Comparison of Electroacupuncture Frequencyrelated Effects on Heart Rate Variability in Healthy Volunteers: A Randomized Clinical Trial

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study aimed to compare the effects of high frequency electroacupuncture (EA)and low-frequency EA on the autonomic nervous system by using a heart rate variability measuring device in normal individuals. Fourteen participants were recruited and each participated in the high-frequency and low-frequency sessions (crossover design). The order of sessions was randomized and the interval between the two sessions was over 2 weeks. Participants received needle insertion with 120-Hz stimulation during the high-frequency session (high-frequency EA group), and with 2-Hz stimulation during the low-frequency session (low-frequency EA group).
Acupuncture needles were directly inserted perpendicularly to LI 4 and LI 11 acupoints followed by delivery of electric pulses to these points for 15 minutes. Heart rate variability was measured 5 minutes before and after EA stimulation by a heart rate variability measuring system. We found a significant increase in the standard deviation of the normal-to-normal interval in the high-frequency EA group, with no change in the low-frequency EA group. Both the high-frequency and low-frequency EA groups showed no significant differences in other parameters including highfrequency power, low-frequency power, and the ratio of low-frequency power to high-frequency power. Based on these findings, we concluded that high-frequency EA stimulation is more effective than low-frequency EA stimulation in increasing autonomic nervous activity and there is no difference between the two EA frequencies in enhancing sympathovagal balance.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 World Health Organization Western Pacific Regional Office, "WHO standard acupuncture point locations in the WesternPacific Region" World Health Organization 2008

2 Mori H, "Unique immunomodulationby electroacupuncture in humans possibly viastimulation of the autonomic nervous system" 320 : 21-24, 2002

3 Starke K, "The sympathetic axons innervatingthe sinus node of the rabbit possess presynaptic opioidkappa- but not mu- or delta-receptors" 329 : 206-209, 1985

4 Lin JG, "The effectof high and low frequency electroacupuncture in pain afterlower abdominal surgery" 99 : 509-514, 2002

5 Knardahl S, "Sympathetic nerveactivity after acupuncture in humans" 75 : 19-25, 1998

6 Park SB, "Standardized tests of heart ratevariability for autonomic function tests in healthy Koreans" 117 : 1707-1717, 2007

7 Agelink MW, "Standardized tests of heart rate variability:normal ranges obtained from 309 healthy humans, and effectsof age, gender, and heart rate" 11 : 99-108, 2001

8 Thomas D, "Somatic sympathetic vasomotorchanges documented by medical thermographic imagingduring acupuncture analgesia" 11 : 55-59, 1992

9 Chae YB, "Reviews on acupunctureand autonomic nervous system: heart rate variability analysisin humans" 24 : 25-36, 2007

10 Bilchick KC, "Prognostic value of heart rate variability inchronic congestive heart failure (Veterans Affairs’ SurvivalTrial of Antiarrhythmic Therapy in Congestive Heart Failure)" 90 : 24-28, 2002

11 Montano N, "Power spectrum analysis of heart rate variabilityto assess the changes in sympathovagal balance duringgraded orthostatic tilt" 90 : 1826-1831, 1994

12 Stener-Victorin E, "Ovarian bloodflow responses to electroacupuncture stimulation at differentfrequencies and intensities in anaesthetized rats" 1082 : 50-56, 2003

13 Lin MT, "Needle stimulationof acupuncture loci Chu-Chih (LI-11) and Ho-Ku (LI-4)induces hypothermia effects and analgesia in normal adults" 9 : 74-83, 1981

14 Friedman EM, "Modulation of immune cell functionby the autonomic nervous system" 74 : 27-38, 1997

15 Hsieh CL, "Modulation of cerebral cortex in acupuncturestimulation: a study using sympathetic skin response andsomatosensory evoked potentials" 26 : 1-11, 1998

16 Han JS, "Mobilization of specific neuropeptidesby peripheral stimulation of identified frequencies" 7 : 176-180, 1992

17 Kim HW, "Low-frequency electroacupuncture suppresses carrageenaninducedpaw inflammation in mice via sympathetic postganglionicneurons, while high-frequency EA suppression ismediated by the sympathoadrenal medullary axis" 75 : 698-705, 2008

18 Ogata A, "Low and highfrequency acupuncture stimulation inhibits mental stressinducedsweating in humans via different mechanisms" 118 : 93-101, 2005

19 Lin TB, "Low and high frequencyelectroacupuncture at Hoku elicits a distinct mechanismto activate sympathetic nervous system in anesthetizedrats" 247 : 155-158, 1998

20 Hung CF, "Identification of opioidreceptors in the sympathetic and parasympathetic nerves ofguinea-pig atria" 14 : 387-394, 2000

21 "Heart rate variability. Standards of measurement, physiologicalinterpretation, and clinical use. Task Force of theEuropean Society of Cardiology and the North AmericanSociety of Pacing and Electrophysiology" 17 : 354-381, 1996

22 Han Z, "Endomorphin-1 mediates 2 Hz but not 100 Hz electroacupunctureanalgesia in the rat" 274 : 75-78, 1999

23 Huang C, "Endomorphin andmuopioid receptors in mouse brain mediate the analgesiceffect induced by 2 Hz but not 100 Hz electroacupuncturestimulation" 294 : 159-162, 2000

24 Liao JM, "Electroacupuncture-induced pressor and chronotropic effectsin anesthetized rats" 124 : 18-25, 2006

25 Liao JM, "Electroacupuncture at Hoku elicits dual effect on autonomic nervoussystem in anesthetized rats" 42 : 15-20, 2002

26 Mayor DF, "Electroacupuncture" Elsevier ChurchillLivingstone 352-, 2005

27 Wang Y, "Effects of synchronousor asynchronous electroacupuncture stimulationwith low versus high frequency on spinal opioid release andtail flick nociception" 192 : 156-162, 2005

28 Dyrehag LE, "Effects of repeated sensory stimulation sessions (electroacupuncture)on skin temperature in chronic pain patients" 29 : 243-250, 1997

29 Stener-Victorin E, "Effect of electroacupuncture stimulation ofdifferent frequencies and intensities on ovarian blood flowin anaesthetized rats with steroid-induced polycystic ovaries" 2 : 16-, 2004

30 Lin TB, "Effect of electroacupuncture on blood pressureand adrenal nerve activity in anesthetized rats" 285 : 37-40, 2000

31 Suter B, "Does acupuncture influence the cardiovascular-systemvia the ventral-nervous-system" 124 : 36-38, 1994

32 Kleiger RE, "Decreased heartrate variability and its association with increased mortalityafter acute myocardial infarction" 59 : 256-262, 1987

33 Nishijo K, "Decreased heartrate by acupuncture stimulation in humans via facilitationof cardiac vagal activity and suppression of cardiac sympatheticnerve" 227 : 165-168, 1997

34 Kimura K, "Changes in skin bloodflow and skin sympathetic nerve activity in response tomanual acupuncture stimulation in humans" 34 : 189-196, 2006

35 Middlekauff HR, "Acupuncture inhibits sympathetic activationduring mental stress in advanced heart failure patients" 8 : 399-406, 2002