국내 석유계총탄화수소 위해성평가 방법 마련을 위한 국외 지침 비교 및 고찰 = Comparison and Consideration on Foreign Guidances for Establishing Risk Assessment Method of Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons in Korea

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This study reviewed standard operation procedures for fractionation and analytical methods of total petroleumhydrocarbons (TPH) in north america and european countries to aid proper establishment of risk assessment protocolsassociated with TPH exposure in Korea. In current, the TPH fraction methods established by Massachusetts Department ofEnvironmental Protection (MassDEP) and Total Petroleum Hydrocarbon Criteria Working Group (TPHCWG) are mostfrequently employed worldwide. Both methods were developed on the basis of direct exposure of TPH from soil, althoughthe method by TPHCWG also took into account the mobility of TPH. Volatile and extractable fractions of petroleumhydrocarbons were analyzed either separately or together. TPH fractionation methods were evaluated based onconservative toxicity values considering the uncertainty of risk assessment in light of current standard protocol foranalyzing soil contaminants in Korea, and it was concluded that the method developed by MassDEP is more appropriate.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 Pinedo, J., 20 (20): 1231-1248, 2014

2 임영관, "국내 유통 중인 석유제품 내 석유계 총 탄화수소화합물(TPH) 분석" 한국공업화학회 27 (27): 546-550, 2016

3 박인선, "국내 유류오염지역에서의 석유계총탄화수소에 의한 비발암 인체위해성평가 전략" 한국지하수토양환경학회 16 (16): 10-22, 2011

4 US EPAb, "Vocabulary catalog"

5 MassDEP, "Updated Petroleum Hydrocarbon Fraction Toxicity values for the VPH/EPH/APH Methodology"

6 Dempster, H. S., "Tracing organic contaminants in groundwater: A new methodology using compound-specific isotopic analysis" 31 : 3193-3197, 1997

7 ATSDR, "Toxicological Profile for Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons (TPH)"

8 Environment Agency, "The UK Approach for Evaluating Human Health Risks from Petroleum Hydrocarbons in Soils" Environment Agency 2005

9 FDEP, "Technical report: Development of cleanup target levels (CTLs) for Chapter 62-777" Florida Department of Environmental Protection 2005

10 Parsons, "Technical Memorandum: State Approaches to Petroleum Hydrocarbon Toxicity" Air Force Center for Engineering and th Environment (AFCEE) 2011

11 TCEQ, "TCEQ Method 1006"

12 TCEQ, "TCEQ Method 1005"

13 TCEQ, "Summary of updates to the tables accompanying the texas risk reduction program (TRRP) Rule"

14 NIER, "Statistics on facilities subject to specific pollution in 2016"

15 Tomlinson, P., "State and federal cleanup levels for petroleum hydro carbons in soil: State of the states and implications for the future" 22 (22): 911-926, 2016

16 Ministry of environment, "Soil Environment Conservation Act"

17 TPHCWG, "Selection of Representative TPH Fractions Based on Fate and Transport Considerations" Amherst scientific 1997

18 Oklahoma DEQ, "Risk-Based Levels for Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons"

19 IDEM, "Risk integrated system of closure: Technical resource guidance document"

20 LDEQ, "Risk Evaluation/Corrective Action Program" Louisiana Department of Environmental Quality 2003

21 MDEQ, "Risk Evaluation Procedures for Voluntary Cleanup and Redevelopment of Brownfield Sites" Mississippi Department of Environmental Quality 2002

22 US EPA, "Risk Assessment Guidance for Superfund Volume 1 Human Health Evaluation Manual (Part A), EPA/540/1-89/002"

23 Environment Agency, "Review of comments on: Environment agency public consultation paper-principles for evaluating the human health risks from petroleum hydrocarbons in soils" Environment Agency 2009

24 DNREC, "Remediation Standards Guidance Under the Delaware Hazardous Substance Cleanup Act"

25 MEDEP, "Remediation Guidelines for Petroleum Contaminated Sites in Maine"

26 US EPA, "Provisional Peer-reviewed Toxicty values for Complex Mixtures of Aliphatic and Aromatic hydrocarbons" US Environmental Protection Agency, Superfund Health Risk Technical Support Center 2009

27 NIER, "Project on Risk Assessment of Contaminated Site and Study on the Advancement of Risk Assessment Guidance (II)" National Institute of Environmental Research 2015

28 Environment Agency, "Principles for evaluating the human health risks from petroleum hydrocarbons in soils: A consultation paper" Environment Agency 2003

