Evaluating the bond strength of FRP in concrete samples using machine learning methods

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

In recent years, the use of Fiber Reinforced Polymers (FRPs) as one of the most common ways to increase the strength of concrete samples, has been introduced. Evaluation of the final strength of these specimens is performed with different experimental methods. In this research, due to the variety of models, the low accuracy and impact of different parameters, the use of new intelligence methods is considered. Therefore, using artificial intelligent-based models, a new solution for evaluating the bond strength of FRP is presented in this paper. 150 experimental samples were collected from previous studies, and then two new hybrid models of Imperialist Competitive Algorithm (ICA)-Artificial Neural Network (ANN) and Artificial Bee Colony (ABC)-ANN were developed. These models were evaluated using different performance indices and then, a comparison was made between the developed models. The results showed that the ICA-ANN model's ability to predict the bond strength of FRP is higher than the ABC-ANN model. Finally, to demonstrate the capabilities of this new model, a comparison was made between the five experimental models and the results were presented for all data. This comparison showed that the new model could offer better performance. It is concluded that the proposed hybrid models can be utilized in the field of this study as a suitable substitute for empirical models.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Jian Zhou, "Use of Intelligent Methods to Design Effective Pattern Parameters of Mine Blasting to Minimize Flyrock Distance" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 29 (29): 625-639, 2020

2 Miloš Milovančević, "UML diagrams for dynamical monitoring of rail vehicles" Elsevier BV 531 : 121169-, 2019

3 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "Three hybrid intelligent models in estimating flyrock distance resulting from blasting" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 35 (35): 243-256, 2019

4 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "The use of new intelligent techniques in designing retaining walls" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 36 (36): 283-294, 2020

5 Mahdi Shariati, "The effect of RBS connection on energy absorption in tall buildings with braced tube frame system" 국제구조공학회 34 (34): 393-407, 2020

6 M. Ismail, "Strengthening of bolted shear joints in industrialized ferrocement construction" 국제구조공학회 28 (28): 681-690, 2018

7 S. N. R. Shah, "Steel Rack Connections: Identification of Most Influential Factors and a Comparison of Stiffness Design Methods" Public Library of Science (PLoS) 10 (10): e0139422-, 2015

8 A. Cladera, "Shear design procedure for reinforced normal and high-strength concrete beams using artificial neural networks. Part I: beams without stirrups" Elsevier BV 26 (26): 917-926, 2004

9 Masoud Paknahad, "Shear capacity equation for channel shear connectors in steel-concrete composite beams" 국제구조공학회 28 (28): 483-494, 2018

10 Farzad Tahmasbi, "Shear Capacity of C-Shaped and L-Shaped Angle Shear Connectors" Public Library of Science (PLoS) 11 (11): e0156989-, 2016

11 Abdolrahim Jalali, "Seismic performance of structures with pre-bent strips as a damper" Academic Journals 7 (7): 4061-4072, 2012

12 Dongchun Tang, "Seepage Analysis in Short Embankments Using Developing a Metaheuristic Method Based on Governing Equations" MDPI AG 10 (10): 1761-, 2020

13 Zhao, H., "Research on the bond performance between CFRP plate and concrete" 2000

14 Nguyen Thoi Trung, "Reduction of cement consumption by producing smart green concretes with natural zeolites" 국제구조공학회 24 (24): 415-425, 2019

15 Ali Toghroli, "RETRACTED ARTICLE: Potential of soft computing approach for evaluating the factors affecting the capacity of steel–concrete composite beam" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 29 (29): 1793-1801, 2018

16 I. Mansouri, "RETRACTED ARTICLE: Analysis of influential factors for predicting the shear strength of a V-shaped angle shear connector in composite beams using an adaptive neuro-fuzzy technique" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 30 (30): 1247-1257, 2019

17 K. Zorlu, "Prediction of uniaxial compressive strength of sandstones using petrography-based models" Elsevier BV 96 (96): 141-158, 2008

18 Ali Toghroli, "Prediction of shear capacity of channel shear connectors using the ANFIS model" 국제구조공학회 17 (17): 623-639, 2014

19 Mahdi Shariati, "Prediction of concrete strength in presence of furnace slag and fly ash using Hybrid ANN-GA (Artificial Neural Network-Genetic Algorithm)" 국제구조공학회 25 (25): 183-195, 2020

