The Desertification Narrative in China

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

Chinese officials and scholars ascribe land degradation to previous governmental regimes and local land users, particularly ethnic pastoralists, which are always criticised as ignorant, irrational, backward and uncooperative. The ethnic pastoralists are the clear losers in the desertification discourse in China, who have always been damaged by central planning, land use policy and government ideas on rangeland. There is no reliable objective data found to believe that the Grain-first campaign and land reclamation have greatly led to land degradation in China. There is skepticism about the Chinese government’s recent enclosure policy on rangeland, which is thought to be effective in preventing land degradation by transforming nomadic pastoralism into sedentary livestock farming.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 United Nations Environment Programme, "“Environmental Data Report 1993-94”, Prepared for UNEP by the GEMS Monitoring and Assessment Research Centre, London"

2 "Xinhua News Agency. “PRC’s Inner Monglia to tackle increased desertification”, Beijing, May 25. Available from Foreign Broadcast Information Service FBIS-CHI-2000-0525 at"

3 Lattimore, Owen, "Writings of Owen Lattimore, studies in frontier history" Oxford University Press 1992

4 Ho, Peter, "The myth of desertification of China’s northwestern frontier: The case of Ningxia Province (1929-1958)" 26 (26): 2000

5 Williams, Dee Mack, "The barbed walls of China: a contemporary grassland drama" 55 (55): 1996

6 Mearns, Robin, "Territoriality and Land Tenure among Mongolian Pastoralists: Variation, Continuity and Change" 33 : 1993

7 Edmond, R. Louis, "Patterns of China’s lost harmony: A survey of the country’s environmental degradation and protection" Routledge 1994

8 Zhao, S., "Origin and development of the Shamo and the Gobi of China, Evolution of the East Asian Environment, VolumeⅠ: Geology and Palaeo-climatology, Centre for Asian Studies" University of Hong Kong 1984

9 Li, R. Maria, "Migration to China’s Northern Frontier, 1953-82" 15 (15): 1989

10 Ho, Peter, "Mao’s war against nature? The environmental impact of the grain-first campaign in China" 50 : 2003

11 Shapiro, Judith, "Mao’s war against nature: politics and the environment in revolutionary Chin" Cambridge University Press 2000

12 Scoones, Ian, "Living with uncertainty: new directions for pastoral development in Africa" IT Publications 1995

13 Wu, Bo, "Landscape change and desertification development in the Mu Us sandland, northern China" 50 : 2002

14 Smil, Vaclav, "Land degradation in China: An ancient problem getting worse" Routledge 1991

15 Hu, S. Tsung, "Forage Resources of China" Pudoc 1992

16 Humphrey, Caroline, "End of nomadism? society, state, and the environment in Inner Asia" Durham: Duke University Press 1999

17 Spooner, Brian, "Ecology in development: a rationale for three dimensional policy" United Nations University Press 1984

18 Swift, Jeremy, "Desertification narratives, winners & losers" James Currey Ltd 1996

19 Zhu, Zhenda, "Desertification in the Northern Territory of China: Present Status and Trend of Development" 1 : 1990

20 "China’s Agenda 21: White Paper on China’s Population, Environment, and Development in the 21st century" China Environmental Science Press 1994

21 "China National Committee for the implementation of the UNCCD. China National Report on the Implementation of the United Nation’s Convention to Combat Desertification"

22 Williams, Dee Mack, "Beyond great walls: Environment, Identity, and development on the Chinese grasslands of Inner Mongolia" Stanford University Press 2002