Reinforcement of Labor Market Dualism and Inequality in South Korea: The Legacies of State-led Coordination and the Dominance of Enterprise Unions

다국어 초록 (Multilingual Abstract)

This article examines why South Korea has failed to mitigate labor market dualism and inequality, despite a series of the government’s policy efforts over the past two decades. It argues that the legacies of state-led coordination and the dominance of enterprise unions reinforced dualism and inequality in the Korean labor market. The legacies of strong stateled coordination over its market economy, which had been institutionalized and consolidated during the authoritarian rule, substantially weakened economic and political incentives for business and labor to develop a strategic coordination mechanism based on mutual interests and cooperation even after democratization. The dominance of enterprise unions, whose organizational structure had been also established during the period of the authoritarian government, further restricted the coverage of collective bargaining only exclusively to union members and strengthened a division between labor market insiders and labor market outsiders. The lack of strategic coordination and enterprise union-centered industrial relations have strengthened labor market dualism and inequality in Korea, as opposed to reducing them.

참고문헌 (Reference)

1 이병훈 ; 홍석범 ; 권현지, "정규직-비정규직의 연대정치: 현대자동차 울산공장 사례를 중심으로" 한국사회학회 48 (48): 57-90, 2014

2 조형제 ; 백승렬, "유연 자동화와 숙련 성격의 변화 - 현대자동차 차체공장의 시스템조정 노동을 중심으로 -" 한국산업노동학회 16 (16): 275-306, 2010

3 백두주 ; 조형제, "시스템합리화와 노동유연성 -현대자동차 사내하청을 중심으로-" 한국산업노동학회 15 (15): 349-383, 2009

4 김영미 ; 한준, "내부노동시장의 해체인가 축소인가 기업규모별 임금격차 분해를 통해 본 한국노동시장의 구조 변동, 1982～2004." 한국사회학회 42 (42): 111-145, 2008

5 이철승, "결합노동시장지위와 임금불평등의 확대(2004∼2015년)" 비판사회학회 (115) : 103-144, 2017

6 Caraway, Teri L, "Working Through the Past: Labor and Authoritarian Legacies in Comparative Perspective" Cornell University Press 2015

7 Korea Ministry of Employment and Labor Press Release, "Workforce in the Platform Economy" Korea Ministry of Employment and Labor

8 Thelen, Kathleen, "Varieties of Liberalization and the New Politics of Social Solidarity" Cambridge University Press 2014

9 Estévez-Abe, Margarita, "Varieties of Capitalism:The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage" Oxford University Press 145-183, 2001

10 Hall, Peter A., "Varieties of Capitalism : The Institutional Foundations of Comparative Advantage" Oxford University Press 2001

11 Statistics Korea, "Union Organization Rates"

12 Frey, Carl B, "The Technology Trap : Capital, Labor, and Power in the Age of Automation" Princeton University Press 2019

13 Cho, Sung-Jae, "The Subcontracting System and the Stratification of the Employment Structure in the Korean Automotive Industry" Korea Labor Institute 2004

14 Martin, Cathie J., "The State and Coordinated Capitalism : Contributions of the Public Sector to Social Solidarity in Post-Industrial Societies" 60 (60): 1-36, 2007

15 Kim, Dong-Bae, "The Restructuring of the Wage System: Past, Present and the Future" Economic, Social, and Labor Council 2016

16 Häusermann, Silja, "The Politics of Welfare State Reform in Continental Europe : Modernization in Hard Times" Cambridge University Press 2010

17 Yang, Jae-jin, "The Political Economy of the Small Welfare State in South Korea" Cambridge University Press 2017

18 Wren, Anne, "The Political Economy of the Service Transition" Oxford University Press 2013

19 송지연, "The Political Dynamics of South Korea’s Human Capital Development Strategy" 극동문제연구소 44 (44): 461-486, 2020

20 Kang, Sudol, "The Platform Economy and Labor Unions: A Case Study of Sweden" 65-89, 2021

21 Thelen, Kathleen, "The Origins of Nonliberal Capitalism: Germany and Japan in Comparison" Cornell University Press 200-227, 2001

22 Kim, Ki-Chan, "The Lowest Percentage of Transition from Non-Regular to Regular Workers"

23 Park, Tae-Ju, "The Hyundai Automobile Company as the Exemplification of Korea’s Industrial Relations"

24 Kang, Minhyoung, "The Formalization of Informal Workers at Hyundai Motor Company" 51 (51): 108-134, 2023

25 Emmenegger, Patrick, "The Age of Dualization: The Changing Face of Inequality in Deindustrializing Societies" Oxford University Press 2012

26 Statistics Korea, "Survey on the Economically Active Population: Additional Research by Employment Status, August 2021"

27 Statistics Korea, "Survey on the Economically Active Population: Additional Research by Employment Status (Waged Workers’ Characteristics)"

28 Statistics Korea, "Survey on the Economically Active Population by Employment Status" 2019

29 Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD), "Stat. “Trade Union Dataset.”"