20 Houssam Toutanji, "Prediction of Interfacial Bond Failure of FRP–Concrete Surface" American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) 11 (11): 427-436, 2007

21 A. Mukherjee, "Prediction of Buckling Load of Columns Using Artificial Neural Networks" American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) 122 (122): 1385-1387, 1996

22 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "Predicting tunnel boring machine performance through a new model based on the group method of data handling" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 78 (78): 3799-3813, 2019

23 Amir Mahdiyar, "Practical Risk Assessment of Ground Vibrations Resulting from Blasting, Using Gene Expression Programming and Monte Carlo Simulation Techniques" MDPI AG 10 (10): 472-, 2020

24 A. Nosrati, "Portland cement structure and its major oxides and fineness" 국제구조공학회 22 (22): 425-432, 2018

25 S.K. Sharma, "Plate–concrete interfacial bond strength of FRP and metallic plated concrete specimens" Elsevier BV 37 (37): 54-63, 2006

26 S.E.M. Shahabi, "Performance of shear connectors at elevated temperatures − A review" 국제구조공학회 20 (20): 185-203, 2016

27 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "Overbreak prediction and optimization in tunnel using neural network and bee colony techniques" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 35 (35): 1191-1202, 2019

28 Yefei Wu, "On shear bond strength of FRP-concrete structures" Elsevier BV 32 (32): 897-905, 2010

29 Mahdi Shariati, "Numerical study on the structural performance of corrugated low yield point steel plate shear walls with circular openings" 국제구조공학회 33 (33): 569-581, 2019

30 Mahdi Shariati, "Numerical study on the axial compressive behavior of built-up CFT columns considering different welding lines" 국제구조공학회 34 (34): 377-391, 2020

31 Hamid Sinaei, "Numerical investigation on exterior reinforced concrete Beam-Column joint strengthened by composite fiber reinforced polymer (CFRP)" Academic Journals 6 (6): 6572-6579, 2011

32 Koosha Khorramian, "Numerical analysis of tilted angle shear connectors in steel-concrete composite systems" 국제구조공학회 23 (23): 67-85, 2017

33 S.E.M. Shahabi, "Numerical analysis of channel connectors under fire and a comparison of performance with different types of shear connectors subjected to fire" 국제구조공학회 20 (20): 651-669, 2016

34 Nehdi, M., "Neural network model for preformed-foam cellular concrete" 98 (98): 402-409, 2001

35 M.Y Rafiq, "Neural network design for engineering applications" Elsevier BV 79 (79): 1541-1552, 2001

36 Maryam Safa, "Moment rotation prediction of precast beam to column connections using extreme learning machine" 국제구조공학회 70 (70): 639-647, 2019

37 Jamal A. Abdalla, "Modeling and simulation of shear resistance of R/C beams using artificial neural network" Elsevier BV 344 (344): 741-756, 2007

38 Toghroli, A., "Investigation on composite polymer and silica fume–rubber aggregate pervious concrete" 2017

39 Arabnejad Khanouki, M. M., "Investigation of seismic behaviour of composite structures with concrete filled square steel tubular(CFSST)column by push-over and time-history analyses" 2010

40 Saeed Nasrollahi, "Investigation of pipe shear connectors using push out test" 국제구조공학회 27 (27): 537-543, 2018

41 Ali Shariati, "Investigation of channel shear connectors for composite concrete and steel T-beam" Academic Journals 7 (7): 1828-1831, 2012

42 Jian Zhou, "Investigating the effective parameters on the risk levels of rockburst phenomena by developing a hybrid heuristic algorithm" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 1-16, 2020

43 Lei Huang, "Invasive Weed Optimization Technique-Based ANN to the Prediction of Rock Tensile Strength" MDPI AG 9 (9): 5372-, 2019

44 Haiqing Yang, "Intelligent design of retaining wall structures under dynamic conditions" 국제구조공학회 31 (31): 629-640, 2019

45 Holzenkämpfer, P., "Ingenieurmodelle des Verbunds geklebter Bewehrung für Betonbauteile" Technische University of Braunschweig 1994

