양성자 펌프 억제제인 에스오메프라졸은 위궤양, 역류성 식도염, 졸링거-엘리슨 증후군 및 미란성 식도염 치료를 위해 단독 혹은 비스테로이드성 항염증제와 같은 약물과 함께 주로 사용되...

http://chineseinput.net/에서 pinyin(병음)방식으로 중국어를 변환할 수 있습니다.
변환된 중국어를 복사하여 사용하시면 됩니다.
https://www.riss.kr/link?id=T16812858
청주 : 충북대학교, 2023
학위논문(박사) -- 충북대학교 , 응용양학과 제약산업공학전공 , 2023. 8
2023
영어
513.33 판사항(5)
충청북도
제어방출시스템을 이용한 역류성 식도염 치료용 에스오메프라졸이 함유된 신규 제형개발
XI, 115 p. : 삽화, 표 ; 26 cm
충북대학교 논문은 저작권에 의해 보호됩니다
지도교수: 박천웅
참고문헌 : p.103-109
I804:43009-000000058714
0
상세조회0
다운로드양성자 펌프 억제제인 에스오메프라졸은 위궤양, 역류성 식도염, 졸링거-엘리슨 증후군 및 미란성 식도염 치료를 위해 단독 혹은 비스테로이드성 항염증제와 같은 약물과 함께 주로 사용되...
양성자 펌프 억제제인 에스오메프라졸은 위궤양, 역류성 식도염, 졸링거-엘리슨 증후군 및 미란성 식도염 치료를 위해 단독 혹은 비스테로이드성 항염증제와 같은 약물과 함께 주로 사용되고 있다. 에스오메프라졸은 양성자 펌프를 직접적으로 억제함으로 역류성 식도염 치료에 더 강하고 빠른 효과를 보이는 것이 특징이다. 그러나 에스오메프라졸을 함유하고 있는 대부분의 제품은 장용코팅된 펠렛 형태로 위에서 바로 흡수되지 않고 소장에서 용해되어 흡수되도록 설계되어, 복용 후 즉각적인 치료가 필요한 환자에게는 적합하지 않다. 또한, 에스오메프라졸의 짧은 반감기로 인해 야간 산 분비 돌파가 자주 발생하여 환자의 수면을 방해한다. 이러한 약물 제형적인 단점을 극복하고 역류성 식도염의 효과적인 치료를 위해, 제어방출시스템이 적
용된 신규 에스오메프라졸 함유 제형개발을 수행하였다.
1장. 수산화마그네슘이 함유된 속방성 방출 이층정 연구
이 연구에서는 시판제품보다 약효 시간이 빠르고, 생체이용률이 개선된, 산중화제 함유 신규 에스오메프라졸 이층정을 개발하였다. 산중화제 종류 별 산 중화능, pH 완충능 및 배합적합성을 통해, 복약순응도가 향상된 수산화마그네슘 및 비율 (350mg/T)을 선정하였다. 위산에 분해되는 에스오메프라졸 특성을 고려, 시간 차 속방출이 가능한 이층정 제형으로 선정하여 모의 위 내 환경에서 에스오메프라졸 방출패턴 및 pH 변화를 관찰하였다. 또한 에스오메프라졸 층의 부형제 양별 평가를 통해, 산중화제층 보다 빨리 방출될 수 있는 최적 비율 연구를 수행하였다. 생체 내 약물동태학 실험에서는 이층정 정제가 시판제품과 유사한 생체이용률이 확인되었으며, 약 3.5배 빠르게 흡수되는 것을 입증했다.
2장. 이중방출 미니 정제 폴리캡 연구
이 연구에서는 야간 산 분비 돌파 예방하기 위해, 약효 지속시간을 연장하며 개선된 생체이용률을 나타내는 신규 이중방출 미니정제 폴리캡을 개발하였다. 에스오메프라졸을 함유하는 미니정제 코어 연구를 통해 신속한 약물 방출이 확인되었으며, 내부 코팅 후, 유드라짓®L30D-55 수분산 코팅으로 1차 방출 미니정제를 제조하였다. 또한 동일하게 코어에 내피코팅 후 유드라짓®S100/유드라짓®L100 혼합액으로 코팅하여 2차 방출 미니정제를 확보하였다. 코팅된 미니정제는 시험관 내 용해 및 현미경으로 특성화 하였으며, 각 10개 미니정제를 경질캡슐에 충전하여 이중방출 미니정제 폴리캡을 완성하였다. 미니정제의 조합은 시험관 내 방출패턴 및 생체 내 약물동태학 연구를 통해 최적화하였다. 이중방출 미니정제 폴리캡의 생체이용률은 시판제품와 유사하였으며, 최고약물혈중농도는 약 50 % 낮아졌고, 약 1.7배 약물 흡수 지연효과가 확인되었다. 추가 약물동력학 결과에서도 위내 pH 4이상 유지함으로서 야간 산 분비가 개선되었음을 확인하였다.
