "DEA and ranking with the network-based approach : a case of R&D performance" 38 : 453-464, 2010

26 Kim, M.S., "Countstratgy Post catch-up in Mobile Phone industry" 22 : 1-16, 2010

27 Lin, M.I., "Applying integrated DEA/AHP to evaluate the economic performance of local governments in China" 209 : 129-140, 2011

28 Cho, K.T., "Analytic Hierarchy Decision Making of Proceeding Leaders" Donghyun 9-12, 2003

29 Kim, S.H., "Analysis and Application of Decision making. 8th ed" Youngchimunwhasa 379-401, 2009

30 Wang, Y.M., "An integrated AHP-DEA methodology for bridge risk assessment" 54 : 513-525, 2009

31 Kim, B.W., "An effective R&D performance measurement system : survey of Korean R&D researchers" 30 : 19-31, 2002

32 장현덕, "AHP와 DEA 활용을 통한 효율적인 유망 기술 선정" 한국기업경영학회 18 (18): 67-85, 2011

33 Yang, W.M., "A study on the selection methodology of R&D projects using DEA/AHP with ordinal factors" Kyung Hee University 2003

34 Choi, J.W., "A study on the improvement of management outcomes in the start-up companies using AHP and DEA-Focusing on the tenant companies of business incubator center" Ky

35 Yang, T., "A hierarchical AHP/DEA methodology for the facilities layout design problem" 147 : 128-136, 2003

36 Shang, J., "A Unified Framework for the Selection of a Flexible Manufacturing System" 85 : 297-315, 1995

37 Kim, H.B., "A Performance Indicator Roadmap Framework for evaluating Government R&D Programs" 1-9, 2009

38 Kim, Y.G., "A Direction of Industrial Technology Policy for Open Innovation" KIAT 2011

39 Rhim, H.S., "A DEA/AHP hybrid model for evaluation and selection of R&D projects" 24 : 1-12, 1999

40 Bitman, W.R., "A Conceptual Framework for Ranking R&D Projects" 55 : 267-278, 2008

41 Yim, H., "2010 Technology Level Evaluation Report -95 Focued Science Technology-" KISTEP 2011