46 Chuanhua Xu, "Improving Performance of Retaining Walls Under Dynamic Conditions Developing an Optimized ANN Based on Ant Colony Optimization Technique" Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) 7 : 94692-94700, 2019

47 Atashpaz-Gargari, E., "Imperialist competitive algorithm : An algorithm for optimization inspired by imperialistic competition" 2007

48 Mahdi Shariati, "Identification of the most influencing parameters on the properties of corroded concrete beams using an Adaptive Neuro-Fuzzy Inference System (ANFIS)" 국제구조공학회 34 (34): 155-170, 2020

49 M. Q. Feng, "Identification of a Dynamic System Using Ambient Vibration Measurements" ASME International 65 (65): 1010-1021, 1998

50 Armaghani, D. J., "Hybrid ANN-based techniques in predicting cohesion of sandy-soil combined with fiber" 20 (20): 191-205, 2020

51 Soudki, K., "Guide for the design and construction of externally bonded FRP systems for strengthening existing structures" 2004

52 Jeon, J., "Fuzzy and neural network models for analyses of piles" North Carolina State University 2007

53 Danial Jahed Armaghani, "Feasibility of ICA in approximating ground vibration resulting from mine blasting" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 29 (29): 457-465, 2018

54 Shariati, M., "Fatigue energy dissipation and failure analysis of channel shear connector embedded in the lightweight aggregate concrete in composite bridge girders" 2012

55 Teng, J., "FRP:Strengthened RC Structures" SCU 2002

56 Du Béton, F. I., "Externally bonded FRP reinforcement for RC structures" 14 : 138-, 2001

57 Yang, Y., "Experimental study on bond performance between carbon fiber sheets and concrete" 3 : 36-41, 2001

58 Morteza Naghipour, "Experimental study on axial compressive behavior of welded built-up CFT stub columns made by cold-formed sections with different welding lines" 국제구조공학회 34 (34): 347-359, 2020

59 J. Yao, "Experimental study on FRP-to-concrete bonded joints" Elsevier BV 36 (36): 99-113, 2005

60 Mahdi Shariati, "Experimental investigations on monotonic and cyclic behavior of steel pallet rack connections" Elsevier BV 85 : 149-166, 2018

61 Shariati, M., "Experimental investigation on the effect of cementitious materials on fresh and mechanical properties of self-consolidating concrete" 8 (8): 225-237, 2019

62 Shariati, M., "Experimental and numerical investigations of channel shear connectors in high strength concrete" 2011

63 우상균, "Experimental Study on Interfacial Behavior of CFRP-Bonded Concrete" 대한토목학회 14 (14): 385-393, 2010

64 Majid Khorami, "Evaluation of the seismic performance of special moment frames using incremental nonlinear dynamic analysis" 국제구조공학회 63 (63): 259-268, 2017

65 Ali Toghroli, "Evaluating the use of recycled concrete aggregate and pozzolanic additives in fiber-reinforced pervious concrete with industrial and recycled fibers" Elsevier BV 252 : 118997-, 2020

66 Mingxiang Cai, "Evaluating Slope Deformation of Earth Dams Due to Earthquake Shaking Using MARS and GMDH Techniques" MDPI AG 10 (10): 1486-, 2020

67 Mahdi Shariati, "Estimation of moment and rotation of steel rack connections using extreme learning machine" 국제구조공학회 31 (31): 427-435, 2019

68 Behrouz Gordan, "Estimating and optimizing safety factors of retaining wall through neural network and bee colony techniques" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 35 (35): 945-954, 2019

69 Xiufeng Liao, "Effects of a proper feature selection on prediction and optimization of drilling rate using intelligent techniques" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 36 (36): 499-510, 2020

70 Ali Ziaei-Nia, "Dynamic mix design optimization of high-performance concrete" 국제구조공학회 29 (29): 67-75, 2018

71 D. O. Hebb, "Drives and the C. N. S. (conceptual nervous system)." American Psychological Association (APA) 62 (62): 243-254, 1955

72 Xing Wei, "Distribution of shear force in perforated shear connectors" 국제구조공학회 27 (27): 389-399, 2018

73 Emad Hosseinpour, "Direct shear behavior of concrete filled hollow steel tube shear connector for slim-floor steel beams" 국제구조공학회 26 (26): 485-499, 2018