29 CDPHE, "Practical Quantitation Limitation Guidance Document"

30 CL:AIRE, "Petroleum Hydrocarbons in Groundwater:Guidance on assessing petroleum hydrocarbons using existing hydrogeological risk assessment methodologies"

31 Ecology, "Part VI Calculation of Method B and Method C Cleanup Levels for Petroleum Mixtures"

32 Ministry of Environment, "Official Korean Testing Method for Soil Pollution"

33 Montana DEQ, "Montana Risk-Based Corrective Action Guidance for Petroleum Releases"

34 MDNR, "Missouri Risk-Based Corrective Action Process for Petroleum Storage Tanks" Missouri Department of Natural Resources 2013

35 MassDEP, "Method for the Determination of Volatile Petroleum Hydrocarbons (VPH) by Gas Chromatography/Photoionization Detector/Flame ionization Detector"

36 MassDEP, "Method for the Determination of Volatile Petroleum Hydrocarbons (VPH) by Gas Chromatography/Mass spectrometry"

37 MassDEP, "Method for the Determination of Extractable Petroleum Hydrocarbons (EPH)"

38 Regional Water Board, "Metabolites: Literature Review and Assessment Framework"

39 US EPAa, "IRIS Integrated Risk Information system, Benzene" US Environmental Protection Agency

40 UDEQ, "Guidelines for Utah’s Corrective Action Process for Leaking Underground Storage Tank Sites"

41 NCDEQ, "Guidelines for Site Checks, Tank Closure, and Initial Response and Abatement for UST Releases"

42 Alaska DEC, "Guidance for cleanup of Petroleum Contaminate sites"

43 Ohio EPA, "Guidance for assessing petroleum hydrocarbons in soil" Ohio Environment Protection Agency

44 Ecology, "Guidance for Remediation of Petroleum Contaminated Site, Publication No. 10-09-057"

45 Lesage S., "Groundwater Contamination and Analysis at Hazardous Waste Sites" Marcel Dekker, Inc 60-, 1992

46 HDOH, "Field Investigation of the Chemistry and Toxicity of TPH in Petroleum Vapors: Implications for Potential Vapor Intrusion Hazards" Hawaii Department of Health 2012

47 MassDEP, "Evaluation of MassDEP Volatile Petroleum Hydrocarbon (VPH) Methods" Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection 2016

48 NIER, "Environmental Testing?Inspection QA/QC Handbook, Second Edition"

49 TCEQ, "Development of human health PCLs for total petroleum hydrocarbon mixtures" Texas Commission on environmental quality 2010

50 TPHCWG, "Development of Fraction Specific Reference Doses (RfDs) and Reference Concentrations (RfCs)for Total Petroleum Hydrocarbons (TPH)" Amherst scientific 1997

51 US EPAc, "Detection Limit/Quantitation Limit Summary Table"

52 Scarlett, A., "Chronic toxicity of unresolved complex mixtures (UCM) of hydrocarbons in marine sediments" 7 : 200-206, 2007

53 MassDEP, "Characterizing Risks Posed by Petroleum Contaminated Sites: Implementation of the MADEP VPH/EPH Approach" Massachusetts Department of Environmental Protection 2002

54 AEHS, "Characterization of C6~C35 Petroleum Hydrocarbons in Environmental Samples-The Direct Method"

55 CCME, "Canada-Wide Standard for Petroleum Hydrocarbons (PHC) in Soil: Scientific Rationale Supporting Technical Document PN-1399"

56 Fowles, J.R., "Assessment of petroleum streams for thyroid toxicity" 254 : 52-62, 2016

57 Ecology, "Analytical Methods for Petroleum Hydrocarbons, ECY-97-602"

58 WDNR, "Analytical Detection Limit Gidance & Laboratory Guide for Determining Method Detection Limits"

59 TPHCWG, "Analysis of Petroleum Hydrocarbons in Environmental media" Amherst scientific 1998

60 NIER, "A study extending risk assessment in soil sector -Focused on pilot project in petroleum contaminated site (‘12)" National Institute of Environmental Research 2012

61 RIVM, "A proposal for revised Intervention Values for Petroleum Hydrocarbons (Mineral oil) on base of Fractions of Petroleum Hydrocarbons" Netherlands National Institute for Public Health and the Environment 1999

62 Kim, G.B., "A Method of Developing Risk-Based Cleanup Target Levels at Petroleum Release Sites" University of Seoul 2008