30 Durazzi, Niccolo, "Social Solidarity for All? Trade Union Strategies, Labor Market Dualization, and the Welfare State in Italy and South Korea" 46 (46): 205-233, 2018

31 Rehm, Philipp, "Social Policy by Popular Demand" 63 (63): 271-299, 2011

32 Rueda, David, "Social Democracy Inside Out : Partisanship and Labor Market Policy in Industrialized Democracies" Oxford University Press 2007

33 Busemeyer, Marius R, "Skills and Inequality : Partisan Politics and the Political Economy of Education Reforms in Western Welfare States" Cambridge University Press 2014

34 Park, Hyun-Mi, "Research on the FKTU’s Organization Strategies: Focusing on the Organization of New Unions" FKTU Research Institute 2019

35 Woo, Jung-en, "Race to the Swift : State and Finance in Korean Industrialization" Columbia University Press 1991

36 Thelen, Kathleen, "Prospects for German and Japanese Capitalism, edited by Kozo Yamamura and Wolfgang Streeck" Cornell University Press 183-211, 2003

37 Pierson, Paul, "Politics in Time : History, Institutions, and Social Analysis" Princeton University Press 2004

38 Fleckenstein, Timo, "Organised Labour, Dualisation and Labour Market Reform : Korean Trade Union Strategies in Economic and Social Crisis" 49 (49): 452-472, 2019

39 International Labor Organization(ILO), "Non-Standard Employment around the World, Understanding Challenges, Shaping Prospects" ILO 2016

40 Korea Contingent Workers’ Center (KCWC), "Non-Regular Workers through a Lens of Statistics" 2020

41 Statistics Korea, "Non-Regular Employment"

42 Cheon, Byung-Yoo, "Multilayers Gaps: The Structure of Korea’s Inequality" Paperroad 2016

43 Lee, Yoonkyung, "Militants or Partisans : Labor Unions and Democratic Politics in Korea and Taiwan" Stanford University Press 2011

44 유형근, "Militant Labor Unionism and the Decline of Solidarity: A Case Study of Hyundai Auto Workers in South Korea" 사회발전연구소 41 (41): 177-199, 2012

45 Roh, Joong-kee, "Labor Regime Change and the Korean Government’s Labor Policy(2003–2018)" Humanitas 2020

46 Kim, Yong Cheol, "Labor Politics in South Korea : Changes and Dynamics" Mind Tap 2017

47 Song, Ho-Keun, "Labor Politics and Market in Korea" Nanam 1991

48 Nijhuis, Dennie O, "Labor Divided in the Postwar European Welfare State" Cambridge University Press 2013

49 Lee, Sophia Seung-yoon, "Korea’s Precarious Workers" Humanitas 2017

50 Jung, Ee-hwan, "Korea’s Labor Market Segmentation and Solution for the Problem" 163 : 7-20, 2018

51 Kwak, No-Pil., "Korea’s High Robot Density"

52 Koo, Hagen, "Korean Workers : The Culture and Politics of Class Formation" Cornell University Press 2001

53 Palier, Bruno, "Institutionalizing Dualism : Complementarities and Change in France and Germany" 38 (38): 119-148, 2010

54 Alt, James, "Inequality, Labor Market Segmentation, and Preferences for Redistribution" 61 (61): 21-36, 2017

55 Song, Jiyeoun, "Inequality in the Workplace : Labor Market Reform in Japan and Korea" Cornell University Press 2014

56 Thelen, Kathleen, "How Institutions Evolve : The Political Economy of Skills in Germany, Britain, the United States, and Japan" Cambridge University Press 2004

57 Iversen, Torben, "Equality, Employment, and Budgetary Restraint : The Trilemma of the Service Economy" 50 (50): 507-546, 1998

58 Keum, Jae-Ho, "Employment of Non-Regular Workers by Firm Size" 35-56, 2012

59 Lee, Jung-Hee, "Employment Structure of Korea’s Shipbuilding Industry" 22-34, 2016

60 Jung, Ee-hwan, "Economic Crisis and Employment Systems : A Comparison of Korea and Japan" Hanwol Academy 2011

61 Boix, Carles, "Democratic Capitalism at the Crossroads : Technological Change and the Future of Politics" Princeton University Press 2019

62 Iversen, Torben, "Democracy and Prosperity : Reinventing Capitalism through a Turbulent Century" Princeton University Press 2019

63 양재진, "Corporate Unionism and Labor Market Flexibility in South Korea" 동아시아연구원 6 (6): 205-232, 2006

64 Kim, Eun Mee, "Big Business, Strong State: Collusion and Conflict in South Korean Development, 1960–1990" State University of New York Press 1997

65 Hancké, Bob, "Beyond Varieties of Capitalism : Conflict, Contradictions, and Complementarities in the European Economy" Oxford University Press 2007

66 Korea Ministry of Employment and Labor Press Release, "Announcement on the Labor Union Organization Rate in 2020" Korea Ministry of Employment and Labor

67 Statistics Korea, "Analysis on the Business Management"

68 Kim, Hyun-Soo, "Agree to Increase Wages by 4.5% between Subcontract Companies of Daewoo Shipbuilding and Marine Engineering and Subcontract Workers"

69 Lee, Myungjin, "A Study on Korea’s Inequality: Labor Market Inequality and Asset Inequality" National Assembly Futures Institute 2020