This study examines whether defensive and enterprising earnings provide incremental information to capital market over accounting earnings. Defensive and enterprising earnings are developed for the purpose of practice application. Defensive earnings a...
This study examines whether defensive and enterprising earnings provide incremental information to capital market over accounting earnings. Defensive and enterprising earnings are developed for the purpose of practice application. Defensive earnings are suited to meet the needs of defensive investor, whose primary aim is to avoid committing serious mistakes or losses. Defensive earnings are designed to mitigate two problems with the accrual income statement, the omission of fixed capital and the omission of working capital. Enterprising earnings are suited for enterprising investor, whose main objective is to own companies that are both sound and more attractive than the average. Enterprising earnings are designed to mitigate two problems with the accrual income statement, intangible growth-producing initiatives are expensed in the year incurred and stockholders` equity is considered free. The sample consists of 2911 manufacturing firm/year with December 31 fiscal year end for the period of 1994 to 2002. The analysis are based on the regression of firm-size adjusted return on the changes in accounting income, defensive income and enterprising income. The empirical results show that defensive earnings provide incremental information over accounting earnings, but enterprising earnings do not for the total sample. However, enterprising earnings provide additional information for the high-tech firms, but they do not for the low-tech firms. This paper examines whether the concepts of defensive and enterprising earnings represent the quality of accounting earnings by analyzing relative magnitudes of accounting, defensive and enterprising earnings. The information effects of defensive earnings(enterprising earnings) are smaller for the firms with big differences between the rankings of accounting earnings and those of defensive earnings(enterprising earnings) than for those with small differences. The results of this study indicate that practice oriented earnings concepts, defensive and enterprising earnings are useful for price determination.