The ‘-Pacific’ part of ‘Asia-Pacific’: Oceanic diplomacy in the 2017 treaty for the prohibition of nuclear weapons

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The 2017 Treatyfor the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons (TPNW) was negotiated at the UN over the objections of nuclear-armed and -allied states and established a global categorical ban on nuclear weapons framed in terms of humanitarianism, human rights and environmentalism. The TPNW also placed ‘positive obligations’ on states to assist victims of nuclear weapons use and testing and remediate contaminated environments. States and NGOs from the Pacific region advocated for a strong treaty text, particularly its positive obligations. They were influenced by the region’s history as a site of nuclear weapons testing in Marshall Islands, Kiribati and French Polynesia/Te Ao Maohi; the 1985 South Pacific Nuclear Free Zone’s precedent; and earlier diplomatic efforts and activism linking denuclearization with decolonization. In doing so, Pacific and other formerly colonized states flipped the ‘standard of civilization’ script embedded in humanitarian disarmament law and applied it to their former colonizers. The paper demonstrates the agency of small states—the ‘-Pacific’ part of ‘Asia-Pacific’—in multilateral policymaking on peace and security, often overlooked in international relations scholarship. It draws on my participant observation in the Nobel Peace Prize-winning advocacy of the International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN) during the TPNW negotiations.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Mathur, R., "‘The west and the rest’: A civilizational Mantra in arms control and disarmament?" 35 (35): 332-355, 2014

2 Biswas, S., "‘Nuclear apartheid’ as political position: Race as a postcolonial resource?" 26 : 485-522, 2001

3 Hickel, W., "Who owns America?" Prentice-Hall 1971

4 Griffen, V., "Vanessa Griffen. [Online video]"

5 Ritchie, N., "Valuing and devaluing nuclear weapons" 34 (34): 146-173, 2013

6 Borrie, J., "Unacceptable harm: A history of how the treaty to ban cluster munitions was won" UNIDIR 2009

7 International Campaign to Abolish Nuclear Weapons (ICAN), "US pressured NATO states to vote no to a ban"

8 Melville, H., "Typee: A peep at Polynesian life" The Library of America 1982

9 Bigelow, A., "The voyage of the golden rule: An experiment with truth" Doubleday 1959

10 International Human Rights Clinic (IHRC), "The treaty on the prohibition of nuclear weapons and the compact of free association between the republic of the Marshall Islands and the United States.’"

11 Bolton, M., "The nuclear taboo and the international campaign to abolish nuclear weapons" e-International Relations

12 Regnault, J. -M., "The nuclear issue in the South Pacific : Labor parties, trade union movements, and Pacific Island churches in international relations" 17 (17): 339-357, 2005

13 Smith, R. H., "The nuclear free and independent Pacific movement after Muroroa" I. B. Tauris 1997

14 Maclellan, N., "The nuclear age in the Pacific Islands" 17 (17): 363-372, 2005

15 Tong, A., "The new Pacific diplomacy" ANU Press 21-24, 2015

16 Slade, T. N., "The making of international law: The role of small island states" 17 : 531-543, 2003

17 Ruff, T. A., "The humanitarian impact and implications of nuclear test explosions in the Pacific region" 97 (97): 775-813, 2015

18 Reynolds, E., "The forbidden voyage" Greenwood Press 1961

19 Ritchie, N., "The diplomacy of resistance: Power, hegemony and nuclear disarmament" 30 (30): 121-141, 2018

20 Shih, S., "The creolization of theory" Duke University Press 2011

21 Samoa, "Statement to 2014 conference on the Humanitarian Impact of Nuclear Weapons in Nayarit"

22 Marschik, A., "Statement by Ambassador Alexander Marschik, Vice-Minister for Political Affairs"

23 Acheson, R., "Starting somewhere: The arms trade treaty, human rights and gender based violence" 22 (22): 17-19, 2013

24 Hey, J. A. K., "Small states in world politics: explaining foreign policy behavior" Lynne Rienner 2003

25 Stavrianakis, A., "Small arms control and the reproduction of imperial relations" 32 (32): 193-214, 2011

26 Mathur, R., "Sly civility and the paradox of equality/inequality in the nuclear order : A postcolonial critique" 4 (4): 57-72, 2016

