기술영향평가의 메타평가 모형 및 지표개발

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

  Technology assessment focuses on providing information and participation of public. And it could be considered as a type of policy analysis(narrowly) as well as a type of policy evaluation(widely). Based on these characteristics, meta-evaluation model for technology assessment was developed.
  The system of technology assessment can be understood as a circulation of ‘planning’, ‘input’, ‘process’, ‘output’, and ‘utilization’. Delphi method was used to verify the validity of meta-evaluation model and indicators determined through the theoretical review. Delphi survey was consisted of twelve experts and it was performed three rounds in total. Eventually, total forty eight evaluation indicators were developed. As an important point of view, the five components of meta-evaluation model for technology assessment included sub-items as follow: evaluation purpose, evaluation design and objective(technology) in evaluation planning; evaluator, evaluation organization, evaluation budget and information in evaluation input; evaluation method and procedure in evaluation process; evaluation credibility, evaluation availability and reporting in evaluation output; and impact on policy and public in evaluation utilization.
  And then, the reliability verification was performed by the members of Technology Selection Committee and Technology Assessment Committee. The survey of twenty six members turned out that Cronbachs α was over .60 in evaluation items and components, and the overall reliability was .9448 which was high enough.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 남궁근, "행정조사방법론" 법문사 2003

2 김순남, "학교평가의 메타평가 준거개발" 2002

3 배호순, "프로그램평가론" 1994

4 김인호, "체계적 기술영향평가 방안에 관한 연구" 한국과학기술기획평가원 1999

5 박종수, "정보화사업 메타평가모형의 설계와 적용" 2003

6 이영희, "유럽의 기술영향평가" 과학기술정책관리연구소 1997

7 이찬구, "연구개발사업의 메타평가에 관한 연구: 정보통신 분야를 중심으로" 1997

8 김종길, "신기술 확산에 따른 기술사회족 역기능의 전개과정 및 대응전략" 1 (1): 235-259, 2001

9 임성옥, "사회복지시설 평가에 대한 메타평가" 2003

10 신태영, "기술예측방법론" 과학기술정책관리연구소 1995

11 박병무, "기술영향평가 제도운영을 위한 추진방안 기획연구" 한국과학기술기획평가원 2002

12 김재우, "국내외 기술평가모델 체계화: 기술평가방법, 유형, 기법을 중심으로" 한국과학기술정보연구원 2004

13 이영희, "과학기술의 사회적 통제와 수용성 연구: 생명공학을 중심으로" 1 (1): 71-103, 2001

14 송위진, "과학기술과 사회의 주요 쟁점분석 연구" 과학기술정책연구원 2003

15 김명수, "공공정책평가론" 박영사 2003

16 Standard, "The State of the Art" The Johns Hopkins University Press 146-163, 1981

17 Schot, Johan, "The Past and Future of Constructive Technology Assessment" 54 : 251-268, 1996

18 Yi, Chan Goo, "The National R&D Evaluation System in the UK: Meta-evaluation and Applicability to the Korea Case" 2003

19 Palm, Elin, "The Case for Ethical Technology Assessment: eTA" 73 : 543-558, 2005

20 Braun, Ernest, "Technology in Context: Technology Assessment for Managers" London and New York: Routledge 1998

21 Bongers, F. J, "Technology and society: GSS-supported participatory policy analysis" 19 (19): 269-287, 2000

22 Eijndhoven, Jos, "Technology Assessment: Product or Process?" 54 : 269-286, 1997

23 Vig, Norman J, "Technology Assessment in Comparative Perspective" Albany: State University of New York Press 3-35, 2000

24 Petermann, Thomas, "Technology Assessment Units in the European Parliamentary Systems" Albany: State University of New York Press 37-61, 2000

25 Paris, "Society and Assessment of Technology" OECD 1973

26 Genus, Audley, "Rethinking Constructive Technology Assessment as Democratic, Reflective, Discourse" 73 : 13-26, 2006

27 Guston, David H, "Real-time Technology Assessment" 24 : 93-109, 2002

28 Vedung, Evert, "Public Policy and Program Evaluation" New Brunswick and London: Transaction Publishers 1997

29 Worthen, Blaine R, "Program Evaluation: Alternative Approaches and Practical Guidelines" White Plains: Longman Publishers 1997

30 Genus, Audley, "On Constructive Technology Assessment and Limitations on Public Participation in Technology Assessment" 17 (17): 433-443, 2005

31 in Eleanor Chelimsky, "Old Patterns and New Directions in Program Evaluation The American Society for Public Administration" elea (elea): 1-35, 1985

32 Hong, Heung Deug, "Meta-evaluation of National Large-Scale R&D Programmes: A Comparison of Evaluation Systems of 6 National R&D Programs" 2000

33 Gotthard, "Democratic Function of Technology Assessment in Technology Policy Making" 11-16, 1993

34 Porter, "A Guidebook for Technology Assessment and Impact Analysis" 1980