본 연구에서 비글견을 대상으로 한 생체 내 약물동태학 연구를 통해, 에스오메프라졸 함유 이층정과 이중방출 미니정제 폴리캡의 생체이용률은 시판제품과 유사하였으며, 치료효과를 위해 제형적으로 약효시간 조절이 가능함을 입증하였다. 결론적으로 제어방출시스템을 통해, 약효 문제를 극복하고 효과적인 최적의 치료옵션을 제공할수 있음이 확인되었다.
다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)
Esomeprazole (EMP), a proton pump inhibitor (PPI), It is used for the prevention and treatment of gastrointestinal symptoms by anti-inflammatory analgesics, and for the treatment of Helicobacter pylori infection and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GE...
Esomeprazole (EMP), a proton pump inhibitor (PPI), It is used for the prevention and treatment of gastrointestinal symptoms by anti-inflammatory analgesics, and for the treatment of Helicobacter pylori infection and gastroesophageal reflux disease (GERD). Unlike other mechanisms of action, PPI, such as EMP, directly inhibit the proton pump, so they have the characteristic of showing a slightly stronger and faster effect on GERD treatment. However, most products containing EMP are provided as delayed-release tablets designed with an enteric-coated multiunit pellet systems (MUPS), and are not suitable for the treatment of diseases that require immediate therapeutic effects after administration. In addition, EMP has a short plasma half-life (about 1.3 h), resulting in nocturnal acid breakthrough (NAB) occurs frequently, disturbing a patient’s nighttime comfort and sleep. In order to overcome these shortcomings, it is development of novel EMP-loaded novel pharmaceutical formulation for GERD treatment using controlled release system and provide various treatment options.
Chapter I. EMP-loaded bi-layer tablet with magnesium hydroxide for immediate release
In this study, a novel EMP-loaded bi-layer tablet containing an acid-neutralizing agent with faster onset time and improved bioavailability than a commercial product was developed. Magnesium hydroxide, an acid-neutralizing agent, was selected because of its acid-neutralizing capacity, pH-buffering capacity, and compatibility. It was found to be the most suitable acid-neutralizing agent for products with improved patient compliance (350 mg/T). Considering the characteristics of EMP that decompose in gastric acid, a bi-layer tablet formulation capable of time-dependent release was selected. Through the simulated conditions in the stomach release test, fast release and pH profiles were confirmed and compared with those of EMP-loaded commercial products. In addition, the amount of ingredients in the proven acceptance range was determined such that the acid-neutralizing agent layer could disintegrate faster than the drug layer. In vivo pharmacokinetic (PK) studies showed that the drug concentration-time curve (AUC) of the bi-layer tablet was similar to that of a comparable EMP-loaded commercial product and that Tmax was rapidly absorbed approximately 3.5-fold.
Chapter II. EMP-loaded mini-tablet polycap for dual-release
In this study, to develop a novel EMP magnesium-loaded dual-release mini-tablet polycap (DR polycap) with prolonged onset time and improved bioavailability to prevent NAB. Different types and amounts of diluents were evaluated to obtain EMP-loaded mini-tablet core preparations capable of rapid drug release. Inner coating was performed using a fluidized bed, and 1st release mini-tablet conting was achieved by coating with Eudragit®L30D-55 (ELD-55) aqueous dispersion. In addition, it was coated with an aqueous dispersion of Eudragit®S100 (ES-100) and Eudragit®L100 (EL-100) to realize optimal 2nd delayed release mini-tablet characteristics according to each coating thickness and polymer blend ratio. Each mini-tablet was characterized by SEM-EDS, light microscopic and in vitro dissolution test, and then ten mini-tablets were encapsulation in hard capsule to prepared a DR polycap. The combination of mini-tablets were optimized using in vitro release testing and in vivo PK studies. The AUC of the DR polycap was similar to that of a commercial product and that Cmax was lower by about 50 %, Tmax was extended by about 1.7-fold. Additional PD results also confirmed that NAB was improved by prolonged the maintenance of intragastric pH above 4.