27 Wesley-Smith, T., "Self-determination in Oceania" 48 (48): 29-46, 2007

28 Weivel, A., "Security, profit or shadow of the past? Explaining the security strategies of microstates" 23 (23): 429-453, 2010

29 Council of Delegates of the International Red Cross and Red Crescent Movement, "Resolution 1: Working towards the elimination of nuclear weapons"

30 Cardinal, P. -A., "Resistance and international law; De-coloniality and pluritopic hermeneutics" 1 (1): 40-52, 2016

31 Georgescu, C., "Report of the Special Rapporteur on the implications for human rights of the environmentally sound management and disposal of hazardous substances and wastes, Calin Georgescu. A/HRC/21/48/Add.1" United Nations Human Rights Council

32 Mathur, R., "Red cross interventions in weapons control" Lexington Books 2017

33 Eyley, C. P., "Protest at Moruroa: first-hand accounts from the New Zealand-based Flotilla" Tandem Press 1997

34 Maclellan, N., "Prohibiting nuclear weapons: A Pacific Islands priority" ICAN Australia

35 Leadbeater, M., "Peace, power and politics: How New Zealand became nuclear free" Otago University Press 2013

36 George, N., "Pacific women building peace : A regional perspective" 23 (23): 35-72, 2011

37 Stringer, K. D., "Pacific island microstates: Pawns or players in Pacific rim diplomacy?" 17 : 547-577, 2006

38 Teaiwa, T. K., "Pacific history: papers from the 8th Pacific history association conference" University of Guam 125-142, 1992

39 International Court of Justice(ICJ), "Order of 22 June 1973. In ICJ, Reports of Judgments, Advisory Opinions and Orders: Nuclear Tests Case (New Zealand V. France): Request for the Indication of Interim Measures of Protection Order of 22 June 1973"

40 Bright, M., "Nuclear: Winds of change in Paris; nuclear testing in the south Pacific has given rise to questions about the relationship between France and her colonies"

41 Harrington de Santana, A., "Nuclear weapons as the currency of power: Deconstructing the fetishism of force" 16 (16): 325-345, 2009

42 Gusterson, H., "Nuclear weapons and the other in the western imagination" 14 (14): 111-143, 1999

43 Horowitz, A. J., "Nuclear savage: The islands of secret project 4.1" Primordial Soup and Equatorial Films

44 Firth, S., "Nuclear playground" University of Hawaii Press 1987

45 Jacobs, Robert, "Nuclear Conquistadors: Military Colonialism in Nuclear Test Site Selection during the Cold War" 통일평화연구원 1 (1): 157-177, 2013

46 Robie, D., "Niuklia Fri Pasifik"

47 Waltz, K., "Neorealism and its critics" Columbia 98-130, 1986

48 de Vries, P., "Moruroa and us: polynesians’ experiences during thirty years of nuclear testing in the French Pacific" Centre de Documentation et de Recherche sur la Paix et les Conflits 1997

49 Van Fossen, A. B., "Money laundering, global financial instability, and tax havens in the Pacific Islands" 15 (15): 237-275, 2003

50 Ogashiwa, Y., "Microstates and nuclear issues : regional cooperation in the Pacific" University of the South Pacific 1991

51 Spivak, G., "Marxism and interpretation of culture" University of Illinois Press 271-313, 1988

52 Stavrianakis, A., "Legitimising liberal militarism : Politics, law and war in the arms trade treaty" 37 : 840-865, 2016