74 Jianguo Dai, "Development of the Nonlinear Bond Stress–Slip Model of Fiber Reinforced Plastics Sheet–Concrete Interfaces with a Simple Method" American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) 9 (9): 52-62, 2005

75 Maryam Safa, "Development of neuro-fuzzy and neuro-bee predictive models for prediction of the safety factor of eco-protection slopes" Elsevier BV 550 : 124046-, 2020

76 Jian Zhou, "Development of a new methodology for estimating the amount of PPV in surface mines based on prediction and probabilistic models (GEP-MC)" Informa UK Limited 35 (35): 48-68, 2020

77 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "Development of a new hybrid ANN for solving a geotechnical problem related to tunnel boring machine performance" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 36 (36): 345-357, 2020

78 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "Developing a new intelligent technique to predict overbreak in tunnels using an artificial bee colony-based ANN" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 78 (78): 165-, 2019

79 Javad Katebi, "Developed comparative analysis of metaheuristic optimization algorithms for optimal active control of structures" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 36 (36): 1539-1558, 2020

80 Ye, L., "Design proposals for the debonding strengths of FRP strengthened RC beams in the Chinese design code" 2005

81 Oehlers, D., "Design of FRP and Steel Plated RC Structures: Retrofitting Beams and Slabs for Strength, Stiffness and Ductility" Elsevier 2004

82 Neubauer, U., "Design aspects of concrete structures strengthened with externally bonded CFRP-plates" 1997

83 Hongquan Guo, "Deep neural network and whale optimization algorithm to assess flyrock induced by blasting" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 37 (37): 173-186, 2019

84 Alireza Afshar, "Corrosion resistance evaluation of rebars with various primers and coatings in concrete modified with different additives" Elsevier BV 262 : 120034-, 2020

85 Yousef Zandi, "Computational investigation of the comparative analysis of cylindrical barns subjected to earthquake" 국제구조공학회 28 (28): 439-447, 2018

86 Zhenyan Luo, "Computational and experimental analysis of beam to column joints reinforced with CFRP plates" 국제구조공학회 30 (30): 271-280, 2019

87 Mehran Shariat, "Computational Lagrangian Multiplier Method by using for optimization and sensitivity analysis of rectangular reinforced concrete beams" 국제구조공학회 29 (29): 243-256, 2018

88 X.Z. Lu, "Bond–slip models for FRP sheets/plates bonded to concrete" Elsevier BV 27 (27): 920-937, 2005

89 Takeo, K., "Bond characteristics of CFRP sheets in the CFRP bonding technique" 19 (19): 1599-1604, 1997

90 Chajes, M. J., "Bond and force transfer of composite-material plates bonded to concrete" 93 (93): 209-217, 1996

91 Shariati, M., "Behaviour of C-shaped shear connectors in stell concrete composite beams" Universiti Malaya 2013

92 Fathollah Sajedi, "Behavior study of NC and HSC RCCs confined by GRP casing and CFRP wrapping" 국제구조공학회 30 (30): 417-432, 2019

93 Arabnejad Khanouki, M. M., "Behavior of through beam connections composed of CFSST columns and steel beams by finite element studying" 168 : 2329-2333, 2011

94 Seyed Mehdi Davoodnabi, "Behavior of steel-concrete composite beam using angle shear connectors at fire condition" 국제구조공학회 30 (30): 141-147, 2019

95 Chulin Chen, "Behavior of steel storage pallet racking connection - A review" 국제구조공학회 30 (30): 457-469, 2019

96 S.N.R. Shah, "Behavior of steel pallet rack beam-to-column connections at elevated temperatures" Elsevier BV 106 : 471-483, 2016

97 Koosha Khorramian, "Behavior of Tilted Angle Shear Connectors" Public Library of Science (PLoS) 10 (10): e0144288-, 2015

98 Shariati, M., "Assessment of stiffened angle shear connector under monotonic and fully reversed cyclic loading" 2017

99 Shariati, M., "Assessment building using none-destructive test techniques (ultra sonic pulse velocity and schmidt rebound hammer)" Universiti Putra Malaysia 2008

100 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "Applying various hybrid intelligent systems to evaluate and predict slope stability under static and dynamic conditions" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 23 (23): 5913-5929, 2019