The results of in vivo PK studies in beagle dogs, AUC of the bi-layer tablet and DR polycaps were similar to that of a comparable commercial product, and it was possible that Tmax can be controlled for therapeutic effects. The DR polycap was confirmed to improve NAB by prolonged onset time through PD results. In conclusion, we developed a controlled-release system to overcome drug efficacy concerns and provide optimal treatment options.
목차 (Table of Contents)
참고문헌 (Reference)
1. Antacids Therapy, Morrissey, J. F., Barreras, R. F., 290 (10), 550-554, , 1974
2. Do We Need Gastric Acid?, Allescher, H. D., Rogler, G., Göke, B., Prinz, B., Keller, J., Fried, M., Dauer, M., Schiefke, I., Mönnikes, H., Lippl, F., Seidler, U., Pohl, D., Fox, M., 77, 184–197., , 2008
3. MUPS tablets-a brief review, Sunil, B. J., Dinesh, M. S., Chandewar, J. M., Shajahan, A., Anil, V., Mangesh, E. B., 2, 847–885, , 2010
4. Multiple unit pellet systems: a review, Vijayasri, K. S., Sirisha, V. R. K., Kamalakar, R. G., 2, 419–425, , 2012
5. Pressure-induced photoluminescence of MgO, Zhang, D., Wang, L., Yang, K., Li, X., Zhang, J., Yuan, Y., Lee, Y., Kim, T., 30 (19), 194002, , 2018
6. Tableting of coated pellets: review article, Bodmeier, B., 43, 1–8, , 1997
7. Management of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease, Harrison, R., Nostrant, T., Heidelbaugh, J. J., 7, 1311-1318, , 2003
8. Management of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease, Nostrant, T. T., kim, C., Heidelbaugh, J. J, Van Harrison R., 68 (7), 1311-1319, , 2003
9. Mathematical comparison of dissolution profiles, Moore, J. W., Flanner, H. H., 20 (6), 64-74, , 1996
10. A Gut feeling about GABA: Focus on GABAB, Receptors, Hyland, N. P., Cryan, J. F., 1, 124-136, , 2010
1. Antacids Therapy, Morrissey, J. F., Barreras, R. F., 290 (10), 550-554, , 1974
2. Do We Need Gastric Acid?, Allescher, H. D., Rogler, G., Göke, B., Prinz, B., Keller, J., Fried, M., Dauer, M., Schiefke, I., Mönnikes, H., Lippl, F., Seidler, U., Pohl, D., Fox, M., 77, 184–197., , 2008
3. MUPS tablets-a brief review, Sunil, B. J., Dinesh, M. S., Chandewar, J. M., Shajahan, A., Anil, V., Mangesh, E. B., 2, 847–885, , 2010
4. Multiple unit pellet systems: a review, Vijayasri, K. S., Sirisha, V. R. K., Kamalakar, R. G., 2, 419–425, , 2012
5. Pressure-induced photoluminescence of MgO, Zhang, D., Wang, L., Yang, K., Li, X., Zhang, J., Yuan, Y., Lee, Y., Kim, T., 30 (19), 194002, , 2018
6. Tableting of coated pellets: review article, Bodmeier, B., 43, 1–8, , 1997
7. Management of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease, Harrison, R., Nostrant, T., Heidelbaugh, J. J., 7, 1311-1318, , 2003
8. Management of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease, Nostrant, T. T., kim, C., Heidelbaugh, J. J, Van Harrison R., 68 (7), 1311-1319, , 2003
9. Mathematical comparison of dissolution profiles, Moore, J. W., Flanner, H. H., 20 (6), 64-74, , 1996
10. A Gut feeling about GABA: Focus on GABAB, Receptors, Hyland, N. P., Cryan, J. F., 1, 124-136, , 2010
11. A comprehensive review on pharmaceutical mini tablets, Kumar, K., Teotia, D., Priyanka, P., 8 (6), 382–390, , 2018
12. Review of Disintegrants and the Disintegration Phenomena, Desai, P. M., Liew, C. V., Heng, P. W. S., 105 (9), 2545–2555, , 2016
13. Comparison of canine and human gastrointestinal physiology, Dressman, J, 3 (3), 123-131, , 1986
14. Shortcomings of the first-generation proton pump inhibitors, Tytgat, G. N., 13, S29–S33, , 2001