53 Choi, E. H., "Law school team helps nuclear disarmament campaign win nobel prize" The Harvard Crimson

54 Kiribati, "Joint statement on behalf of Pacific Island Nations: Second conference on the humanitarian impact of nuclear weapons Nayarit"

55 Pugh, J., "Island movements: Thinking with the archipelago" 8 (8): 9-24, 2013

56 Alston, P., "International human rights" Oxford University Press 2012

57 Hau’ofa, E., "Inside out: literature, cultural politics, and identity in the new Pacific" Rowman & Littlefield 27-38, 1999

58 Lyons, P., "Inside Out: literature, cultural politics, and identity in the New Pacific" Rowman & Littlefield 291-318, 1999

59 Finucane, M., "Harvard Law team helped group that won the Nobel Peace Prize" The Boston Globe

60 Johnston, B. R., "Half-lives and half-truths: confronting the radioactive legacies of the cold war" School for Advanced Research Press 2007

61 O’Rourke, D., "Half life : A parable for the nuclear Age"

62 McTaggart, D., "Greenpeace III : journey into the bomb" Collins 1978

63 Maclellan, N., "Grappling with the bomb: Britain’s Pacific H-bomb Tests" ANU Press 2017

64 Maclellan, N., "Grappling with the Bomb: Opposition to Pacific nuclear testing in the 1950s" Labor History Melbourne

65 Latham, A., "Global cultural change and the transnational campaign to ban antipersonnel landmines: a research agenda" YCISS

66 Bolton, M., "Global activism and humanitarian disarmament" Palgrave Macmillan

67 "Fiji, Nauru, Palau, Samoa and Tuvalu. Elements for a treaty banning nuclear weapons. A/AC.286/WP.14" United Nations General Assembly

68 Fiji, "Fiji statement in the first committee general debate on disarmament measures and international security"

69 Fiji, "Fiji statement at the United Nations conference to negotiate a legallybinding instrument to prohibit nuclear weapons, leading towards their total elimination"

70 Johnston, B. R., "Environmental disaster and resilience: The Marshall Islands experience continues to unfold" 40 (40): 2016

71 Weir, C., "Ending nuclear testing in the Pacific: Bishop Bryce and the Pacific Conference of Churches. 20th Pacific history association conference"

72 Docherty, B., "Ending civilian suffering: The purpose, provisions, and promise of humanitarian disarmament law" 2010 (2010): 7-44, 2010

73 Hau’ofa, E., "Dreadlocks in oceania" University of the South Pacific 124-149, 1997

74 Scott, J. C., "Domination and the arts of resistance: hidden transcripts" Yale University Press 1990

75 Rutherford, K., "Disarming states : The international movement to Ban landmines" Praeger Security International 2011

76 Banivanua Mar, T., "Decolonisation and the Pacific: indigenous globalisation and the ends of empire" Cambridge University Press 2016

77 Karlshoven, F., "Constraints on the waging of war: An introduction to international humanitarian Law" International Committee of the Red Cross 2001

78 Teaiwa, T. K., "Bikinis and other s/pacific n/oceans" 6 (6): 87-109, 1994

79 McQuire, A., "Australia’s refusal to join nuclear arms ban treaty ‘gutting’ to aboriginal victims" BuzzFeed

80 Clinton, H., "America’s Pacific century" Foreign Policy

81 Johnson, W., "Against French nuclear testing: The A.T.O.M. Committee" 11 (11): 213-216, 1976

82 Maclellan, N., "After Moruroa : France in the South Pacific" Ocean Press 1998

83 Boahen, A. A., "African perspectives on colonialism" Johns Hopkins University 1987

84 Bolton, M., "Addressing the humanitarian, human rights and environmental harm of nuclear weapons tests at Kiritimati (Christmas) and Malden Islands"

85 Oldham, R., "Address to UN conference to negotiate a legally-binding instrument to prohibit nuclear weapons, leading to their elimination: Roland Oldham, Moruroa e Tatou, Tahiti"