수사절차상 참고인 강제구인제도에 대한 비판적 검토 = A Critical Examination of the System for Compulsory Arrest of the Witness in Investigative Procedures

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

The investigative agency presents the need to introduce the system for compulsory arrest of the witness for reasons such as the finding of substantive truth, the quick processing of the case and the like. This is seen to take into consideration the efficiency of investigation and the expediency of investigation. The current Criminal Procedure Law requires the evidence preservation application system(sec. 184) and the witness examination claim system(sec. 221-2) as the method of forcing the witness to attend in case the witness disobey attendance for no justifiable reason.
Improvement is needed in a method of making use of the original intent of the witness examination claim system rather than the introduction of the system for compulsory arrest of the witness. It is claimed that the system for compulsory arrest of the witness should be introduced through a form of new legislation for reasons such as the delay of procedures,the leakage of investigative secret and the like though the system for compelling the witness to attend the court in the Criminal Procedure Law exists. This claim is thought be undesirable in terms of the principle of voluntary investigation and the prevention of human rights abuse.
Therefore, this study attempted to make a deep examination of the problem of the witness examination system and grounds for pros and cons of the need for introduction of the system for compulsory arrest of the witness in the procedures of investigation and then present views on the validity of introduction

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 손동권, "형사소송법(개정신판)" 세창출판사 2010

2 박미숙, "참고인의 출석·진술강제와 수사상 증인신문청구제도" 한국형사정책연구원 13 (13): 6-183, 2002

3 이정호, "참고인 출석강제 제도에 관한 연구" 30 : 2003

4 서보학, "참고인 강제구인제도에 대한 비판적 고찰" 한국형사법학회 21 (21): 57-80, 2009

5 정진수, "증인보호제도에 관한 연구" 한국형사정책연구원 1996

6 오병두, "증거보전을 위한 증인신문의 청구" 서울대학교 대학원 1995

7 정웅석, "실체적 진실발견을 위한 제도적 고찰- 참고인강제구인제도의 도입을 중심으로-" 법무부 2000

8 김영철, "수사절차에서의 개선입법론" 한국형사법학회 (22) : 222-266, 2004

9 도중진, "수사절차상 참고인조사제도의 효율화방안" 한국형사정책연구원 17 (17): 299-344, 2006

10 노명선, "새로운 진술증거 확보방안에 관한 개정" 법무부 2010

11 이종환, "미국의 참고인 수사제도에 관한 연구" 21 (21): 2006

12 정석우, "미국의 검찰 벌칙부 소환영장제도" 법무연수원 15 : 1999

13 안태근, "미국 형사소송법상 중요참고인 체포제도" 법무연수원 15 : 1999

14 정용수, "독일 형사소송법상 증인보호제도" 법무연수원 15 : 1999

15 대검찰청 검찰21세기연구기획단, "구속제도 정비방안 연구" 9 : 1995

16 "“공정한 사회 구현을 위한 선진 형사사법제도”, 법무부 보도자료, 2010. 10. 4"

17 "“5번 청구 5번 퇴짜…… 檢-法 오기싸움?”, 동아일보, 2010. 7. 16"

18 Kamisar LaFave, "MODERN CRIMINAL PROCEDURE, 7th. Ed" 2002