15. Therapeutic options for refractory gastroesophageal reflux disease, Ronnie, F., 27, 3–7, , 2012
16. Advantages and Disadvantages of Long-term Proton Pump Inhibitor Use, Ishimura, N., Kinoshita, Y., Ishihara, S., 24, 182-196, , 2018
17. Pharmacokinetics and Pharmacodynamics of the Proton Pump Inhibitors, Kim, N. Y., Shin, J. M., 19, 25–35, , 2013
18. Factors Affecting the Dissolution Rate of Medicaments from Tablets II, Plein, E. M., Jacob, J. T., 57 (5), 802–805, , 1968
19. Targeting drugs to the colon: delivery, systems for oral administration, Ashford, M., Fell, T., 2, 241–258, , 1994
20. American Gastroenterological Association Technical Review on Constipation, Locke, G. R., Pemberton, J. H., Bharucha, A. E., 144 (1), 218- 238, , 2013
21. Combination of PPI with a prokinetic drug in gastroesophageal reflux disease, Ndraha, S., 43, 233-246, , 2011
22. Proton-Pump Inhibitor Therapy in Patients with Gastro-Oesophageal Reflux Disease, Fass, R., 67 (11), 1521–1530, , 2007
23. An improved in vitro method for the evaluation of antacids with in vivo relevance, Van Aalst, P., De Kaste, D., Barends, D. M., Van Riet-Nales, D. A., 53, 217–225, , 2002
24. Preclinical formulations for discovery and toxicology: physicochemical challenges, Neervannan, S., 2 (5), 715–731, , 2006
25. Medical Management of Gastroesophageal Reflux Disease and the Challenges: A Review, Das, S., Mazumder, A., Kumar, N., 12 (2), 902-909, , 2022
26. Pharmaceutical mini tablets, its advantages and different enteric coating processes, Rao, V. U. M., Sirisha, B. V., Mounika, A., 4 (8), 523–541, , 2015
27. Update on the epidemiology of gastro-oesophageal reflux disease: a systematic review, Sweet, S., Winchester, C. C., EI-Serag, H. B., Dent, J., 63, 871-880, , 2014
28. Evaluation of Acid Neutralising And Buffering Capacities Of Selected Antacids In Ghana, Bekoe, S. O., Brobbey, A. A., Ayensu, I., Appiah, E., Adu, J. K., 8, e00347, , 2020
29. Formulation and in vitro/in vivo evaluation of esomeprazole enteric coated minitablets, Omari, D. M., 39, 156–165, , 2017
30. Antacids Revisited: A Review of Their Clinical Pharmacology and Recommended Therapeutic Use, Maton, P. N., Burton, M. E., 57 (6), 855-870, , 1999
31. Potassium-competitive acid blockers - are they the next generation of proton pump inhibitors?, Ofosu, A., Rawla, P., Gaduputi, V., Sunkara, T., 9 (7), 63-68, , 2018
32. Pharmacokinetics of esomeprazole following intravenous and oral administration in healthy dogs, Mills, P., Satake, N., Cook, E., Bennett, E., Sykes, B., 7, 123–131, , 2016
33. Characterization of the GI transit conditions in Beagle dogs with a telemetric motility capsule, Grimm, M., Weitschies, W., Bollmann, T., Lotz, R., Schäfer, K. J., Boeck, G., Blattner, S. M., Koziolek, M., 136, 221-230, , 2019
34. Effect of splitting the dose of esomeprazole on gastric acidity and nocturnal acid breakthrough, Hammer, J., Schmidt, B, 19, 1105–1110, , 2004
35. Preparation of pH-dependent modified-release pellets of urapidil to improve its bioavailability, Tang, X, He, H., Li, H., 16, 212–218, , 2011
36. Alginate therapy is effective treatment for GERD symptoms: a systematic review and meta-analysis, Umscheid, C. A., Falk, G. W., Morgan, S., Metz, D. C., Riff, B. P., French, B., Leiman, D. A., 30 (5), 1-9, , 2017
37. The role of dexlansoprazole modified release in the management of gastroesophageal reflux disease, Fass, R., Frazier, R., 10 (2), 243-251, , 2017
38. Evaluation of Different Concentration of Binders on the Dissolution Profile of Paracetamol Tablets, Malviya, R., Nagar, G., Sharma, P., Pant, S., 9 (2) 82-85, , 2015