101 Lei Sun, "Applying a meta-heuristic algorithm to predict and optimize compressive strength of concrete samples" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 37 (37): 1133-1145, 2019

102 Mahdi Shariati, "Application of waste tire rubber aggregate in porous concrete" 국제구조공학회 24 (24): 553-566, 2019

103 Danial Jahed Armaghani, "Application of several optimization techniques for estimating TBM advance rate in granitic rocks" Elsevier BV 11 (11): 779-789, 2019

104 Diyuan Li, "Application of polymer, silica-fume and crushed rubber in the production of Pervious concrete" 국제구조공학회 23 (23): 207-214, 2019

105 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "Application of deep neural networks in predicting the penetration rate of tunnel boring machines" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 78 (78): 6347-6360, 2019

106 Mahdi Shariati, "Application of a Hybrid Artificial Neural Network-Particle Swarm Optimization (ANN-PSO) Model in Behavior Prediction of Channel Shear Connectors Embedded in Normal and High-Strength Concrete" MDPI AG 9 (9): 5534-, 2019

107 Mahdi Shariati, "Application of Extreme Learning Machine (ELM) and Genetic Programming (GP) to design steel-concrete composite floor systems at elevated temperatures" 국제구조공학회 33 (33): 319-332, 2019

108 Brosens, K., "Anchoring stress between concrete and carbon fiber reinforced laminates" 1997

109 J. F. Chen, "Anchorage Strength Models for FRP and Steel Plates Bonded to Concrete" American Society of Civil Engineers (ASCE) 127 (127): 784-791, 2001

110 Z. S. Wu, "Analytical/Experimental Study on Composite Behavior in Strengthening Structures with Bonded Carbon Fiber Sheets" SAGE Publications 18 (18): 1131-1155, 1999

111 Karaboga, D., "An idea based on honey bee swarm for numerical optimization" Erciyes University 2005

112 Mohammad Mohammadhassani, "An experimental study on the failure modes of high strength concrete beams with particular references to variation of the tensile reinforcement ratio" Elsevier BV 41 : 73-80, 2014

113 Qiang Xie, "An experimental study on the effect of CFRP on behavior of reinforce concrete beam column connections" 국제구조공학회 30 (30): 433-441, 2019

114 Mohammad Mohammadhassani, "An evolutionary fuzzy modelling approach and comparison of different methods for shear strength prediction of high-strength concrete beams without stirrups" 국제구조공학회 14 (14): 785-809, 2014

115 Ali Toghroli, "A review on pavement porous concrete using recycled waste materials" 국제구조공학회 22 (22): 433-440, 2018

116 Mahdi Shariati, "A novel hybrid extreme learning machine–grey wolf optimizer (ELM-GWO) model to predict compressive strength of concrete with partial replacements for cement" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 1-23, 2020

117 Mahdi Shariati, "A novel approach to predict shear strength of tilted angle connectors using artificial intelligence techniques" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 1-21, 2020

118 Yanru Zhao, "A new methodology for optimization and prediction of rate of penetration during drilling operations" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 36 (36): 587-595, 2020

119 Edy Tonnizam Mohamad, "A new hybrid method for predicting ripping production in different weathering zones through in situ tests" Elsevier BV 147 : 106826-, 2019

120 Mojtaba Daie, "A new finite element investigation on pre-bent steel strips as damper for vibration control" Academic Journals 6 (6): 8044-8050, 2011

121 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "A new approach for estimation of rock brittleness based on non-destructive tests" Informa UK Limited 34 (34): 354-375, 2019

122 Mohammadreza Koopialipoor, "A neuro-genetic predictive model to approximate overbreak induced by drilling and blasting operation in tunnels" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 78 (78): 981-990, 2019

123 Warren S. McCulloch, "A logical calculus of the ideas immanent in nervous activity" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 5 (5): 115-133, 1943

124 Ebrahim Noroozi Ghaleini, "A combination of artificial bee colony and neural network for approximating the safety factor of retaining walls" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 35 (35): 647-658, 2019

125 Jian Zhou, "A Monte Carlo simulation approach for effective assessment of flyrock based on intelligent system of neural network" Springer Science and Business Media LLC 36 (36): 713-723, 2020