화이트칼라 범죄의 심각성 및 양형기준 개선방안에 관한 연구: 횡령, 배임을 중심으로 = Research on the Seriousness of White-collar Crime and the Improvement of the Sentencing Guideline-Focused on Embezzlement/Breach of Trust Crime-

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The objective of this article is to measure the seriousness of white-collar crime and the national perception on the sentencing, and to explore the problems in the sentencing guideline if the sentencing is insufficient compared to the severity of the crime along with how to improve it. This study examined the general discussion of the seriousness of the crime prior to the full scale debate on the magnitude of the white-collar crime. In the case of foreign countries, there has long been the awareness of the crime of the interest in the social consensus and thereby the cases are plentiful, on the other hand, in our country there is not much concern on this theme, and therefore it is hard to find the records of the research except research by a few scholars. In addition, there are only a few attempts to seek out improvement in the sentencing guideline by logically relating the severity of the crime with the sentencing guideline On the one hand, in regard to one of the most serious white-collar crimes which emerge in contemporary society, in particular, embezzlement/breach of trust crime, it is remarkable that court tended to punish it more generously compared to, so called, street crimes. Of course, this tendency has considerably relaxed since the enforcement of sentencing guideline in 2009, however, most Koreans have the perception that the sentencing is insufficient, compared to the magnitude of the white-collar crime. The issue of sentencing of white-collar crime stems from the imbalance of the sentencing criteria and the extremely poor law enforcement, and in order to address these problems, it is necessary to arrange it upward within the reasonable scope and to develop actively aggravating sentencing factors along with benchmarking of foreign cases and including them in the actual sentencing guideline. Since the research on the exploration on the sentencing factors is none other than wasteland in South Korea, the active research on this is expected.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 김혜정, "횡령･배임죄 양형기준제도의 준수현황 및 개선방안" 한국형사정책연구원 26 (26): 55-84, 2015

2 최호진, "횡령⋅배임에 있어서 기업의 고위 경영자에 대한 양형분석과 문제점" 법학연구소 39 (39): 63-91, 2015

3 최인섭, "화이트칼라범죄에 관한 연구: 유형과 사례분석을중심으로" 한국형사정책연구원 1996

4 성빈, "화이트칼라 범죄에 대한 외국의 연구동향 - 통제(control)적 이론을 중심으로 -" 아시아교정포럼 9 (9): 109-144, 2015

5 박성훈, "형사정책과 사법제도에 관한 평가연구(VIII): 범죄의 심각성 및 형벌의 적정성에 관한 국민의식 연구" 한국형사정책연구원 2014

6 이윤호, "현대사회와 범죄" 박영사 2011

7 이주형, "최초 양형기준에 대한 비판적 고찰" 21 : 45-93, 2009

8 승재현, "우리나라 양형위원회 양형기준모델의 타당성 평가" 법조협회 59 (59): 87-135, 2010

9 경제개혁연대, "우리나라 법원의 화이트칼라 범죄 양형 분석: 법원의 집행유예 선고율을 중심으로" 경제개혁리포트 1-18, 2007

10 최한수, "왜 법원은 재벌(범죄)에 관대한가?" 231 (231): 6-25, 2015

11 이현정, "양형위원회의 양형기준안에 대한 비판적 고찰" 법학연구소 21 (21): 359-388, 2009

12 양형위원회, "양형위원회 연간보고서 2007" 양형위원회 2008

13 이민식, "양형기준 시행현황 분석 및 개선방안에 관한 연구I" 대검찰청 2011

14 성빈, "성폭력범죄 양형기준에 관한 연구" 동국대학교 대학원 2011

15 이창한, "성범죄의 심각성에 대한 법관과 일반인의 인식차이" 한국공안행정학회 18 (18): 273-300, 2009

16 Croall, H, "White Collar Crime: Criminal Justice and Criminology" Open University Press 1992

17 Sutherland, E, "White Collar Crime" Dryden Press 1949

18 Warr, Mark, "What is the Perceived seriousness of Crimes?" 27 : 795-814, 1989

19 Croall, H, "Understanding White Collar Crime" Open University Press 2001

20 Quinney, R, "The Social Reality of Crime" Little, Brown & Company 1970

21 Rossi, Peter H, "The Seriousness of Crimes: Normative Structure and Individual Differences" 39 : 224-237, 1974

22 Cullen, Francis T, "The Seriousness of Crime Revisited: Have Attitudes Toward White-collar Crime Changed?" 20 : 83-102, 1982

23 Kelly, Delos H, "Seriousness of Delinquent Behavior: An Alternative Perspective" 10 : 124-135, 1970

24 Von Hirsch, Andrew, "Past or Future Crime: Deservedness and Dangerousness in the Sentencing of Criminals" Manchester University Press 1986

25 Rossi, Peter H, "Just Punishments: Federal Guidelines and Public Views Compared Federal Guidelines and Public Views Compared" Aldine Transaction 1997

26 McCleary, Richard, "Effects of Legal Education and Work Experience on Perceptions of Crime Seriousness" 28 (28): 276-289, 1981

27 Von Hirsch, Andrew, "Doing Justice: The Choice of Punishments" Northeastern University Press 1976

28 Clinard, M. B, "Criminal Behavior Systems: a Typology" Holt, Rinehart and Winston 1973

29 Clarke. M, "Business Crime: Its Nature and Control" Polity Press 1990