39. A new multiparticulate delayed release system: part I: dissolution properties and release mechanism, Kleinebudde, P., Schultz, P, 47, 181–189, , 1997
40. Electrospun diclofenac sodium loaded Eudragit® L100-55 nanofibers for colon-targeted drug delivery, Chatterton, N. P., Branford-White, C., White, K., Shen, X., Yua, D., Zhua, L., 408, 200–207, , 2011
41. Alkalosis resulting from combined administration of a nonsystemic antacid and a cation-exchange resin, Schroeder, E. T., 56 (5), 868- 874, , 1969
42. Use of the pentagastrin dog model to explore the food effects on formulations in early drug development, Ollier, C., MacGerorge, D., Zane, P., Vicat, P., Guo, Z., 57, 207–213, , 2014
43. Issues related to the use of canines in toxicologic pathology-issues with pharmacokinetics and metabolism, Tibbitts, J, 31 (1_suppl), 17-24, , 2003
44. Studies on drug release from pectin/ethylcellulose film-coated tablets: a potential colonic delivery system, Fell, J. T., Parkins, D., Wakerly, Z., Attwood, D., 153, 219–224, , 1997
45. An overview: Current clinical guidelines for the evaluation, diagnosis, treatment, and management of dyspepsia, Zajac, P., Vogt, M., Super, M. E., Holbrook, A., 5(2), 79–85, , 2013
46. Site of Action of GABAB Receptor for Vagal Motor Control of the Lower Esophageal Sphincter in Ferrets and Rats, Monroe, M., Partosoedarso, E., Hyland, N., Abrahams, T. P., Mcdermott, C. M., Hornby, P. J, Ekstrand, J., 120, 1749-1762., , 2001
47. Pharmaceutical mini-tablets, its advantages, formulation possibilities and general evaluation aspects: a review, Dutt, A. G., Rao, V. U. M., Kiran, R. S., Keerthi, M. L., Sannapu, A., Krishna, K. S., 28, 214–221, , 2014
48. Development of novel bepotastine salicylate salt bioequivalent to the commercial bepotastine besilate in beagle dogs, Cho, K. H., Choi, H.-G., 39(6), 901–908, , 2012
49. Physico-Chemical Characterization, UV Spectrophotometric Method Development and Validation Studies Of Timolol Maleate, Mohammedi, H., Shyale, S., 6 (2), 163–166, , 2011
50. Review article: esomeprazole d enhanced bio-availability, specificity for the proton pump and inhibition of acid secretion, Andersson, T., Keeling, D., Lindberg, P., Carlsson, E., Lundborg, P., Fryklund, J., 17, 481–488, , 2003
51. Blends of enteric and GIT-insoluble polymers used for film coating: physicochemical characterization and drug release patterns, Lecomte, F., Walther, M., MacRae, R. J., Siepmann, J., Bodmeier, R., 89, 457–471, , 2003
52. Comparison of Acid Secretion Rates Measured by Gastric Aspiration and by In Vivo Intragastric Titration in Healthy Human Subjects, Feldman, M., 76, 954-957, , 1979
53. Review article : esomeprazole - the first proton pump inhibitor to be developed as an isomer Pharmacology of proton pump inhibitors, Kendall, M. J, Shin, J. M., Sachs, G., 17 (Suppl. 1), 1-4. 21 10, 528-534, , 2003
54. Relationship between drug dissolution and leaching of plasticizer for pellets coated with an aqueous Eudragit® S100:L100 dispersion, McGinity, J. W., Bando, H., 323 (1), 11–17, , 2006
55. Development of a novel combination tablet containing trimebutine maleate and mosapride citrate for the treatment of functional dyspepsia, Choi, H.-G., Kang, J. H., Cho, K. H., Park, Y.-J, Choi, Y. K., Yong, C. S., 400 (1-2), 145–152, , 2010
56. Histamine-2 receptor antagonists at night improve gastroesophageal reflux disease symptoms for patients on proton pump inhibitor therapy, Castell, D. O., Agrawal, A., Hila, A., Tutuian, R., Mainie, I., Rackoff, A., 18 (6), 370-383, , 2005
57. Design and Evaluation of a Novel Gas Formation-Based Multiple-Unit Gastro-Retentive Floating Drug Delivery System for Quetiapine Fumarate, Katakam, V. K., Reddy, S., Yamsani, M. R., Panakanti, P. K., 13 (4), 489– 496, , 2014
58. The use of novel tools for the assessment of powders and granules flow properties and for the analysis of minitablets compression process, Nalluri, B. N., Szymanska, M., Sznitowska, M., Kubiak, B., Krotka, J., Kotlowska, H., 46 (4), 547–556, , 2020
59. Species differences in hepatic and intestinal metabolic activities for 43 human cytochrome P450 substrates between humans and rats or dogs, Nakagawa, T., Yabuki, M., Nishimuta, H., Nomura, N., 43 (11), 948-955, , 2013
60. Pharmacokinetics and acid suppressant efficacy of esomeprazole after intravenous, oral, and subcutaneous administration to healthy beagle dogs, Song, G. H., Koo, T. S., Hwang, J. H., Jeong, J. W., Seo, K. W., 31 (3), 743-750, , 2017
61. Non-destructive prediction of enteric coating layer thickness and drug dissolution rate by near-infrared spectroscopy and Xray computed tomography, Ariyasu, A., Hattori, Y., Otsuka, M., 525 (1), 282–290, , 2017
62. Preparation and optimization of various parameters of enteric coated pellets using the Taguchi L9 orthogonal array design and their characterization, Lakshmi, P. K., Balasubramaniam, J, Shravani, D., 1, 56–63, , 2011
63. Challenges of Correlating pH Change with Relief of Clinical Symptoms in Gastro Esophageal Reflux Disease: A Phase III, Randomized Study of Zegerid versus Losec, Gruss, H.-J., Walker, D., Regula, J, Jones, D., Shing, R. N. K., (10) 2, e0116308, , 2015
64. The safety, pharmacodynamics, and pharmacokinetics of immediate-release formulation containing esomeprazole 20 mg/sodium bicarbonate 800 mg in healthy adult male, Hong, T., Yoo, B. W., Park, S. J., Kim, D., Kim, C. O, Park, M. S., 13, 3151, , 2019
65. The safety, pharmacodynamics, and pharmacokinetics of immediate-release formulation containing esomeprazole 20 mg/sodium bicarbonate 800 mg in healthy adult male, Yoo, B. W., Paek, M. S., Kim, C. O, Hong, T. G., Park, S. J., Kim, D. S., 13, 3151-3159., , 2019
66. A pH-Dependent Colon-Targeted Oral Drug Delivery System Using Methacrylic Acid Copolymers. II. Manipulation of Drug Release Using Eudragit® L100 and Eudragit® S100 Combinations, Kurjakovic, N., Stedul, H. P., Khan, M. Z. I., 26 (5), 549–554., , 2000
67. Evaluation of thermal and film forming properties of acrylic aqueous polymer dispersion blends: application to the formulation of sustainedrelease film coated theophylline pellet, Amighi, K., Moes, A. J, 21 (20), 2355–2369, , 1995
68. A pH-dependent colon targeted oral drug delivery system using methacrylic acid copolymers I. Manipulation of drug release using Eudragit® L100-55 and Eudragit® S100 combinations, Prebeg, Z., Khan, M. Z. I, Kurjakovic, N., 58, 215–222, , 1999
69. Novel application method of talcum powder to prevent sticking tendency and modify release of esomeprazole magnesium enteric-coated pellets Role of Eudragit in targeted drug delivery, Zhang, W., Joshi, M., Wang, W., Liu, Z., Chen, H., Liu, J., 21 (4), 405–414. 21, , 2015
70. Pharmacokinetics and pharmacodynamics of a known active PPI with a novel Dual Delayed Release technology, dexlansoprazole MR: a combined analysis of randomized controlled clinical trials, Zhang, W., Vakily, M., Atkinson, S. N., Wu, J., Mulford, D., 25, 627–638, , 2009